Atul Jaiswal v. M/S Nector Bipoharma Pvt Ltd

1 IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
%&'( () 2 3041 11  %&

           .   4
*     +,-./ 

0     +40 4 
  
 # 

  !"#
  #  "
Mr. G. S. Sawhney
% .  

*



 " $ 


&

*

+
!
+,

*
 
 



 







*
+, ,

 !
"

" 
#
$!
$




!

 


 


)*!
+














%$ $&'


/
!
 
 



  +!
() 
% 

 

     
-+,

*

+ +

 !

* !)
*

&
*
*

+ 
!
+,

*



 



+
 
+,

!


*

+ +
!!,
) )*! 



&
* 


0-!


+ 

*  ,



)*!

 
-
.
.
*
-
,
 '- 

+,

!
$

"


*

+ +

 !
 
* !)
*
-
!!-

**
* 


* +

 
 

$
1  





)*

 

! +!

+



 (
.

!
 !


*

  +!
! 


.
!

 

) !
*! 

 

4
. 
!+ 






+,
!
 !


*



.!!
*!


 
*  +,

 !
$
)



 
*  
 
  
 $
 
 

*
!!




 !
)

* !) ) *
(
)


 
* 


)*




)
)!
!! ! 


!+!

+

- -
!!

 !
*  

 )

&



5

)


1 
$ 

 


)
 ,

 

*+!  

* !) 
 

+  
 
  

$


 ! )


*  !)
*' 
& 
)
.
+
   )
)

)

 : 

& & (   3772 * , 8$%
      

  

 !" # "

"$$%   &' ' 

& ( ) #  ! * +, - . /*0 =2"% 1 1 1'   

& (

   $ *+, 23$% &4  

&  ( /  3737-30 * -* 0 "" % .' &' 

& & ( #5.

 -#6/0 378 -20

*

- 0 $$%

4 : 

& & ( /     37" -!0 * * -*0 887% #9 :  1 

; & ( <   =" *+, , "$2%
  

&  *+, $8 8% '  . 

& ( ) #  %  ! * +, =2"

 # & ' 

; &   88 *+, , "2 %

 

) !
*! 

 

-!!
 

*

3 3)
 
*
+,

!
!
$


.!
 



 

 +!+!
- 

 

*
- -

5  .
+ + 0
. 

!
!
$

 

 

* !) 
 
)


%
*!


)
 

.
* *! 
 !
-

 
* !)
-
6  




*

 

** 
+

!  !
$ 
- 
)


* 
-

!,
/
,;
) )



** 
+

!
$ 
1 

)
-

!
.!
 

*.

 


8
$ 

*
- 

*   )

 
!


,


 
+
.


 
) )




*+ +!
 
* !)
- 

) ,



:!  






+
*! 
*
5

)


Gurappa Gugal and others Vs.

. State of Mysore : 1969 CriLJ J 826 and Shokat Ali Vs. Stat te of Haryana :

: 2020(2) RCR (Criminal) 339.

#



 
* !)
-
 .
+ + 0
6 
+ +


-
 5



-

* 


* 
+,
)0
+.
 

) ,
*



,


 !*

1-.
-!
 5 





the learned tri ial Court failed to consider the f fact that 
!


.
6 
)
+, ,
)*!,
 5



 

* !)
-


+
*+! 
 

*
+-
  

*+! 

* !) 


* * 
*


-
!

!


,
: 


6
 
+
) 

.' &' 

& ( #5. -#6/0  378 8 -20

*

- 0 $$ %  !,

.-



 

) 
+.

! 

.-

 


!-

! -

+.



* 
*

!!-


)*



*
+, ,

!
  !
" 
#
$!
$ $ 


!

 

&


 


)*!
+














%$& &'


/
!
 
  




(
% 
- +,

* 

+
 !

* !

!)
*


- 
!!
 !
*  

 1-.

*

  

 
+

$ $
  -

*


- 0
+5 

 

 

 * ,
+!

,
*


* 

+
!
 
 




(

+ 

,
 


 *,
+!



 
  

*
!!
+
!+!

+
)

5

 !
 ,
 +5 

,
 


 
 !
+!

+
*
+, ,

  $

   
-
!-

 !

+.



,
**! 

!
+ 

  
$



 !
+ +!


 
$
 !!
+
+
 
*


)
6*  !,





  !!
+
 

6*

,
* *

)



+


! 
 
 
$

*!
 

)

&!!

** 


* 
+

!
$ 


!!

!
)
,

(

) 
!




*
!

**
+ 

!
$ 
-

*


- 0
)
 ,

*
!

!!
+

)

+
)

& (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE 1 11 %&


Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable Yes/No