High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/35978/2019allowed

Rohan Jain v. I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University Jalandhar And Others

2020-02-28Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal8 pages

!"!# $ %& ' !

)*+",!-"

, .& -/ #'- 0&! 0&!

# $ % &&" % '''

! !!2 0$30(

!&1 !

!.! &4 5 6-$30( '# 6$30(

!! 0 '''

&()*+,+--./0

.& 1 ! 2 07

! 8 )

9.&71"!5 0:

6 ! 60"! 6&075

; "

"--#71-0& !

! 02&<7

(7 ! .& !<7 &-0 # 0

= !4 2 6&1&# <7 ! .&5"1!( ! &!4 0&7"

0$ &"

$ !7 !!1! 6

00= --0 "1.&"

07 0&! &>;& 7!4&

& 0$&4 ""

-#& 6$&4&- 24 1"!0 #& 7! 4&>.& 0!

0 #& !5"1! !4 !!00 >)76"-# !7#

)077#7 2>.&

4! &4

0 0&1 !4 2011! !&!

!&/

77 ? .&77 (#0

0 (0 77"

00 4&& 4 0 # & !711! 6 #<7 &/ # !1!0 4

.&1 !&-- 60& !0! #4# 11- 0&&! 4 &-0 ;4(!$& 0 7

0(0!0!00 .& !0!4 &-- 60 #&1 ! #4# = .& --40 0!0!00 0 && -6!"

0&&0 1

0 # "&!# 71 00&11-.&1 !& 11!&0&71 "&!#(0 !1! 00? 0 - 0&!4&&!0!00

0 #&;6&"!.&11-4 $&4(!$0 7

0 & 70# (0!0! ( 0 4&-$1"!

" 07 070 # A2 -!2 / # & 1 ! &0 01 0 & &!6! & 311- 4&

$! 8--6

!"-!

&& 7 !&0 !"2

!7&!-- &)

" .&"

$&1! 4!1 -0 ) 1! &4!1 $& (!!0&& 5"1!( ! 10&&1 !4

&&20 & 12 0 - 6 & 6 !7 6$ & 20&1 ! !7(& 4& 7& 64 -0"

0!& !1.&4& 4 !7(0 & 64 0 0&! ! &-0&1 !&

311-4& -

0$&"

4! & !4 2 4#.& ! "-0 !6"7 0 & 2 &5"1! $&1 " 70 1-6# !&( 6!6"04& &5"1!( !;4 "

0&&& 1"

& - --6

) 1! &4!1 $& (!!0 &&7!-!-0"1 "11! &&!6 &4 (! "11-0 &1 ! 00@"11!"

# &! 64 6! 0&7 = 3 0-0 4! & -0 &- & ! 8/ # 4&&&--6

- 71- &(

0)& (!!0&&1 !4 04! 6 311-4& 0"

0& "--< 24 (- - &4&&!"6& -"0

(# )& "!&! (!!0&&1 !070&

7 2 #4# & 00= %6!0 6 "11-# 7!- !-0"1 #&/

77$& 0&&

"11-0 $4&

!7 "6& #&1 !"

0!& %6&)

!7 3$ &! !! !!0 >&3>%6!0 !0!1

0 11-$& 0&&311--3"&!#1!

--# <7 0&!!0 & 0&&0 &/

774 1!1! 4! & -0 &- ! B )

" ? C!

- !&1 !& 00&&!0! /

77 4-- &1

0 #&311--3"&!#0 !( 0 &6!"

0&1! 4! 71-0 4& .& 6

&1 &&< 24 (- - &

311-4& "& 04&4 <7 0 #&/

77 !&311--3"&!#.&1 !4 (!

! 04&&--60 < 2(- - &4& !4 & &4 &.A 6!-0"1 "!&!$311-4& 77"

04&7 -1& & "!!"

7 -1& & !(!0 !&311-4&&

<7 0 ! # "&77"

.&! 6&& 311-4&4 77"

6&!"6&7 -1& 30@"11!"

# &! 6& 6! 0 0$&"

$&!0!

0 #&/

77 4-- &311--3"&!#!(0.&!0!00 !2 6

7 !7&!-- 1 !B )

"& 1

04&"

" # &4"

!6! 11!"

# &! 6.&!0 &/ #6(!

0 1! ! 1"

!7(- !7&!-- &--6 0$ &"

$&!0!00 (0 "

(- 1!

0 64&","! 0

-!1! 6! B/ # " 7 && 1!"

- & 00= !-!-# &4 && !&0070& 6"-;&0070& 6"-( !&/

77 0"

0!&!"7 "11-# 7!-!-0"1

#&/

77 !-( !0

-6-# 71"6 0!0!

30@"11!"

# &! 64 6! 0 0$&"

$ !

! --0 !

3 1# & !0 6(!

6 1!( $ 1"

1!0"!$ !

6 7 0" 0 "

!- <7 1-0 !!0 3

<"!8 %6"-

$ 0&! ! 6!1!0"0 -4 &#!!-( & 1! !(!

# 8

# $ !

)

% &

%6"- &!0 - (!"

4&&7#

5" 8-"

E1!

!!6 7 - 0&!7

-! 77"

.& " 8-"

!1!0"0 8 /)0 0

0 0

% &

%6"- 1! ! &1"

(!"

7 6!1!0"0 8 )!

0!-"

$2 ! !1!0&7# < 04 !

" -

& ! ))!

0!-"

$0$ $6$&$$,$-$($< 0E !1!0 -

& 4 !

)))!

0!-"

7 !1!0 -

& &! !

)A!

0!-"

!1!0 -

& "! !

0!-"

" !1!0 -

& ( !

A)!

0!-"

1 !1!0&7# < 0 ( !

A))!

0!-"

# !1!0&7# < 0 ( !

$ " -

& 4 !

!7& ( (0 & "0 (-(0

6( 11! !&/

77 0 !1! & ) 1!7

--0(0 !&77 "!&!$&!!6 7 -1& !&!7

-! 77"

& - #0 !1!0 -

& 4 !

3070-#$&7!-!-0"1 #&/

"& &311-4&$&71- 706

&1 !$ &71- 0&.A 6&( &4 &1 !

&6!"

0&&&0070& 6"-3-&"6&$& &1

&& (!070& 6"- " -#1-6E0 !& !6" 64& &5"1!( ! 3

"7 6& 7 !!$ 1!7

- !& "&! 6(6 #&1! !1!0

!7 0!0 3 1!%6"- "1! "0 0&/

77&(!6&-0(0 ) & $&1 !"-0 &(1!0"0 #(0 !7& 0;"-0 -#&(70 " 7

<7 &(0 6!-06

&7.& 11!"

#& 6( &1 ! 0$&"

$1! &(

(-0.&311--3"&!#& 1

0 !0! &0#!1!

00? !(0 # !7& 7

!!0& 00 6! 0@"11!"

#&1 ! .&! &! 1 &7! .&--6 6

& && !< 2&0 04 -00 #&7 & 311- 4& ;4(!$ 1!"

- !0!00 1

0 #&/

77!

1!0&0 !!0 # 6 & !6!0 3-&"6&$&!0! 0 &(!!000-0!

!0 # 6& !$- 6!6!0 6&(- -# &< 2 &311- 4& &"-0&( 6( )

$&1 &"-0&(

! 0 4&& (0 .&/

77& 1! "70&1! &< 2 &311-4& ! & &71- &5"1!( !- ) &"-0&(-

0 - !6!0 6& !"-

!1!0 61

#!0!6

&1 ! = !1

311-4&4"-0 ,"

#1"

&1 !"

-&! (0 !!0 &4&& 67 0 "&(0 (- -

&!!0311-4& ! 0(!#77 -# 40# 1--# ##"

611- 0 "0 1"

&0 !1

"&0( -

& 1 (-# - &0&& 0 0 !

%6"- "1! 1!(0 & 1"

! 01

- 0 %6"- E.&1"

!7(- !7&!-- .&"

$!0!00 !2 6& 7 &1 !7&!-- ! B--6 1 -#4&" ,"! 0 1! !7 6(-( &1! ? .&1 !& - 0--6 31!0 (7 & -1 0 & 4&&& ! "-0 -

"7 6&1 06"-#

! & 0 6 2 ! 71-# 6 4& & 1! "!- ,"

$ 1"

0 ! ! 0@" .&

"71 &&!6 (! 1!(0 4 &311-4&& !"!

0&1 !.&"

$)0 0711!1!0! ! & 0 2 !71-# 64&&1! 3!0 6-#$&4!1 --40 )71"6 0!0!

00 $ 0? !@" &0.&! &--$&4(!$ !0! !"!# $ 3&" %4