Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Bhagwati Parshad & ORS



 !"!#!$% &$'!%( !'#%!

')*'*+,- .

 /*)0,1/+*23452)* 33*00) 6, 789)&/,7)7*/, %*,3*), % -!:5" % $; "'% %6%


          

     !"# $ %  &

 '''''

'% %6%<  /0182*) (   )         "

 *     +    )    *"#  $ ,-.   ,/%0   "

   (      "  "

   

  1  21  )    /- %, ,/%3   "

     ( "  4  $  2   (

 $


&533,/%- (1          "    "        )      "        %,-////       

# 6

 #      

           

# 6

 # )    1    %.

/% ,/%- )  ) )     " " "  1 1      " "1 1       )  7  ) )  )   (( 8 97  7 #    )     )

"

9    )9     

 :   )    1   


9 ; "  1 1    $ ;
%%(030%  " 1   "

     1 1         

          1    1  #  

# 6

 # < )   9     4  $  )  )    "1             = $ %       > 

         1   1       ?  1     ,3@  ./-    
  %0&/     1  "

)  7             "        )   

1 "  ,,    1  )  )9 1 )   ( 8 97  #   )    1 %5///      )            1       $ & ) )    1     "

      $ %  )           "

            (        " ,/ +  1)  

;       )    $  0 = $ %  ,       >   #  )     1          9 1      )   )        (    1   )      )  1    ?

 " 1   1   $ %    

<)      "  9        

   "           )     

 1   )   )    $ .    "   ) "          )

 $ .  

       )     9 1        "   9 1 1               1   )    1      1            1   )

 " 1               A   %@00 =      B  C>              

      )  "  "     )

( ( "             1   ) 1  %

:   $ %        "

  1   1   "  1 1    $ ;
 %%(030%    1 1   "

  1   

# 6

#D*

,

  $ %    )     

  )       D*

.

:   $ % )    1   

     1        1

                   D *
.

-

 

;           "      1      ( "        )     

 1 1   1 "

      1         ) "          

%,-//// 1 )   6 0E    "    

      1            F      

         " 1   )     ) # 

   "  

      "    1 )

 ) "    

      ( "             " 1  5/

   1   "    "           )  "      

(       21  )     1 ?              "

"      )       1 1   1 "

      1      " 1        ) 
:,

  9 
 
:.

  1         )   
:,                ? G    "  ( "     )     1   " 99         )     G          "    H "

H                    %&%

=IG

%>          )    " 99      
:.

      "   )9           )    1 1                                   )   " 99  )    )    (               # )  (      1  )1 1    "    1   )  ) 

=

           )      J 

:,


  )           #        1           #        "  
          "

           #   "   H9)H

  1              %&&       ) " J    1 1      1          1  1   "        1     "

<)         ) )          "        

      )     )    1  )   1   )  9    "

           (     1   1     

(  1  1             " G   "  ( " 
:- <         1     

  )         1 1   1 "

 $ %=     1  >                %3.

)       IG

% (      1       1 1   1 (  1                  )  )  " 1   1             
                        )  "           )  )  "

      $     "     )  1 



       (    )    " G    "             )            "        " 

(    )       1    "  ( "

 )      "          )  " 1         )      "     "         1 "  ( "  " 1      J 

  

 1      "      )   J        (     "     "

      "

"         1           <H" G    ;1))7*/,6, %>,)7;))*% /,3/) /3/)/  

 %  % ?0    

       "                    )        " J     1           "

         1 ) "          )         <H" G         "        1      )         9        1 1   1 "

      1  

(  " 1         J       " )    

    "        ( "      %.    )  

.

G )      "  5/E      ) "






    " 1  "     "#     " 1  G =&>  "      ) "

 G   ;2) ;/06*/2)7*/,6, '*07 /,3/)/3/)/  

%  % ?0..  %-       "       G               " )       

( G   ;/06*/2 ,13/       

 


 
  


  


    



  
 




 

 
   

!    
  

   
     "   
  
        

 



 
   



   


# 

  


   $

  %          


    
        

 
  

   
  
  

        




  


 
 

 

   
     

    

 
 

 
   

   
&   
 




 

    
  
   

 

 
  
   

!   
 

 

       '  
  
        
   
    

       




  
 
 
 






 




   

!  

   ( 
 

     

  ( 
              #        " 1    1       )  1     <)       "   "  "

 ( "           )   5/

   1     "     )     1 I         ) " 5   1    #        " 1 (      "   "   )   1      )  

      ;/0  6*/2  ;13/         %. )     G    "   ) 

    "             "

   1           G     )     ) )    1 "  1    1    "       1 G 

"         "       )  "  9  )    G    ( "     9        "

&/// )   )  )9 1  8    8 97  "     ( "            "

       (          ) 1  G "

    <

          ) 1

  "  /% /% ,/%- "

 1     



  G 1     ) 1        9  "      ) 1 55-3 

(            "  9         

&/// +     1   "#   "         )  8  )    1 %5///        1  &/// )     

<)       "      "  

      "      1 #1         "

      )  )9 1  8   8 97 

 )    1 %5///  %0///   "      ( "  )    )           ) 1  G   " )    "    H9   "H ?            <

)    "        1         ) 1   "     

  9   "        )  

55-3 %/ (      )     "    55// "    #        1     ) 1  "

&///  1  )   )    "    "

  1        " 55//

( G   )    "   "

   "#             )        ) "                "      "   "#

 82#**/0,1/+*23452)*6, 1 %20,717/1%2)7*/, 

%  % ?0

<  ) 



<H"      1  #1      8   )0,1/+*23452)*6, &/4 ;*)7    )7*/,  .

  %  % ?0  <          )  ) "  "        "                  1  ) "                     1 ) "                    1    ) "        

(             ) "     )         G        6

-////  

 1       )            $

<        55//   1   =-/E   >

55// K ,,//L 33// M  )    G %.

5%.- = 33//  ,5&&> 

   %0 

+   

5%.- ! %, ! %0L

%%/0@-- 

?  G

%5/// 

+   

%5/// 

? 

  = -////       >

0//// (

%,%0@-- (       G  @E    "           1          



  F        

<)    1  "

 ( "  )        9  

8   1 )                 "   "

       G  )   

 "   "

 1     )  "#      <)  ) "     

'% %6% $'#"

 .

   


#
 )#*  


)#*