← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/606/2018dismissed

Bir Singh @ Beera v. State Of Punjab

2019-04-12Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu11 pages

 

     

 

  

  

    !"  

     !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

 $%&'( )*+,-(! ,$2( 0,$310,21)   # $ %

& &

  #    &   % & !"

# ' !(& &(   

!.,/01! "!4  

   

!

" #

 $!"#%

"" "

"& ' ""() "*  +!"#',



- ' *      &"

"   '() 

* #.  /0  1 #"0 

"  "  

 1!

 (!

"*1 2 3, /0        ) ' *  (  (   + 

&

,-    +(   &  (  (  (  1  1!

!

  

4 &  '   1 )0 

30-',



- ' 1

1 0  

 #'0 1 5"

%

# "

#%!" 

$ %

),



- 3 1 6*/ 

!

#0  

  1

 1"  *!7!%  %, - #

1"" 

%

11"

#  %'0  # 0  8"  9  7!% 0  #" (!

:)  ;!

# 9 !

7!% 0 

(!

)  #  (!

 2 ,  '  9

 7!%  " %



 %

1

0  

* #

  , "

9 $ ) ,   " "   %  1%%   0   

/ 1 5"

%

% % 

%" !

    /0

 !  

 (!

4,  '0 *!7!% 1%



"

 ! 

* #' 0 

* # %"0 -



1- #  9

 7!%  5)(!

) 1  , "

9 $ ),  0 % "0 ("



# 5 # $! 0 -

' 11!" * # #0  

" -

1 " %  !  # 5! $! '9

 " "

     " "(")  0   

   % %  < %

5 #

0 1% "

"1

0 !

!

1%

#  1"

%

 1!

< % " !%( 0

 !

1  

%

 11!"0  1""!

"*1 22  ,   /  1 "     0

      "  1  /  0   1 5 1 " 

"



 1"'  1"

(5 / 1' 



& = "  1!

   #    (

    

5%

) #!" 

1!

 

" 5 1  = "

1!

  #  *



" 1%

5%

) #!" 

1!

 5" 1 () " 

("!(

"! "

$!"#%

""  " ! (0

2 > 5 " "1!

   

"#  !#

$!"#%

"1"5)1  !) .

/       *           -(( 0(   "+1 2 ( 3 "+  &40  /,

3 5    !

 "+  -

"5 (0 (  6 7   + (  

"5  8(08( 

  !

"5 7     

    +  " 9     

"5 )(0 (     !  7   +  "     (  

"5  8(0(       7    "       (     + "    3

     

"5 (0 (    7    +  "       (     +  "     .

"5  (0 (&)(( 

 :

 5 )(0 (   ( ;

' 5 (0 ( (&8( "5"5! 

& 

"5 )(0)( 

    + (   <

    & 5 !

+      &   6 (&5     (     !

5 - ((    :

/8    2 (  (          

 (& 8

." 

# & 1 2 ( (( 5  3 (1!+  (( (5    1!+ 6 (     3 5   " .,.

8 # /     &51!+  ( 2 (  = * +&

6 & ( 1  (   56    +" 5+ 3 5+ 

1!+  ( 2 ( 5(5"    ( 2 (5+ (  (&  5 6  

  6   &5& 6  (    3 ""1!+  3 1 2 (    1 2 (   ' (     5    3( >40 /8, ?5   '    -0(  &             +     &5  " 

#

4 ;

/.% (  8

.&  (    1 (   "+   !

56  3   /:1 ("1 2 ( 3 1 2 ((

5  @  3  5     @ 3 6"6     @ 3 5     +5 5 +  6 "5" 1 2 ( 3""+ (1 &5    3"      5+(   3"   (" ( 5     5  ( + 

  "5    " 1   2 (       /

'      8

.& 5 37&  & $ &  6 3  5 5      + 3   ( 3   A  (   3" ( 

(    (5

      7 "6 "6 &55+  - "+5 '56    +((5   -((  0(   5      7 

.&       &          @    (     ( 

  >40 /

,=?6   6        % #!  6  5   7  :

.&(  (  3  &("  5 (  ;;-; ("-"0   3  ( 40 /

,# /

 3*5   8

.&  537     '   7        A    &  40 /

,4  -"+   1  (5 ( -((0(  * 1 2 (56    " 5 (    ( +&(   ( 

/  '"    56     +5 6 - 5 (  

/ ) ! $7                  ;

:- ;;:

       ( &  5   (1!+2 (    A( 3"  ( "("+ ""     5    * (  

  (   / ),

3    .8-'  4  

?

/   ( "  $ 7    "             :;)::-)) 8)  & (" 5   (!2  '5 

.

3 "           "(  "+     ""     5

  5'

   '

  40 / , * +

 40 / ,* 3" 

("(8

.8

.  (     '5 (  40 / , 3 "      ;;;-;

;.  ( 1 (  2 ( 3"          ;;;-       (    *(  +    ( *((  &55 

/ 8  '     6!          

( +(  2 (

.

/ .  3        "        

      ;;;-;

;: '5   ( 1 (  ( 3  (

 (40 / .,  40 / .,

:



 0( / !2     5

  5 !*(  +&  6 5(5  +

;   5    7 8

.&5     5   1 (> ?(   3("(  (+

  3"+ "

"+      "  (    & 66 (6    !

+1 ( 3  5+ 5   + 3 "5      (  

#    2 ( 1 2 (  (  ;

# ' -0(  &((  5    .

:

 ( + (      0(  -  - (5  (""   :;)::-)) 8)   +651 (  8

.

 6 55 "   651 (     ;;;- 

( ( 

  &  6&  "  

 40   "  3 " " 5(+( + 5 ( (+ 7 

.&  (  "   (  " 5       

.8

.& 5  5 "       5

;

          &  1   (    

    1!+  

 ( 1 (0

 !  



',>4

: *!7!%  "  1"  / " 

* # # 5 #-

(0 (")   9

 1  , "

9 $ ),  0 % "0 (" 

# 5 # $! ' 11!" * # #0  

" -



) %  9

 7!% " " 

 /:1 (5  5     &+5 5 6  "5"1 2 ( 3"     5 !

+     &   6  (&5     (     !

5 -((   

C9 40 0"    E EE4E 5 5 ( "EE%

&    &!   &

5& 6&" + &  "6 6 

9  

 

 ( +    

   (+5 3  

 (   '   &  !

56    9          

            

 5 +"  "+5 35& ( "5 

  55      5     ("    :;)::-)) 8)  '  5    

.

 /  ("$7   

         :;)::-)) 8)&55   (!2  3" 

("(8

.8

.  (     '

 40 / , * +  40 / ,*    :;)::-)) 8)5 9   + ) /  !  2     (    

       &  6&  "  

 40 ' 

 

.&+ "   5 6 5( 3  5 /  ((  ((( (& "       A ( ( ' -0(  &( 

.&  (  "   (  "  5        :;)::-)) 8)5   (  9      8

.&   &    "       6  "+   

 55    /(  +  & / !2 5 9    6 "+

 5 5     '5

 0  &5    !

  6 "+(   !

 "+5  5& (5  6 "5   

  (5"  

"+   1!+  (  56"+

 

   "  "+ /8 2 (( (  / !2 5 

.

 +   

. " "  5

.&5   (9   ' / ! 2 5   +  &( 5A " "+   6 5"+ 

  " ( >40 /

,=? 4   1!

    5"    1   #

   

() " 

("!(   11   ! 

 0   0  "$!"#%

""1""()  " !

11"

#)'    " % "   >!(?

= 

  >3   ?

  =  / 6 ,  F,$  / " F,$