High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4558/2018dismissed

Barkat Ram And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2024-04-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra13 pages

!"#$% & "#"'#( !"#$

)$ *+) , ,

, -

*+) , ++ ! !"#$ %&# ##% !#'#$ %&# ###$ %&# (! )#"$

"*$ ###+! ,!#!#$ *$ #### ## !# $ *$ ### #) # !+#"$ %&#( #-! !#$ %&# ( ./# 0 #"$ %&#+! #)#!$ %&## !#+#,!# !#$ %&# ( 12 3# ! ! ,(& 4 ,

, -

. 1 ! !!#+$!&"#'!# !!#(6#& "( #&& !' 74 ,%"8 &"99:;990(!,(< #( #&(#+!#(&#(=#! (!(&# #

19192>3?:4;@(!&1>A@% B,3*4B?922>;1@>.#

&"##(&# # 11192A3?A;:(!&1>A@% B,3*4 B?922A;1/9/ # #+# @2 # 9.1111 3?124=# "# (#"" )!+#12:/)!#110:'"1@;;11;9;93/?@&!#!4$19;930?19

&!#!4 #" '# 19?1: 3( ( #&= >?1@ ( ( &''&#" "#" !!#"# &:9$:/C::#* ## %"'"#4#-#'# # (!#922/?2:D B 4#&(#+!#(&#(=#! !(&#

# 1/@113?114;@(!&1>A@% B,3*4B?9211;1:1@ # &"##(&# # 12@193?1.4;:(!&1>A@% B,3*4B?9219;900:# #+# @/ # 9091.3?1@4+! "#

(!(#"" )!+#12:/)!#110:'"1@;;11;9;9 3/ ? @ &!#!4$ 19;930?19 &!#!4 #" '# 19 ? 1: 3( ( #&=@?0(.2'# + # .2'* "#"

!!#"# #* ## %"'"#4D ,

EF B 4=#! (!" ,;

;99@.2A # 9>11103?1A4 ,$ F 3 04+! # %#&= "# '#

>?1@!(!#( %"'(&''&#" "# %"' "#( F 3?:$?AC?124 "# '# 1?9#&= ! & !#( "&!# #( (#%(! "

#'"

; F #3 124 !+ !#' 6&!# +!! &("# " 12D "(!#!#!# 6&(++ ((!#3 +"

!+&'"'#"#( # &"# "6&#! !(!((&#"

$+!!#%#& !#"((!%# "

3 124# !&(!( #&= !#' ! # ( "& D %4#&(#+!#(&#=#!! #(< 22/: # 991>3?994;1@0$1@>$1@A$.9.$@@0$/2:<, # !# &* #'# =& !$ "

#!#&( 12 '#"&" # &%#& +! ! "&#" "& >CA#!+(& " # &(

+!!&'#"&#D %4#&(#+!#('# #'(!"

' =;% ##!+# +!#"## &#&"# (! #&= !'

""#( "&# !#' #( !%# "

12# !(!G ! %"% !'&'#"&#3?994D ;

%4#&(#! &+!&!! H ",'# '

##!&"#(#&# &&'#&(!&#$&" ! # ( !&#" ! # ! #'# ;

&'##"#+$!(-&D # (!& &=&!" # 9>11103?1A4 # </: # 991>3?9.4$ ! &(!

(! H ",I

9 !#"( (!# %# &'

!!#(6#& ' 4 !# ! #&= #! !# # #" #

&#&"$# ;$! !# #&)# &!"&$#) #&=! -&"# $#'&!#$ !"# (&?

12$ '# ##(! &@(&#$ # &#' !B# &=&$1>A@3!#(( !&#"" #!H&(1>A@H41919922>$# #"+!!#

"# +#&" # &"##'# &:(!H&( 1>A@H1119922A$!# "# &" ! #+# @2 # 9.119211 4 !#! -&"# + -&'#(,%"

811A11(9211 " #H)/ 01 2#'3456 #5

5+5!0 ,545 "7484#4*. +!$!,#('#)

&# %#34$ %#34 +!( &' 6#&

!#($& '#)(&!#+!! # ## &(!#&= ##('!#&#""#&= ##$ ! !,( !##&! -&%&'"#

&#'&! !' (!#&= #! -&! "# && $!#&=$#!!, #( &# ! #$ !# ! + ( ' '# !# 6& ! !""$!+!## " "&

! #

' () %' *+,) ' ()!

%' *+,)! % % & '

!! !

- %

# %

' #

# #

# .#

/ 4 ,="$!"# &"(! & !#+!! -&"# +#" #"+! ! ,$!+!!# (&# &! # #! #&= #! "#"$ & !# # &! ! &##"'#)# $!#! "# 3#4# &#'#""+ !+3#4#!##" = #&& ! 3%4 !# ! 6&!# +!&! !# +!

&'#(! -&"# $!?&? 12# ! F #!$!#"'#(#%(! #&= #!$#!! &"# "6& !+(

' '#&#""+!!###&= (!( + (# # ( "!##" &" !#

6&!# 3%4 !# & &''&#" %"'$ !# &''& !#&= "# !# + &$!#

# ! $! & !#! -&"# #" = ((#&"# ! "&$ #!!#&= "# # "# ('#&=

"# 7" (51#:52 4 #5 ;

'34<4#!7"("#

#5>8 !1

1#:52 ?153 5151"# .

#"!(!#+ ! !!# (" ,8.9.:(9211$+!$"( '"#!"(&"#' !#++! &#%# ! +%$&% "!# + +# ' #+!

#+% 9.299211$ +!" ("#(!+! #&"# @ !##'#$&%(!# %$!#+ #! &#' !#921>$+!#$!#"

&'# +3#4$+! +# ' # +!

#+ +!" ("#(!$!+#'# 9.299211$ ! +!!#+ &#' "# " $ & ! #" + ' # +!

#+ ,="$!##!! # %#%%& ( "## "#&! / ! # ( '#) ! # % &&" &' #) ('!(#&'$!#!&!#"" !#($!# '# !#(#"'%#"# $&!# (!#(

"#"$!6#6(#& &'! ! # %%&# #&!$! % -& 6.

Even the Hon'ble Apex Court in a judgment rendered in case titled "M/s Star Wire (India) Ltd. V/s State of Haryana and others", reported in (1996) 11 SCC 698, has in the relevant paragraph of its verdict, paragraph whereof becomes extracted hereinafter, thus declared that any belated challenge, as made to the relevant lawful fully terminated acquisition proceedings, thus is hit by the vices of delay and laches, and thereby too, the said belated motion as existing in the instant petition, is but required to be declared as misconstituted. "' 0 1 ! !

! #

)% % ' 3 4 '

5 # ' ' 6 $ " '

5' * % 9:; << 3=4 '> =;!

@ "

# ' &

9 <<63 4'>>= ; '0 #

' + 9 <<634 ;!

> %

' 3 4! ' "#

%# A#

$+ :

@ !B >

7) #

C-

0 304B !B 78

E3 <<64 '>> ;!

%! ' 3 4

# #

% %

' 6 )

# ' % 0 7) #

9)$1 <6 '> 6; > F

. %

% !

%. % % ! % 5

! # !

F 78

5+ $

93 <3 4'>>= ;2' C% 78

9)$1 <'> <;2) 7) #

"#, 93 <4 '>>=;2C-

5 C 78

* C !>

.!F %7) 9)$1 <'>=<=;2' 5 @ 78

H B D

9:5 <<3=4 '> ;2$#5 !I

& '

9 <=' '>>6=;2' 0& 7 8

* 8>( #* F ' % B !)

9 <=' '>>6=;2C > !

* #

C 78

9:5 <<3=4'> < ;

' * % #

, '

93 <<634'>>

< ;

> * >

> & C > " F % #

5 $

,#7$# > 0# B 78

9:5 <<63=4'> 6;!#

> % > % '

3 4! ' 6 > ' "

0 '##"("$#(( #%$%#" !#! "# (!+##&= +!# > "$#&!#+# @2$#'# &("# '# ./99#&$#+# +!(+#&

9.119211$!(!#&= "# +# "%

! !##.>9$! #'3

4 A

& "$#&!#+# @/$#'# &("# '# 12A@#&$#+# +!(+#&

9029921.$!(!#&= "# +# "%

! !##>90$! #'3

4 12 %$+!(! &# !"$ #(( #%$(! !+$ ! &&

!#(#"#'(# &'#$!!#+# 3#4$#'&%"&' #'(@$9@$>@$>>1;?

3#+# @24# 1.$//$29$20.;?3#+# @/4#!!#% "# !"# +$+!#$! #"#&#'!#

!,( J$* #'$(!

#%#"# "( "# !"# "&&

11 !($!((&(!# %$##""!#! && $!##

& # =# &!# % & &(!!#( (##'$#$" ! K " 6,% & &#" #H$ ,# ) %H C H$+!&! 'B03> # 4@

< 6(< = 6$!# # $ #4## #' %!#&=

"# !#&= #! (!&' (&(! !#,'## ##&B# &=$ !# "## "'&$921.3!#((!&#""

#!H&(921.H4D

4!# &'##'

(! "# !"# "&& $&#""

+!!# !#% '# !&' (&( !H&(921.H 19 "#"!#"! &#&"#'! '#) (#"# &"##'( &9@394(! ! # ,'# # ##& B# &=$ !# "## "'&$921. 1. !# & !# #" &# ! "$ #(( #%$!#! -&"# ## #"&'(!"# "#$ ! +! ! , & (' '#) # (&+!!"#"#"#"!&# &"#' !# ! (&#34 ( #&=34 # = =#! !&#&"#'!#!#&= "# ## #"

&'(!"#"#!&#&"#'!##&!! -&"# "# ('#&=

1@ '#"$#"+!#('#) (#+# 3#4 # "% ( ( ! -& "# ! #&=

#!$ +! # ##" ( ! &'# #'!# "# !"# "$!!&'" %'( !$"# %!#&= "# ! #&= #!$# $+!#&&'#&'" %'( !$ " # !% ! "# " && "#"$!&#& !##! "# # !#&= "# ;# "# ('#&=34 1/

&$#"'#(#%!"$#(( #%$!# ! -&# &#'( !

&/(!L&(1>A@K(! !#&= #

"# (' #&=$ -& +!( &#' ( !(#&'!#! #"&6 ! #&= "# $ #! &#' ' $ " #( ! #

-& +"" & %$ +! ! -& !# -& &#'' ! !#! #"" &&34+6 !#&= "# !#&((&# &@(!H&(1>A@H +# =" 1: <="+!#(!#&(#(&#

&@(!H&(1>A@H!#&'"%'( !$" # !#&= #!$# $#&&'# %'( !$"# $!"# "&& $!$+! !# #"" &&34 &#'# !#&= "# !#&((&# &@(!H&(921.H "#"!# &&34+#!G "# !

-&"# #! -&"# !% !#&= #! !($!('"-& ! -&3#4$ !#! -&"# +#'# "( "# &&'#" ! ! "( ( "# ( &!

&&34;#&=$!+##+""( &" 10 !# & &# ! "$ #(( #%$ (! !+ !#"((&? 12$!# !6&!# +!&!&& ?!"# (!# $ # $! #'&& $!+#'(!"%#"&

+#'(# " !"&) #&& "#(

F $ &'(#&"# +!##&&!"#"+! !6&!# +!&! &#' ? 12# !

#'&& $!## #+"" #"' "&# ;&# & ( # "& "&!($!# 6&!# ' (#&"# # "&<="$!# 6&!# ?' # "#! #& ( ! % &#"" +! ! "& +! &#' #!'#&!#"" #! #&(! 1> !#! !!"# &"(!!#

!# % %#34# (&$# &#' & !,&#)/ 01 2#'3456 #5 ;

'34<$# $ ! !#(&(""& !#!+(' '#$#

&#' 6& & ( ! -& "# #! !# &"# "6& 1A

+%$(!# # !#($! # '= -& # #&!-&

92 !#('#) (!# %(&$ &'

% !(#&'$!# ! %#3#4# &#' # !# ++'" 91 %$!!#&#$! &#' #

! "("# !# "(-&(! #"&#34("&$#'&!#$!,'#) # %?

#?%!# #"&#34 ?& +!!#'

(

&@>(!L&(1>A@K$# $#"+!!#'

(! "%#"& 99 !($ +! # # 3#4$ ! %#34 3#4+'" # "'#""!=#!

(!' (&#34#!+!!!#

&# + # "( ! 6 !# ! -& ( ! #"&#(!#&& ("&$! &

'(!"%#"&# '( &@>(!H& (1>A@H!($$"#&+!#%&" "#& ! 3#4#)!# %6#& ## #! &# !-

'3#4'# !, 9. ##'"#"+!!34 &"#'# ?& #(!-& #"&#34("&$!

'# '( &@>(!H&(1>A@H'(! "%#"& 1#4> !

"7521 "'5 9@ <#('#!$!,( '!+$ # $+!!# % %#$!#' ' !'

#&= (&#34 # &= ! #+# 34 # '## # #(('

9/ #& 9:

&!'#&#"(!# & $!$#""! #"&#34$(#$#"# 34 ( ;,

, -

< ;++ < )#% ! 8!!#) ;#

; 8!!# " ;