← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/54637/2018dismissed

Murari Lal Tayal v. Central Bureau Of Investigation

2019-01-22Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram15 pages



        ! "#$ %$&'(')*

   + ,-"-'."/"0"/   $)#-"/,-$", )1$(#'2"#')  

 * 3. 4 4    *          

    

  555   6   !

"#



   $%&  

  '()* +  

,-.

/ 

1 2 &3'4 33'(



'43(&3'4   '&3





$&3 $)'

 

  '%53 +  

, -.

 '*+'.

+ .



 '*+&.

    '(%% 

        +6 '. 0

   ')*  +6 &.



'53*&3'%



 

8

   2#  9 +6 *.

/

     





 

 #  



# / 



'53*&3'%

/ 



 

# 



/ 



'53*&3'%

 







  







7



#

    2#



#

#





#



 2# '())



'*'3&335 







6 7



 9

#



   



  2 :













 1





 





 



  #





    7





7

 2

 

 9





  ; 9

 2 : 7



 #



; 





:

2 :

''3)&33)

    

#





 





 

7  1





 







2 :  9



 

'%35&33)





&335&33)



!

/  



  !



7







 

8

 



<



   ')* 

 





  1 

  





 

   !

7





  

# 

 

 1

#  





# "

 

 





#



 9

  









7

 !

7

  

#







 



  

 

  



 

#





 

: 

 

 !

/   + 

= =.

/ 

7  

 2 : 7

#



 



 

  



:

2 :

''3)&33) 

 

 



 6

&535&33) 



 

 1





  



!



7



7 



# 

7

>  '(%(?

> 



 2# '())?



  

#   

 2 







 

#



    





  2 :



7 

    

 

   

 



 !



 7

 7

  

 "

  

 @



7#  !



 

7

 





  "



"



   

  

#    7



 A

 6



'&3*&3'% 





1%)%% &3'4 

 



 2#













   #  7

  



# 6   





6  @



 



A

 2

7







7#

7



 

# 



 2  7





/ 



&$3%&33)

   

  A  C

 

#    2# +;

4).





   

 

 &*3%&33)  3)D*3



 &$3%&33)      E

 / 





&$3%&33) #

A



2=7 6

   ! " !

#$%&% ' ()* +  !

 #,%-&.*/%.0%*1$,%%, $$% )+ &,",% #  2$%%%  ,% 2,)3,%.% ! +#,$"*( ,$" 4$5$""*1**%$,  ! #)*,"

,3/,0%*2" 4"4,6  7(8! ! #%%, 7  9     9%$  $*  *  %$,  ++  !   

#   %%,   $$%$*/$*-:;.,*%$,++  !  

A

 :  

44$ ()**%$,+++ !)09 7





7

 

  F

 0





 

7

 7

7  6

 

 





 

<





  7

 

/

 







 

F





F







7 

/



 <7 

   !



7

  

A





<



  

#

#   

#

  





 1  6

 

 

 





7





     



    @



7



 



 ;

4)  A  C

 @ A

 2=7 6  





#   



 



  

 7





 

  "







A # <

 A

 2=7 6





   







7











# 7A



A





'&3*&3'%

2-7 6 3 &&,

  %% ,*",$6 %%,7- 

 





&$3%&33)

&(3'&3'3 

 2# 



 6





    









  

7

 

<

 



 

 7

7

 

 +

.

 1

6

 

 &&3'&3'(





   





 !

  7



 '(3 

 #







 





 

 





  &3$   

 

< 

 

# E 



6





!

7

   

  6

 7

  



 7

7



#

  

# 9

 





 9 

  # 7     

7



 '35  @  '%)& 

9

+

 7 





 2

7



 *'4 



 

  



#

 

 

   



 









 







4$#$,</,",%/, *,/)%,% 0%*  ! " ! #& 1 62)  ! " ! + #4%2$* $$%%,=,%2,.  ! " !  #>.*$ "%%,%$  ! " !+ #;- $,%

,)"&%*<?&%$ .6    ! " !#2$$4" %%, 1 ;, $!  ! " ! + #;'"6"- ;"$.$ 3 &&, +  .

%09 !

!*,/*,* #%%, 7- $2$0 ++ ! " !

 #%%,2$ $99$" ++ ) !

  ,/.* .,/-93%0%* 2)  ! " !   2

 









 





7









 7   

#



 

   2#  9



#

#F

   



 

  

 



















9





 

 

 



















  "

 

9



#

 9

#

   

<









 

 



2









    

#

  











 A  7

  

#

9 < 

 

<

 

7

 



#F



9

  7

 

  A



2=7 6 

6

7









7 

 7  

6 7



  

#





 



  9 < 







 2

/

A 





< 





 

 



 







/

 

 

   





A

 2-7 6 @&%;,,&:@&%   ! " ! 



A











<



    



# 9

   



 7   



   7  6

/







 

<



7

 

 0















 #  



 7



/

 7



#

   6

, 9 <-



# 7



A



2-7 6





  





 



  

7

 

<   

 7   '(3  

< 

  7 

6



# 

   

 

A 



 



 

7





 

, <- 

    8

 9

A 

 



  

 









  8





#



9

 H  '(3 +'.

+7.

  



    '(3 +'.

+.



 9



    '(3 +'.

+.





   





> 

 

 

 ? "  

  



 

  

9 <   '(3 +'.

+.

 

# 





A



    '(3 +'.

+.

 



 &3$  

   









 



  9

 



   





 



 

   





  

9 

7  1

7 

9

/

 

  

/  &3* 

9

/









 

#  









7  







  

 7 

<



  

 

9 <

9

  

 6 



   

#F 

< 

 6  

  

< 

 

 7 



9

/

E  

/

0





# 

7 

 



<  



#  

6 

   

#

< 

 6  



F   

   









  ;

/ 





 



  

 

 









#



 

#

 

  

<





  





 

<  "

 







 

/



 7





7#

 



   + 

7  8  

 

;

9 F 

I

1

; 7

I

1