← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/913/2020dismissed

Ahmed v. Samsu And Others

2026-02-17Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj17 pages

            

 ! "#$%$ &' ())*) 

))) $ $ &+ % ,-- - - 

- )))%. &"&

%     '  /0 ) - ,

-)  1  



     

 !  ,

-)  12 )

+ 3 "# $%%%% & ! 

!!

       &  %&      !  '     (

   !!

   (  

)  & %&      !    



   *! 

!  +   

, (

  -%-%-! +& .

   ' "

 '/!

. )+&   ! 

0  +  1

   "(  "  + 02 %

 34 5 4(    3  

 '6#072 8%% 

4 -277 7 8%$ 6"     4  

  9   0    )

    , (

 %%:%2! +& 4  .

 ) )+&

!! ! +& ! 

, (

 * "   +  ( )  !  1

  4      ! 

! %%

   !     !! ! 

!    

! +    

  !   

)  ) !  -%8   

 



    

        

                   

        

        

   ! "

   #

      $

 !

% $  &  !  '

() *) $ # +

,-,,.,,)/    "

 

    ! "

      "

   #

      0    

 #

% 

  !"

  !1   2,  ( !  

 

  #       "

  

7 3 "





    

4 7 *(

) ,   &   (

; ) , (

!  ) + 

+& 

 

      + * "       !

, (

!* (      *  

!!

+&  "  ! 

"  +(   !!)   * "    !

   ( ) 

)     

) !!   

  !

(

 8    +(

+&   

 ! 

  +    (!



(<   

 

=,!

   ="

+  9  6       !    !    ) )   ((

   

 ++&     

  (  6            (!



 ) )    4!     

       !     

   

      +

& (  (

9       !  !

 

 (!



   ( &((+ 6     !

&   !            (!



    1  6      %>%>% (!



) (

 

 (9   

&  =(   !) . 

 *(!



  )   !)) 

 

 =,!

    ( &    ) &    

 & ) 

& 

 +&    !   ( & =(  <  4++4 # (  4( 6 ( 

 9 ! ?

   9  ) )      )!      6  

   <  @<   + )

 (  (!



    + ) ( & 

   4++( &   ( & 6  



  # (       (!



   4(  4    =(   !

      !     (!



6     ) (!



   !)!! 

   !   =(  ' + )    (!



; 4++ + )    (!



;   4     + )       (!



;   # (       + )   )    (!



 4(  + )     (!



   

   6 (  + ) )   (!



;   + )     (!



;   9 !       + )        (!



; ?

4(  9    

+ )     (!



6     ) . 

!)  (!



  ()   + )+&

 4++   6  

   <    + )  

 .  ).   

6  

   # (    + ) 

     .     4     + )   )    . 6     

     !   + &  

 #  7%%>A 0 78%%" (+  !  (  (!



   

   

 ( 6             

8 0 (.     ++(  !    !    )& (        

 (!



    ( & ((+  *  ,  )   "  = !  

  ) &) (  (

'(   !   ,  )   ! *(!



)   

4 ,

= ! 9 ))  (  (

B 

 

  (!



!&     

  !   $   (!



  (  '6# )    9         ) !!  #& )     (

 )

  ) (!

    &   !

4 :7"")  +(

  

 !   ( &4(  # <    4++ :  "!   

) !!

        

4 %:"" -      !(       ( & 4( 

# <   4++)   ((

  !

 + 

4 -7778%$)   2 6" 72% ) &!

  

&  (           !!

 )   

4 72 ""  ((  !  ))!



( 0    

 *  !!

  )  !

& 

) 1    =(   :>>%$    )    ((     

         %>%>%:

$   &  ) ,  ! 

  2 * ! 

 D(   (!



 ( <    B   7>>%8 +  +      ((    =(  =!   (  (

 (!



ED B> % . )  D(    B   %2>%7>%$ +  

((    =(      (= !!     ! 

  465,& ) D(  B7 $>%:>%$+  

((    =(  * )

 )  D(   B- %>%>%-    &((   (  4( EDB7>&((   ( 

EDB7>F &((   ( # ED B7>"  46. " ) D(  B >%>%:

&    ((  =(  =    EDB>'6#EDB>  (

 EDB>F 7

++ )  D(    B8   %8>%->%:    D(  >%7>%- B:= !!    ! 

  9 5   0&  )  D(    B$   %:>%>%:   ((    =   

  EDB$>     1EDB$>F EDB$>" 

# EDB$>9 EDB$>E 8 # 6 ! .  D(  B:> +(

  

! 

 

: $ 46? ! ) D(  B2)(    )  6C ! 

  : *  4 5 & <(     4      ! 

  7$%-+&(  !  (

 - (

      ! 

 4  77 "" )  ! & ) &   

 

 

 

(+& ! 

 !

 (    +



 2       4 * (       

)  (

ED9 !&  "  ED9 !& # "     

 +&(  !  (

 %    )          )   

  * .

    '  "

  '/!

 .    , (

 -%-%-   ! 

)   +  !    

  ! 

  +&     +   +    &  ! 

0  )1

    (

(      "(  !!  +  0"#- %-   -%2%- )  !  +   "    4   5 , (

 %%:%2  !! )   ( =   ! 

!  

 

!!  +   ! 

 

  "   )  & 1

   ! 

 0         +  (

(+&!



    

-  &    '6#  )      &   

'6#+  ! 

&D!

   !  )  

  = !    9      )       !   ( +   ( +

  

 6     +(

   &   )! +    (  ! 

0 )  )



 (

  ! 

)

  =    

 "      

    

#    !   &!  D   ,    +&*"   !!  !    ) )   &(



   ,    +&  !  )   +& ! )!  ) ) 

+

+    ! 

 0    !  6  

  , (

)!   ,

  

(  ) 

 

   (!    

 + +& !   7 6    

!!  +  

!      , (

! +&   "  )

  !!

"   *   "        (

    +   !     

   +     

 

#    

 !   )

   ,    

   + /5  / #   #  %  /

   

 



/   



      

 / 

   

60 # # 7     

2 

   %    

2222 /   60 /    2 222      

    "

       # 

   #  )  +   #         60   # 

 

/    #      

8#  

     60    # #    # 

  9 #1



  

 60   #    

            /  /

#      

 / #

.

+  #/      

60

 

   #      

 



  





 

  #      #     

  *





 9 

     #      

              

 60  9     # 



 



 /     #  

        

       #       /    /   

 

60   /   

 



    /   #  

  

 (   

 

':2  !  ;  ':<  %  2222 9 

       

60   

 = ':.*>  # 

 



!3<"   ':.

6    60  #  

  =  ':.*! 

 

% 

':.

' 

60= ':.*! /  /   2 222    

    ,      

   

 ':2   ':  

           1  /   %  '    9 % #   

    #  1 # 





= ':(*> = ':(*"





?+  ' 

  /  

   

 2222    @ .'$    

 

 

  

  

? +    #    1  /   

  &

$ % 

      9       

   $ A &

$ %  # 3 > 3   22222  / 

   #  

  2 ) '$  22222 !  # 

 

   3  1 

 7        

 !  ;  /  

   3  1 

 7

 1 < 9     

 /  60 /    

     

</ /   #&

$ % 

  

  

    <       

/ #       $

   

   <   '  

# 2*2 )'$ 

    

2       

    $ % 

     /    #%      / 

  ).#    

   /  #        #   3  1 

760 # 

  

     

 <  !

      /      

   

   

          

    #  %   

  *

60

3  1 

7 #  #    

   #  #

     

   

 

#    

3  1 

 7 #        3  )22 "

'

"

 =     

     

             3  1 



 *)         

   

     =      #  

    

/ *    /     2222

 2)222

            22222  /  /

 

 3  1 

7 6      /    2.222    

   2.222 

/   

   

  # /  

  =  ':2*!  /  

   # 

  2 222  ( '$  =    

  /  2.222 

  # 

 2 222    ## 

('$     / 

 9   

60      

    / /  

 * 

   #      /         

 #

-  / 

  #       # 7     

   

60

   #   @  

 = ':2*!# +  <

    $#

#             

 9    

  "

 





  3

;    2 )2-  

/ <

  + #  /  #   5  !''

3  / /   / #  /   #       /   #     

    

       

        

0   B3

 ? $# 2@@-" <"

  24 / # #/ 1  # # /

    

  /  /

  / # /     / /   #     



  

4 8 '

    )  +& 4  " , (

 %%:%2* 

!   , (

  

 B      

     

     

 /  

 C  9 

    60# 

    9   

3  1 

7  # 

#

  "

 #   

  



      / /  

  #  #

 # /  #           /        # #     /            #   2  3 

   

     

        60 #    

7 

    "

       /  

   

 #   

  = ':2*!      

%  2 2 22 /    / 

     

2 22 ! 



 #  1   <  ! ; / %  '   

/   /   

   $ % 

   %% = ':(*>   = ':(*" /    #   

 ? +  9   3  > 3 

   $  &

 $ %   22 2 22   /  



   1  !  ;   #   

  3  1 

7  



    1 <  

 3  1 

 7 22 2 22 ! 

  ': 1 <

    $ % 

           D          3     1   ! ;  /  

   3  1 

 7  22 2 22 /     1  <        2 22  D    #   <   

          3    

    60

   

      "

           

  /  60 /    

     

 < /  /      #&

$ % /  

 

   <       

  /  # %     7    60 # 



 #  

       

 

     

 

 7 



                       # 

 

     

  /     

     

  

  

            #

 #      

       

  / #  



/     

    # #

 

#       

    7      60



         #        /     

       !  

    #  

   

      

   



         

  

 

 

#            #   960    # 

 

            

    

 

 

   # 

   #  

  *

  

    #  #  

  # 1    )  3    

     

         

 



     

3  1 

7 

 5   

"

 

/     "

       

          

     #  % 

  #  # 3  1 

 7 #     !         

   /  

     

 3  1 

 7 #       )22

"

'

"

9 

   

     

   

 

    

 #   $ 0

  1  !  ;     

8         

 !    3  1 

7/ 

  1  /      #   %    

 

 = ':2*!

9

   %            

  1  !  ; 

3  1 

7 

9    

   # #

    

   

 

       /    

               #  

7   

605

      #   /     

         

          60 #  

    9      #1

      

   

  60        



  

    #    



      /  /

   

   # /   

/    



  9

    #        60    "

    #       

    

   #   #  #                /  

   %  

 

>/  #   #   #      / 

  #  # 

 # #   #  #

     #    9 

          4 $    

 

  +    ! + 

& +&+  " 6 )  ! 

&

    &       !  



$

    (     +(     )

   ) 

9 

       

!

 %%%F    !   !  +   4 ,  = !      +  (        

   ) 

  ) )

   (( +&

! 

!   : =    +      +     ! G 

!).  9    (

 ! (!

 +)

 )    +  ! (

 ! *+      (   !    ,   

  !    

     &  , &   +    * (     ! 

  !  

) & !

  

 -   

!  )  ) D    ,    ="      !!    6   

& 1   D(  )   

   +&  ! + 

) +& "  )   

)   +      !++    ) ( ( 

          6      

  !( +   

 (       

 :  +      ( &+  (&  

)  ()



 +

 

 )        

&+&+ 

"  2 '  

 & !  &(!! &(   

  , (



! +&+  "    & ! *! 

!   ( 

: 7% !&   + 

="  4  "((

  (    &  4+5 +6 (2 *)

,

-)  1 + + +