← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/36395/2019allowed

Anar Kali And Others v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited And Others

2024-07-15Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri17 pages

     

 



   

 !"

#$ "%&'&#() * +* ,  

  

       

 

  

 )- . * / / /    ! "" # $ %

 !  '# $ %

 ((((( / /  * 0 1 ) *

+

&   % ,,-

.

   &  /   

  % &    0   

     

%1 

+ 

"

 " 0

  0

 

#   

  & 

  .





& '



2 

,33-  *

+ &&%

 %  



 

  " 0

00 

4 !

5 4!6

&&% &

    

5

&



786

&' 

)

0 0#

,

 

 

9

&&   " &    "   ,33-,33,0 

0 $% &

+ 

)#

  :  

9339,33; 

 

  &    &  %

 +0 &%



 $

  ,*

9 

 "

0)-  &

   0 



 &  &

+  

% %

 + % 0

   + 

 

   

 

%     &   *

&

 

,33;$  9#

)0 &  +

"



 2

1 ###

<    %

$

  









;=:



%/

0&



 

% %

&% ,;%0 +

   

   %%

 + 

&&%     # 

&  

& % 

%

& 

 &%   #    %   0     + 



  0 *

&



,3))#

   )  0  

 &%   1%

 ,;%$ 

 

)>3>,3))5  -6/

% #

 %

&% 

&

&% & + ,33-5  ?6 +

'

 & %

% &  +

$

 % 93>

.

 &/  9

  &

+



&&   " ,33-,33,#

)



0 00

 &99 #

 , 90  *

)



 0

% 0 0

,33, *

&

#

,0



 



   

   9       

 )3@,     &

+

"

&   $ 

% 0 &

   &    &  %

  1&%   &  

 0

+

 &



0

  0   $%  &

+

  " 00  &'  

  



 % &%  



 &+ & 0 %%





&%  +

'

 &  

 +



    +



&%   +

'

 &#

%+

  0

  

 +



+

 ?  &

+

  



& &%



&&   " +  

 $ 

  9

,33;

%

)%+ 

&% ,;%%%  % 0

  

 0

$

 

 0$



,3))$  - &

+

 

,33-

%

"

&% 

0 0& 

$ & % 93>

.

 &/ 0 +

  0

  ?*



%0

,3390

     0

    )  4  



%  )#

+

0



+



&



 

 %  #  & 

  &+    #



% 0

 

 <  



   <  %

&%

,

& #  + 

+ &

&,;% &

+





 



 &%



 +

 0 

% &+  <%  &;=:

  0

%



 $ 0 +

 %



$  9

0 0

,33;

% %

 %+

,;

%

% &,3390 0 <

%



 ;

  +

&%+ &   $

 

   #

% &,33-5  ?6 % 

0  

% &0

 

%#   +

   $     .  ; 

 

&   '

 

#

&



0  % 

$    &%        : 

   

 0%

0   0+



  0



%&%%  && %





 & $%   &



. -

 

%0 $



 % <   + 

     %

    

  $    %

 &%

 0

 

% % 

#

#



& &&%   0  %%



;  -

&  

%  ?0 0 

+



%%$

%+ 

 

%

 ,33-

#

 $ %  $ ,;%

)

,3))$  -

 &

+

% 

%

 

% ,33-#



 &&% 

;

 

%

,33- 





%

,339

  &

 &

  %

 &

 

 &  

%  & 

    ,339# 

%%

,33;0 0 $ 

    



A

% &,33-#

&  

% &,33;0

 /

0

% &

 ,339 ,33;

  0

<

%

%

,33-% 

%  

0

 &% &





 ) ,;%

,3))



% 

 &

 &&% 

;

,33-

% - B 

   #     %    &

 

#+

0

)







 #

  

$



  %

0  

&

 &





 &  #

  

$

+ %  0 <% 

;=:

 

0



 0     0  % $ 

   ) 

 %

 %



  %



,;%0+

<  $  9  &

%

 0 %

   9

&% ,;% +

$

)

,3)) 

0

) %

+ & 

%

,33-

 C

  %    &  

 

   

 &  



 +

.

&"

%



'

 &



&&% 0 

  %&%  0

0

B1'B +



%

%%  3)3A,33-#

.



'

 2 

,33-%



%+ *

 



+ %  +

%  



#

 

+    7!D8  &

+



% & 

 &   

    + 

 .

&  "

%

 

'

 &  # 

   )    +

  

 ,;% %



 &+ &

; &,33-

% &



? - &,339

%$  )

0

% 0





&

 

'

 

 

-5%6

 

%0

'





% %  % 0

 

% 

% 5+6 &+ 5)6 & ?

 0





 &

 

  & 

 $    & 

 

 + 

#&

<

<  

 "%

)  

%

 

0





#

0

 ,;%

%

,339 

$

 A /

    &

 > *

% 0

) 0 0 

0 99  &



& 

+ " 

,

 

0

0

 &)C   

9

 &)- 



&&   " *

)





  &

&&   " ,33-,33,#

)

  &%



0





$  ,



 #

0 %

 



    

  



&



)$  9 *

0

   9 

933;,33;0

%

 % + 

   <  &  ;=  &  %

   

<  

 %   % 

    

%% 

 



% %  # 

%

 0

&E 0





&

 

&%

.

  ,339  

&& &

  0





& 

 



   

 $+  &$%%   0

 #

%

&  &%

&% ,;%

0+

$  )3 *

$

   9 

933;,33;0 00

+

"



 2

1  ##

)

%    "This is to inform you that the seniority list of ex gratia employmеnt саses has been maintained in this office 01.04.3003, in accordance with the provision of rule 6(1) sub

rule (a) & (b) of the Haryana Compassionate Assistance to the dependents of deceased Govt. employees Rules2003. According to rule 9 (b) of the ibid Rules2003 the appointments can be made upto maximum of 5% of sanctioned posts (falling under direct recruitment quote in group C&D categories).

The exgratia employment cases are dealt strictly as per seniority taking into account the date of death of employee in each case. However if your case is not finalized within a period of three years from the date of issue of the Haryana Compassionate Assistance Rules2003 or within three years from the date of death of employee due to nonfulfillment of all the conditions as laid down in the Rules or due to non availability of vacancies for the purpose, your case for compassionate financial assistance for Rs. 2.5 lacs will only be considered in terms of ibid Rules adopted & circulated vide this office memo No.Ch12/EXG3 dt.16.5.03 read with memo No.Ch29/EXG3 dt.10.3.04 and memo No.Ch38/EXG3 dt.13.09.04 respectively."

  

     

 

   

 )) /

%

&  + &

; &,33-  0+ 

  %

$ 

 

%0 

  ?*

 

%

,33-  ?

%  F  !"#

$%&'

$( &$)(**$*'!$( '*+*,*'  - .//0 " *

1  



1  -2

 

 1 3/4

,

* 

& 

2  -2  5  

 

       

1 

   1  -2  2    "    1 

  1 1 

  - 

 2         &  2

  

 

    &  2

 26" 7 879      2  -  1  

2 , 

   1  

        &  2

$ .//0 8.9 2 1 1  1  . -:



    

 2    &  2

& ,; 1

2   

  

  



- "

 -2   1   1  3  -

2 

  1   1 

   -  

   

   2  1  740# #   -  2 - 

     &  2

 5  1  + 1 

 1   1  <879 '

 2&  2



 2

2

1  

  1    1  = 

2

 1      -2

    2



1

     11 "

89  

2 



 

2

 

2



  

 



 

2"  2 > 8-9 

 2  

2

  

&    



   

    

2



    



 

2"  2 -    



  2"

 2 > 819   2  



2

    

    &      



   

    

2

 



  2

 2  8.9   2     -  -   

   2   

 2



  

1  

 

 1   1 - 1

 839  2  &  2

      11       &     1  1    

 

   1    2    

  

  2 



 

2

 8#9 ?

 

2



  &  2

 "   1 

2 



 -   

 2

 

2







-    8<9

  $   1       -        1 

 11   1  0  1  "   1  -

1  



  11 

  2     -     1  1    

 

    1 

   

 





 

   

 "    

$ .//3.//<

1 2-  



 2  1   1   

2, 

  1  

     

     &  2

$ .//0 @ *  2  -           

  1 



1 

  

 -     

&  

   &    8*   "** 1 9    

 -

  A 2  , 

   1  

  &  2

$ .//<

1  1 

2- 

1 1  

   -2  6 !  



 

   

 "    

 .//3 .//<

1 2 -  

 

 2  1    1   

  6"

! 

  1 

 2

1  

  



 1   1

 

  

11 

 2  -  



  1 

   "

,

 1

2 &  2B ), *

 

%$  ?0  

0



+

 %

% &  +

$

 %  93>  & 

 .

   &  /   &     %

 +0 <  &% %

  

 + 

& & '

 

  0   $% 1'

 

*

  " 00 

'  %

  

& ,#

%



%

  0 &



 

     &

  &+    +$&%  ; $

&  '

 

# 

 &



0  % 

$ &%  :

 

 0%

0  0+



%  0



%&%%

+

 

& $% )9

-

%&% $



 %   + 

0   / &

$

& 0

 

<   $

#,339 ,33;

% + #  



&% $ 

 .

 

 

  & 

 

'

 2 

,33- )? /

%

)  

% 

0  $  -



   

0

%

0 %

0

,339 ,33;  *

#

& -0  



  0 $   

%&%

 

 7

  % 8 <   + 

 0  ); 

: 0 0   %  

 %     

 0

 

    %    

 F

 % <   +



 0 G 

*

&%

%   $  % 

& + 

)

,33,#

 <  %



,3390



%&  & +

 0 

,33; 

 

 +

 $

% 

0& <  &%

,;  %   

 +  & 

$        %  *

#      $   %  

 



 &  

% 5  ?6% 

%

,33-0 

 % &0#

0

 $ %



$  9 

933;,33;

$

<  &% ,;% 

 

&% & # $ % 





+ %  &% 0

  

%

   )  0  &  %  + 

 &      F

 % <   + 

 G 4

 %

 0

  & <   &%

-

  %

,330  

%+

) 

;#

)0 

&



<   &% + 

0 +





; )- *

&%

%

0     0

  



% &,33-

%  +  

& 

&%

,3))$  -#

)  +



   ,;

% 

 % % 

)0

,;%

&,339

%0 0

 

 &% 

% &,33-

% 

 

-

 

% &,33-+ %

% 0

 4

-

,33-

%

   

  ) 

 ; 0 

 % %  

 

)%   &

& 0

$

; &,33-

% )C

  %    &  

 

     

    %     + 

 .

&  "

%

 

'

 $ 7! D8#0

+

  

&&% 

"

&

0

B1'B



  % & 

%%   

 )A,33- 

 

  .





& '



2 

#,33-%



%+ % % *

&  

 +

.

&"

%



'

 &      $ 



  &%&%  #

1,33-

%

&    $ & % 93>

.

 &/ 0  & % +  0

% &0+ : 

 + &&%

"

  %  

& 

 .

&  "

%

   

      $  % %



  0

&   % 93>

.

 &/   $  %

.

     

         

 

     !"# + $   AC 1 

   



 

73/3.//@11 - =    - 

   -2



 24A.//@ 8$"79 -

2 



  -

,

 - 1

.//0$   -

   1 3/4

,







4A.//@8$"

79 -

  -2

+ 1 ,   ! 1   1

2 &   2* 



    -2

+ 1 ,   1  

   

 

          1  3/4   

,



1  

  1

 7A.//0 8!"49 

  1 

7A.//0  

.//0 $   -

    1 3/4 

,

* 

- 

    1 3/4

,

1 - 

-

    -2  

1   1   1

70.

,

*   1 2- 1 ,



1 :  D-

  ,



1  $ 

$"

 %$ #!&

"

'()

*+,$-##!*+*'

1  -



2





 - 1  1  ."

 

 /

0%$ #!& 1"

'  2 3$4,5+6  273 (8

+62  3$**(/ !"

 %!!&)  '

 37$,*' 



 -

  21

1 

1   1 1 -   

    * 

    1     

     -2 

 + 1  ,    

1  1           

1 

 1    1 70.

,

  -

-2

   

.//0$         1  3/4   

 ,

  8!"49    -

   2

  



 1     2      -  11 -      

1   



.7/4.//@7#7.//A 8!0;!"@9   25 



  1   1  -2   " " 2   

 -    

 

   

 + 1  ,   

4A.//@

-2  7 04.//@ -  - 

    -

- 

  +

    



11

  



.74.//@8"09

  

7#7.//A8!"@9 -2

    



     

- 

 



 

  -2 

733.//@8!"<9 

 -



 

 





 

12

  

    

-

 !



B )A *

  

 91 #2- 30



+

$  %

.

 

% & 4"# :##

/ 

#;(  !'.

0"   

 

 #   !"#%#"

( !+75 * 

$

 

%  , 

 - 

     

$    $ 

     1

3/4

,

*     2 1  

1 -  



 $  1 - 

-2

     1 

   

    -      1 1  

/A/0.//@  2





  

  2$ 

 1

  -

  -2   

1 

,  

   %         

    

     !"#'  23$4**6  23 $8,5< )> *

  &    %    &  %&%

     $ 

+

 +

.

&"

%



'

 &#

 +





 0

&   % 93>

.



&/ +   % &% 0

  /

% % 

%+

 &   % 93>

.

   &  /       + :     $  

   %  +

"

 &   % 93>  $  % + : 

 +

 *

&& %+ $

 !7D8 ,3 

    0    +     %    &

0  

? -

,339

%

 5  )6 

+

%

)  &%

 0 





% 

0



 



 + & &&% +

)  

    

 

 0  

 &  

 + &

  *

   + 

 &

 



0$ 0

&%

 

 $ 

  ,;

%

,3))

)$  - *

&  %

 +



 )





%

,339 + % <%

% &,339

0

$ &



,;%*

%   +   &



 +  ,) /$ 0

+ &%  %% #

 *

  



& &%

)

;

,33-

%5  ?6

  

%%

  %%

)&

 

%

,33-% 

%  &

  

   ,;

%0   +

 

)# +  

   )#  0

   

 & 

 

  &  

  0



H-=

5 6 ,, /%

   

 

) 0







& 



) +

&  

&

H>=

5 6 ,9 .



 &%  %% 0

+ 0 0 

%   0

0  



+ &   "  

  & +

%     ,;0  

,3))#

 .

 0   %% E%

0

0 00

 %   %   $$  



  + % &+  

$  %

/ 0

  



&  

%

,33-&

%%  % 0

0   *

 &   %   & 

 

#   

   &



&  $ 

& 

   *

 8+ " .

 =

4#

  !"#!> /1-

!-! !  !"#2*+ 537$55  + $



&   % ,)

.

 &/ % 

$ 

*

#

.

 

$ 0

% #

 &

8 

& 

  % ,)

.

 &/  ,? /$ 0

+ #

  0     )#33#3331 5

%60 0 

  &%

 *

 %  

 

)0







& 



/ / 



* +* , 



1 I 1

 4



+ I 1