High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/843/2018dismissed

Manjinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-08-17Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

! "## $%%&'#(&")'*+,-. /0123452678739:;<)'<")"( -09=7952>?79@A <<<<B21717392> CDEFGF ?101234BH9=0I <<<%28J395291

KL M N

! OOOOO B>28291: -><PQ09R0980STP5U3601243>1A2J21717392> -8<V7Q097P>3>0TPPWBH9=0I OOOOO

! M M < XA2 J>28291 >2U78739 J2171739 A08 I229 J>242>>25 0@07981 1A2 7QJH@925 =H5@Q291 095 3>52> 50125 )(<);<"); J08825 IY ?J2670S $3H>1T B0170S0T ZA2>2IY 1A2 J21717392> Z08 639U76125 095 829129625 13 H952>@3 >7@3>3H8 7QJ>7839Q291 13 1A2 J2>735 0S>205Y H952>@392 7<2< ([ 50Y8 43> 1A2 3442962 JH978A0IS2 H952> ?261739 \34]/B?P6109513J0Y0479234%8<")))^&< "< ?HQQ0>7SYT 1A2 40618 34 1A2 6082 0>2 1A01 39 [<)#<")#T ZA29 0 J3S762 J0>1Y A20525 IY P?_ `08J0S ?

79@A Z08 J>28291 39 1A2 I>75@2 34 6090S -2A8 79 6399261739 Z71A J01>3SS79@ 79 1A2 0>20T 0 J2>839 Z08 8229 63Q79@ 4>3Q 1A2 8752 34 ]0IA0 60>>Y79@ 0 JS08176 I0@ 79 A78 >7@A1 A095< V2 @31 J2>JS2a25 095 1>725 13 2860J2 IH1 Z08 0JJ>2A29525 IY 1A2 _9U2817@01739 344762> 095 31A2> J3S762 3447670S8< V2 5786S3825 A78 90Q2 08 -09=7952> ?79@A 839 b012 ?05AH ?79@A< +9 820>6AT \ c@ 34 J3JJY AH8c Z08 >263U2>25 4>3Q 1A2 JS08176 I0@ 60>>725 IY A7Q< d_% ]3<(' 50125 [<)#<")#T H952> ?261739 \ 34 1A2 ]/B? P61 Z08 >2@7812>25 01 B3S762 ?101739 ?

!" #

$% "

& '

( "

) (&"* #" %"'*! & #&&& +!

*+ ,!+' "+) -) .

" /

" & 1'! '!, 2 # !) 3! + !* %

" /!0

& '!

& # " " !" 4 -5- (")6)() 7++

& !"'! !* ' "+ #

& 0 #&& & ! ! ++* %+ '

+ ! +' &'+%

$!! !

)8!%!09(: &4!*&#1'!;<5) =) 7% " &"!*

& +"! !+ % "

! * !*

&" *&

& /! $" *& " "0

"+ ( "

& !+ !

" &

" /

0 $"!*!* & ' *+ *!

& ) 7 "!*+,0

!" # !/ ! !

! '!

! $ /! "! )5) >) ?!***"/0 &

!"%+ & "!

"/ !

!) 2) @"! !+ $'

"+ ( "

& ''

*"/ "" " #&+ !/ !*

!") A ! !!

# ! # B !

& " /",

" !*) .&" # +, % C , !!*

& '

& %% % D "! 4! @$ " ",0

&"% "0

$+ %

"!*

& '

+ "+!!

$"+ ) C) 3!

&" &!0 +"! !+ $'

"+ ( "

% " !"!*

& /!0 & "*& +, !/

!") .&"% "0

!"/ $') E) 9"+"! !+ ! &") F) G%"! ! + $

" % $+, '

& B*'!

$, 9 !H$+ .& 4 "' ( "

! IJKKL IMJN OPQ RSJST UV JWJPSMJNX Y5 4(( 3!@! 4(

"# $ %$"

"&" '&( )&(#

"# "#("* #(

+ "#

++$& '" #((#( ), -# , !

./012340 5/670 89: .;7;4 <= /2>7?@ ABBC DEE FG &

)(#-% ! "&" *#-# )#$&(# "# - (#$"

" #H&* # & ,

## # " '" #(( " '

" #$#((&-

#& "

"# $ $ ( "&" "# &$$(# '&( +& (# * $&"# I J .;7;4 <= /2>7? 89: K7L?10 .12MN@ AOOPC DEE OO Q R) # S# D-#*# -" ' #

"&" "#-# (

)&- -#$ - "# $ %$"

), -# , ! "# ("&"#*# "(

++$#-( &

)(#-%# "&" TUJ" ( '#

(#""

# "&" "# "#("*

+ & '" #(( (

" "

)"#

($&- # *#-#

"# !- "&" # &# ( "

)# &

++$& )" &( & - #

+ $&"

## "# $-$*("& $#(

+ "# $&(# "# -"(

V + -

## # " $ -- ) -&"

I S( &!&

## (

W#("

'#"#- "#

++$& &(

# )#-&"# +& # "

$ * '" "#(# - %( (

- +& -# '&(

# "

&$V

+ "*# &

-" ", "

&(( $&"# ( *#

## # " '" #((#( '" "# (#&-$& ("-$"

,$ * ,'""#(#- %( (UX BI J "# $&(# &" & " ! "# -#$ %#-, "

V &$#

"# - & )"

# & $ *# + -'&- "

'" #(( "# (& - $## !(

#("# *&V !

+ #++ -"(I J & $&(# '#-#

## # " '" #(( &(

" )## Y # "# (&+#(" $ -(#

# "

"# -" ( "&" " $

$&-#+

($-" (# "# #% # $#

$# '" #((#( '$ "# ("& " *&""#- &( )##

# & + "#- #% # $# (

"#-'(# "-("'

-", & (-#( $ + # $# & "#, & (

" &#&- "

&%# & , * "%# "

+& (# * $&"# "# &$$(# "#-# (

-#&( + -

" "

)# #%# "#*

- &$# -# & $# ($"#("* #(I I S# -# $"& $#

"# &-"

+ "# %

&!#-( "

" Y &(

## # " '" #((#( ( #"#- ("-& !#

- )# #%&) #I Z# #-&

, # # )#

! ! "

"! ! #$%

$%! &' % ! (!

"!) $ *

%+,$

")#$),% & $$#' -$ !! $%. /0. 1 %'% ! $ '% !) 2! , 3 - #& % %' !) ' ' !) , ! !) 456+ ! " # ' &

-# ! 3 %-%$ ! 789:8;< =;:>? @AB =C8CD EF G:H8IJ K0L//M N 5OO P0/+ ")% Q R& S) 5#,% O #%! &%' !)! !)% " #--$! ','! '$ ,% '#$' & !) ,% $#! % %' !) $ , ! -

3 '$. S)%- %+ !) ' ' !) , ,%$ ! !) --$ - O)$ T2% , ! -$$. S) $ '%' , " !)! % ' ' !) , - !) %$ !$ ! !) --$ - !) O)$ T2% " # ' & #--$! ! $ $ #' !)! !) , ) & !,%' "!). Q R& S) 5#,% O #%! !) $ - =C8CD EF

9;AA8 @AB U8:VG9; =8?EEJ 0LL K/M 5OO NNW+ ")% !) , - $& K XM " ! - % $)$ 2! -!% - #% ' - %$ % + &%' !)! YS) '$ - Z[*/ " $! %$ ! !) --$! !)! !) %!$ "% 3,! !) T2$ \ 3) -% ")% !) "% &% # )! ' ! - % $)$ 2! . S) % ! ,$! ,,% ! ) & ' & !) Q ) O #%!. 1 ] ^ $ K#,%M+ ! "

' ' " !)! ")% !)% ' ' !) , + !) ,% $#! % " # ' &$ # %& . [)! " ,)' % !' ! ,% ,% ' - $#! '

- !) _' %!$ . 1 !) &$3 % #' ! !)! ,%!$# % $+ ") ' - N !) " !)% ' !)% " $ % '$ ! "!) ") !) %!$ "%

+ !) '$ " %'%'. ` '$ "

' ! ) " !)! !) $ !%&' %!$ "% ,% ,% $#! '

' ,% ,% - %. a#! !) -$!# !#! '--%! )%. S)! & + !) Q ) O #%!R X#'

! ' !' $%#! ' !

! " #$ "

"%& '(%" ) *%*%+

'(%" ,-./01 203 45-5/ 67 -89-.-: ;<<= >;? @'@ >'%A &? B=C D-EFE 203 G1/ 45-5/ 67 -89-.- C ;<<H >;? @'@ >'%A &? ;IJC

65E- K-E 203 45-5/ 67 -89-.- C ;<<>B? @'@ >'%A &? IC (* & "

! " L "

*"" % "

% C #$ #%! M "

" &$ L N $C O A "

% ;< $ %* "!&$ "

M "

A*& " "

PQRC )(& " # L"& " "

L "

*% (" C * &&$ ) "

% *%L % % "

&( "

" "

A*&

# "A*%)"

% "

M #%(M " (" "

" "

A*&

# "A*% )"

% "

" "

% ) & S ! !&#& T A""% L L "C UVWJC 'X(%) % Q M

LL%A "

" "

A*& *% & ) *" "

LL L "

A & YZA %C [ & ) *%*%

" C )

UVWC '@\ Q M

"M% &&$

L%A %*" L "

A*& *% & )"

[]'

"%& '(%"

# *%*% **% " L ! %M "&$

&( "

" "

% )

A*&" & S ! * L LL!" L []' '

AS(% Q M ' "#& X(%! % Q M C ) **% *% (" )" %M% M *" L

*%*%"$ #$ !"M" M LL % [&S L A*& )"

PQR "

" "

$ %A " " ) &

("$ "&& *" )"

PQR %M% "

% & )%

% C )

) *%! L%A "

%*%"YZUVWO^R#$"

PQR OJ T" "

"MC (%!$ L

%" ("

%" ("& M "

"(% L %! & \(% " L "

]M '(%" (

A""% A$ " # *" ] _#&

Q(*%A '(%" "

-F`//5 4E.a1 ,EFF 203 45-5/ 67 11-55E0a-81: >;<;;? H Q'' ;<JC %M% "

Z% L *)% #$ "

]M '(%"

! " # #" $ % "& "$ '( " " "& )" "& # " " $ " "& *""$ " +" " ) " "& " "& # #* "

! # #" " %, "- #*"

" " ++# " "& ) "

# %*!&" #. /& 0!& 1*" #)

! " # #"

" *++ " 2# "& 3*#"

4 " "& ++

" #*"

"& #+ " # 2")

-. 5#" 678 "& 1)

9#* 1 : &" '191;< " 3*#"

"& +*+ " , "

" "& ##"

", ++",

!$ " # $ # + $

" "& !* ",

, +# ! *#&

#*". /& %3#" "& + " " !&" + " " #"

3*#"

-. /& & " % -

= * -&#& " % ") "& )" * # . >"

"& " -& # "& )$ "& ?

1*"

" -

!"& *+ "& #" # "&# ""& !.; @A . /& 1*" BC BDEBF GHI BJKHL MNCBDO PQ@R 511 S T 9U0 VA7$ *+ "& #"*) WBXBYYBEL LZN[LBD\ GHI BCB\BY ]^YXLO :PQQP< A 511 A7$ -& -& -& 2+* "& #+

3*#" "& 0!& 1*"$ 0 _% /& 5*+) 1*" & & "& "$ '> # "

%3#"

3*#" "& 0!& 1*" ! * 5#" RQ@ 191$ " #

*+ *+ #)

#*" 4 + "

*+, 3*#" $ ) " ##" )# ! 3*"#

) )# #+"

-$ !* ", +#*$

#" ++ +# *" ++ " & & " ") " -&#& * "$ "& & $ ) 3*, " "& * ) "

$ $ "& "&$ )

!" #$% &'$ ( ! # )"!

*!+#"#, - * !

+"+#" ". !

/#!

/ 0 !

/ ! !

+" +!1 !!"$ 2" /# / .+! !

"+ " !

!! "

0 +"**!! 0, /" + ". # 34

0 "! "! 0, !

+"# ." !

!!"4 + *

.# / ! *+ / ". 5!+$ ( "!

". + !

3"# # !"

+"+#" !

, "!

3 "0#0!."!

+" +!"".!

!!"$ &$

/ +" !

* !! #/ ". !

."1. 5/*!4 !

)"! 0# !" .

, !, " ##/ #!, !

./ "+"0, !

! #)"! 0,!

!!"

0+" +!$ &7$ 8#!

!#,4 !

! " !!"

0, * 0/ 0.!".*!$

9:9;<9= >;<?@ 9ABACD EF G$H * I !

J/K " L MK2" I !

0# L MK2"