Mangal Sain Sharma v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"!#$!%&' ( (
)*!&+#&'&,'-!.!'* ( (
/0(111
!"# !
$%
&' !(")! !
*
!"# ! +
,,,,, 11 2 ( #)3 - ./+'
'
0 12 *1 +1*3$"4 5+% 6 7'!- - !
! !
869& # ':75;25+1*; ** 1< +1*;
2+2!2+.!2+;!.<+!*./*.=7 '
+
- 5 9 > 9
-
"
9 #9
" $ %
9 9 !
# +* 1+ +1+;
" ** 1< +1*; "4 5*
? # !
- 2+;!2+2!2+.!.<+!*./*.=7 '# 12 *1 +1+3 "
12 *1 +1*3 "4 5+
.
-
12 *1 +1*3 $"4 5+%
< -
$"4 5*% - - "
* <! !$ %! @-!" ! 9 ( $>
%! ' # 0 +1+'
'
$"4 5+% - ! !
$"4 5+%9
!"!# $"%$ "&%$$"%$ '() *) ( ) +%+$ $"%& "!"%$"%& '
), *-.) /'$"%0% 1 1 2"3'4 5) ( ) )$"$&% 1 1 +3!' 67,8
)$"$&& 9 67 +2)6 5 ).
/ $"$2$ 1 1 0+: ;
- *5 ! ! 0
- +5 ! !
$"4 5+% 9 # 9 # 99 4 " 99
# 4 # +1+ '
'
! 9 9 ;,84) < ,.,< $"%2%2 +&#: / 7 #
= ? !9 #4 # +11!+1+!+12+1.'
'
95 $""<9 =
!
"
# !
$
%&'
%&'
( >$"$ ?= %!
%&'
)
$
#
* !
" + # !
"
!
',,( '!- $ + +
%!
#
" +
( .!-
+ +
%!
"
/( $"&=4 ?= -
!
$
!
','
/( $"2@ ?= %! -
!
!
) ! ) ( '!0
%!
( .! -
%!
( 1!2
( 3! 0
45(/ *1 - # 5 - AB '
!"!#
$"%$ "&%$$"%$ : 5 1(6 7
" 0(.%189',%' :" ; < <
( -
+
1%4 1', -
" (= 7
>
?
+ ? "(;((
$
$
+
',' " "
(6 :"
+
1%41',
-
" (= "(;(( +
',' "
" ( 6 : "
$
) ( 6 : "
> > ?
?
";
','" " (6 : "
'3('(',%%
+
1%4 1', -
"
"(;(( (
<
( 3(2
:"
"(;((
$
+
',' " "
7
> >
?
)
"(;(( (-
$
+
',' " "
(
8(6
+
',' " "
(6
$ +
( -
+
',' " "
+
%38
(6
$ +
',' " "
! " !
# !
$
( 5(+
',' " "
" "
',,3!
@
) (@ 4(6
@= (-
+
%! +
','
)
$
(@ &(6
( (('.(8(',,8
0(+(A(&'. B! '%(8(',,8( %,(2 :"
"(;(( (6 "(;((
$
+
',' " " (+
) "(;((
:" ( :" $
+
',' " " (:
: "
+
1%4 1', -
" (6 "(;((
','" "
(
- AB ' 8() *) ( ) +%+$ $"%& "!"%$"%& :' 5 '8(6
$
+
',' "
"
) (6 +
','"
"
',,3
)
(6
$
(( +
+ )
+ ( 0
6 C A ( ',%, .! 7"7 " !188# 0 <
A (< C (;6',%' %'!+"1.'!( - AB ' ;,84) < ,.,< $"%2%2 +&#:' %,( +
',' "
@
) @
$
(-
) $ (6 @
) @ +
%&" "
! "
'3',,3!
( (('. ;
',,8(6
(6
@= (-
%! +
','
)
$
(@ %%(6 DE
$
( 6 @@
(6 @@
(<
(:
@@
$
) (-
" F+
(+ F ',%.!'+""1.3
" (- )
@1,( 6
$
+
','
" ( ("(
) (6 +
','" ( ("(
',,3
$
(@ !
%'(- $
$
$ +
',' " (6 @ $ @
+
' ! "
@'(@ !@ $ @
$
" " # @ %.(-
$ "
$ (0
$ +
',' " (- $
+
',' "
+
',, "
(6
$
+
',' " (-
( %1(-
( -
( AB ' 8), *- .) /'$"%0% 1 1 2"3:' 5 ''(
)
$
( +
',' " ( ("(
" "
! ',,3
''
;
',,8 E
) E(6
)
(6
$
)
(6
<
(6
" G)>
( 0) ) ',%1 .! 7"7 " ! 5&. ',%1 1!
;
7((;(!13& ',%1!%1+""8.4
@%%(+
',' "
@
) @
$
(-
) $ ( %'(6 @
) @
%& "
"
! "
'3 ',,3!( (('. 8 ',,8(6
( 6
@= (-
%! +
','
)
$
(@ 6 @@
$
( 6 @@
(6 @@
( <
(:
@@
$
)
(@ HHHHH HHHHH HHHHH '1( 6 $
$
(2 E
$ E
G)> 4
@%1(- $
$
$ +
',' " (6 @ $ @
+
' ! "
@'( !D $ E
$
" #@ -
$
$ ( 0
$ +
',' " (-
$
+
',' "
+
',,
"
( 6
$
+
',' " (@ '3(2
$ (0
( (=-7 =-7 B (
@A
+
3,, 3,%3, .1 -
" (:
'.(%'(',,&(
+ " (@ HHHH '4(0
+
','
" ( ("( % :
" ( 0
:"
( -
) +
0 6 " (I( ( 0 < ;',%% '!7"7 7
!'&.
',%%!%'+""8&3( '&(2
(<
+
',' " ( ("(
"
$
+
','
"
( (<
)
0 <
A ( - AB ' 84 5 ) ( ))$"$&% 1 1 +3!:' 5 ''( 2
) +
',' " 0('3',,3
$
(J%4KL-
(
J%4KG)> (0)) ',%1!%1+""
8.4# ) ( :
0 ',%5! . +"" 3'4# < " I + !(L - AB ' 8 67,8
)$"$&& 9 67 +2:' 5 1(6
@@
%+
',' "7 "
)
0('3',,3
)
( - 0(%'
"
)
%+
',' "7 " (-
G)> ',%1!%1+""8.4"
"
%+
',' "7 " ( 3(-
(-
)
("
% +
',' "7 "
) (:
: " (
+
I
( - AB ' )65 ) .
/ $"$2$ 1 1 0+:' 5 4(-
) "
%
(+
%!+
',' " ( "
'. ;
',,8 0('3 ',,3(+
%!+
',' " ( "
A$"$ = %!
%&'
)
$
!
" + #
!
"
!
',,(@
!
6 @ @
@ ) @
'. ;
',,8(6
$
'. ;
',,8
) ( 6 $
(6
$
)
',,1(6
'. ;
',,8
(2
'. ;
',,8
'. ;
',,8( &(2
%3>
',%%
+
+
',' " ( "
%
+("( "2 %!
7) ? "2 .!( 6
(6
+
',' " ( "(
%,(-
%5>
',%'
(6
(6
%5>
',%'
( -
+
',' " ( "
(- + ?
? - ++
+
F 6 " '1 A ','.
+
',' " ( " %8 ; ',%.
( %%(
+
','
" ( "(:
(6
( :
$
%!+
',' " ( "
(<
( =
%3>
',%%
+
',' " ( "(6
(- %
%8;',%.
(
(6
%3>
',%%
%!+
',' " ( "(6 $
(+ $ (+
(6
)
( **
" # +11!+1+!+12+1.
'
'
9 9 4 99 +11'
'
! 9
9 4
5 0
C 0 ! 4 9: 9 - 9 9 4 +11'
'
7 ! +12'
'
!
*+ " !9
' 9 !
' 0
A9# ! 99 ' 0
*2 - # AB '
# # 0 ' 9
' - ! ;,84) < ! AB ' 99 +1+'
'
! # '() *) ( )'),
*-.) /'4 5 ) ( ))' 67 ,8 ))65 ).
/
# #
*.
" ! 4
9 +11 '
'
! 0 # +1+'
'
9 +11'
'
4 9
7 9 4 9 0 ! ! 9 #
+1+'
'
9 4
9 7 ! +1+'
'
9
*<
' !9 9 4 # 4 !
9 >
' "
!9 ' # 0 7 ! 0 9 # +1+'
'
*;
7#9 #!7 !
12 *1 +1*3$"4
5+%0 - 9 0 +1+'
'
*3
! ' 4
9 9
*/ - #
11 ,4,"* 2
C D C D