Sharda Devi v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-.
.
/0#1(# !%2* ......
%$*$*&,%1
3%1+4+
77%#5+8 4,9#:
&$0%1+ ......
%+7&,(%,$+ ; <
/ /
1%+%,$ 1.
=./.
!#(>#58 (2&)#$%8
7%$*$*&,%1.
1.
#2,%%$ /*,?08 /%,*&1 ! 4,9#:.
1.
./.
0#40#,8 1.
&0*$ /#7%0*@#8
+.
!%%7*A# 0#40#,8 (2&)#$%+
. . /
.
%$*$*&,%1
/0#1(# !%2* '*5%( )*2*5 4,(%1 1$*)5%+ &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#8 *,$%1 #5*#8 +%%A*,?
,#$41% )%1$*&1#1* +%$$*,?
8
77%#5+8 4,9#:
+0&1$ ;
&66*++*&,%1; >0%1%:@ 0%
8 &+0*#1741
+0&1$ ;&55%)$&1; .
8
#5#,(0#1 !*2*+*&,8
#5#,(0#1
+0&1$ ;!*2*+*&,#5 &66*++*&,%1;
19#, /*,?0 #,98 %0+*5 &+0*#1741.
.
71#@%1 1%+$&1*,?
>0%1%:@ #,98 %0+*5
&+0*#1741 1%+$&1*,?
.
8 >0%1%:@ 470%5(.
1*%'5@8 &, (%6*+% /01* #1$#7 /*,?08 71%2*&4+ #,98 %0+*5 &+0*#17418 71&)%%(*,?+ >%1% *,*$*#$%( '*55*,?
2#)#,)@.
741+4#,)% 71&)5#6#$*&,
64+$1* 64,#(* )#55*,?
47&, #775*)#$*&,+ '*55*,?
+#*( 2#)#,)@8 %*?0$%%, #775*)#$*&,+
*,)54(*,?
&,% 19#, /*,?08 >%1% 1%)%*2%(8 #))&1(*,?5@8 $0%*1 #,$%)%(%,$+ >%1% ?&$ 2%1*'*%( '&16 5&)#5 7&5*)%.
$1#,+7*1%+ %0+*5(#18 &,% /01*
#+07#5 +&, *5A0*
#6 #'&1%+#*( 2#)#,)@8 #?*+$1#$%
/0#1(# !%2* #'&1%+#*( 2#)#,)@ '&1>#1(%( 6#$$%1 &55%)$&1.
. 0% 47&, #771%)*#$*,?
1%5#$*2% 6%1*$+(%6%1*$+ )#,(*(#$%+8 #,98 2*(%
.
%+7&,(%,$ 19#, )0#55%,?%(
'*5*,?
#77%#5 :%'&1% +#6% (*+6*++%(8 2*(% .
.
. %*,?
#??1*%2%( #?#*,+$ #'&1%+#*( &1(%1+
8 71%'%11%( 1%2*+*&,
:%'&1%
)#6% #55&>%(8 2*(%
>0%1%:@
&1(%1+
>%1% 19#, #,9.
.
#'&1%6%,$*&,%( )*1)46+$#,)%+8 '*5%( )*2*5 1%5*%'
+8 ,&$*)%( #:&2%.
<%#1,%( )&4,+%5 +4:6*$+
%11%( 5#> '#)$+ #55&>*,?
1%2*+*&, 71%'%11%( $0%1%:@ +%$$*,?
1%#+&,%(
8 #77&*,$*,?
.
8 >0%1%:@ 470%5(.
*674?,%(
8
#?#*,+$ +%$$5%( 5#> 6#$$%1 )0&*)% 5*?0$5@ *,$%1'%1%( >*$08 %2%, $>& 2*%>+ #1% 7&++*:5% 4,5%++ $0%1% 7#$%,$ *55%?#5*$@ &1 7%12%1+*$@ $0%1%*,.
'#*5%( 7&*,$ &4$ #,@ *55%?#5*$@ &1 7%12%1+*$@ &1(%1+ &66*++*&,%1.
,%B$ 6%1*$&1*&4+ *,#+64)0 #?*+$1#$%8 @&4,?%1 #?% %(4)#$%(
+ 1%?#1(+ 5#,(0&5(*,?
)&,)%1,%(8 +4''*)*%,$ 5#,(0&5(*,?
*,2&52%( +&)*#5 >&1A 2*55#?%.
#5$0&4?0 %B+%12*)%6#,8 +*6*5#15@8 04+:#,( :1&$0%1 5#>
+%12%( 16@8 $0%1%'&1%8 '#6*5@ 1%,(%1%( +%12*)% /$#$%8 &,% )&,+*(%1#$*&,+ %,2*+#?%( 4,(%1
45% - 4,9#:
<#,(
%2%,4%
45%+
+0&1$ ;<
45%+;.
<%#1,%( )&4,+%5 )&,$%,(+
>0*5% +%$$*,?
#77&*,$6%,$8 &:+%12%( >0*5% #77&*,$*,?
#+7%)$+ 1%?#1(+ #2#*5#:*5*$@8 1%#(*,%++ (*+)0#1?% (4$*%+ #2#*5#:*5*$@ )&664,*$@ (41*,?
5#$% 0&41+ )&,+*(%1%(8
*,(*)#$%( >0#$ 6#,,%1 #:5% (*+)0#1?% (4$*%+ %2%, (41*,?
5#$% 0&41+8 ,%%( +& #1*+%+.
))&1(*,?5@8 71#@%1 +%$$*,?
*674?,%(
:%*,?
4,+4+$#*,#:5% %@%+ 5#> 1%+$&1*,?
&1(%18 #77&*,$*,?
<#6:#1(#1.
-.
%1 )&,$1#8 )&4,+%5 19#, &77&+%( +4:6*++*&,+ &, :%0#5'
+4:6*$$*,?
*674?,%(
1%#+&,%( 94+$*'*%( (&%+ )#55 *,$%1'%1%,)% $0*+ &41$.
%B+%12*)%6#, &, #))&4,$ 0% (%+%12%+ 71%'%1%,)% 6#$$%1 +#*( #+7%)$ *?,&1%( &66*++*&,%1.
0#( #1:*$1#1@ 6#,,%1 >*$0&4$ )&,+*(%1*,?
6%1*$+
,%B$ :%*,?
%B+%12*)%6#,8 7&++%++%+ ?&&( )0#1#)$%18
-
16@ 1#(4#$*&, %1$*'*)#$%
- 1#*,*,?
/%)41*$@ %1$*'*)#$%
- *++4%(.
5#,(0&5(*,?
%5%)$%( 1%+*(%,$ &+0*#1741 B /%12*)%6%, %5'#1% ++&)*#$*&,.
*+8 $0%1%'&1%8 )&,$%,(%( 0#( )&,+*(%1%( #'&1%+#*( #+7%)$+8 #))&1(*,?5@8
0#( 1*?0$5@ &1(%1+ 5*#:5% 6#*,$#*,%(.
*$0 #'&1%+#*( +4:6*++*&,+8 )&4,+%5 71#@%( (*+6*++#5 )*2*5 7%$*$*&,.
.
0%#1( )&4,+%5 1%+7%)$*2% 7#1$*%+ 7%14+%( 7#7%1:&&A >*$0 $0%*1 #:5% #++*+$#,)%.
.
%1%8 #77&+*$% +$#$% 1%5#$*2% 6%1*$+ )#,(*(#$%+8 )#, +466%( 4,(%1 #1$*)45#1+ %$*$*&,%1
/0#1(# !%2*
%+7.
&.
19#, /*,?0 ?%
@%#1+ @%#1+ (4)#$*&,#5 C4#5*'*)#$*&, .
.(.8 !*75&6# .. $0 7#++ 16@ 1#(4#$*&, %1$*'*)#$% <#,( 0&5(*,?+ - =#,#5 =#,#5 #15#
%)&66%,(%( #?*+$1#$%8
/%12*)% #$*&, 4+:#,( :1&$0%1 5#> +%12%( 16@ B+%12*)%6#, '1&6 ,(*#, 16@ .
:#1% 7%14+#5 #:&2% )0#1$ +0&> @&4,?%1 #?%D %(4)#$%( &. #?*+$1#$%8 4A%1*#,.
.
*2*5 -8 &,;:5% /471%6% &41$ 0%5( >*$0 1%?#1( /$#$% 4,9#:8 #?% )#,(*(#$% 1%5%2#,$ '#)$&1.
+ '#1 1%)&66%,(#$*&,+ 5&>%1
%2%,4% ''*)%1 )&,)%1,%(8 #5$0&4?08 :&4,( 1%)&66%,(#$*&,
%2%,4% 4$0&1*$*%+ '#2&41 )#,(*(#$%D (4% )&,+*(%1#$*&, #))&1(%( +4)0 1%)&66%,(#$*&,+ $0%@ #1% 7&+*$*&, #++%++ +4*$#:*5*$@ )#,(*(#$% +4)0 1%)&66%,(#$*&, +&6% 7%1+4#+*2% 2#54%.
$0*+ 1%?#1(8 1%'%1%,)% )#, &:+%12#$*&,+ )#+%
!8
*2*5 - $6# 2+ 0%
%2%,4%8 4,9#:8
<
-
. 5$0&4?08 &>,+ 5#,( 7%$*$*&,%1D &:+%12%( '#1 0&5(*,?
5#,( )&,)%1,%(8 +#6% $#A%, *,$& )&,+*(%1#$*&, &,5@ 7417&+% +%)41*$@ $&>#1(+ ?&2%1,6%,$ 1%2%,4% )&55%)$%( <#6:#1(#1.
%$*$*&,%1 #:&4$ - =#,#5+ 5#,(8 +4''*)*%,$ $#A%, *,$& )&,+*(%1#$*&, 7417&+% +%)41*$@ 1%2%,4%8 )&55%)$%( <#6:#1(#1.
&1%&2%18 )#+% "#
!
*2*5 8 $0*+ &41$ &:+%12%( 5#,( 1%2%,4% +$&&( #:&5*+0%( :&$0 /$#$% 4,9#:
#1@#,#8 5&,?
:#)A8 $04+ &>,*,?
5#,( )#,(*(#$%+ 7&+$ 64)0 +*?,*'*)#,)% #,@ '41$0%1.
.
41$0%16&1%8 )#+% #
$## %&& !8
*2*5 D
0%5( !*2*+*&, %,)0 $0*+ &41$ )0&*)% )#,,&$ 5*?0$5@ #+*(%8 %2%, $>& 2*%>+ #1% 7&++*:5%8 4,5%++ $0%1% #,@ 7#$%,$ *55%?#5*$@ &1 7%12%1+*$@ $0%1%*,.
%+$#:5*+0%( 6#*, #4$0&1*$@ <#6:#1(#1.
>0& &,5@ #771%)*#$%+ #,$%)%(%,$+ #55 )#,(*(#$%+ '1#@ :4$ 7%1+&,#55@ *,$%1#)$+ >*$0 $0%6.
04+8 +4:9%)$*2% +#$*+'#)$*&, )&45( *?,&1%( )#2#5*%1 6#,,%1
&66*++*&,%1.
.
%+*(%+8 ?&,% $01&4?0 7%14+#5 $0%1%&'
+0&> 1%'%11%( 1%5#$*2% 6%1*$+ (%6%1*$+ )#,(*(#$%+ $0%1%#'$%18 <#6:#1(#1.
0% 1%#+&,%( 94+$*'*%(8 (&%+ )#55 #,@ *,$%1'%1%,)%.
&1%&2%18 &55%)$&1E+ 470%5( &66*++*&,%1.
0#$ #7#1$8 *674?,%(
8
&:+%12%(
%0+*5(#18 0#( 19#,
0%1%*,8 7%14+#5 +0&> %0+*5(#18 0#( &,%
#+07#5 +&, *5A0*
#68 '#)$4#55@ *,)&11%)$.
41$0%18 &:+%12#$*&,
?*2%, #,@ 1%#+&, >0@ 0% 71%'%11*,?
71%+%,$ &2%1 8
$&$#55@ 6*+75#)%(.
1&6 &1(%18 %2*(%,$ '&4,( :%$$%1 75#)%( )#,(*(#$% &$0%1 )#,(*(#$%+ &:+%12*,?
+0% @&4,?%1 #?% %(4)#$%( &$0%1 )#,(*(#$%+ #?*+$1#$%8 4A%1*#,.
41$0%16&1%8
#77%#1+ +>#@%( '#)$ :%*,?
5#(@ #2#*5#:5% )&664,*$@ (41*,?
5#$% 0&41+8 6@ )&,+*(%1%( 2*%>8 71%+%,$ (#@ 6&(%1, $*6%+8 #'&1%+#*( '#)$&1 )#,,&$ )&,+*(%1#$*&, #77&*,$*,?
5#(@ 7&+$ 6&1%+& >0%, %(4)#$%( 5#(@ 0#2*,?
(&,% . .
.(.
0&5(+ ..
(*75&6#.
#'&1%6%,$*&,%( '#)$+ )*1)46+$#,)%+8 #6 )&,+*(%1%( 2*%>
4,+4+$#*,#:5% +#6% #))&1(*,?5@ #+*(%.
%+45$#,$5@8 #55&>%(
#77&*,$*,?
#,98 %0+*5 &+0*#17418 470%5(.
.
%,(*,?
#775*)#$*&,
+8 #,@8 +0#55 +$#,( )5&+%(.
/
!
-.
.
+9A+ 0%$0%1 +7%#A*,?1%#+&,%(
"%+
& 0%$0%1 1%7&1$#:5% "%+
&