← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/36032/2019dismissed

M/S Vikas Gram Udyog Samiti v. State Of Punjab And Others

2023-05-02Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari13 pages



     

    ! "# $%&

'

 "%&%(&) $%&

  

  

  

  * +,* - -- .  +,* - .,  

    !

"  #$   "  #    %&" '

"  %(&"  #  )*   !

"  #  )+  ,&"('-  ....

-- . /

  0)1(020)34"%(&$

/ 0 $    ## $## &1//232/4" #   &  5$  " #

#& 67*8

#9 9 &#242:32/67    #&& ;& 

&#;" 

&

 &*718&& !

9 7 &8 & "/4*6"       ;/4*6 & ;" "

 & $  <  



    ## 5$  " #

 &  #  " "  ##  ! " 

   "   ## " 

<   

 &"      #"    #   &   1//232/4"

$  ;  # ##  3

     "  

  " 

 &"     " & < #" # ## 2=//32/4" #   & "$ #>

)+"$ #&    -(567!!7%&!%819 2 0"& $)%(&! 28%"19 : 1717%& "

1 8 0& # &  "   " ## & " # ## 1//232/4"$ $ #&   ## &# "

$ ##

 &*718;/4*6 & ;"

   $  ? #



     

    

 

     !  

 " 

       !  

 #      !

  

        

   !

          !  

  !     

 #   !    !

$$

!

     %

  



!"

 

#



 

! 

 

 $

  

 

# !

 



   %

" #$



  

   

  



!!!





& 

! 

  #  



  #$ !  &    

    

 

 

! "

    



         

'

    

 

    

   

     

      ( "

   )   #  *  # +

 

%',

!) "

 -!

#

   !  

'

 

  #   "

  

.

" !

    

 

 ( "

 #

     "



"  

'

  

!"





## 

 #

"

#$  $-# 

 !"

 #

$     

.

%

"

         

    

!

'

 



"

 %

     %'  ,

!  ) "

   -!

#  

    

 

"#      

+ 

   

.

$-/ 0  "

  $ "

 & 7 

8"  "

#& 67*8;& 

&#;"

  ? >//" " "

 &    

 & #0 & #&  ;&  &#;" ? # $ &7 8 0 &              '

'

1  "



"    !"



!

   !"! "

 

 ! 

 

      ,!       %'  !!

#         ( "

           

)



 %  2  #  %'  3  !"!

 "

   



!





4$      

 *   ) "

     %



   !

  

"



    

     

   )  + 

    !      #  

+ 

 



 

 

 #

 !   

 

 " 

#    %

"  "

  

67

   !

   8 

   9

 "

    : 0#

   

 #  !"

 #

#

#  #   

          "

  !"

 ; 

 

  03





    !"

   

!6

#



!"!       



"

 

* ) "

 <%5



=  



  

6

#



!"!       

  

"  

    

 )  ) "

 <%5



; 



  "

!

  



 



()*! !

 "$

!

    

        

       

       +   () !

, -$   &(.

$ ).  // 8 0    #  $#  #    <& ##    2=//32/4"  $     #>   )  +  $ #&    "$   #

 

< " #

 &*7/28;/4*6 & ;"

   $      ? #   "   #   "        &"

$  " # # 

  < " &# & #



"  & /: " #"    & " # &#  "  &##



" #& $ &$# #& ## "

 " #  & #0  "   #$#$ &2=//32/4"  "$ #  #  

   " #  #

  &&  &7/28 &*;/4*6 & ;! <&"       &      "            ## " 

 &#" # & 1//232/4"&   "  <# &2=//32/4"#& &&  6           

!



 !"

 

 

 #  !   

 #   #   





4$ 

!    "

  

 

   

  

"

 ( "

  



 >

#'







 

    #

!,!

 



  #

"

 ( "

 .#   ! 

   

%! #"!

%  



%1   ?%   

    

1) 

 

 1)  #   

  1

    

        

      

   

 /  0!%&!8%"" ; )17&419 05%# 0"4(6 &1 6 (#> )*""#> )+&

&           $      &      &         $   "    &         "

 #&       ># "  "

 ## &   " # "   #/2 &&!

9 7 &8

#"  /4*/" 

    $      ? #   "   "   #&&    # 

#       !&&#  ##     "      &     # #&&  &    "      

 7 

8"  $  "$  "#  &"      " "  ## " 

 &#"&1//232/4"

  <   <#&2=//32/4"$  #> )+"$ #&    " #

&& &      &  0 "   #     $ 

    *% "

 !

         %

!   % @  !!  -#

1





  !

# +  



%  

   

!





  %



 "



 "

 #

 #  

!

 





   

   %'  A!

 +       2 !  -   -#B 0   

 !   !



 #  

!

 3

# 



$   

!> # # 

# +  

  #  

!

4 



   "





" 

-

2 



& 



 



 

   

&

   



 

  & +  

#  !!



 #  #  

!



" 



   

'

      & %

" 



$  

        

   

! 





 !      #  

!

 3



 #  

!

 "



"  +  



$  # "  #  !!   -

1







! 

  !       #  

!

    03



   

!

 

 %

 

<

  "     +  



  



 #  

!

#   #

   

+  



  

  



 ;  3

#  

     #     #     

!

 



  





" # 

 

 

!





 # 

 

"  # 

"

      +  

 

 !

 



#   

 

!

  

"   %

"     !"



 

 

 !

 

 

"    @  !!  

  !

#  

   

 +  



     



  

  "  !

 1   C-    #  

!

!!

"



+  

 

  #



  

  



#   + 

 

 / :    "

    ! "#&

&7 

8" #& $  "#       #  /8

 &  $    &     

 #  ## "   "    #

  "#" &1//232/4"$ 



&# ## 

### "  #" # ## ## " $    $#$  &&&$0  "  & #   #  " #   & "$  &#&   

 #  ##   0 "      #      #&         #   &&     $    

  #   &  >#  # &" & #&   

&   

### "   # " ?   ### "

              "      #

# " "  &

#

# "

 &&  

### "      

 

  &!   

#  

  ?  */"" ?  *3"  &  $  #> )* 0# " "$

 &   #&         

 #  ## "      &&  # "   

   &

  ? ##& " ## ; &  &#;7 ? >//8" " #

# 

 &&"$  & ?  */"" ?  *3"

 

 &#> )*"   "

#&    #$&#  @"

# "# $ ## "    &$

#0  " 

## #&



   

### "$&  &  &

  "   & "    ?  "$   

### "

&   ## ##"    "&       & 

 #A $  " ?  "$&  &&     # &  ##& "      

    "     #1//232/4"$ ## &"  &

 &    $   &    #       "      

   0  "$ " 

$             # 

# "  $#  $ ##1//232/4" #   7 

8"$ ## 

### A <&" $  #   # $ 

 & "

        

      ## "    &   

 &    " "

   ## " 

 &#

# " # ##1//232/4"  " $ 

### "$ #&   "   

#" 

 & 

     ## "   $&     #   &

#  0!%&!8%"$ )27&7&419 " 27 81%19 : 1717%& "8%"=(0!97&40&$ ! 117&40!7$ %819 !(5! =( &10()17%&9 2$%&<  />9 " 5?

19 )%" !:%&$ &1% >0!$ )20" $0!19 9749 !157$$ "

* 0"& # &

  

   & "  <#"$## &2=//32/4"$  #> )+



$ ## "   " &&<     "            #            ? #

   " # "

  < " #

 &*7/28;/4*6 & ;" <  &# & #



 " /:     #"  "      &#    "           &   #& $ "& $ # #& ## "  &  < 

#0    ##& " "  #

&& #>  )*+"  #   

   7

8" #

  &*7/28;/4*6 & ;" $&& " &6;& 

&#; + (  "    # &#      !       &   # &      "     "      

  0  "    $     #    

       #"

  #"&&  

 & " "

 && #   "##"$# $    <&2=//32/4"#>  )+" "$   & "      &  " B  "$ # #>   )  +"  $    &        

### 0  "$ #&    

#" #   # #"#

$ " 

    & "    #      

      0  "  # <&  



  "   #"   #> )+" 

# 5$  "##  "& @     & "     

     &         & "

?

" "  # #"#> )*"

  & 0  "

  &7/8 &32

;/4*6 & ;" & $ # ? # "  ## " "    "  " ## & @    &  0*%1$ 4$= 

 

    "



   "

 

  "

     %       "

     %  "

 

 #  

  

# 

   #

      !

   % >"   

 #   

 "



 

% 

  

!

 / =    "###> )+"&  @            & "    "    #>

)+ 

#&        & 0  "

#"$##   ## # ## "

  & 

  ?

"   "    ## " " 

 &*7 

8" ";&  &#;" "    ##-  &  "

    ## &#"  #> )+"



# & " "    B 

"

#& 

      & "#>

)+" #

 &  " " & ?

" ## "  # $"

      #  "       "      #

   ""  "&  &&  ?

 #   "  &&#  ##  7&02"$ "

4 A $ " !   $ 

""$     "      0# & " &2=//32/4"$ #>

)+"$ #&    "  & /2 )   #   // # #  & #" "&&



&#7 8""&  7 8    @-- .A   @.,  A 

     

9 19 "!: 037&4B" 0!%& $ 

!B%

9 19 "" :%"1052

!B%