High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/37551/2018allowed

Amar Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-01-28Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj11 pages

"#$#%&''

! (& )*( ' +, +' ----- $% & '()*& #& +#,-&.* *(&& &+#,-& / *" &"& ('0& + + 1& & 22222 , +' .'/ 0 12 , *'3* "

&1 0&# * "

" .& 5 * ,- / * " ./ 66777 &4 3.* &44 -

8' &4 9 / + *., + #'

3 * -'

/ & 3'0 + '

4 / * " - / * "

&1 / / *

,- '

*"4-1/6:6;<6;66=;66>6< #6>66> &

4&""& 3 9*&4//*" - *& * " .& &"" # & & "& 0 ." * ! "& / 1& & 667>?&/ * &0.&

#* '3* * 0"410 @-*& 3 * " - '# , * &#

%% #"& & 0& " # & & "& 0 ." & * ,

0 1'

,#- "

1+& #"'

+09&4&, -* #&/A 3 - *&*" *&#& 4 /4#%=6=B/77>4#&

-4&0 3

+.*-*.& # #/91* '

.*&# - *

# * -4&0 /*"4-1#&#66777

/# 91 * & / 1& & '90# *& * -4&0 / * " / '

* &#"4-1*&#9 A-#91*

*3 '

#*& " . &,&4&94 : 0/ 04& 41"4&-#"

*&#4& /4#

.*-* 8' / -

# & 9/ * '

.& & .** "& 0 . C

& 4#9 5# ,- /*"4-1#&# 66777 * &# .

" .& # # / ,# A'#30 #&#666691

' 3*/44. 3# -

%:%

# $% &''()*+,&'''-

0 1 2 3

2 2 45

6 4

)

5 8

%=%

" = * &/ &# A'#30 / 6666 .& '9A- 0& / -*&44 3 "-&4&, 9/ * D94'"

* 0& /

!" !#

$ * &#" .& # 0

#91* D94'"

/ #&,# A'#30 #&#6:66 &-#.**&9,& #*&, 3 " 9' 5 * ,- / "& 0 . C

+ * */ - & 1

0 / 1& &&##

#&4 /B66* 91 3 *& - * "&

# 91 * 3* '

*& && # / &41+ * "& *'4# &C &""

& &- / 5 3 * ,- / #&41 "& 0 . C

& * .

# -0"4& - * + * #"& ,5*#'-& "& -0"40 #* &0& 3&,& %#&# * 04& 41"4&-#0"41 " /

0/*

/ / 04& 41"4&-#"

*&,9 &"" ##&4 3.**"

" &

%<-44-,41

- *& .* & # 3*&/ &##,4"0 + "

. *., &C 91 * * 5 * ,- / * " # " * " *&, 3 9 0#-&441 @&0 # & # *

" *&, 3 9 91 * 1'

,#- #-&4 //- * - //- - *&* 04& 41"4&-#0"41 & .44& "

.*. A'

*" *&# -* 9 5#91

%B% *#"& 9' * "& 1 .& @ ## * " .* *&# 9 # #&44* &#9 / B / * '

&4 # &.

* #&# 76> "&

# 91 * '

.* - / * " .&

-# & # * %& .& # -# -

# * -& / * " / / 0*#&/* &"" ,./* A'#30 #&# 6=66> "&

# %667%6? 4# %&"'

(

'/ - &4 0&# * &//#&, #&# 6B6>6= /4# 91 *

& - + 1'

*"& -0"4& -* #&#6>6B6=-&44 3'" * /'

* * 1 " / * " & &,&4&941 / * " * 1& 6 - *& & " * &/ &#&//#&,+ # "'*&*" *&#9 &"" # & "& 0 ." + & #"'

+ - 09&4& 6=67>? #- '#. C& &"& 0." &""

@0&41/ :1&

9/ *"&

#&.&1 6766 &4 &#*&& "4-1 #&# 76<6 / / ,- .&

'# / &# *-;- &-;"& 00"41- '9A-/'4/440 /*/44. 3 - #

$% /5

)

&% :

+%%;

%?%

)

< <" )

# 0

/ 5

, 2 !

'90 *& .* & # 3*&*# -

8' . 9&""4#&44 04& 41"4&-#"

+*., +* ,- / *" . 44 5# <

* - *&& " *&/ &#&//#&,/4#91 * +* &0/**'

9& #/*" /3'

#& &4

7.* & & #* 3* /(*'#&&0.*.& &"" #& "& 0 ." & &'

&+ - 09&4& :6:7>7 & # .& &

%<% &4 :7 *&# &4 &#1 9 5# - ## *& * -+ "

*0& 3**&,&4 &#19 5#.* & * 9 // *& 9 3, *" > '

4 / * " *& &4 "4&-# 4& - * A'#30 #&# 66= "&

# 91 D94 * '"

0 '

* 0& /)((

* +

& 3'/,-. / $0 1$* 4,& @ &-* / &# *'

$% =&> 2

. 9

. @ 7 &

4&""& 3 9*&4//* %&+ *., + /

*&/ &#&//#&,& #- *&*" % 0& 3*

-#-& #+, *'3* & #* 3* / (*'#& &0

& -'4# 9 5# - * .& 44 & &

%>% -'4# "

#'- & 1 - /-& / 8'&4/-& .*-* .& / *

&4- #

/* /-& #&#76<6 6

* - *& & "

-4&0 3 9 / /

.& 8' # /'4/44 * &-&#0- 8'&4/-&

& "

- 9# * &""4-&94 ,- '4 - ## *& & " *

,- '4 &""4-&94 * #-& #%0& 3* * "-, #"& + C .4#3 / * 3 &4 4& 3'&3 & .44 & / 34 * 4& 3'&3+& 0&19"

- 9#91* ,

0 / 000+.& *

&4&-&#0-8'&4/-& 4& - "4&-# - # B #.*-* @ &-#& '

$% =A

4 * / * -

. + *., + # "'# # : &C 3 *-

# & *- -'0 & - -#&9,+ ,# *&*-4&0/*#-& #" / /*"4-1/6.*//-/ 0*#&.* * A'

. "

0#*& 9 # # 441 *9& /- # B #/*

&# "4-1 & " .*-* * "

- #-& # ## *&, & 1 &-&#0-8'&4/-& /

#* = / #*& ,./*'

# "'#" *&*#-& # " *&#9 3&3# * ,-.** *1& 7>?& #*&# ,#& '-*44*"&

#&.&1 66+*&, 3 #:

%7% 1&

/ ,-+* 4& - - # B #.'4#9

4,& *

&#- # # "

- 9#& 10 0'0&-&#0-8'&4/-& - /-& 8' # 9 9& # 91 & "

. C 3 & & "& 0 ." & #* 41 8' 0 "

- 9#.& *&*;

* *'4#"

* 8' C .4#3/* 3 &44& 3'&3& #/ 34 *& 0&19 "

- 9# 91 * ,

0 / 0 0 0 * &9 - / & 1

- #;

" *& #-& # 0& 3* ## "

C .4#3 /

3 &44& 3'&3 34 *4& 3'&3& "

- 9#/ 000+* -& 9 & 1 "

'0" *& * &# ## /'4/44 *

&4- #

/ -

# & /* -4&0/ /*"4-1/6'

341+* + * &#&//#&,*&#

'90#*& #'-& &48'&4/-& - /-& '"" /* -4&0 *&#9 /'

*#910& 3*+*., +*1*&, /

#& 1 - # & " .*-*& 1 "-/-&-&#0-8'&4/-& .& 8' # 9"

#91&"

C 3&"" ;

&3&

*" / ." C 3 C .4#3 / * 3 &4 4& 3'&3 & # 34 * 4& 3'&3.& * 41- &"

- 9#/ 9 3 5#*" / ." & # * 3, /&- - .* * #-& # *&# &4 &#1

,#/ &" #/:1&

+-&

'0#*&*.'4# *&, . C 3 C .4#3 / * 3 &4 4& 3'&3 * 34 * 4& 3'&3 & .'4#9

&4/ *0&

& ## -*& 3* #' B / # *& * A- / * -4&0 441 * &/ &# 9& & 3

0 &4 @ - '

&C 91 * .*-* *&, &C -& 3 / * &-'&4 3 '

&4 * 0

%6%

#91*" * &#" .*'& 1-0"4& 94& -* *& *'

3 '

-#*#"

,& /*9 //

'-* .*0 -&4 3 '

.*-* & '9 & &# '"" # 91 & 1 ,# -& #91 /

34&-C/&-&#0-8'&4/-& .* & '-*

8' 0 *& 9 "

- 9# * "4-1 .'4# 9 / - 3& 0"41& '

143& ? 3 /-& 41+ / * # -

3, 91 * '

A'#30 #&#6666 *0& / 2 *&* -4&0 / *&44 9 #-4 # 41 * 3 '

# *& * 0"41 # "

* &-&#0-8'&4/-& * &# A'#30 && #/ &41& '9 8'

. "&

# -0"4& -*

-+*4&-C/&-&#0-8'&4/-& -'4# 9-#& *9& #-4 9 // *"

.* ,#/ :1&

8' 41+/ #*&* &

3, 91* .44/'

## 4&.& #& 9& #'" "

&--&4&""4-& / * "4-1 4/ 3 40 $ % 50# 4

#% #$ ""0!#%617

115 !' > * & # -# 5 * ,- / * " / 0 * #& / "4-1 .*'

3 '" * &443# 8'&4/-& ;- # /

# 4&'

B # / * "4-1 / & -*+ 6+&4 3.*&44-

8' &49 / 7 * #/'49# 91* %"& .* & " #/* 0 * / -"/- /#-"1/*

%% 6 0&#-4& *& -& *&#0

949 / +/& 1+&

4& #.* *&/ &#" #/* 0 * +*" ;* 43&4*

*&449 4#* &#9 / &4 3.* E?F"

'0/ 0*#&*1/44#'44* &-'&4# 9'

0 /, +' 2 . B ** "&C 3;

& # & ! ; ** " &94 $ ! ;