High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31850/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Sgt Pawan Kumar And Another

2024-11-29Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

! "# $%&'( "%&%)&* $%&'+

!" # $% &# '(

)

,' -., //

/ 0

-., / // / , +,* -./ ( 01 & .123

1 2 2

)

5 /

/ 0

1 #0

,+0 1 )

)

895

*13 1.

:,10 +5 1*

*1*

8

;, 93 )1* 21

<*

# -,

=21<

)

*1-2.

7*

2*3)242*56"%)&$

)

> *1

!!!

4 1

0120

<*=12 =1+

?$ 8 &9 *=01 +*

@=

! ,

0 =,

*1-2 7 ! )$%892572. :3; < =2&$77;!4787$ >72< =1 <) 2.

1* !B

24 *1-2.

2< =21<

)

>=* <) ,0

.3 0,3

*1-2 7

0

2 @*3

)

42* 3 -4

21

<*

# -,

0 =1 =0122

>=

89 ,

3 21

# -,

)1*

"

70=0 ; 1=* 0 14 /

!

"

#!

$

%&!'&!%'%%!

(

!) !

<)21

1*

1<

)

02* , @.

1* *1-2.

=,

)

=:%"47: "!

(

3 -=1< 7* @*

*1*

1@ )1

; 1=* 0 14 / **************************** +

!

#

!!

,-'.

/ ( ( 0

1!2345%'%% !

" # 3'!3%!%'32) 2 @*

1*

)1*

8,) 21

<*

# -,

)

*1 42* 1+1 1 )

-4

&: " &* !%:397!%)"3 C4

=*

<1D

44=@ 1*>,*=1

)

,4,2 11

* 700

-4122<

@E@ <<-

*4

23

22*

<.3 *) 12 1+3

2*3 <<-

<-11 *4 1-20< 3

1<

<1 *=*3 . 1)) ,)

2< 0

,1-2

0

12

,1-2

1=:,

<3 =)2

0

>,*+<

G-2 );

3

=1 2* $ %

!3

)

*

& '

((

&)

2@1 )1 1+ 1)0

*= ; 1=* 0 14 %&!0/

6

7 8

%'. !

9

: (

;

0

3&4%< 0 # ""

3=> ! 0

!" 9

!? - 5 32 @! A

! 0

!

& ! "

!? 32 @! "

B

B

!?32 @! "

#

9 !?32 @C "

(

""<D

; %''%E<: 7D

;

<

=4 &

! >'!

F

9

!) !

=@

1* +89

1- ; 1=* =)23 0 ,+0 *2.

*=21 3

*1-2.

12*

<<-

<-11 *4 1-20< 3 70=0

;

,)

0 ,+0 ,=0 *1-2* <<-

@12**

<.3 . 0

1+ 4

*1-2.

023 1+

*1-2.

<<-

<-11 *4 1-20< 3

12* 70 *1-2.

:,1 ,<

3 <) 1@2.

*=21 1

=1 **2.

= 11 *1-2.

*=21 1

>

: (

;

0

3&4%<0 # ""

3=> !

,

3 0 ,+0

,<)

1+

)0.=12 12 0120

<<-

*4 1-20<

)=122.

1+

22*3

=

1- , - 70 *1 (

0 ,+0

4,

,<)

*

1

==,

,-:, 2.3

01))

*

1

89

*13

,<*

:,2

"

@= <<-

*4 1-20< <) 1@2.3

@

7< :,1 4 8,)

*

<)2 .

=13

<1

*=01 +*3 ,)

=21<1 2*

=@ *1-2.

(

41= = =,<1 1 *1

@=

=2 2.

, H*3

*=21 700

@E@

:,2 :,1

@= *5

1<

C <1.3

0 4,

=)289 . =1

12

*1-2.

2.

/ <

1==)1

=

** @1@ - 70 70=0 7@

=2,**

.

0< 4

2* -9 4,

*

1

43 <1.

,-:, 2.

=2,**

@=

1<

12 *1

, 4 <*=12

)

2* ,2*

01@ -

*=*

<*=12 ;1< 1

<1*3

2*

,)

1< 722

*<*

01@

*, .

,1

8,)

1

1

=2,* +

(

*=21

<1 *1

+,*2 21*

01)

I&,*

8(21

J I$ 2< / & =)2I

4

3

* 700

1- =)23 700

<

2<

)

<.3 14

2< <*=12 ;1< 1

<1*

01203

-=1<

=

** 1- ,

- 0< *5

700

-=1< 1)) **

<1 1+ (

*

41= 700

=1,12

;, ,)

*13 *5

43

22<

)

1D )21=3

1=@

0<

-.3 <1.

=2,*

:,2

@=

<.

,=0

-=1<

"

1**

+10

=

*3 700

** 122.

=*

<1D *12* =@ =* 12 =0=D3 )1 =,21 2.

1)) 1

1*@

*13 0

,+0 <)2 .<

1

<*=12 =0 :,3 @2 -2 =D =01

=

=

4

<3

-=1<

=* (

4 <)2 .< 412 ,21 2.3 <1.

=2,** :,1 ,)

,-:,

1)) 2< 1D

)21=3

12

7*

+

@= -*

<1

2.3 4 <)2 .* =0 :, 1+

1)) 2< 1D )21=3

21*

=2,

<1 =*

*13 .

<1

0- 2<

2

<.3

1@.

1

= ,21 2.

,-:, 1=@ *=

5 ,)

43 *,

,2*

1, 122.

21*

722

=2,

1=@ ,)

-=1<

=*

44=@ =1,12 =

=

,2* 12

*1-2.

7@

*1@

; 1=

)

-=1<

=

** 21 *

+1 )1 1+ 1)0

<),+

; 1=* 0 14 / **************************** =!

"

;

!

!0

!

!)

!

1*

=

@12 <

1)) 2< 1D )21=

-=1< <1*

=)2 8,) *=21

G-2 );

=1 2* $ %

!

70=0 7@ **

-*

)

3

2*

<.3 ** <1D 2<

+ 4

*=21 1

>,*+< 8,) ,<)

=,

:,2

41@ 1-2.

7* @1@

)

#0 ,+0 ,<)

-,1-2

21* @*

-, ,<)

-=1< =1

)

7@ =1 @* 1**,= *=01 +

@1@

)

3

2.

-, ,<)

1, 122.

** =1

*,.

+1+ 24

*1@

1 +3 0

,+0 <)2 .<

1

-2 =D =01

= =1,12

=

=0 :,893 <1.

-=1<

1@2*

<.

23 -=1<

=*

=* 12 = 41<2.

0

. (

1*

<*=12

)

722

<*

1

12 -=1<

0

-=1<

! 7@

1*

)

8,) *=2 -

=

**

.)*

1

01@ -

=

**

; 8,) 19 1*2.3

@*

-,

,<)

8,) -

2* )

-.3

1

+@

7+01+

)

<*=12 - ; 1=* 8,) 19

)=, ,2.3

* =1

1+

22

<*

1

-*

=1

:,2

=* 12 = 41<2.

0

.

2.3

*=21

1**

*=21

@=

)

,

>,*+<

);

3

=1 2* * !

" # B &+ (( , &')&- 70 *=21 1

<1*

; 3 4

*

7*

* ,21 2.

,

*41-2

+0 -=1< @*

)

D :,1 1))

*

<1*

41@

$@

7 *=21 1

<1*

*= 8,) <1D *=21 1

;) ,21

<3 -.3 ;) ,21

<3 <1*

*= 8,)

<1D ,

4

4 @1@ *4

2

3

2

< D

7< <1* ,

4,22 <)2< 3 )2 , -*

)=@

-1 4 .3

*21.

21=0

4

3

4

1))

*

*= 8,)

# -,

,44

22+12.

,)02*

7&24 "$ "%:397!%)"3

14 <103 4

)

70

- @1

1- @3 1< *<*

<),+

)1* 21

# -,

<1 1 144 <*

)

+70 * 1))2=1

893 4 . /

/ 0

/ / , +

KL 00

)1D +5 1

* / ?5

00

)

1-2 / ?5