High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/54617/2024allowed

Subhash v. State Of Haryana

2025-04-09Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil9 pages

"# $"% &'(&) *+,-./

$ " %&'

() " *+*'

)

)" $ ,-.

(

/'0 *+ * *+*'

" **12

(

* "

" ,-.

! "#$$%& ' &( ")*+%&

, "-./0-0$1(

,, , ,23

, 2, 4 4

24(5224 2 24 ( (22

, ( 2 2

, ( 2 "#6/*##07 (2(,,

4 5,( 5,,

2 ( 2 4 2(

5 ( 2 8# 4 !9 2 ,,

2 , :( '&(")*+

(2 7(2 , 2,(

(2 2 2

(5$*;00"*0049( 2 2, , 5

(5+8080";###,, 22 (

2<(22, 2( 44 2(2 ( ,22, 2 22 42

45 44 22,,

,44

, 2 ,2 22

24 22

24(52 2 4!")"+%#0 ( ,22 ' 2 22(5224 2 4 !")"+%#0 ( 4(5, (5 "#6*##0 7 ( 42 )0!9 2

!$8+%&,22 2

(

(52

2 24 ( 4 2 5 ( "#6*##0 2

, ( 4 222 2(( =(

(2 4( 255

2 :44 > (5 44 5

2, 2(2,2

(52

222 2

0 2,2 2(2,2

(52

24(52(522 4 2 4 ( (2

5(7

(2 2( "#6*##0 25 :44 2 2( 5

2, , 2(2,2

(52

2222

:44 ,&( 9,((, 4

(5+0$#***"0+ 4 25

(5$*;00"*00- 4 5( 2 ( <(2 2, 2 4 '&(!")*+%&

2, 2,22, , , (5 8 #0"##0#;

8# !9 5( ,2 ,42 :44 , &( 9,( (, 4

4 5( 2 ,2 2 4 (24 (

2 2(2, (2 2(52 2 4 2 , 4 2 ,, 2, 5 :44 2(2,2

(52

2222

, : 44 5 222(2,2

(52 "#6*##02

224 ,(5

5 ,2 4 2,

(242(2,2

(52 "#"*##02, 5 24 :44 9( 2 4(,2 4

( 4( 5 ( , ,425 44(522 4 22 (?220)0 3 24(

7, "# ,2 4( , )05 2@ ,5(53#0;-,

( 2 6 "%;0-%) & 39 &

A 9 25 , 4@B @9@ 24( #800A6@ 4(

,2 "0 C 5 2 (4 ,

,(2

4"0 C 5 2 2"#- 2 2

4#800 C 5 2 2;0#8

2, ,24 A6@ 2 4 2 ,2 , (5 $*;00"*00- ( 72,,5

(5+8080";###,3

2, 5 6 . 6 A6@ 6 0)0 3 2, 2(,( 4!9 252

2, 4(( ,( 4( ,2 2, , 5 2 ,, 2, 22 4 5 , 5 2 4 2( 22

22 - , 2

,2222 2,4 > (5"#6*##057 2 2 ,

,2222 52>4(2

2 "#$$(2

2222

> :44 , >5,( 2( 2 , ,

22 &2 2,

(525 ,2222 4 #800 A6@ 4 6 . 6A6@ 0)03 2

;0#8 2

(

2 , ( 2 ##D E 4 !9

, 2 5 2 ( '

&( ")*+%& 4

2 4 24 2 2

2 (52( 5 444 22( 522, ,422,

2( 522,

, 2

2 ,2 2, 4 2

(2 9/ 1

= @9#0"##0#;/0#F;0G '

+1/&1/(+1* 1 2&.3') +) /.& 4&/(/(+1&5 5 " )

$ "

6 *%++ $

7 3 $ - + /+ 3) 6 )

$ " 3

) "

+0 *+*% )

$ 3

*' + *+*%

/ " 6

+ 6

$ 83 1 2&.3') +) /.& /3/& 9

" "

) " )

*%++ $

7 3 $ - + /+ 3) 6 ) 6

3 4 33 "

% 13'6*(* 3 ) "

" :

)

$ "

6 6 ) :

) 3 "

+0 *+*% )

$ 3

*' + *+*%

/ " 6

+ 6

$ 83

" " "

6 ) 3

$ $ $ . $ " !")3

8 " ;

)

$ ) " ") !

3 8 .

!")3 " "4 #4( ,2( 4 '( 2,( 2 ,2(, 4 5,2 5

5 (

4( (

22 ( 2(225 , (2

22, 442 5( 224 4( ,2( 2, 4 442 = ,44( '( 2,( 2 45

2 ( ,( ,2 '

, 2 D C,22

2 (2E 2 C, H4( 24252 , , 2,, 5 22

2( ,22 5 4 , 2 22 ( '( 2,((2 ; 2(5 45

2 2 4'( 2 25( 2 C 24'( 2 25 (2 55

(54 25 2 (5

( (= 2

2 22 2, 5

,2 2

42 (2242 87

2 2,

425 2 2 (2 2 2 (

2 ,2 ,,2 2 52 ,,( ,

4 (

222 4 2

44 2 4 222(2,2( 2

2 22( 5(4, ,2 '( (24 2 24

,2 (2 2, ,

22 24 4 2

44 2 52 ,, <( 5 2

44 ( 4(2 4 2

44 2 ( 2 ( C,22445 2 ( 5 4 '( ( 2 ,,, 2 2 2 22 4 '( 2 (2 24 2/ 442 5(24442 42 (42( 442 2 (,

2(24(2 2 2C

2 4 5

, @C, 2 8;-4 4

( "*+; <(

24 ,,

2 5 5

5 2

2 8;- 4

( "*+; ),( 2 ( ( 2<( 5 ,5'(

4 2(2,(2,2,

(2 '( (2 2 22 4

(

4 (2 ,2

2 ,,2

5 <( 24 #" 4 2 ( 4 (2 , 22 2 ,5 22 5 2 ( /(

2 ";$#

22 #0"+D8E D

E8"-F

7 #0"+D)E,C( 2DE80$FD#0"+E"0

-)$ - 2 5 (4, 45

2 5 5 ( C,

2 H 4 #0"+ D";E 6@-0* 524 4 2 3(52 4 ('5 D"*$0E#

)-) 52 2 5 ! & / @, "*#8 ( 8+- 5

2 5

2 ,( 2 4 2 2 @, ( 2 "*;"

5;)-

252 45

2( 4(2 2 C, , 45

24 /

5 , , 45

2 2 ( 5 2 + 2( 5(25

2( 5 2 4(2 45

2 4 '( ( 2 2(4 (25 C 2 '( (2 ( ,22 2 24 45

( 522 25 ,5 4,

5 45

(2G

" " " "

6 )

$ !" " "

" ) $ " 3

8 " ;!

#$ !

(

$ 6 " 4

" $

$ ) 6 "

" 3

" ) $

3) 6

/ "

- 6

" 3

)" $

3 " ) $ "

"< "

) - 4 3

6 3 )

$ $ " 8

$ "%

72, %2 =2%! 7,5 =2%!