Balwinder Singh And Another v. Prem Singh And Others


 

      

         



       

 

   

  

    

 





   


 !"##!$$"%&'
#$"(%())'"*!"++*(!,!-"+"(%'&& !./-+!0!%& "%--!1*!!-"&!-2 3#"''!-45& !)(*'&"##!$$"&! 6/*&(% (,($ ##!"$6 7-"&!- 3/# 6-$(%+& !./-+!0!%&"%--!1*!!-"&!- 9 3  45  (,($  /-+!:* (,% ;  !*"4"''(  < !*!45  & !(*  '/(&  )6* '#!1()(1#!*)6*0"%1!6)16%&*"1&<(& 16%'!=/!%&("$*!$(!)6)#!*0"%!%& (%./%1&(6%<"'-('0(''!-  *(!)$5& !)"1&'6)& !1"'!"*!& "&& !#$"(%&())')($!-'/(&)6* '#!1()(1#!*)6*0"%1!6)"+*!!0!%&-"&!-9 333"$6%+<(& #!*0"%!%& (%./%1&(6%#$!"-(%+& "&' *6<()!6) /*-("$(%+ :6& !*6)-!)!%-"%&'
*!'#6%-!%&'; "- "+*!!- &6 '!$$ !*' "*!6) $"%- 0!"'/*(%+  4('<"' 160#*('!-(%> "'*"6 238:
;'(&/"&!-"&,($$"+!?"*>"/*(%& !(*)",6/* )6*"&6&"$'"$!16%'(-!*"&(6%6)
@
&& !&(0!6)!A!1/&(6%6)& !

"+*!!0!%&& !!%&(*!'"$!16%'(-!*"&(6%<"'#"(-&6 !*"%-& !*!+('&*"&(6% <"'#6'&#6%!- 6<!,!*#6''!''(6%6)& !'/(&#*6#!*&5<"'-!$(,!*!-&6 & !#$"(%&())'"%-'(%1!& !%& !5"*!(%#6''!''(6%6)& !'/(&#*6#!*&5  !

#$"(%&())'<!*!& *6/+ 6/&*!"-5"%-<($$(%+&6+!&& !'"$!-!!-*!+('&!*!-


(%& !(*)",6/*4/&' *6!,(-(!-6%2 $!",(%+4! (%--!)!%-"%&'

"' !*$!+"$ !(*'

)&!* !*-!"& & !#$"(%&())'*!=/!'&!-& !-!)!%-"%&'6% %/04!*6)611"'(6%'&6+!&& !'"$!-!!-*!+('&!*!-4/&%6& (%+<"'-6%! & !*!)6*!"$!+"$%6&(1!-"&!-9 9<"''!%&&6& !-!)!%-"%&'"'>(%+ & !0&6+!&& !'"$!-!!-*!+('&!*!-6%  9(%& !(*)",6/*  6/+ & !%6&(1!<"'*!1!(,!-45& !06%9 94/&& !5-(-%6&&/*%/# 4!)6*!& !6))(1!6)/4 !+('&*"*!*"4"''()6*!A!1/&(6%6)'"$!-!!-

,!%  ")&!*  & ('  ,"*(6/'  *!=/!'&'  <!*!  "$'6  0"-!  &6  -!)!%-"%&'  )6* *!+('&*"&(6%6)'"$!-!!- 6<!,!*& !*!<"'%6*!'#6%'!'6& !#$"(%&())' 4*6/+ &'/(&'!!>(%+-!1*!!6)'#!1()(1#!*)6*0"%1!"'<!$$"'#!*0"%!%& (%./%1&(6%   !'/(&<"'16%&!'&!-45& !-!)!%-"%&'45)($(%+.6(%&<*(&&!% '&"&!0!%& "%-#*!$(0(%"*564.!1&(6%'*!+"*-(%+ -!$"5(%)($(%+& !'/(& 0"(%&"(%"4($(&5"%-$"1>6),"$(-1"/'!6)"1&(6%<!*!*"('!-"%-6%0!*(&' (&<"' (+ $(+ &!-& "&' *6!,( "-!A#(*!-6%2 ( !

25!"*'

4!)6*!& !-"&!6))($(%+6)& !'/(&"%-& !'/(&('4"**!-45$(0(&"&(6%

& !*",!*0!%&'(%& !#$"(%&<!*!"$'6-!%(!-"%-(%& !!%-(&<"'#*"5!- & "&& !'/(&4!-('0(''!-

)&!*160#$!&(6%6)#$!"-(%+'6)& !#"*&(!'& !&*("$ 6/*&(% "$$)*"0!-'!,!%(''/!'"%-& !*!")&!*& !#"*&(!'"--/1!-& !(**!'#!1&(,! !,(-!%1!

 #6%16%'(-!*(%+& !#$!"-(%+'"%-!,(-!%1!6%*!16*-& !&*("$

6/*&-!1(-!-& !0"&!*("$(''/!'6 "%-"+"(%'&& !#$"(%&())'"%-(% )",6/*6)-!)!%-"%&'< !*!"'(''/!'6 8&67<!*!-!1(-!-(%)",6/*6) #$"(%&())'

(''"&(')(!-<(& & !./-+!0!%&"%--!1*!!-"&!-9 3

8
#"''!-45& !&*("$ 6/*&& !#$"(%&())'#*!)!**!-"##!"$4!"*(%+6 7 -"&!- 3"%-& !'"0!<"'"$'6-('0(''!-& *6/+ & !(0#/+%!- ./-+!0!%&"%--!1*!!-"&!-2 3 !%1!& (''!16%-"##!"$

!"*%!-  16/%'!$  )6*  & !  "##!$$"%&'  "'  "*+/!-  & "&  & ! #$"(%&())'
"##!$$"%&'<!*!& *6/+ 6/&*!"-5"%-<($$(%+&6#!*)6*0& !(*#"*& 6)16%&*"1&"%- "1&/"$$5& !5 "- #"(-& !!%&(*!'"$!16%'(-!*"&(6% &6 0& ' *6!,(4/&& !'"$!-!!-<"'%6&!A!1/&!-"%-!,!% !*$!+"$ !(*' ",!)"($!-&6*!'#6%-&6& !$!+"$%6&(1!-"&!-9 9 !'/40(&'& "& & !)(%-(%+'*!16*-!-45& ! (,($/-+!:* (,% ;!*""''("%-/# !$- 45& !('&*(1& /-+!"+"*6 "$( "*!%6&4"'!- /#6% 16**!1& "##*!1("&(6%6)& !!,(-!%1!6%*!16*-& !*!)6*!(%&!*)!*!%1!('<"**"%&!- 45& (' 6/*&

/*(%+& !16/*'!6) !"*(%+(&('%6&-('#/&!-& "&& !'/(& "' 4!!%-('0(''!-45& !&*("$ 6/*&6%& !+*6/%-6)-!$"5"%-& !'"(- )(%-(%+<"'/# !$-45& !"##!$$"&! 6/*&  !'/40(&'& "&& !1"/'!6) "1&(6%  <6/$-  "*('!  )*60 & !  -"&!  6)  (''/"%1!  6)  $!+"$  %6&(1!  "'  ")&!* *!1!(,(%+& !'"0!& !-!)!%-"%&' ",!%6&!A!1/&!-& !'"$!-!!-(%)",6/* 6)& !#$"(%&())'"%-& !-!"& 6)' *6!,((%& !5!"*('(**!$!,"%&"' & !*!<"'%6)(A!-&(0!)*"0!)6*160#$!&(%+& !'"$!&*"%'"1&(6%(%& ! "*+!!0!%&&6'!$$-"&!-9 333  !*!)6*!& !)(%-(%+6%& ('(''/!

-!'!*,!'&64!'!&"'(-!

 )&!* !"*(%+& !$!"*%!-16/%'!$"%-16%'(-!*(%+& !!,(-!%1! 6%*!16*-& (' 6/*&)(%-'& "&16%1!-!-$5& !"+*!!0!%&*!$(!-/#6%45& ! #$"(%&())'<"'!A!1/&!-45' *6!,($6%+4"1>6%9 333"%--/*(%+ !*$()!&(0!& !5%!,!*"'>!-& !'"(-,!%-6*&6!A!1/&!& !'"$!-!!-< 6

2
-(!-6%2 ( !

")&!*06*!& "%8B5!"*'6)& !!A!1/&(6%6)& !'"(- "+*!!0!%&

 !"*+/0!%&& "&1"/'!6)"1&(6%<6/$-"11*/!< !%& !$!+"$ %6&(1!<"''!%&45& !#$"(%&())'&6& !

'6)' *6!,(('160#$!&!$5 0('#$"1!-"'& !*!('%6"1>%6<$!-+!0!%&45& !-!)!%-"%&'"&"%5'&"+! 0/1 $!''"-0(&&(%+& !"+*!!0!%&1$"(0!-45& !#$"(%&())'  /*& !*"

#!*/'"$6)& !(0#/+%!-./-+!0!%&'*!,!"$'& "&& !)(%-(%+'*!16*-!-45 46& & ! 6/*&'"*!4"'!-/#6%#*6#!*"##*!1("&(6%6)!,(-!%1!"%-$"<6% & !'/4.!1& 66& !*#6(%&<"'"*+/!-45& !$!"*%!-16/%'!$

 /'& (' 6/*&)(%-'& "&& !"##!"$-6!'%6&(%,6$,!"%5 '/4'&"%&("$=/!'&(6%6)$"<  !'/$&"%&$5& !"##!"$)"($'"%-('-('0(''!-

 /$5    

/$"&(



  !& !* !#6*&"4$!

 !'@6  !& !*#!">(%+@ !"'6%!-  !'@6