Asha Grover v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!
"#$$%&'&()*$+#$,-$. / *,#'0".1$.
$#&#&($.
2$.'3'
*#"#$".4"(" #0$.'
$'+(5$(#'
! "#$% &'()*% *) $
.$'$(#) ."($'063,".*0".,"/51%"#$/ .#0$+$#&#&($. .6&."( "7*&(80//".4"("/ .#0$*#"#$ ."89$$#$(&:"7/51%"#$/ .#0$"++7&%"(#' ;;;;; *) $+& 0$+."4$.&(#0$+.$'$(#:.&#+$#&#&((-$0"7+$#&#&($. *,#'0".1$.&'.<3"'0&(8#0$.5$.5"#$5 (($=3.$
>!+"''$5-4.$'+(5$(#>&'#.&%#0&75 .#$%#&( (&#/0&:"(& 0$"%#':0&%0$,"("#$.,#0$:.&#+$#&#&(".$#0"#"#$. /+$#&#&($.%(#&(3$5#:.?"'%%3(#"(#(%(#."%#-"'&'&(#0$ &'#.&%#0&75 .#$%#&(*%&$#4 &%$/0&:"(&#$.8$##&(885"((3"7 "++."&'"7.$+.#7&?$-$0"1&3./%,,&#,$(##53#4"(5?(:7$58$ :.?/0$.'$.1&%$'/1&5$7$##$.&(#$(#5"#$5 @ (($=3.$ >!/ :$.$ .$($:$5 ., ".%0 # 0&7$ :.?&(8 "' "( ''&'#"(#/'0$/#0.3807$##$.5"#$5A B &(#&,"#$5.$'+(5$(#> &.$%#.>%3,> $,-$. *$%.$#".4 .$8".5&(8 "?$ -&77' 8$($."#$5 -4 #0$
$,+74$$' #0$ *%&$#&$' +&(#&(8 3# (",$' #: +$.'('/ &$/ *,# $(3"(5($,&# ."($'063,".*0".,"/7$".($5%3('$7.$+.$'$(#&(8#0$ +$#&#&($. '3-,&##$5 #0"# &('#$"5 7?&(8 &(# #0$ "77$8"#&(' &( #0$ %,+7"&(#/'0:%"3'$(#&%$ (($=3.$ > !:"'&''3$5##0$+$#&#&($.
:0&%0:"'5374.$+7&$51&5$.$+745"#$5A @ (($=3.$ >!0$ 5$+".#,$(#:#"50$.&(8##0$+.&(%&+7$("#3."793'#&%$/&$/'$.1&(8 "(4%0".8$'0$$#"8"&('##0$+$#&#&($.%(.(#&(8:�#0$5%3,$(#'. ,"#$.&"7/ ( #0$ -"'&' ($ '&5$5 $(<3&.4 .$+.# 5"#$5
(($=3.$ > !/#$.,&("#$5#0$'$.1&%$'#0$+$#&#&($.1&5$.5$.5"#$5 (($=3.$ >!('3++.##0$%(#$(#&(/.$7&$53+(#0$ 9358,$(# #0&' 3.# &( ,- . /0-, (1,-, 2 303 (, !,4, ,, . 1 3+()#%(#$(5#0"#$1$(#$.,&("#&( #0$'$.1&%$'#0$%(#."%#3"7$,+74$$:375-$+$(#935&%&"7.$1&$:
$.%(#."/ .6&."( "7*&(80/7$".($5''&'#"(#51%"#$ $($."7/".4"(".$+.$'$(#&(8#0$*#"#$.$7&$53+(#0$'#"(5#"?$(&(#0$ :.&##$('#"#$,$(#'3-,&##$5#0"##0$'#.4(#".5&(8"(4++.#3( .%(.(#&(8:�"(4,"#$.&"7&'"&8,$(#&,"8&("#&("'(3,$.3' ++.#3(&#&$'"'.$1$"7$5.,#0$%(#$(#'#0$$(<3&.4.$+.#(($=3.$
> /:$.$8&1$(/,3%07$''5%3,$(#'"7''3++7&$50$%(#$(#'#0$ $(<3&.4 .$+.# (($=3.$ > 5"#$5 "7' .$1$"7 #0"# #0$ "%%3(#"(#>+$#&#&($.0"5'3-,&##$5&(8.$"#5$#"&7' -&77'#0$+$.&5 ., B # @ /:0&%0'0$%7"&,$5#-$&(#0$0"(5:.&#&(8 *,# $(3"(5
-&77'#0$+$.&5., # @&(#0$ 0"(5:.&#&(8 ,&# *0$ :"' 5&.$%#$5 # +.53%$ .$%.5 #0$ %,+"."#&1$."#$'/-3#'0$$&8($5.$73%#"(%$.&,+''&-&7#%77$%##0$
'",$/#03'/#0$"77$8"#&('.$7$%#$5&(#0$%,+7"&(#:$.$3(5#-$ -"'$7$'' "#0$. &# :"' #0$ 53#4 #0$ "%%3(#"(# # 1$.&4 #0$ -&77' 5&7&8$(#74 "# #0$ .$7$1"(# +&(# #&,$ ( "%%3(# ,"?&(8 "7'$ %,+7"&(#'"(5."&'&(8<3$'#&('"-3##0$53#4"''&8($5#0$./'0$:"' 0$75#-$3(&##:.?(#0$+'#"%%3(# 0$.$&' A@ 3(5$. .5$. 37$ ( -$0"7#:+$.'('/(",$74/,?,"."(5 $(3#-$&,+7$"5$5"'
$'+(5$(#'A"(5@.$+.$'$(#$5-4 ."89$$#$(&:"751%"#$(#0$ +.$,&'$#0"#'&(%$#0$+$#&#&($.0"5-$$((3.'&(8"(&,'"8"&('##0$, "(5&7$5#0$%,+7"&(#:0&%0,"4(#0"1$".>.$"%0&(8%('$<3$(%$'"# #0$&. %".$$. "(5 &( '3%0 %&.%3,'#"(%$'/ #0$&. +.$'$(%$ &' $''$(#&"7 "(5 ($%$''".4.#0$+.+$."5935&%"#&(#0$:.&#+$#&#&( 0"1$0$".5#0$7$".($5%3('$7.#0$+".#&$'"(5"++."&'$5 #0$+"+$.-? 0$"%#'(".."#$5"-1$".$(#&(5&'+3#$53-#/#0$ +$#&#&($.0"5,"5$%$.#"&("77$8"#&('"8"&('##0$+.+'$5+".#&$'/&$/ .$'+(5$(#'A"(5@/-3##0$5$+".#,$(#&('#$"5"50$.&(8##0$ +.&(%&+7$'"?&(# 3(&'0,$(#"(5++$"7 37$'/#$.,&("#$50$.'$.1&%$' 1$(&'0$0"5-$$($(8"8$5(%(#."%#-"'&'-3#0$.'$.1&%$'%375(# 0"1$-$$(#$.,&("#$5:0&7$$(<3&.
&(8&(##0$"77$8"#&(',"5$"8"&('##: ".$,$(#&($5 +$.'(' $8".5&(8 0$. 0"(5&%"+($'' &( (# 8&1&(8 #0$ %,+"."#&1$."#$'/&$/$=%$''&1$",3(#.$7$%#$5&(#0$-&77'+.$+".$5-4 #:+$.'('"'.$$..$5#&(#0$$(<3&.4.$+.#(($=3.$ > &'(#&( 5&'+3#$ ( +7"&( "(5 '&,+7$ +$.3'"7 #0$ $(<3&.4 .$+.# 5"#$5 (($=3.$ > !
5
"77$8"#&(':"'#$=",&($#0$%(#$(#'#0$%,+7"&(#'3-,&##$5-4#0$ +$#&#&($.#%(.(#&(8:�#0$$(<3&.4/+$#&#&($.0"'-$$(3(5 #-$3(&##:375-$&(#0$&#($''#0&(8'#$=#."%##0$.$7$1"(#+.#&( #0$'",$/#0380#0$'",$&'$=#."%#$5&(#0$:.&##$('#"#$,$(# C
!"# "$ "% &"'(
'"
!" "$ '
"# '' ' )
* ("
"' '& '& "! '' '#
+
,
-
*
.
)
-
-
"' '& '& "! '' '#) ,
+
)
+
, ,
/
,
+
+
+
+
,
6
)
0 '
+)
) 1
'% "$ &"'!)
+
,
,
-
2 &"'!)
,
)
+ ,
0 ,
. , 3
)
, /
, 5
,
,
6 +
.
+
,
. 6 +
. ,)
1
)
+
6-
,
,
, )
0 ) .
6
, 0
)
+
7
6
,
+
(" 78-8'
&# '
+ 6
,
&$'8-88'( "' "& &"'(
,
+ 6
'' " &"'( 1 +
0
, )
,
,
0 '6'!
,9
)
4
+
,
-
) + + . ,9
,
,
+
,
+
0
, ,
,
,
- ,
, , /
,
, - ,
+
+
,
+ , :
",#0$1&$:#0"##0$+.%$53.$"5+#$5-4#0$.$'+(5$(#' &(5&'+$('&(8:�#0$'$.1&%$'#0$+$#&#&($.&'(#&(8$.,"($##0$ +.1&'&(''$.1&%$93.&'+.35$(%$/+".#&%37".74&#&'-"'$5(&,+3#"#&( .$7$%#$5&(#0$$(<3&.4.$+.##($8"#$5#0$1$'#$5"77$8"#&('/#0380&(
'#.&%##$.,'%"((#'+&7#0$%".$$.#0$+$#&#&($.*0$:"'.$<3&.$5#-$ ".5$5"+.+$.++.#3(%%.5&(874/#0$&,+38($5.5$.&''$#>"'&5$ .&#+$#&#&(&'"77:$5 $'+(5$(#'".$5&.$%#$5#"77:#0$+$#&#&($.# %"..4(#0$:.?/-3##0&':375(#+.$1$(##0$,##"?$'#$+'�$4 5$$,&#"++.+.&"#$"(5($%$''".4#075"(4$(<3&.4"8"&('##0$+$#&#&($. &("%%.5"(%$:": .&#+$#&#&('#"(5'"77:$5 ( 8 -9 + *) $ ,- &':;% 1 1 38 ,< => ,3
.
?
3>
1 1
,9
?
3>