Shamsher & Another v. Mubin And ORS


  
       
 

 !"# $#%&'&() 

*
 



   





 ) + , -.- 

/#'#(") /0#"!(1!2/3$4%!"# /"0#!22#55!("'  
    !

0#  !6!/$  $!"#$ 

  2!''#$  78 "0#  "/  %%&$#("

5!&9'/&7:(!53#6!"!":0 /'0/"3+"0#/&7:(!5+0!'7##(!''!&5#$ 78"0#2!/#("' '!;/!(! '##<&(=#(0!(%#9#(" %92#('!"&( !6!/$#$:($#/-#%"&(>> "0#"/.#0&%5#'%"3*

 /'0/"3+"0# *

%"+ 0#  !22#!5  &'  !%%92!(&#$  78  !(  !225&%!"&(  &5#$  :($#/ -#%"&(  ?    "0#  ,&9&"!"&(  %"3  *>   /  '0/"3  +"0#  *>  %"+  %($(!"&(    $#5!8   3@  $!8'  &(  &5&(=  "0# !22#!5 0#  /#!'( 9#("&(#$&("0#!225&%!"&(&'A:"#$7#56) 0!"&"&'/#5#4!(""9#("&(0#/#"0!""0#!22#55!("'!/#(" <(6(  6&"0  "0#  "#%0(&%!5&"&#'    5!6  !($  "0#8  !/#  :558 $#2#($#(":2("0#!$4&'# "0#&/%:('#50#!22#55!("'9#"

6&"0"0#&/%:('#5&("0# /$ 2/&53

3(58"0#("0#,$

 :('#5  0!'  ':==#'"#$  "0#9  "  &5#  !(  !22#!5  7# /#  "0&'

(+75#  :/"  #  0!'  !5'  "5$  "0#9 "0!"  (6  $#5!8 0!' %%://#$&( &5&(= "0#!22#!50#/#!

"#/3"0#8!//!(=#$"0#

:($'!($!22/!%0#$"0#&/:('#5!"#6!" /"0# :/"0#/ !%"&(#0!'0!($#$4#/"0#%28 "0#&92:=(#$/$#/" "0#!22#55!("'!($':==#'"#$"0#9" &5#!(!22#!57# /# (+75#&=0:/""6!'(582''&75# /"0#9"/#!%0!($ 9##""0#&/2/#'#("%:('#5( ?

0:'"0#!22#!5&'

(67#&(= &5#$!($ "0#$#5!80!22#(#$$:#""0#!74# 9#("&(#$/#!'('C (  "0#  !74#  A:"#$  /#!'(3  "0#  %!:'#  /  $#5!8 0!'  7##( 9#("&(#$"0!""0#!225&%!("'9#""0#&/%:('#5( 

!($"0#86#/# ("!6!/# "0#"#%0(&%!5&"&#' 5!6 "#/9##"&(="0#%:('#53"0#8 !//!(=#$"0# :($'!($"0#2/#'#("!22#!5!5(=6&"0"0#!225&%!"&( %($(!"&( $#5!86!' &5#$ 0##D25!(!"&(2:" /"0&'(#&"0#/'!"&'

!%"/8(/7(!

&$# :/&(="0#%:/'# 0#!/&(=3(2&("#$A:#/87#&(= 9!$#"5#!/(#$ %:('#5  /  "0#  !225&%!("'E!22#55!("'  !'  "  60#(  "0#  !9:("  

%92#('!"&(!6!/$#$78"0#/&7:(!56!'$&'7:/'#$""0#!225&%!("'E !22#55!("'  !($  60#"0#/  !(8  #D#%:"&(  !225&%!"&(  6!'  &5#$  ,#!/(#$ %:('#5 /"0#!225&%!("'E!22#55!("''"!"#'"0!"!(#D#%:"&(!225&%!"&( 6!'  &5#$  !($  &(  "0'#  2/%##$&(='  "0#  !9:("  6!'  $&'7:/'#$  "  "0# !225&%!("'E!22#55!("'&( :(#3

?4&$# !8/$#/ /:/"# :($(58 $!"#$ @?

?0&'&"'#5 #'"!75&'0#'"0!""0#!225&%!("'E!22#55!("'6#/# &(":%06&"0"0#&/%:('#5!($&"0!'6/(=587##('"!"#$"0!""0#89#""0#&/ %:('#5&(2/&53

!($!""0!""&9#0#':==#'"#$"0!"!(!22#!5'0:5$

 7# &5#$ "  &'  6#55E'#""5#$  "0!"  !  5&7#/!5  4&#6  &'  "  7#  !$2"#$  %($(!"&( $#5!87:"&(%!'#'"0#/#&'!(&(/$&(!"#$#5!83'"/&%"4&#6 0!'"7#"!<#( 0#-:2/#9#:/"&( 
 

         

     

!" #

$!%30#5$!':($#/)E
 

    

  

   

    

 

         





    

                                

         



  

    



  

       

            

 

!

    " 

# 

$ %  &

'()*   

   

 

    

            

        

 





 + 

   

   

         



  

     

 "

(%!'# 9!5#($:1:9!/ #/!!($"0#/'.#/':'0#-"!"# F#'" #(=!5

  &4&5? 3"0#-:2/#9#:/"0!'0#5$"0!" "0#  $#5!8  &(  &5&(=  "0#  !22#!5  /  /#4&'&(  %!(("  !($  '0!55  ("  7# 9#%0!(&%!558%('&$#/#$!($&("0#!7'#(%# +':

&%&#("%!:'#+$#5!8'0!55

 ("7#%($(#$(%!'# '#/&:'(#=5&=#(%#3"0#$#5!8'0:5$("7# %($(#$ 0#-:2/#9#:/"&(# & '(   )

*"

+ + " ,*-

" + . /(  + /"$0 -

!"

#

!,3&(2!/!=/!20 0!'0#5$!':($#/) ,,-.

  

,,     ,, 

      



    

%

    





   

   





  



%

    

 

     

    

     

                     





,, 0#-:2/#9#:/"&(%!'#12     #  3 
&&

, *" 4+ %% 60&5#$#!5&(=6&"0"0#'%2#

G':

&%&#("%!:'#G0!'5!&$$6(!':($#/) ,,             +           !

    ! 

   

     

  + 



  

 







      

    

  

,, (  "0#  2/#'#("  %!'#3  "0#/#  &'  (  #D25!(!"&(  /  9:%0  5#'' '!"&'

!%"/8#D25!(!"&( /%($(!"&( $#5!8"6:5$7#!22/2/&!"#" 9#("&("0!""0#+':

&%&#("%!:'#+#D25!&(#$&'("7(!

&$#!'#D%:"&(6!'

7#&(=2:/':#$7:"!22#!56!'(" &5#$

 (4&#6 "0# !%"'("#$!74#!($5!6$&'%:''#$3(=/:($ &'9!$#:" /%($(&(="0#$#5!8 0#!225&%!"&(&'$&'9&''#$!($!'!/#':5""0#/# 3"0#!22#!5 &'!5'$&'9&''#$7#&(="&9#7!//#$ 
 !

"#  

* 9< F0#"0#/'2#!<&(=H/#!'(#$) #'H F0#"0#//#2/"!75#) #'H