High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27078/2023dismissed

Harvinder Kumar v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And Others

2024-05-18Mr. Justice Namit Kumar20 pages

$

2" '

# /

$/;

3""

!"

2"

"

"#

4 ) (!& )

! '& 4 (! 5 & ) '

"

" 6 $

& &

!

" " '7 (

%"& !"

'! !" % % %

( ! "

)' " *+

! "

, "-(

'( ! "

"

" ( " ! "'"

!

$$..

& ! !'! ! "'"

!" " ! ( ( " $/$$ 0)1 /8& ( ! '

"9 "

"

! "- -( "

.+$* %"

"' :

'"& " !

! "

& ! ! !

! "'"

< ''% :

:

0

.$$.

. " ? < ''

- '!( "" "9 %& ! "

- '!( ''

*$.

. ! ! "

!

"

- '!( '! ( $*$.* =" "'"

( "

;;$.. ! " "( ( " 2( < '' 5$ " "'!

( !

! (

"

$$ , !" !

! ! ! ! -

& & ' -

! '

%"& !& !

! < ''% :

& 5 6- > ?! & :!& '! !&

( "

$$.. !

"

"

%"

- '!( " " '! ! ( " " " ! % $... !

"

" "

" ! $

$../ ' ( ( "

$$.. '

%" "' !

!

?! "

"

( $$.

! !

( ' "#

! ""

#

!

!

% &'

(

)

, !"

! ! ! " ( !" % ! "

"

' $/$$ !% ! ( "

$$..

. ?!

& ! " "

( "

!"

"'"

$$.. "

;;$.. ;

@ '

' '

%& "

" ! "!

% %

%

< 3-"

" 5(& > % '%& 56>?& : !& ! !" " " # * # # +

. ""&

,-.

. @$@ !

+

/ 0

#

#

. @$@

!.""

12 3 , 4

+ 5 .""6

+

$57,578971:.&

& ""*

#

1

+

+ ;.

.

;.

! ""

1

#

. @$@

!

+ /

0 <

=12 3

, 4> "

""?

+ 5 .""?

( *"?

1

! ""?

;

+

1

""!

+

;.

&

#

/

/.

1 ,

-.

. * * ""!

?

1 /

52 3

37

< 3

B2 3 37 322

3

52 3 B2

3 .

.

0 <

: < - 37

5 C

# 5D@$@

! ""

0 <

#

!

= + 1.&>

1319C @

1

/

@

8 1

/

"

/ +

1

1

# #

! "" 0

1

! "" )

/

/ , "! & ! "

"

" ! " ! ! "'"

! ( "

! '

!"

'

$$.. ! " ( ( " "

!

! 9 9 '

' '

!

! ,?, ! (! %" 1 '

' ''

- , !"

! " ! ! " " """

! (

% '!"

*

'

"

! '

! !

"

" ( "

$$.. ! "

"

! ! ( " "

"

! "

.+$* % " "'

' ( ! " "' !

! "

" ! ( "

$$..

$/$$ "' !

! ' " "" % !"

"" 6 $

$../ / '

"

!

' '

! ( "

!" '

% &

' ( , &

' ) # # *

+

! "#

$ @ ! ! !& '

'

"

! "

"

" ! "

.$$. " ? < ''

- '!( ""

( !

"

- '!( '

'' *$. & ! !

"

- '!( '!( $*$.* "'"

!

*

( " ;;$.. % ! " < '' 5$

$$ ! " !" $* %"

!" ' ( ( "

$$.. ! " "

" """ ! ( (

% '!"

! " ! "

" "

& ! " ( "

$$.. " ! " ( ! 9 9 ' !" "'"

! ( " ;;$.. ! ' ( "

"( !" ' ' '

!'! ! '9 $.. , ! ! '

"

! " " ! '

! ! """' .

?!" 0

1# #

* -./ !

! '

"( ! 9"

% !"

" ! " #

3

&

2 +

+

* @

&

/

/

E 2

+

2

!3

!!34 +

& %

/ / 2

3 %

!

$-./

G.

:

@

$ 9

5 3 ;

4 ; 5 3

@;

"&"

3

"I

3

4 1/ C

1 9

1

0

:

J <

H!?* =6> I

F( 9

,#

2

#

4

2

# $

2

2 /

* @ 3 5 B H""6= >

; ; ;

6&?

""6 =*> &!

I

0

+

& 9

0 9 +

& 9

+ 2

@

K 0

& 9

3

/

+

@ 3 5 1 (

J @;

"!?

3

6I

0

&

9

0

+

#

@

+

0

+

2 ,

+

2

/

2

&

#

.

+

+ +

# 2

/

#

4

#

@

//

B

.

F

/

+

B

2

@

K

@

2

.

/

+

/

8

2 E

$

2 /

3

K

+

.

L< /K

L;

M 8/K

@

F

&

+

2

32 5

3 0 6 => 39$

G.

F"

@

0K 3

9

"

+

?

:

9

#

+

!

@

+

N J ( J

$$

3 ?=> 3 9 $ * &

=> *&* G.

F& #

+

+

&

9

#

6!

"

"

(

& 6

? $

*

6 /

6 &

O

?

C

#

(

?!

* !7.

$

/

@

57 ;

B E N

@ E ="!">

6&

C

/

@ + C

G

F1

.

1 K

K

+

2

B 1

+

-

@

-

0

+

+

$

9 @

2

2

K

F

!

E

3

</ E 3 5

<

E ""?=> 39$

6"

=39>

=""&> & &?

@ /

$

$

3

G

+

. =>

=> 3 +

+

$

+

@ +

/ /

$

"!"

+

#

+ .

=> =>

+

=>

=> +

$

2

"

3 J C E 3

0 "

""!=> 39$ & =39> =""?>

& !

/

$;

9

@ G

F$

&

9

/

/

M 1 3

K

2 F

@ N @ E <

E

""?=> 39$ ?

=39>

=""?>

"6 G

F8

2

$ ; 1 J

J

2

$ +

9 < =

> / J @

2

$ ?.

."

"!?

J

F

@ - 8 4 $ < ;

E *=> 9$ ?!

=39> = *>

*? C

F$

"?&

0 "" @

"?& ""

$/

9 B <

5

<

:

2 @

/

F

0 K C , 1 "

"6

G F@

=> # K

P

=>

K

#

@ 2

# P

@

$*

N

F

@

#

@

3

/

# #

2

@

(

/

# (

(

# F H,

I )

$ A!& >" :'!

!" 1#) #

5 4

* -./ /$ !" ! " # "

:

2

! 6 "

=1.&>

6 *

/

9 9 <

$

9

:

J

+

*

* ""?

J

(

@

3 9

( B 5 9 1 3 E

?="> ?! G

F6

;

8 1 ?

?

/

3 @ $ @

"!

.

8 1

@

+

2

$

9 B

+

# 2 3 - 8 4 $ <

;

E H= * *>

*?I

N 1 J (

J 3

H & => C,

* *?I </ 1

9 C 5

B

<

H= &> *

IF

3 J C E 3 0

E =""?> & !

3

9G

F$ 9

&

9 @

3

/

/

M 1

2 3 K

.

7

"?* ; "!

;

2 F

@ /

/

2

J

) $$ ?! ' ' ( ( " !

'

$$.. !"

! ! % "" "' ' "- % ! ! " 6 $

! % $../

' ( $../& !

'! !" !

$.

( "

!

' $$.

.. ?! "'"

!

( " ;;$.. ! '

! "

* %"

!" '

( " $ < " "

& ! '

!

( "

$$.. ' '' " % ! 9 9 ' 1 ' "'

' ?'!' '"

"",,, 2 ( " $..*

< '' 5$ " ' '

! ,?, ! (! %" 1 ' ''

- ?!

! 9 9 '

' '

! ,?, $$.. !

""

'!

<' :

' 1 4'!& $..

./ ! '

!

%

!

! '

1 $$$..; ?! & ! (

(

""

( ' 1 $$$.. ?! '

!

% ( ( ! "

"

! " 1 4'!& $..

$.. ! ! '

!

' %

""( !" 1 ?

?! & ! !"

" !

!" ' "" ' ' $ $.. '

( ( !" "'" ! ( " " < '' 5$ ;;$..

?! "+(" ' % '

"

!

! '""

% & , & 0" 8

' ! '"

! " '

" " !"

! " "+(" ?! ( ! '"

) # 0" 8 " "

' ! '"

! " '" "

! "

! " '" " ! !"

"

! !

- ! ! "

$.$ !

1 "'

* %"

" !" "'"

( " % ! "

" ! $;$$ !"

"

( (! ( "

! "'

'"

! !" ! '

"9

" % "

$;

,

! & " "

% !

! " " !% """

$/;

2 !! "

-(+"

# B"+6

!! 2

# B"+6