← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26787/2023allowed

Guru Hargobind Charitable Medical Educational Society v. National Commission For Indian System Of Medicine And Others

2024-04-01Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda9 pages

  



        

 ! "#   $%&'(&)*+*,-. . //$01*,(2$*%$13&"&(*)$3(/)$%*,$3)*&%45 &%*%*,&  $%*,$366*++*,',(*$,4+%&6'"&(*)*,&$,(%2&+  &+7,(&,%+

 

  ! "# //$01*,(2$*%$13&"&(*)$3(/)$%*,$3)*&%45 &%*%*,&  $%*,$366*++*,',(*$,4+%&6'"&(*)*,&$,(%2&+  &+7,(&,%+  "-  89"

  :9  89"

  :"  

&+&,% " :$3$;(<)$%&;'%2&7&%*%*,& " :$%*=&4$;(<)$%&;'&+7,(&,%+; $,(. "+>$%*$;&,* $,&3/,+&3;'&+7,(&,%   ?????  :9;! $3#  2*+(&(*+7+&+'%>),,&)%&(7&%*%*,+1&%>&&,%2&+$6&7$%*&+

%2&+$=&'),<&,*&,)&;'$)%+$&1&*,0%$=&,'6 

  

2/02$7/13*),%*)&($%&( 

%2&$%*,$366*++*,' ,(*$, 4+%&6 ' "&(*)*,& !' +2%; %2& 66*++*,# *,<*%&( $773*)$%*,+ ' &+%$13*+26&,% ' ,&> 6&(*)$3 )33&0&+  , &+7,+& % %2& +$*( 7/13*) ,%*)& %2& 7&%*%*,& +/16*%%&( $, $773*)$%*, ($%&( 

 %2/02 >2*)2 *% +/02% %2& 66*++*,@+$77<$3%&+%$13*+2$,&>4/<&(*)33&0&>*%2$,*,%$=&)$7$)*%4 '  +&$%+ *, %2& $)2&3 ' 4/<&(*) "&(*)*,& $,( /0&4 /+& !' +2%; " /+&#  3,0>*%2 *%+ $773*)$%*, %2& 7&%*%*,& +/16*%%&( $ , 1A&)%*, )&%*'*)$%&($%&( 

14%2& %$%&' /,A$1$,(),+&,%'6 %2&$''*3*$%*,0 /,*<&+*%42&7&%*%*,&@+$773*)$%*,>$+$++&++&(14%2&66*++*,@+"&(*)$3



++&++6&,%$,( $%*,0$(!'+2%;%2&$(#2/023&%%&($%&( .. ; %2&$(0$,%&($,77%/,*%4%%2&7&%*%*,&%&)%*'4 (&'&)%+2/023&%%& ($%&( B  %2& 7&%*%*,& 1/02% % %2& ,%*)& ' %2& $( %2$% $33 %2&  (&'&)%+ 7*,%&( /% 14 %2& $( 2$( 1&&, )/&(  >&<&; %2/02 3&%%& ($%&(

BB %2&$($0$*,>%&%%2&7&%*%*,&0$,%*,0*%$,%2&77%/,*%4% &)%*'4 (&'&)%+ >2*)2 ,> 2$( &(/)&( '6   % C  2/02 *%+ &+7,+& ($%&(

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

C '%2&$(>$+%2&,),<&4&(%%2&7&%*%*,& &A&)%*,0%2&7&%*%*,&@+$773*)$%*,,B)/,%+2&7&%*%*,&$77&$3&($0$*,+%%2& &A&)%*,'*%+$773*)$%*,1&'&%2&66*++*,>2*)2>$+(*+6*++&(%2/02(& ' %2& 66*++*, ($%&(    + ,%*)&( &$3*&; %2& $( 2$( '/,( $+ 6$,4 $+ B (&'*)*&,)*&+ *, %2& 7&%*%*,&@+ $773*)$%*,  , $77&$3 %2& 66*++*, $))&7%&( %2& 7&%*%*,&@+ &D73$,$%*, E/$   ' %2+& (&'&)%+ 1/% &A&)%&( %2& 7&%*%*,&@+$77&$3, )/,%+ ,  %2&7&%*%*,&'*3&($+&),($77&$3 1&'&%2&<&,6&,%',(*$2&3$+%($%&'$(6*%%*,0+%/(&,%+'%2&$)$(&6*)

 

+&++*,  .>$+  1/%+*,)&14%2$%%*6&%2&<&,6&,%',(*$2$( ,%(&)*(&(%2&7&%*%*,&@++&),($77&$3%2&7&%*%*,&$77$)2&(%2*+/%%2/02  

 >2*)27&%*%*,)$6&/7'2&$*,01&'&$(*,$%&&,)2,

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

 >&& )2$33&,0&( 14 %2& 66*++*, 1&'& %2& /7&6&/%>2*)2>$+(*+7+&(',C  .2&/7&6&/%>$+'%2& <*&>%2$%%2&*,%&*6(&!+#7$++&(14%2&(*,$%&&,)2'%2*+/%+2/3( 2$<& ,% 1&&, 7$++&( 1/% +*,)& %2& 6$*, 7&%*%*,!

  *,>2*)27&%*%*,;%2/02(&($%&(   ;$)(*,$%&&,)2' %2*+/%*++/&(,%*)&$,(0$,%&(*,%&*67%&)%*,*,%&6+'%2&&$3*&(&+ 7$++&(14%2&(*,$%&&,)2, C $,( .*, 

 



2/02 7&)*$3 9&$<& % 77&$3 !# !+#.

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

C %2&$(&A&)%&(%2&7&%*%*,&@+ $773*)$%*,'%2&'33>*,0&$+,+- H2&&7&+&,%$%*<&'%2&77+&()33&0&>$+$0$*,$+=&(%+/16*% *,(*<*(/$3+$3$4+%$%&6&,%$+(*&)%&(14%2&2&$*,066*%%&&%*33 76 ,C ;1/%$'%&2&$*,0,*,(*<*(/$3+$3$4+%$%&6&,%>$++/16*%%&(  

    

  $+(*&)%&( 14 %2& &$*,0 )66*%%&& $,( %2& 77+&( )33&0& )/3( ,% 7<*(& %2& )673&%& ()/6&,%+G&<*(&,)&+ % '/3'*33 $,( )6734 >*%2 %2& +2%)6*,0 &3$%&(%%2&*,(*<*(/$3+$3$4+%$%&6&,%'+/1+%$,%*$%*,0%2&'/334'/,)%*,$3 2+7*%$37*%>4&$+     

     

             



     

 

  

  !    

 "    

  

           #$%

& %    '

( (    , &+7,+& ' %2& +$6& 77+&( )33&0& +/16*%%&( %2& +/02% ()/6&,%+ 1/% $'%& <&*'*)$%*, *% *+ 1+&<&( %2$% %2& 77+&( 33&0& +/16*%%&(%2&1*6&(*)$3>$+%&6$,$0&6&,%$0&&6&,%>2*)2*+,%*++/&(*, %2&,$6&'%2&)33&0&$,(2$<&+/16*%%&(%2&1*6&(*)$3>$+%&6$,$0&6&,% $0&&6&,%)&%*'*)$%&>2*)2*+*++/&(,   $,(,%+/16*%%&('%2& &E/*&( 7&*( '6 <&61&  % &)&61&

 % +/1+%$,%*$%& %2& )3$*6 ' 0&,/*,& '/,)%*,$3*%4 ' 2+7*%$3   

      <&61&; %&)&61&;



%+/1+%$,%*$%&%2&)3$*6'0&,/*,&'/,)%*,$3*%4'2+7*%$3 2&&7&+&,%$%*<&'%2&77+&()33&0&>$+$0$*,$+=&(%+/16*% &E/*&( ()/6&,%+ $+ (*&)%&( 14 %2& 2&$*,0 66*%%&& %*33  76 , C ;1/%$'%&2&$*,0,()/6&,%+>&&+/16*%%&( 

  $+(*&)%&(14%2&&$*,0)66*%%&&$,(%2&77+&()33&0& )/3( ,% 7<*(& %2& )673&%& ()/6&,%+G&<*(&,)&+ % '/3'*33 $,( )6734 >*%2 %2& +2%)6*,0 &3$%&( % %2& #$%

 &  %  

  '

 (  (  ' +/1+%$,%*$%*,0 %2& '/334 '/,)%*,$32+7*%$37*%>4&$+1&'&+/16*++*,'$773*)$%*,      

           

   

    

 

 

  

  

)* +*+ %,-$ ).  "        / 

!   

        

     

    " "



     0$1  

    ,%2*+&0$(%2&77+&()33&0&>$+$+=&(%+/16*%%2&2+7*%$3%$D 7$*(&)&*7%'%2&3$+% 4&$+1&'&+/16*++*,'$773*)$%*,%+/1+%$,%*$%& %2&)3$*6'0&,/*,&'/,)%*,$3*%4'2+7*%$3 ,&+7,+&'%2&+$6&;%2&77+&()33&0&*,'6&(%2$%,%$D*+% 1& 7$*( % %2& <&,6&,% $/%2*%4 $+ %2& 2+7*%$3 $,( )33&0& 1/*3(*,0 *+ /%+*(&%2&%>,73$,,*,0$&$2&&7&+&,%$%*<&'%2&77+&()33&0&>$+ $0$*,$+=&(%+/16*%+/77%*,0()/6&,%*,+/77%'%2&*+/16*++*,%*33

76,C ;1/%$'%&2&$*,0,()/6&,%+>&&+/16*%%&(*,%2& +%*7/3$%&(%*6&7&*($+(*&)%&(14%2&&$*,0)66*%%&&$,(%2&77+&( )33&0& )/3( ,% 7<*(& %2& )673&%& ()/6&,%+G&<*(&,)&+ % '/3'*33 $,( )6734 >*%2 %2& +2%)6*,0 ' +/1+%$,%*$%*,0 %2& '/334 '/,)%*,$3 2+7*%$3 7* %> 4&$+ 1&'& +/16*++*, ' $773*)$%*, " 

      "   2'3 2,4    

     (

 56 

 



    

    2

  7 ' 3    % 

  '  )89   2,4  )8:1     -

   -

    

 ,%2*+&0$(%2&77+&()33&0&>$+$+=&(%+/16*%%2&(&%$*3+' 7<*(*,0

$,('$)*3*%*&+%%2&2+7*%$3+%$'''%2&33&0&+G+7*%$3+ $+ 7& %2& 7<*+*,+ ' 6734&&+@ <*(&,% /,(+ $,( "*+)&33$,&/+

<*(&,%)%;CB )%;C.$,(&3&<$,% /3&+$,( &0/3$%*,+ , &+7,+& ' %2& +$6& %2& 77+&( )33&0& +/16*%%&( $ ()/6&,% *++/&(14%2&

''*)&&D73$*,*,0%2&

+)2&6&$,(&7&+&,%$%*<&'%2& )33&0&+$*(<&1$334%2$%%%$3,34 +%$''2$<&1&&,&,33&(*,

+)2&6& $,(%%$3,34.+%$''2$<&1&&,)<&&(/,(& &$*,0 66*%%&& $+=&( %2& 77+&( )33&0& % +/16*% $33 %2& ()/6&,%+ ' 2$<*,0 &,33&( +%$'' *, 

 $,(  $3,0>*%2 6,%234 $))/,% +%$%&6&,%+ 1/% , +% &$*,0 /16*++*, >$+ +/16*%%&( &,)&; +2%)6*,07&+*+%+$,(*,<*&>'3$)='$,4%2&+/77%*,0()/6&,%+; %2&0&,/*,&'/,)%*,$3*%4'%2&2+7*%$3*+(/1%'/3I B 0$*,+%%2&$'&+$*((&'%2&$(($%&(

C ;%2&7&%*%*,& $<$*3&( ' *%+ +%$%/%4 &6&(4 14 '*3*,0 $, $77&$3 1&'& %2& 66*++*,  ,   %2& 66*++*, 0$,%&( %2& 7&%*%*,& 77%/,*%4 ' 2&$*,0 !%2/02 <*%/$3 6(&# $,( %2&&$'%& %2/02 *%+ (& ($%&(   &A&)%&( %2&

 

7&%*%*,&@+$773*)$%*,2&7&$%*<&7$%'%2&+$*((&'%2&66*++*,&$(+ $+/,(&- H , (

   

 ;  6 (  ,(*<*(/$3 +$3$47$*(1$,= +%$%&6&,% ' $33 %2& 2+7*%$3 +%$'' '

. 6,%2+ +%$%*,0 '6 &)  % <

 *, 2*&$)2*)$3 $,( )2,30*)$3 (& $,( $))(*,0%%2& '6$% &,)3+&( >*%2%2&3&%%& 33&0& +/16*%%&( %2& ()/6&,%+ &0$(*,0 *,(*<*(/$3 +$3$4 1$,=+%$%&6&,%+' +6&+%$'' 33&0&(*(,%+/16*%*,(*<*(/$3+$3$4 7$*( 1$,= +%$%&6&,% ' $33 +%$'' ' &)&61&  % <&61&

,        ,'   

 *"&(*)$3 $+%& "$,$0&6&,% $0&&6&,% *+ *++/&( ' 9  9   9$,( ,% ' %2& 

   

J "9  99  9   9$,(

33/%*, ,%3 &%*'*)$%& *+ ,%+/16*%%&( 33&0& 2$+ +/16*%%&( D%&,(&( * "&(*)$3 >$+%& )&%*'*)$%& $,(

33/%*, ,%3 &%*'*)$%& 66*%%&& J&*'*&( %2& +$6& ,  

  2& +/16*%%&( $D 7$*( &)&*7% *+ ' %2& +&++*,

 $,(,% ' %2& 3$+% 4&$+ 33&0& +/16*%%&( %2& &%*'*)$%& 0*<&, 14 <*33$0& 7$,)2$4$%; ,(>$3 66*%%&& J&*'*&( %2& +$6& ,     .  2& (&%$*3+ ' 7<*(*,0 

 $,(  '$)*3*%*&+ % %2& 2+7*%$3 +%$'' ' %2& 33&0&+G +7*%$3+ $,( &0/3$347$4*,0 '&& +$6& $+ 7& %2& 7<*+*,+ 33&0& +/16*%%&( ()/6&,%+'

$,( 66*%%&& <&*'*&( %2& ()/6&,%+ $,( 

 $,(  *, %2& ()/6&,%+ %2& &+%$13*+26&,% $,( &6734&+ ,$6& *+  "&(*)$3 (/)$%*,$3 )*&%4 33&0&(*(,%+/16*%%&(

$,( '$33&3*0*13&+%$'''6&)&61&  % <&61&

 /16*++*, )$,,% 1&),+*(&&(2%)6*,0 &+*+%+ 33&0& +/16*%%&( $,= +%$%&6&,% '



' 6734&&+@

<*(&,% /,(+ $,( "*+)&33$,&/+

<*(&,% )%; CB   )%; C. $,( &3&<$,%

/3&+ $,( &0/3$%*,+ *+ ,% +/16*%%&( +$3$4 (*+1/+&( $))/,%   $,= ))/,%  ..B.C *, %2& ,$6& ' "G+ // $01*,( "&(*)$3 (/)$%*,$3)*&%4*,>2*)2+%$%&6&,%+ &,%*&+'+$3$4%$,+*%4$))/,% $A=% ,/61& B 

*+ '/,( 33&0& (*( ,% 7<*(& (&%$*3+ ' %2*+ %$,+*%4 $))/,%

$A=%; $3$4 (*+1/+&( *, %2& 6,%2 ' &1/$4 , C   '6   ))/,% ,/61& BB .C  . >2*)2 *+ $))/,%'/+*,033&0&*,%2&6,%2 '$,/$4

$,($,/$4 +$3$4 *+(*+1/+&('6%2&+$6&$))/,%'%2& /+*,0 )33&0&; 33&0& +%$%&( %2$% *, %2&D*+$,=, .  *,%2&,$6& '  4/<&(*) "&(*)$3 33&0&; ))/,% C C.

 *+ 7&, $,( +$3$4 '6

&1/$4 *+ (*+1/+&('6%2*+$))/,% I

 7&/+$3 ' %2& $'& E/%&( 7%*, ' %2& (& &<&$3+ %2$% %2& 7&%*%*,&@+$773*)$%*,%+&%/7$,&>4/<&(*)"&(*)$333&0&>$+&A&)%&(14%2& 66*++*,,%2&0/,(%2$%%2/02%2&7&%*%*,&2$(+/773*&(%2&1$,=(&%$*3+' %2&%$,+'&'+$3$4'6*%+1$,=$))/,%%%2&1$,=$))/,%+'*%+&6734&&+1/%*% 2$(,%+/16*%%&(%2&)&+7,(*,01$,=+%$%&6&,%+'+6&'*%+&6734&&+2& %2&0/,(>$+%2$%(&%$*3+>*%2&0$(%%2&(&7+*%'

$,('*%++%$'' 2$(,%1&&,'/,*+2&(2/+;%2&66*++*,>$+,%),<*,)&(>*%2&0$(%%2& +%$''>2*)2%2&7&%*%*,&)3$*6&(%2$<&&6734&($+7&%2&&E/*+*%&,6+ 

9&$,&()/,+&3'%2&66*++*,(&+,%(*+7/%&%2$%%2&7&%*%*,& 2$(+$%*+'$)%*34&D73$*,&(%2&%$,+'&'+$3$4'6%2&7&%*%*,&@+1$,=$))/,%% %2& 1$,= $))/,%+ ' %2& +%$'' >2*)2 %2& 7&%*%*,& )3$*6&( % 2$<& &6734&( 1/% +/16*%+ %2$% %2& 66*++*, >$+ +%*33 ,% ),<*,)&( %2$% %2& +%$'' )3$*6&( % 1& &6734&(14%2&7&%*%*,&>$+$)%/$334,*%+33++*,)&)&+7,(*,01$,=&)(+ '+6&'*%+&6734&&+2$(,%1&&,7(/)&(14%2&7&%*%*,&>2*)2>/3(2$<& ),)3/+*<&34+2>,&)&*7%'%2&+$3$414%2&&6734&&+  ,&1/%%$3;3&$,&()/,+&3'%2&7&%*%*,&($>+%2&$%%&,%*,'%2*+



/%% 6'*3&(14%2&7&%*%*,&/,(&%2& $46&,%'$0&+)%;C !'

G 14 %2& 7&%*%*,& >*%2 &+7&)% % *%+ &6734&&+ E/$ >26 %2& C  )% $773*&+ *+ $3+ *,),+&E/&,%*$3 $+ $(6*%%&(34 %2*+ 1A&)%*, >$+ $3+ $*+&( ,34 % 71&%2&<&$)*%4'%2&7&%*%*,&@+)3$*6E/$%2&0&,/*,&,&++'*%+&6734&(+%$''  , %2& 3*02% ' %2& '$* +%$,( %$=&, 14 %2& 3&$,&( )/,+&3 ' %2& 66*++*,;$+$1<&$,('%2&&$+,%2$%*,*%+(&($%&(

C %2&$( 2$( $))&7%&( %2$% %2& 1$,= &)(+ 7(/)&( 14 %2& 7&%*%*,& +2>*,0 %$,+'& ' +$3$4'6%2&7&%*%*,&@+1$,=$))/,%%%2&1$,=$))/,%+'*%++%$'';>&'*,(%2$% %2& &$+, 0*<&, 14 %2& 66*++*, % &A&)% %2& 7&%*%*,&@+ $773*)$%*, % 1& /,+/+%$*,$13&  &+/3%$,%34; (&+ ($%&(

C  $,(   7$++&( 14 %2& $($,(%2&66*++*,&+7&)%*<&34;$&+&%$+*(&*,)&%2&'/,($%*,$3(&+ $0$*,+%>2*)2%2&$77&$3>$+&A&)%&(14%2&<&,6&,%',(*$%2/02*%+(&



($%&(    ,34 , %2& 0/,( ' 3*6*%$%*, $,( >*%2/% $,4 (*+)/++*, , 6&*%+ 2$<& 1&&, +&% $+*(&; %2& (& ' %2&<&,6&,% ' ,(*$($%&(   +2$33$3+2$<&,3&0+%+%$,(     2&7&%*%*,+$&$33>&(*,%2&$1<&%&6+  K :9L   . .  K :"L 

       2&%2&+7&$=*,0G&$+,&( - &+G 2&%2&&7%$13& - &+G