← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3811/2018allowed

Balvir Chand v. Jatinder Singh

2020-03-13Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal17 pages

 

 !

 

  "#

 "$%#  &' ()(*

 &(+& )  

'' ( ,(-

&' )(. /+

0 ) '

"# 

1 "$%# &2 (&  

'' ( ,(-

&' )(. /+

0 ) '

"

# 

 3 "$%# &4& //&(5&  

'' ( ,(-

&' )(. /+

0 ) '

"6#

6 "$%#  +& 7&  

'' ( ,(-

&' )(. /+

0 ) '

 %* 87% .

79.

  

    

 

  

      

" #    

 $

    

 

79.

7:

 %& 

"

 '

 ( )*++ )*+, )*)-

)*./ 0/+*    

    



 

"

    ! 1   

 2  !     

  3      

    

  

  !"! # # $ 

          $      #  #    %&'

     4  $5

  

! "    

$5

    

7 7

+)3  !



 

  - 0//+  

)+ /, 0//+  5"

(

 8  

    5 "

   5 "

9 3  5 "

:!   " 

   !

 5 &   "

   

!

8  ! !   ;   "  & 77  "

  

   " ! 

   75 "7 (3  8

+)3% !

; 

3    ( )  *  + 

#    ,

$+ *       * +# #  **+  # #     *   +*     

    *

   *  $ * *    -

    $# )  

      # $*+ $# 

*+*  )     %&  .

#$#*+$ ) -

&    

+            /    ) -

%& + # #  

$ 

*     + )     #

-   

   !"" 

 

                 - %&0   1  )      )       *  *     *

*  2     *  *        $+ * + $   3

  

    +   +* / 

 # $   $+##*+ 4 **  $$ #  * 

*  $+ ,  / 

##*+  #

*     ** / * **+

#

 /+  $ $     *  

 !

  #

  "     $(   

   ! 

 

   

'

 ( )*+, 0/+*

 3  "    

8 !

   "

"

 ! 5 #  "

(  "

3!



 , &  5 "

& 1       5  1 

     9 

   "

  

 +*3 

8

     

3

6

&5# . * # # * /  #    

*$#

. ("627$ %8 !& "6227$ %9 :& +#   /;# . *  $     $*+  (  1

  <$  (   

<$  (  #      (       ( /<$ (=/    + * #              

  



 $  #  #  (5#  * # /  /    #(*

40#( >*    $$ *# # +   

     +   .(   ?    #      $   *( <&  5    #     * +   *     #    



 

   # #

 4 $*+( 

*2(  <$  (    >*  2  (  $  @  *

42  >*   02(  2

$ .  4 (**## +  / #  #      #          +      # /  /#  * 3

#  # 

# * +( 5 ##* 2 #    *        

  /*   #  #    (A 8 & 3  "  

3 <5 )  #*+      #   % &       $    1

  

 #   /  *  $   

1 * 

< ($  # ( 5     *     #   *    $  

*      #(   5  #          # /     #*

$     .# 

 #  #*



#  * ( &) #*+ # %&   $  #   *# #              #          #   *     #*(**# #  *      (A = 

' "     5       

8

  (  " 

3!  &

  ! !

!



*  

  

 & 5  3! = 

'



5

      9 

8

&    

' "

 " 

 !"

 3 <+ >   5  

   

 & ?@ >    

 &  ?@

) > 

 5  ?@

.

>      



;

   ?@

, >   

"

   !



 ?@

>      

    

   

 ' ?@

 C 8

  

"

 "  5

3! &

   !

(  " 

3! 

5 "

! 3  "



3!



3!

 ; " 5  

3! "

 

"

    

"&

  

3! 5

5 



3!

 3 ! ! &    &

"

 :   ! &   &

 3!  



    5

  3!

  "  5   ; 

"

3! 5    

3! 8

 5    

3! 

(

 8    1     

  

 5"

(

 8  

 

  "





 %

"

" 

 %    !

%      & '

(   )* %& !

!   3! 

<



 5  

3!

  "





"

 :75   '  

"+

 !

,   &

-.)/(( */

(!

 "  "

! 1 

   

"

@   "

  53 + +)3 

 53 +)3%

    " 

   5 "

 5 &   "

    !



 &  5 "

 "&    ! 75 "7  0 

& 5 "

 

5 "

5 "

4 



5 "

    ! 75 "7  "  



 !

 5 "

8

&       53 0  ! 

&

:  51  

 5 

   3! 

 & "    ;"

 " 

=    

 "

  5 

5 "



  

75 "7

  5 "



 

  51  

 5

:    5    "    

 "         

& 5   3! (  "



@       

  5   ! 75 "7  

"

:  5  5 "

 

 5 "

:    5  

 " " (

 8 ! "

   @ & 

 5   ;"

 "  &

5  

"

 51   

:    5  !

    +)  5  



! 

 5

4 '    5      

  &

&D 

"

 8

&  

3!

 5   3!  

"&

 ! 

    



"

          !

& (  "

(  " 5"

3!       5

5 

 3!

        !

 ; 

 3! :  51  

3!



"

" "

  

  & ""

  +)3% 5  

"

  

 53 0  

"  ! 7 7

@  "

 530      !   

     

9

  5 "  

  

3   &   5 "

   5 "

   5 "

  

  8  ! ! 5 "

"

="   

 

&   5 "

 "& 4 ! 3 5 "  5 "

  5 "

  &  0 0"

0 !

; 

3 :(   0 %&    01   * *  $ *  **+ # #

   , %&      ,    *  *   $ + *       * * ( %&   0 * * $

  * *      +#    $ #  #  *)  # *+    # *+     (A 4  (

 8 5  5

&    5 "

 "& :!

(

 8  ; " 

  5 "

 "& =    

 "

   

))

"

 :75   '  &) . /+&45&  % +.& : "1#  .<<( =      5  :75   '     5  3!

 5    3!   & 5      

@   "

"

  

 "

!

  

   &

"

 

  "

     ( )3: !    :

5

"

  & "

( .3:

4  5 " !   

8   ! & ! 3! 5 5 " 4

 :75   '  !

 !    &

  

   !

 3! & "

( .3:

=    

  



"

$ " !

"

 & '

'-((/1

8

   :75   '  !

;

"

  ;  ! !

 &     

 " 

"

 "  

  

 & ;  "

"  !

 :75   '  !

  !   5"

;

  '  =    

 "

3 

  

)  " % :75   '  

" %

2 ! ! 3   &  '

-(( 45( /)-

=      !



'   "  ..

 !   

"

  :75   '  !

(   

 "

!

   4 :75   ' 

E #           "  +* !

; 

3

;(5/ # *

+  # #   *  $

     

   $     *     $

 **  $$

 , &  5  1      9!(9(:99!       $$    4    +      /       #     ;7 

   $  $/    /*  $ * * 

  4          +     * $         #   *:"6%"&4  (

&5> *   $# $$   $ 

1   ) **  * B4 C # 1 * C * D  +7 > )-B  D  +;> ) B$      $      #*  $ ) -# E D  +!> ) /*(5 $ * *  



* 

 #/

4 * $      

    1   )   *   4 C #    !88   F      G$    !!!  (

&         /    #   * 

   * $/  1    *      

 +   * 

$  +    **    1   /  H /   )          / * * "4  ( 4 :75   '  

!

  1 

"&

4

"



E #  

   

4

 ;

 

  @   "

 5   

(

 8 ! 5 "



 9   5 "   5 "

  5 " &

@ (

 8 

5 "

!

& &

 5 "

    51 &    

4 !

 5 &     5 "

5 



 5 "

!

!

  9

 ! 8  !

  ! !

 " !   !

8

&               5 "

!

     &    ! 

 5



 %

!

:75   ' 

:!  (

 8   9

; " +)3 % 

 5  

"

 51   

@   (

 8     

    +)  

   

+)3  

 " (

 8 "

  

   "9" &   &    !      &

  +  !    

"

     "

!



4



 ;

 



" %  !

  "

& 

  +)  ! ; 

3

6!      

 #  *  *** /   $    #   

$$$  

   

   $  +  #  

 # /     I #  $   

  

  !"7  3*+$( %:&**  ./  **##*+ 4 **  

   *()4 ** 

 /          *  ##  +    

    ##*     J &#     + $

# *  *

  +  #

+  $

  $ +

   **   + $  +*+ $ **

    #+ *, /             

  

     ##*   $  / #+   

    

# # $ 

   

        ##*      +   4 **      **    $    /  *+  #   

  

  $  -

&5 $$$ 

 

**  %&5 

 

 *  *

*  * +#  -

&  *  * # #

    * 

&5$$  * .*+ $#

$

**+/*  * + *  * 

/&  *+  #  *      

%/&5   *    #*  **              #+    *       #

 $

  *  4 ** $+$.

 # **  #  *  *  4 **   **$.   ##*  , /       4 **  $+   /      

 *   $    #     **     #     

*  *$+  $  $  ( %& %&   **   $+ ##*+      4 **     



 #**  #  &) *  %&? 3

    # - &? #+    * *   

   - %&?/ * 

   $$$    

 -

6 %&  *    +  

  /  $#*+$**         $$$     /  $#*+$, /      .$          $   +    **    $      /   

$#*+$  / # /  )

* @ # !"7 ** *  * /  * $#

+ 

$     $ *$  $ +** (K I% &)   * *   **   $$  $  )  3

  #  $ *+ #   # 



+  

  7)  * %>  & !:8   /  # *  

 $  ( 67     F # #  #  #J %&5 # 



+** * / / **   /  # * - %:&JF$ *+J$ * **   

*+ * /

 $ ## $-K

&)I   * *  K *  %&? 3

    - &?   #+    

      # #   + 6I *  K * 7I$+ K- %&?/;I *  K *

   $$$   

   - I%

& + *  *   3

  

++ *   . L/ $

**

+ +)$# /$5  $ $# /$  /*#$$  $  

$

 -K /& I+   * * K  3

      *  $ +    #  * +  J   #   J

  $        #              G *

    !6         $

  %&                #+       

     + *    *  $

  $+ - &?

  / * 

   $$$   

   , /   +  # #

  # **  ** :

I**  #  #  #% &   *K##*+        #

+#

, /             **        #     I    *    *       *

1

*  *K # /   #  #% &   #  #%

&**  *##*+ 

  #  # # + *  $* *, /             **        # + *  # /   #  # /&**  *##*+   

#  # # + *    $+     $( &54 ** **     * $ **    $.

 # **  #  *  * $+ # +4 **  4 **     **$.  ##*  , /       4 **  $+   /      

 *   $    #     **     #     

*  *$+  $  $  ( I%&0 ##*   $  #  #% & #  #%&  **  #  $+  

  #

$ * $**  # 4 ** **$.

 # **  #  *  #  ** *  + $  (K %"&0 **    #  * 

* #    #  #% &

 #  #%

&#  #%&  %&8I  $*#+  #     + $   $ *+ #    #  #% & #  # %&  %&  $ *+#+   *

*   # K    + $ *      #            #  #  % /&   #  #%&  %&  #+   # #      #               #

 */$ $  # 

 **    #  * 

 #  #  %

&          #  #  %&  #  

* + * +  /  $    / $+##*+ 4 **      

 **    #  *  *4 ** ** $.   *+( :I%" &0  /  $   * * 

* *  #  $    # **   $+  



 *    *  

   

 *     #  **   %&@#+   #

 $ $/   

&

 #

 +  $/    * * +#  *   $

  /  +#   / $+##*+4 **  



 #  * **   

;  $4 ** **$.   *+(K %8&0 4 **   +##*  $ + **  /   

/* /    4 **  $+  

    $#           # #  +** (A @   "

+) 

  !      "

 5 <&   "

   

!C  ; +) 

4    



 5! "   

+) 

 (

 8 3  

"

 +) 

:!

 " " (

 ! 

  

 5 & 

@5 &  

(

 8  !   8

"  & "

    5 "

 "& > "

 ;

"

    

& 

 5 "7

 0  "

4 "      "

"      ""



"

4  "&  0   &  5 "



& 5 "





5 "

4 :75   ' 

  75 "7

 7 5 "7

:!  5 



5 "

5 "

@

 5  "

   

 5 "

!    75 "7  99&

5  

"

   51 & 

"

 5 "

<  8    

   9   

   

"

     &

 &"

 

5 "

:!  

 5 "

5   "

   51   ! 

 5

8 ! 

& !    

"

"

4  "   !

 " 

   &  5 "

!

& &



" 5 "

: ! !     " " 

  

"

 5 "

=    3   "



!

 5       

 +)  5  

 5 

 &   "

   

! E"

!

      

!

:  

!

4

"

 





'+%&(=+: 

"

79.

7#

'

     > 

"9  

F9( >  5 

F9(