High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/9813/2018dismissed

Harbans Singh v. Dev Singh Deceased Th Lrs And ORS.

2019-05-06Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill6 pages

!"# $% &&'' (") * $%%")$%+ %" & !" #$ $$$ ,"

"%'-.! *

/// $$$ % &&'' 0&'

$$"* 1)$. "

2&# 3*'4)$4) "* 1&)" 5'' 1)$. "

6 & # '"4)$ ,' 7%&" &&'' &'

') "'" %

%%%5 " 1 & 8 "%"

%)' " "

8)# % 0 * $%5''$' )'' *:)%"$%7" "5 #")' ");)"%"&" " "&". 1) "" % ".'' $ ."$$ $ %)&"&" 5)$% ' %& #5 % &" . &&'' 0

!"# $%% $%< 5 "&" # %'$'"&" *%'" %%" 4.'

$% )%,"55 4.' $%"< <'5=%# %&&'' &" % &' $ % &' % &'

% )1 ! );.'

)&"&" 5'. #

% >

%%)&"&" #' $ !". 5%%5 >%" $% $%>%" $%) ."" )' $%%%" .'

$% ,". 45 $% * $% % %" %'" .'

!"# $% &'

!"# ?)" 4.' $%!"# ?)" 4.' $% %* .'

& 5 4.' $% )"** # % 55 )%," %'" % " $% % "?)">*"" #

% '*"&" 5%%.'

$"#%&'

@%". $$" "

8)# 5% '$&"

."% 5) #'-" % "> )"%"

&'%%5%" %" $#)

$ ".5- $% "*" * $% ''$ % "$%8)%" " *)" #

":)% .%'. %*% " " '' " )' &" )5 %)(")&"'. #1 5""5%'

$%"' %&#5 %&">5 %%&"*" )1 ! );.'

''$"

%% )&"&" 5 )' '. 5)# %" $% &"

') '>%" $%5%.'

)'> %&"" $% >%" $% %)&"&" 55 #

!".$" %" "*" '. % '" $* ' % &'

'. 9&" 5%%%# "'"""*29 2%")

% ' ' % '" # " "" %

;)"%"." %"%'" 5%5" '- " <* $% %* %' ,'

5" $&"'

).#" % *"

"* > %%" "''$' )'' *.' %)5&" " &' 5 ;''5 $)5" ".# "'3)" # %&' < A%%"&'

'%'" &"

"B,, A%%"%&'

' "&". 1) &" "B,, A%%"%) '$''

. #'B, *A%%"%&'

% ') '%&" )B, * A%%" &"&" )" % #

8 % B, *A%%"&'

&& ". ' $%&" )#

%5 )B, *A%%"% '&'.& "

) " 2<3,3B, *' C* 5'# #%%&" "'3)" " $%* "" "). ') % % ) &"&" 5 %&" %"# $ * "" &"*%.> )"%"#"*%%&'

%.'

%. <* $%# ) . )

$ ".

'. &'+"

"'3)"%- .

"$" $&" &&' '# %&&'' 5'.# '"4)$ ,'* 1)$.

6$$"*%" ". &" &&'%#

*%. '

"$)%#% %'"

)"#'5%*$"'

"" . $%) '#

%&" &&'' 7% )" % # )'

&"* "" " .C8, 1.# "%

" <6> )"%")#.%%"&*"'*

""&"*% )" 7%&&'' # $%

* $% ' " %" +"

) )"%")#.%%" " 5%*" "" 5% $%5)'&" "" "%&"&" *)"

%)$%"< <'5"%"% $*%&"&" %')"** > %) &" %%&&'#''5 .&)$ 1)$. " 2 & # 3*' 4)$ 4) "

* 1&)"5''1)$. "

6& # '"4)$ ,'# ) ' # %&&'' #"%")$%) >%*%"'"

%*&") % '5%%#' ,")' %.&)$ 1)$. ""*'%%

% '&"*%&"&" # %&" " C8, 1.# " % " <6

" )" # "'+"

) #'& )

* """ '%&"&" # "'&"&" &">'& %) ' ) '&"*# &* * "" &"&"

# &"). # 7.

5%&& %5 #8 ,A '' % )'."8 %,A .%%

%"* $%%$* E#$ ' %. "$ $%. &" ,'

,A )"%". % 5 " $5%% <* $% 5"* $%. %* %' ,A $"''

.%% %"5 )

- '. ,A 3%" $%5'',A )" "

$%8. #

%*'.% ). <* $%" $5%%)$%"< <'59 % $" # $"*# %.,A ,A $"''

% <* $%5%' %" %* $$ $% &#' '- $ " % 5 " 7% )"%" . % " "

58)# <* $% ) %5 "5'' 5%)

- &")" 7%) "$%'

#"*# #%%'"

)"#'5 %%&"&" &"*#

," %# .# ,A <&'

#. $%* $"* E#$ ' %" "

&" "$). "# '"

%")' %*&" ""%)$%"< <'5*"%')"** '"'

* ." -& $ *5% )'."8 &" 5%"%5 %'" &"< 5%"

'- "% %"< <'59$" %" %')"** $ .'

'* $&"'

).#" "%* $- %" "&" 7%" *

"" %* $%5 '8)%" "

=%%'"

)"#'5"$%'

#"*%% &&'' % .'

"* ' ".% %" 5 '* &"'

F+"

)"#'5%*" " )"" $

$ % &&'' 5%'. &"&" &&"

* ""5%%5"" "

" > .

" & :) '5.)%')# ':) '5 *'* %&&' ) #'& )

''$'

". "&"*" .&)$ 1)$. "

2&# 3*'4)$4) "* 1&)" 5'' 1)$. "

6 & # '"4)$ ,'5%%'' "

" # %3)" &&' %""$). %# " 7%"' "< ' 2 '

%&" &&'?& $ *5% %%."%# ." %:) ' "< ' ' %&&'%#

" ".&&' " $'

& " $'

%&&'.5% ""

$&'(&)) *+,- " A%%"&- $9"

G9 A%%""&"#'