National Insurance Co Ltd v. Dhan Singh And Others

DHARAM VIR 2019.05.10 16:30 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document


     
 !








 


  
!"

 

# "# $ %  & $ % !
!&
& '
 


% !"
""(&
& '

 


%  !

&
& '

 )


 &'  ()*+,-./01 




'
 


(
 

* 


+
'
+
 

  

"
 
,"

(

-
, &
 .



% *
 ./0 -
+
 
%


*+& 1 




!
//
'
 
%
2 
&
..

(
'
+
 

( 
(
 
((

 
(

(   
(

" 
(



 )


"

 
0



 -
3
 4
5
"(

+
 
!"
(
"

' '
 
'
(
 

* 
(
(6"

 
'


 
'
 



&
(&
( 
 
 
!  &
78
 &
1 

+
-

 

 
+"


"
 9#::;<4*5:.

-&
4 '
'

 = 
''"
 =
'
+ 5

'
 

'
"
1+ 

'

+"
 

""

+

 :

,"&


6
3

'
"

 
("

'
 
& ( 
'
(


8

(
 '

 
  
+


8



 

3
 
+
'
 

'

+
 
!" &
># (
"

!
-

):

'
 

$
& ./

"

 
&
 

(
-


( 
( 

:6

(
"
 
(6
'
6"

 "
 "
#

0:



* 

 




'
(
"

 
 
''"
 
(


+
"

 

'
  &
(
 
''"
 
(

(



'

- -



- .



 
"
'


* 

 :


4
5 
'

(

"
 

"
'
  ''"
 


?

 

'




 
( 
"
'




6


 
 

 
'
 


(


 
>#
(
'

@

'
 

"
 
*+
'  
'("

 

 

  

  
    

    
!  "

# $ %   

    '

() 

 ( 

& 

   

& &  

&     $     *+(,-   

&    $

 &     *.//01234/5


 55 #   6

) $

  
7'88  9   
 ) 



 )     

     

   $ 7'88  

  
  

& ) 





  )

&

  

 

 

 

 

  

 

$)   7'8./ 6 .  

* 

 &
( 


+
 
 :(& ?
'

$A

9
+
$
1
( ?

$A
!

(

+" 


 
 <? +

%6
'
'

* 


+" 


 

'

#"
'

<?

#&

'

$
'
 
''"

 

<?

#



 '

<?

# &

'
 
"


'

 


'

'

'
 
''"

 

'
 

'

 
 
!"

(
 +" 






* 
*+
( 
"
(
 

 &
"
  
'
$A
( 
(
 
 :(:: 
'
>#&
 
 
'

!
-
45

'

$&

 +
'

"

 
 "
'
+
 


  '


(
 
'
 

 



  
(
+?

+
 

'


""
"&
 

 

 
 


+
+


 
 
""
"
'
 
''"
 
"

'
3
 ('
'
 
!"

/

A 
"
(



 
*+


  
 
(
"



''
"


 

''"
 







'
 
 

* 
*+

"

 
?


 
 

'
  8"
+
 



+
 
9=+
! 

B)130)*04+()05/.6)07$3.31/,84  )7)9)0,)0, )019/(':
 ;

$22   
(
'



 
 
*+&
 '


 
 
C
'



+




* 
 "&

 

'
"
'
 
&

+ 
+
 



 
 


+
  *+
'
 

3
&
( 
(

:6


: ('&

# &

0:

+
?


 
 D
'
 
' 

+

"
 

'
'

3
 
 '
 
&


(

C&
(




+ C

 


+"

'

 
"

 
 "
+
 






+ '
'
 
:


 
 
(

8'

'?"

"
 
 

'

 


# &

0:
&

+
 


+
"
  
("
(

 


'

( 
 
*+
 '

 


 
'
'
 
9 
E


.
 


# &) )0:


+8

+"

 

 

'

   

("


9 


, &
 -
(
+ +

 
(
+
'

!6:
+
# & .

0:& (&
 
*+


 
'



.& "

( 

 

(
+
# &) )


;



&
 
'
+
'
"

'( -



(
(

 
 
C
'

 +


 

'
(
'
 
*+
(
+
 
8
 ('



'



* 



' 
+'
 
?


B030!0,3)84 30) /83':



  383*2

* "

(


'
"
'

 
 
0

 
#( 
&
(&
 
?


"
 


,"
"
 

 

' (



(
+
 +


 
 +

 

'

(



+
 +
'




 





  


* 
9=+
!


'

  


<030!0,3)84 ).)0(0
+0,(7'F

=2 % '
<>/4().0,+41(3/4 1103**4$1, &4 ?/01()* )*5+11)':
= %



 
* '
 
  
 
*+
 


 

("
+
  

'





+
8




 
8
 '

(
+
 
+
(


 

' "
'
 
(
'

(
" 
 

+

 

' 
'

(
+

'
 .

9"


+&
(



+
' 

 
  '
'
9 
E



.


+
  *+
(


"

( 
 
 

(" +


!6
+
(
+
# &) )
0:

9(&
+
(
'


+
'
"


+
"
 




 &
 
'

 

+


 

 

'
 


 
(

8'

'?"
 "
# &

0:

 


8



  
+
'
"


+
& (&





'
 
 
*+

'
 



,"
"


+
  9=+
!


B(+0 >+.)( --)(@)* )0, )019/( 84 )130)*04+()05/.6)07)0,19/(4':
  $ %2

&
 ( 


+

 
 
+

+
 
('

 
 
+


+



'


* 
" 

+
('
(


''

 
 

 +

""
 
 
''

+
C
(
  

+
 

(
+
" 
'&
8
 



 

 +

 

'
 
('0 &
( 



"
&
+
"
 (
 

'

6





 &
( 
(6 '
'?

* 
('

 
 
(6
'

)


6" 
'

 


'
+
3
 


'  
&
 
'
+
(
+


C
 

'
 
"


+
 


<31/0,() >93.49)0A)(  (38/,3  )0,  19/(4  84  >)4).  )+,  >+.

B9)(  )0, 19/(4&F ;  %&


+

+
 
?

 
 (
+

''


+"
 

(6

+

:  
 

'
 
 0('
( 

+
)



 

'?

('0 6



 (6
+
 
6

 




'
 
'
 "  



+

 


+

6
 
( 
"
 

'


* &



&

 
 

'?
 # &

0:

+

(

 
"
 


?
 ( 
+



9(&
 
+
'
"
 
 D
(
' 



+
"
+
 
*+&
(
'
'
'

 


 



+


'
 
 
 

(

+
+


 
?"
( "  


(


+

'

'  

 D
(
'




' 
"

+ '
'
 
0
  
#

0:

+
"
(

'

 
 

 

+


C

 C


'
(

+
 
9=+
!


<)-.) /0/()*  04+()05/   $1,  84  )0+  ).  )*3)4  9+9(+  ).  )0, 19/(4':

 2 383*
>
+
&
 
 "
'
 
'


?

 B.

-

G
G
G
G
G


"
&
HH




(  
I
=&
I
=&

I' = * 
" 


(

 
 &
&
& '&
"&


''
'
 
&
( 


 

'

A



&

(

?
 (
 



 




  



J !


"
'

" 
"

   
'

+:('
( 
(


  "

'

'
H &
 &
:&
''& 

'
 
 


8"
 HK J
K J
7

1=!

A
*3 #;
4 

-5
J

$


"

 
 

 


' 
&
'

'
H
&
&
''&
 &
"

"

H
>


 
" 
'
 




 
 '



'

  

"

 

'
  

"
 6

"

 


'
'
  
* 
"
"
'





 
 
"

 
'
 


'
 
&
''&  

 


 
'
 




'"
 ""

+
  

(
'

 
%
8
(:



"L
 
 

'

 =

'
?  


'
 

(

 

'
  
'

 
%
8
 '



+ (



'


 

'

 

* 

(

 




'

'
  &
''&


 
'
 

  * 
%
2 



+'
"


" '

 


 
'&


'
"


 ( 




 

 &




" &  




+
(

'


 
 '
>
 $


(

 
( 

 

 
 


 


'(
9"


(


 
KJ

9(&
 
(


(


 


(  

+
(


'
>
 K
#8 
9"


  
     



!
  

"
#$%&
M @6 
9"


 '


'
 (

)  *+,   %

 -%&"M 16
9"


#.  



,  !,  / 

%+'# "01J * 

'


+
(


(
+ "
+
 

'
("


I 
'

=


(

$
! 
45 
 

&
(




(
 
' 

  
'
 
&


'
#


'

'
>  >

'
 
'&



 

 
 &
 
+
'
 

(
+

'

 ( 



" 
(
+

'





* "

:+8

:

+
'
+
  
+


"

 
+
 


'
3
)
#

'
  $&
 


(

(

 

6
+  

'

( 
" 


+

+
 
 
 
*+



&


 
 +
(


 


 
''

'



= '



)-.)  /0/()*  04+()05/  .6)07  $3.31/,

4+6()

 


+

 
+
 


  

 



 

'
"
 
 
 
 ( 


+





+

" &


'
 
'

  




 /),4 .6/04)130)@)(,/,
 :

# &

0:

%
'
 :



G

G
 N
4

'

' C


'
 :

#

45 # &/

0:
45 4#

0:

'
 


" 
'
 
5


 :

#

0:


'
< :

#

0:

1)*  4 2'

' C 9&
 


(
+
 
&

  
 

0

)&.&

0:&
( 


# )&

0:


 
( 

+
(
+
 
*+

* 

(




 

'
D

 
+

'
 

'
'"
'
 



 
 
'

 



* 



'
(
 
'
' 
 
"
,"

(
'
 
*+&
(&
 
 (
+
 
(


 & )(59 ;' =  

  A  
6"0 ; A  
#+ ;