High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30037/2024dismissed

Union Of India v. No 3180431 Ex Nk Om Parkash

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%%$

! &!' !"%$%$

( ) ) *" +,* $ ))

) -

+,* )$ )) ) * !"#$%& '()'((*!#(*%+#,-.*/"

0-/("1"/)/)-2"' )

) -

(-! (/(")2'/*2/4)/1"/)/)-2+/("1"/)/)-2"'("")2

2)-2-02#)*+1*%'0-/("'"//)2 *')#"-0/("-#"#*/"# 522"6!" 7+ *' 1*''"# $% /(" 8"*2"# 9"# -."' )$!2*8 .-2."2"#+4(""$%'/(".8*)9-0"'1-2#"2/- 0-/(" *2/-0 '",).""8"9"2/-0/("#)'*$)8)/%1"2')-20-/("'",).""2#""#$% ()9)2"0"2."".!)/%-1'57(*'$""2*88-4"#+$%.-2#-2)2 /("'(-/0*88-0:;#*%'0-9/(""<!)')/" =%"*'-0<!*8)0%)2 '",)."0-"*2)2 '",)."1"2')-2)2/("

/'0&/1/'23 &!

"'1-2#"2/- 4*'"2-88"#)2/("2#)*29%5("

> " )9"2/7 -2 ;: *2# 4*' #)'.(* "# /(""0-9 -2 ; "'1-2#"2/ - 4*' *2/"# "/))2 1"2')-2+ *'

*#9)'')$8" /- ()9 *' 1" /(" "2')-2 " !8*/)-2' (""*0/"+ "'1-2#"2/- 4*'""2-88"#)2/-"0"2."".!)/%-1'5 '",)."7 -2 == ..-#)2 /- /(" 1",*8"2/ 1-8).%+ !1-2

*//*)2)2 /("* "-0'!1"*22!*/)-2+"'1-2#"2/- 4*'#)'.(* "# 0-9'",).")2/("-2 ;*0/""2#")2 *'",)."-0

%"*'*2#;:#*%'+4().(4*''(-/$%:;#*%'+'-*'/-9*?"/(" '-8#)""2*$8"#/-.-918"/"/("<!*8)0%)2 /"9-0 =%"*'+0-/("

1!1-'" -0 *2/ -0 '",)." 1"2')-2+ /(!' 0- /(" '".-2# '",)." "2#""#$%()9)2/(" "'1-2#"2/ - 4*' #"2)"# '",)." 1"2')-2 $% /(" .-91"/"2/*!/(-)/%0-()'2-/.-918"/)2 /(""<!)')/"<!*8)0%)2 1")-#0-"*2)2 '",)."1"2')-2)2/(" ""8)2 * )","#+"'1-2#"2/- 0)8"#+$"0-"/("

8"*2"# 9"# -."' )$!2*8 .-2."2"#+ 4(""$%' (" .*'/ * .(*88"2 "/-/("*0-"'*)#"@"./)-2-#"("'*)#+$".*9" *88-4"#,)#"-#"#*/"# ("-1"*/),"1*/-0/("'*)# -#")'"6/*./"#("")2*0/"& 6666 66666666666666666666666666666666

! "#

#$ !

%&'

( ) = ""8)2 * )","#0-9/("*0-"'*)#-#"*'1*''"#!1-2 /("5'!1*7+$%/("8"*2"#9"#-."')$!2*8.-2."2"#+/("

1"/)/)-2" 2)-2-02#)*(*'0)8"#/(""* *)2'//(")2'/*2/4)/1"/)/)-2 $"0-"/()'-!/ )&456

6 !

7081/ !' &!

17 0890606 !

$ : ("8"*2"#.-!2'"80-/("1"/)/)-2"''!$9)/'+/(*//(" 8"*2"#)$!2*8(*'0*)8"#/-.-2')#"/(*/)2/"9'-0" !8*/)-2 - =-0/(""2')-2" !8*/)-2'0-/("9%+ ;:

*2#" !8*/)-2 - -0/(""2')-2" !8*/)-2'0-/("9%++/(!'-28%/(" -91"/"2/!/(-)/%4*'"91-4""#/-.-2#-2"/("#"0).)"2.%)2/(" "2#)/)-2-0<!*8)0%)2 '",)."+/(!'$%/("'-8#)"0-()'$".-9)2 "2/)/8"#/-'""?/(""2#-49"2/-01"2')-2/-()9("'*)#" !8*/)-2' *""6/*./"#("")2*0/" 5A B C+ ;:

*+, -.

1 0

2 *3 /0

) 5A B C+7

45 0

1 6

2 )

-"-,"+/(" )2)'/%-0"0"2.",)#"-8).%8"//"-

57D

DD5"2D-87 #*/"#: + )2'"/"#.8*!'"5),7 )2 /("

" !8*/)-2- -0/(""2')-2" !8*/)-20-/("9%+(" "8",*2/1*/4(""-0+)'"6/*./"#("")2*0/" "$# $

$ &$

'( 1"!'*8-0/("*0-"*9"2#9"2/4-!8#9*?")/.8"*/(*/ "8)"0 <!* .-2#-2*/)-2 -0 #"0).)"2.% )2 "2#)/)-2 -0 /(" *11-')/" <!*8)0%)2 '",)."+)'/-$"*..-#"#-29")/+'-*'/-"2'!"/(*/*2 *9%1"'-22"8)'"8) )$8"0-*/8"*'/-2"'",)."1"2')-2

$ ; ("8"*2"#.-!2'"80-/("1"/)/)-2"'0!/("'!$9)/'+/(*/ /("@!# 9"2/-0/("8"*2"#9"#-."')$!2*8+)2.)1*8E"2.(+ "4"8()+"2#""#)2.*'"/)/8"#*'

4*'2-/.-"./*/("4*'.-2/*%/-8*4*2#0*./'+ /(""0-"+2-"8)*2."-! (//-(*,"$""218*."#-2/("'*)#@!# 9"2/ (""8",*2/1** *1('+*'-..!)2/(","#)./5'!1*7*""6/*./"# ("")2*0/" + 1 8"

+9+9*&

4 0 :

;<$

2 =

>?; *9&+99* @ = @

>?;

+993+9*7A

A 0 $

A 0 ; " ; B C=D39+9*E 97**+9*E =8

A $ =8

> /?;0 A .... ....

& =

4 0 F D / 0

/ 0 1

; < $

$ $

$ @ GH < $ 2

; < $ GH G $ ; @

IG ?

< ?

" ; ? / 0 &

&&- $ ‟

!"#

/ & $

/ 0 /0

) =

< +/+0 = 8 =+997

*9&+99*

@ *+< < @

& "

& # $

%012%13%& $&4 &

3513%136"#

0 @ /0

$ $

" ;

/ 0F D/ 0 @ 7

!7 !' 7086 & 0$

)2."/(""61-'/!8*/)-2'9*#")21** *1(- -0/("

@!# 9"2/"2#""#$%/(" -2F$8"1"6-!/)2.*'"/)/8"#*' !6 ! 7 !6//!! 08 ( $)& ! )6!38 5/ +"1-/"#)2"%137#6

' 010+ 1** *1( 4(""-0 $".-9"' "6/*./"# ("")2*0/"+-,".-9"'/("#)'*$8)2 "00"./'+)0*2%+-0'!1*"6."1/)-2 -5),7+*'$".*9")2'"/"#,)#"1-8).%D8"//"#*/"#: +/(!'+ )2/"2#"#/-4-?*'*2-$'/*.8"*/("* *)2'//("'-8#)".8*)9)2 "8)"0 -0.-2#-2*/)-2)2/(""<!)')/"'(-/0*88-0'",)." *+

G $

+J *K&,

*= +99*

(""0-"+/("@!#).)*8,"#)./5'!1*7+#-"'"2#"2" */"# /("'!1** !9"2/*)'"#$%/(".-!2'"80-/("1"/)/)-2"'+/(*//(" "91-4"9"2//-.-2#-2"/(""<!)')/"'(-/0*88+$".-9"''-8)/*)8% ,"'/"#)2/("-91"/"2/!/(-)/%+"'1".)*88%4("2/("("")2*$-," !2#"8)2"#1** *1('+*'-..!)2/(","#)./9*#")2)& ! )6!38

5/ + '/ +*88!#"#/-)2/(","#)./9*#")2(*9* *!F'.*'"+#- )2,"'/@!)'#)./)-2)2/(")/-!/+/-/(-! (@!#).)*8)2/","2/)-2+ /(!'9*?"/(""'1-!'"#.-2#-2*/)-2

-2'"<!"2/8%+/(".!9!8*/),""00"./-0/("*!/(-)/*/)," @!#).)*81-2-!2."9"2/*'.*)"#)2/("*$-,""6/*./"#1** *1(+ 9*#" )2 ! "# /(!' .-918"/"8% .-!2/",*)8'$-/(/("'!1** !9"2/'*)'"#$"0-"/()'-!/+$%/(" .-!2'"80-/("1"/)/)-2"'+/(!'0-#"2%)2 /-/(""'1-2#"2/+/(" $"2"0)/-0/("'",)."1"2')-20-()''",)2 )2/("+9""8%-2/(" -!2#/(*/("(*'2-/.-918"/"#/("<!*8)0%)2 1")-#-0'",)."+ $"')#"'-2/("0!/("08)9'% -!2#+/(*/-28%/(".-91"/"2/*!/(-)/% )'*!/(-)G"#/-.-2#-2"/("'*)#'(-/0*88

-2"/("8"''+ )2 /"9' -0 /(" #".8**/)-2 9*#" )2 /(" ("")2*$-," !2#"8)2"# 1**+ *' .*)"# )2 /(" ,"#)./ 5'!1*7+ /(" .8*)9'-0#!*80*9)8%1"2')-2)2*##)/)-2/-/("0)'/0*9)8%1"2')-2+)0

"<!)"#+4-!8#$""'/)./"#0-9 ; +*'"2,)'* "#$%/("

)2)'/%-0"0"2."B"//"#*/"#

6!/1 7086 & 0$

2*0/"9*/(+/()'-!/0)2#'2-9")/)2/("4)/1"/)/)-2 *2#4)/(-$'",*/)-2'*$-,"+/("'*9")'#)'9)''"#

= (")91! 2"#-#"+*'1*''"#$%/("8"*2"#)$!2*8 .-2."2"#+)'9*)2/*)2"#*2#*00)9"#

: )'1-'"#-0*8-2 4)/(*881"2#)2 *118).*/)-25'7+)0*2% :)

) -

;

:) ) *;

%$%$ 2@*8 808 9/26!3< / ! "

< 808 9 0/41 "