M/S Schlumberger Asia Services Limited v. Union Of India And Another
!"#$
% %
"#"&#'
!"#$ % % () %*'+,&-.
/ 01* 0'
20-03 ! %%%% 3030"# 4
&
#0"#"5 #!011#!1#"3+
%%%%
6"#!
#3
($ 72(%* * * 72(%* 8
!
" #
$
%%%% 8 9%
&&'
&&(
)
)
)
* "
+, , "+
- &./0 1 ++2
)
3
)
)
"
/&61&2
/7.1&2
&
) "
"
8 " 5 "
)
"
./ .6 &./7 7/ .7 &./6 5 "
5
$ 6
.' .& &./:
" 5
5
)
)
;
* 310,
0"!
# ", !
* 0'
31:
!
-1#!
!
&(9498;/'9 &./:;/'
< /6 &./:
1;* <2 ./ &./7;
7/ &./6 =$ ('6'67.7 7&949&./:;/'
7/ &./'
1;* <2 ./ &./6;
7/ &./:
=$ 670/:./> .(9498;
?,9&./(;/>
&' &./( 1;*<2 ./ &./:;
7/ &./'
=$ (06>0(>.
.:98;@ ;
/9&./0;&.9>6 .0 &./0 1;*<2 ./ &./';
# 7. &./( =$ ((&0/0&6
)
&./7;
/6
&./6;/:
$ /00>'0/./9;
"
&0 /& &./(
"
)
$ &&07'0>6&9;
" @3
4 1 @442
&0 /& &./(
"
$ :06'>..'9;
)
&./';/(
)
"
&./0
"
@3
"
"
"
5
B)
"
/&6
)
* "
;
5
;
* "
-
/&61&2
3
/7.1&2
:
C
"
/&61&2
/7.1&2
"
B "
" ;
D;
;D
"
'
C
"
) 3
3
) )
"
9
5
/6 )
3"
3
"
3
" ;
3 ;
B
"
"
; " /&61&2
/7.1&2
"
)
)
( ) "
F
"
"
5
@3
3
"
) * )
* "
/6
"
;
"
"
> E
=
)
/&6
/7.
;
;
%1/2 * ; 1&2
)G
)
"
7.
# &./0
G 12
H 12 "
H 12
)
H 12
G 12
3 <
H 12
"
H 12
"
G 12
3
H
"
H 12
5
7.
# &./0 G
12
H 12 "
H 12
1&2
; 1/2
*
"
5
"
3
" ""
% 1/2
"G
"
H 12
" H 12
"
G 12
H 12
3
" 1&2
3
"
""
I /.
" ) )"
>
;
3
// C
)
/&6 /6
"
4 ) 5
;
/& $
)
!
"
)
"
/0(:
)
" "
<
)
"
3
;
J4 "
D
"H
"
" 3"
" $ /6..9;
C84 )
) 3"
"
"
" $ /.7:9;
C84 I
/7
)
3"
*
3 *
5
"
"
3
/6
"
@
" "
"
)
"
E
"
$ 3
!
# $ %
!
&
'
'(()* ) 3
;
!
"
#
!
! !
$
!
%
&
' ( !
$
"
!
!
$ !
!
(
%
!
! ! " )
*
#
! "
!
!!
! + /:
"
+,- + .$ -!
!
-!
/ 3
;
' !
!
&
)
#
! ! !
,
-
!
%
!
! )
+ /'
E
/&6
/7.
3
*
*
C ) )"
*
)
"
) "
"
; )
"
; "
"
)
"
"
B
/6
*
"
/(
" ) " ? * *@ ?8 @
% % 8
9
K $ K