High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3415/2019disposed of

Yogesh Kumar v. State Of Punjab And Another

2022-06-01Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj53 pages

!"!#" ! $ % !&"!'" !

"()&# ./ , """""

00 1 . 2

"()&& ./ , """""

00 1 . 2

"()!' ./ , """""

00 1 . 2

"()!( ./ , """""

00 1 . 2 , 34, " .1 ." 5

!"#

$$ " " %&

' ()

&"*$+

$ "

72- 1 ." 5"" - .

" " " / "

" "

0 '

-10!

"2 '&'3#/

" $

)

" "

" $860 "9089 ::%9; < " 6 69 %68 . %

()!(7 !&* + ,-

: 068 6 .%

: $$886 6

% '6 -78

-999- %

-9<9-0 '

$ $ ,0

9---9-1

',<0 9-0 9-

97 " &

" : " "

9- !

# +

-7 , ;

" '

"19999984

,999-9

9-99-

"19999984 "

9- !

# '6 -=

9-99- %

-9<9-0 '

$ $ ,=

9---9-1

',<0< 9-0 44444

()!'7 !&* + ,- &

" : " "

9- !

# >

-7 , ;

73- '

"09999984

,99997

-79-9-

"09999984 "

9- !

()&&7 !&* + ,- '6 -18

-999- %

-9<9-0 '

$ $ ,<

9---9-1

',<0= 9-0 44444 &

" : " "

9- !

# >

-7 , ;

" '

"19999984

,999-

--99-

"19999984 "

9- !

# '689- %

-9<9-0 '

$ $ ,7

9---9-1

',<0 9-0 9-

90 "

()&#7 !&* + ,- &

" : " +

-7 , ;

" "

9- !

# '

,999-

<99-

"19999984 '

"19999984

74- 9- !

. ..

7()!(7 !&*+ ,- .

4 $

8" + (

($ )?;"'/(,

@ .

$ @ % "

"19999984

/ "

" $

, 999-9

9-99- / A%B' ) ( @

/" "

999-/ (" 2+ &

3 .

$ " B "'$""@

-9<9-0.

$+ ""

" ""

9---9-1

7()!'7 !&*+ ,- .

4 $

8" + (

($ )?;"'/(,

@ .

$ @ % "

"09999984

/ "

" $

, 99997

-79-9- / A%B' ) ( @

> "

99-9- " /"

/ (" 2+ &

3 > "

75- " B "'$""@

-9<9-0

$/"

$+ ""

/ "

$/"$"

" ""

9---9-1

7()&&7 !&*+ ,- #" .

4 $

"19999984

/ "

,999-

--99- / A%B' ) ( @

A/ " /"

/ (" 2+ &

3 ; "

8"+ (

($ )?;"'/( ,

/ +

@ .

$ @ % "

-9<9-0 ""

$ " B "'$""@

" ""

$ + ""

" @

9---9-1

7()&#7 !&*+ ,- < .

4 $

8" + (

($ )? ;" '/( ,

/ +

@ .

$ @ % "

"19999984

/ "

, 999-

<99- / A%B'

76- ) ( @

" "

099- / (" 2+ &

3 .

-9<9-0""

$ " B " '$"" @

$ + ""

" @

" ""

9---9-1 0 $ / "

" $

$ / +

0 / +

7'&'/"$"

/ "

$ 7 *

" / " "

" " $$

" " "

" ' "

$$ "

"$"

$ $,0

-909-0

$ $ ,7

-909-0 A "

$ "

90 "" 99 1 ;

/ "

/" $ / "

" *

" "

$$ 9

" $

"$("

77-

" A "/" "

" /

" "

4 $

" $("

" ""

" "

"/ ""

" 19999984 /

/" ""

"09999984A "

" $

"$$ ?

$ " "

" ""

" "

$ $ "

$A $

A + ' ;

"+ !&(-=.$ 6 &&" -9 .

$ "

A + '

! "#$#!$ % "&'

; /"

A '

/""

A + '

. $' /" "

/" $

" '

( ) *

78- +)'

$ "

!& #,-=89-<

-7909-0

/"$"$

(-#

. )

/ !" #$# !$ % " 0'0 A/

C / "

0'&' / +

7 '&'"

' /" "

" $$

" $ "

$ "

" "

-- ; "

$ "

- ;

$" " ""

0'&'/

" "

! "! # $%!! !& ! ! ! ' !'' ! !('! !

79-

! !'' ! # #& - "$ " "/"/

" / "$

$/ "

"$$" C " "

" /

" "

/ "

" " ' ""

.. - ;

" /

" "

/" C

A + ' ;

(- .*

. $ 1 2 %!)

"2.% 3

$ % . '/&00 .

A + ' /

/ +

0 "

) * + ! ,!!!' *' #! ! ! ( ! ! # ! -

710-

* !' . ' ! ' ' . ! ' / '' #!

1 . ! ! ! ' / !! ' ! !

'' ! '' *"! !!' * ! '! . 2 3! ! " 4 5 617 " 8 2 + 9 :! : " ; !$ < ! = ! ! ' ,!'! ' < -=

(

" !

4" /

% $

> * ?' " !!' ' '( !! !! !

711- 8?'"8 ! @ +' +!! ! ( + !!"! +!' !''! !!

A . @! :B " ! !8(?B!!! ?'" *

!+ >1 C' . 8 *+ ''!! !!!"' *" !! !! ?'"!!!!

?'"

9 . ' !

! ' ! !'!# ! ! ! -< + $$

( % 5 %

6 )

$ % . '

=9=9- A + ' "

*!!! ' ! 8# $

: !

7" $$ 4

; % ) 83: !

&"7$$7 2 ' " !' '

712- D! * " ! ?' " # !! !& * ! !!'!+> "%" ! ! " #! !! !D!! ' ' *" ?'" !" !' ' 4 !,-$

+, :!

7" $$7 2! !' *!@ %!! ' ' '! E' B! !!' +>

"%" .'! ! ! 8 # ! ; % 2 ! ! ! -+, +. :!

" $$ < - .* 93 % .% . $ 1 $ % !)

"2 .% 3 + . :!&00" $$04<!-8 )8 :!

" $$74! !(' " !'

1 * ! 88F ! ! '!

713- !! ' D! !,-$

* ! 88F ! " / ! -

% % !! "! !! 1 > * ! 88F + ! '!! !' ! ' !!! ' *! 88F !'(' ! ' * " ! ! !' '

D ! * " '!'

) * '! ! ! + >

"%" * !! ! ! " ,- $

'$& ) G! + > "%" ! ! . ! ! ,(

714- ! / !'! (! ! ! ! !'' ' ! !'' !' !!! ! ! ! * ! !',!! 8!' !'+> "%"! ! ''! ! !

''' '' ! ! ! ! ! ( H ! ! ! ! !! ,!'@! 8(? !

) .-

% % # " / ! !! '!' ! ! !' . ! # "/! !' '! ! & >II+ ! + >

"%" !!

715- !

! ! I

) * !! ! +>

"%" ! " ! ' '! ! !' 3 ' ! ' ! ! * ,( ! "D ! ,! ! J ! ! ! ? !! ! !" !

4 !!+>

"%"!

" " !' ' !' ! . 8 #

" !!' ' " '$&

* ! !"! ' !' ! !' ! .%" J! ! +8' . ! ! ! !

716- !B .' ' !' !

!! ! ! !

8!"! ' " !! ' ! " ' !!' @ "!'' '!

# ! * ! ' * " ! # ?' " ! ! * " > 3 !!' !! *" ?'" # !! ! !! ' - 8 ! !! ! ! ! '! ! " '' + >

"%" ! -

% %,-$

* ! ' !'

4! ! !' !!! ( E' B .

717- ! + ) "%"

!! ! ' ! '! !! .' !!! !! ! ' !!!!'!!' ! ! E' B !!' # !

. - " ! EB !! !' *#! !! # ! !'+>)&/61&8 )&/ ! )9 .%" ! ,! @' / '! ! ' !+>)&/.%"!( +G%! H-.* " !! ! '

' "! ' ' #! +' ' !! !& !'F!

" 8 691!"8 69 ! " !' ! E# ! ! !B

718- * !!! " ' !' ?' " ' ! ! * ! @, %, !

!+>).%"!+ A!88 .C',2 !! !+>1 .%"!+A%H8 161 . F'K !+6! >)&8 .%" * ! !' !(

' ! !! 8 #

' ' "

!' ! . ! ! ' " ! ! ,! ! -0

$ " C

( 8#

7" $$4

2 A + ' "

" $ $$ ' "

/ /

$ $

"/ "

$ "

719- -7 ;

( ) 83

-= 3

% . 7 &

9=9991

9 $

-7 , ;

" -77- .

A '

$$ 9 "

A ' /"

)

+ ' -1 " /

(

! " #$# !$ % " &' .

" "" $$/"4 21 !2! L' ' ' 2! # &

?' " 2! !! ' ? ! *!! #!2! 2! ! * !,! *! 2!!2! *2!! 2! . 2!!' ' & ! ! !"?'" ! 2! C '! ?'" *" !!

720- ! ! ' ' ! + >1 C. 8 "+'+K " !! '&

!!+ >1 C.8 4 ''! #!$ < *! #! 2 A)))) * 2!!! ! !'! ?'"" . ! ! ! , ' & ! / ! # ! ! ! ( @' ! + >1!

' , ' C! # !(!# ! '&! * , (+ >18 ! !!!! @' .!! ! !' ! < * ! " .2!! & !'! ? '!" * ! 2 A>J& * 2! !

721-

) ,!'" ; M ;! " !' ! !! ' ! ' " !! !!! ! !!!!! ! , ! * "! ?' " !' &' !! !

# . ! ! ! ! ' " !'

.?'"! 2! ! ?'" 9 A/ $$)

" (>

) 83

0 !" #$# !$ % " 4 4

$ "

$ $"

/ "

4 * ! & +"%!"!! ! ! ! ! !!! !'

722- ! ! ' 2' &

+ ! ! ! !'' ! # ! ! . ! ' ! ! ! ( #! . ('! ! ! # ! ! # ? ' +" !! '!! '' ! ! ! ! .K % ( % ; ,))A

2"2

" 99$ ))A

+""A?N +" ! '! '' ! !! "! " %!! ,!! '! '!

! '! * ! ' ! ?N +" ! !&# + 1 > 2 % 8 ! !!

1 *,! ' ! ,!' ! ?' " ! ?N +" +"%!"! !''!! #

723- ! * ! " ! # +!( ! ! ! " "" ' ,! ? " ! ! (' ! ' ! ! !!! (!(' '!

+1J "%!"!* ( ?' " ! ' ! + 1 " %! "! ! '! ! ?N + " @ 2 K! !( !' " " " !' ' !

! '! ! ! 1 " %! "! !! ' ! ! ! ! " !!,!'! ' ! ! ! * ' ! !!! '! ' * ! ' ! (! . !

724- " ! L

! " !! ! ! ! !! " !'!!'' . # + " %! "! ! ?N + " !! # ( '! - "$ " "/" "

" "

$ "

" / "

" >

" "

" " $ ( $ $

C "" "

" " .

" /

/ " "

""/ "

/ "

" " "

" "

" /

' C

" "

;/ "$"

-1+

$ &

-10 .

" C

$/ .%0 (&0; :0068 %>&*=( 2> +

! " ,

725- .!%"! A 19) ! " D ' !" ! " !

. " ''' ' ' ! ! ' "$%!!&

! '! D

''' ! " '

> 4 ! ''' ! ' ! !! ' .%0 &*0; :0068 %>&*=( 6 *(! '! '

! (! ! '! !! !'

H (!

! .!%"! A 19) $%!! !>6.!%"! A

19) !! (! !>1)!"!! ! !"! !! (!

726- 1

.!' ! '! !!

'! ! !! & &

6!' ' ' '! !!

> .'!' ! '

!!!! '! !!

. ! !!!

'! ! ! ! ! ! ! 1

4 $ ,$ % ) 1

2&/4 > '! , * ' '!!!' $&

! ! D

! ! ! D

!(!

' 6 ! ,

! D

! ! ! D

! ! '! !'''!

727- '!

! ! ! ' &!D

! .!%"! A 19) ! D

! ! " 0.. .! % "! ' ! ! !!"' ' D!! " '$ %!! '! !! '!@' ' ! ! ! ! ,! ! ! ! ! ' "$ "

" / +

0 '&'"/" "

" 3 "

9 '&' +

- '&'

$ ""

/ "

-1 '&' /

/ " "

" " (

9 "

" +

9 '&' "

" " "

" "

$ "

728- '&'" $ " " " "/

0 '&' $ " "

$/ " "

"/"

/" C

/ "

E +

-'&'

$ " / " "

-1 '&' " C

" /

" "

$ " $$

(

$F+

9'&'$(" "

/ " " $ $

" "

$ "

'&' $ " " " "//

/ +

0'&'"

$" $

$$ "

$ $ $" $ $

" $ $ "

" "

"/" C

" /

" ""

729-

$ "

/ "

0 '&' "

$ "

-10/

" / '

" "

$" " / $$ "

""/"

$ "

" "

A + ' / "

0'&'E

/ ""

" / / " "

" "

K K 2 "! 3

"-10;*17 =

/ "

" = <

1 '

" (

"-7 '

-10 /" "

% "

)

A '

(% # $

"9=# !&40" $ &0"

+ >A

# ! ,!! ! ! ! ' !' *

! '!'

730- @# * ! ' ! . !! !! ! ' ! '! !! ! ! ! # 8.! >A

! ' ' ,!' @! !

$ (!' ! < .

" "

" /" C

( . )

$% ; #

$ % . 4& &'

9-1<.

" ""

4 0

< < !! "! .!! ! ! ! '!! ! !!! !(!(! :'! !! '! " (! !(!' /' '

731- ! !' . ! & '!! /! !' ! ' ! * '! ! ! <!'<" !

+ >6 ! ( ! C ! * ! ! !!! ! !!

0 "

$ " "

" "

@! 8(? + FO K /

" "

+KM+!K

$ +

9 '&' $ "

" " "

$ "

-"/ $$ "+

0 '&' 7 .

" "

/ " $

/ "

"" 8"

" /

$ ' C

$$/

732-

# .

# >

# '

" "F

# "8"

" "

" " F #

" "

$ 8

F # "

" $$ "

" "

" "F

" " (

# E

" " " .

" "

$$ " / $$ "

$ $

/ " "

" " 1 "$

"/"

" $

" $ "

$,0

-909-0+

" / $

" "

$ "

(

" $ "

$ "

, 949-1 "

$ $,0

-909-0 "

733-

" 9 .

" /

" "

9 " "

"/ $$

$ "" -9 "

$ $

-1 '&'"/ $$ "

$ ' - .

" /

" "

"" / "

" "

" / "

" $$

8" " 4

# . "

" ""

$ $

4 $

" "$ "

$$ "

" "/"

" ; " $

" " /

" /

/ "

" ""

" " / $$ "

" "

;

" / ""

" "/

(

734-

# ;/ $"

"/"

$ $$

(

" (" " .

$ '

/ "

" " $

4 '4949-1 .

" $

$ "

"" C"'E-

" C

GC' "

" "

, 999-9 GC'-

( "GC'

(GC' $ $

"GC'"$

"GC'=

( 9-4-GC'< " ( 9-4-GC'0 $

9-4- GC'7

9-4-= GC'1

'49<49-1 .

" $

$ "

"" C"'E-

" C

GC' "

" "

, 99997 GC'-

( " GC' $ $

" GC' "$

" GC' $ GC'=

( 9-4- GC'< GC'7

9-4-= GC'1

735- $"

'4--49-1 .

" $

$ "

"" C"'E-

" C

GC' "

" "

GC'- ( "GC'

( GC' $

" GC' "$

" GC'=

( 9-4- GC'<

" " ( 9-4- GC'< GC'7

9-4-= GC'1

'4-=49-1 .

" $

$ "

"" C"'E-

" C

GC' "

" "

, 999- GC'-

( " GC'

$ GC&

$ $

" GC' "$

" GC'=

( 9-4-GC'<GC'1

$GC'-9 .

# ; " "

/ "

4 $

" "

$ $$

736-

C ; "

/" ""

-79-9- $$/

9-99-

--99-

<99- .

" " / $

/ "

( $

" $

" "

"$$

"9999984/"

"$$ ?

" ""

/ "

# $$ $

" ;$$5 "

; "

" "

"$$ "

"/ $"

# .$$ $"/ $"

" ""

$+ ""

" @

" A

" "

$$ "

# . " $"

C / "

" /

737-

" $

""/ $$

# .

$ $

( "

$ / " " "

$ ""

" "

" $

/ "

" /

$ "

" " ,/

$ "

, $ .

" !"

# " "

" $

" "

" " /"""

" (

(

A + '

" ;

" " B $$ )

" '

@ +

!+ # "

" "$"

" "

$ ".

;

/ /

" " "

" "

" $ $

" ""

738- "

(

""/ $$ " "

$ "$

/ A + '

;

" $ "

" A

" ""

" "

C $ " "

A + ' "

( ) 83

-= ! "

; "/ A + ' "

" "

A + ' " $"

(%)

'" $$/'2/

/ "

0'&'

-7 , ;

" -77- /

/ "

" "

" C

4 > *' " O K / +? ! 8 ) > +""

!' +

" ! !! # ! ! ! ! !',!

739- ! . !!! !!" !, ! !!!! ! ! . ! ' ! !' !' ! * !! ! ! !!!!'

* ' ! " ! #

!! . !! !' ! !

A .!"/ + K P " 8 C 6A1) 9 !! )> ) ) ! ' ' !"' ! ! ' '! ! ! ! !!

! ! !! !! ! . !! ! ! !! * ! !!' O K / ! ! ',( ! ! # ! ! !!

740- ! G!! #!! !! !! ! !!! !

.!!

) !! ! ! C! ! ! ! ! * ! * ! ! # '!! !! = .

"/ $

$ " $/ / $"

$ $

$ "

/ " $

$ "

"" " "

" "

$ 4

A + '

(

" !

% $

" .

" $ "/

"$"(

E $ $/"

$ (

$ " "

' "(

" "

;

$/ $"

" " $ ( " $4

741- $ $

(

" "

$ $

" / "

$ "

"/ $$ "$

" ""

$ $

" " "

" $ $

"$$

$ "

" "

(

$ " " " "

$ "

' " "

" $

/ $$ < A

" "

/ "

$/"$ "

/ "

$' /"

$/ $$ ' /

/ "

4 $

" +

=0!# '&'

/" "

" /" /

4 $

$ ' " "

" 0 " 5

" "

(

A ' " "

/ "

9- '&' " "

742-

" "

" / A '

9-!#'&' / +

7'&'$

" "

' "

7 .

$ "

"/ "

/ "

/ $$

" "$ +

9-!#'&' / " A ' ""

" $$ $

/ " " $

9-!#'&'

1 *

/ " "

A '

A ' " "

" "

$ "

$ C

" 9 A

0 '&' " $

" " "

$ "

0'&'

$ "

"" "

743- "

$ ; " $"

$ C

"/ "

" "

" / " $ $/;"

$ "

9- /

" /

' "

$ "

4 $

' + ""

" "

(

$ + ""

" @

" $

/" "

" "

=0'&'.

A + ' "

2#-

.8 %

$ % . 004

9909-

" $

/ "

; " " "

" +

=0!#'&'

" " /

$$ $;

" "$"

"" (

=0!#'&'"

$$ / "A ' ""

/ "

C "

744- ) *('# !! G! +>A"!"! + &+

+ >A "! ! ! ! +>A > .!$ <>A H! P

> " ! " ',!'! ! !! ! , ! ! < *! !! ! , ! !

. *3 + , 2 &00!

" #$# !$ % "4& :!&00" $$77! ! !!!+>A! + 6+ >>! + 6!+ 1.!% "! * ! '!! 3 !! 2 A))J& ,! . ! !! * !! !! ,! ! ' ! * ! !+>A > ! !!! !!!' ', * !

!' ' ! L ' !! !, . !

745- ! ! !' ! *

!' #! <

* !! ! * # !! (' , ! ! . ! (! # ! * !!' ! 2 ! ' * ! ' ! <

!' !+ >1! 8 +' + K ' ? +' ! ! ! !! !!!+>A > "!

> G! ! "!

! + "!! ( ! ! % !

! ! + !$ < A

! ! ' ( '

! ''!D

"!' ! !$ %!!!! ! ! ! ! !' ! !! '! !!! !+>A

746-

* + F ( '' ! &

!! ! ! ! !

> " !

" ! ' ! !! $ %!! ! !! <

+ > "! ! !! ! "! ! !! " !! ' +> +> "!! $ <> -

3 8 ! ! ! "! ! !

!! $ %!!+ ! ! + >A6 ! &

+ !!'N!+>AN

! ! ' N ! !+>A6N! ! < *' ( "! !! ! 4 !

+K 8 8

?+8

A +9.!%"!! #!

! & .!$ < 9 1 % % B % . ! ! !

747- !! !! ! !

! <

9 * ! " 8

+ . 2

" #$# !$ % "&'&:

&!4"#.>7 7$ ))6 9+""9A8 #' " ,! ! !! ! + "!

' ! ! * " ! ( , & > +>A ! ! ! ! ! !!

* !&&&"/ $$ 7 !' + >A > "! " ! ;!@'4" ! ! ! # !!! .

! ' !

;!@'4"+6

"! !' !'2 A)))J&

! !2 ))))J& * "!@' ' (' + >A > "!

1 * ! ! !' ! '! ' . + >A > !!, ! !! ! . !!'! !

. ! ! !!!# & * '' ! + >A > "!

! !!(+ "! H! ! + >A > L ! ! !' ! . + "!!! !

748-

! ! ! !! !+9 .! % "! . O, ! ! !! !,! !+ "!'! % ! ! "?+' ! ! * ! ! !'! -

( %

$ % . 0&'B0&/

9=9=9-0 A + ' /

$ 4

" / " $$

- '&' .

C "

$/ 2 * ' #

!! ! ! + >1 C' . 8 ! ! , !!!' A 8,8 2

"#$#!$ % "&'&:!

&"'$$ '7 "!$ <6 *!' +> $ <> @ !! ! 8 ! ! ! "! ! !

!! $

749- %!!+ ! ! + >A6 ! &

+ !!'Q!+>AN

! ! ' Q ! !+>A6N! ! < +> ( ! ! ! "! ( +9. % " >) +9. % " ( ' ! ! ! 4(+ 9. % " $ <9 +& . !! !

!! !! ! ! ! ! < > *+>A > !

! + 9 . % "

('! !!& <

750- 9 * ! # - .8 % 2

!4"#$#!$ "/ :

!4"#$# !$ % "' 0$

! "# . C> % !#.>" 4/ :!

"0$$/ 96 * ,!'(!' +> " % " ! + + 9 .! % "! * ' + ) . % " ' + !' !! ' ! !+>A > * * !' + > +

! +

( !

! +>A

!>A > L ' ' !! ! !+>A > +> + ) . % " ! +

! ( ''!

! ! !! !+

* !

!' * +

!,<< '!: " !+>19

! ! !' * !+

!: "' ! +>A

! '!+ > !+>A >

751- 1 8 ( ' !!

! ! ! '' ! 4 ) * > - D

" #$# !# " 77&:!

4"0$$ 4 40 ? '! '! ! !' * ! ' ? ? @ $ = D3 $ 1 2&7!

". ?#70/70&$ < !!' !!' ' # ! !

! ! !! H 6>6 * ' D! '! ' '' < 6 *'!!+> ! <8<(+98"+ * 8 8(: !:! + *C! )) >+"" >9 * ,'! +> ! ! ! ! ( + " % " +) % "! ! .

$/ $$ '

4 $

" "

752-

A '

/ " "

=0 !# / +

9-!#'&'

; "

# . '

$ "

,949-1 "

$ $,0

-909-0

(E %

)

-7 , ;

" -77-

9---9-7""

$+ ""

" ""

" "

" $

# .

' , 9<49-1 "

$ $ ,= ' , --49-1 "

$ $ ,<

' , -=49-1 "

$ $ ,7

(E %

)

# .

=0 '&' "

$/ $$ '

/ "

=0 !# '&' /

$ "

/ "

=0!# / +

9-!#'&' A ' "

" "

$ "

" "$

" "

*/ $$ ' "$$

9< " "

753-

" C

-7 , ;

" -77-

"9 "

<= ;

-7<9

$ "

-8 C "

" "

# .

$ "

" 4

" "$$

$/ "

" "

$ # . "

4 $

"$$

(

" /

$ "

" $/$

/ A + '

( %

$ % . 0&'B0&/

9=9=9-0 .

$ $ $$/

" "

+1 ." 5- !&> ! O 5;; $6?096

9 5;;$ 6@8 9