M/S Golden Infrastructure Private Limited v. State Of Punjab And Another

 



    
     

 

!

"#  !

!

         

 


   

         

 

       

     !  

"  



         

 

       

     ! 

"  $   %&$  '
'

'( )

  %&$  '
*
)''

   
 

    

  !"  

 
# 
$

 %&
 ' ()

#*+,-(-.+(./0

 1
 )

#*+/0/./+(.((  '

'( )

 +   /

$ "%%3 "$ %" %%

(

4$$ 3 " "



,

5$+%  3' ( 6" % ,-.*/,,01)2,0/301+

4010/ 22/0,5&67

$   3% /7 /.

(./8
9+(, % /( .:

(./0
9+(7 $  ' (;

#" 22/0, 5&67

:

<                 $   %%"6" %,-."" 22/0,5&67
* %" =(( .7 (./.


9+/


 >

5+%   $%%' ,+

   "        %    "%     "" % "4%?%' 

  @A ' ,$ ",/ .> (./(1;1
 "

<  ' ,"%

 """""6 "4%?6%  "" ";

#

0#2"0,0#81" -

5    %    %    "   "  % ,  -.   B""  &"  '   1  1  '  /    "     (( .7 (./.+"?   59

' /-=/-=(../+>4 (= < =/8/-

#((!(./. 99999 $"? %""% %""

'$"%"$$ % %""1"; """

% ' /-=/-=./+>4 (=-7(, /0 (..-' /-=/-=./+>4 (=-7,0 /0 (..- + C5;'5A
@DC';

A'E'!
FC54;154
'


1;

 
&5  $
$ 
&5  & ( 
&5  4A

%A @$A @$

# @% "  1    

&$ $ #"%( % ""$          "? + F F"  F" " "4 $ #"% / @+ $"+1  (

@+ %"+ + &

, @+  /13

$/"-

&6

 @ #"% $/> % "1  

&$  #"%> %  F #"%$ /> % F"  F" " "4 "" #"%$> %  !"
% $

# @% ( % 51 '4/ / % ""$  "

? +


 %'<  & <? "
  &" '$ 40+55

 %!

6/23/$,/-/20 8- 923/:2342/:23 :,,6/102# "0;422/0,. < / F+1+" ( "+  4AAA !"G
%

#

@%$/> % / F"+
% ( &"+1+'$+ $

& (

 %'< <? "
  &"'$  40+ 55  %! "2/$,/-/26/23/=8-0 8-923/:

  2342/:23:,,6/102#"0;422/0,. < @$AB
""$ "D

F""% "  %    "  4%?    !  ;    

5$"1% ,.

.8 (.//
9+(

5" 9



#$%%$&'$%()((*)+,+-&(#+).$,+-#"
(+./
0123-(4((*)+,+-!5%&+)./()'6$)7-(+.6'+.%&( 8$66+,'#((6-'9+63-(4$&%6'3&%$.'+).$%%$&5+&'.$)3-()&(3(8& :#((6+).+**-(;$4+&'6<= 4'&'-%+9+<3-(4"
-(+. ;;;;

0 $&'$%*+-&(3*-(*(%'.4+%&'-*6+)(3((*)+,+- +).%$&'3+66%5).'--'%$.')&$+6>()'+::(-.$),&(*-(*(%+6  $&'  $% (5&%$.'  &#'  ?5-$%.$:&$()  (3  +,+-  (5):$6 ((*)+,+- @

,-$:56&5-'+-'+$%$)&#''+%&'-)%$.' *')8+:+)& *6+:'$%()&#')(-&#+).9'%&%$.'9#'-'+%()&#'%(5&#'-)%$.'&#'-' +-'-'%$.')&$+6#(4'%+).-'+:#'%6$)7-(+.+).()&#'(&#'-%$.'(3 -(+.$%(8&"$,#:#((6+).%*(-&%%&+.$54



#'-'$%)(#'-$&+,'A5$6.$),+).4()54')&%9$&#$)

4'&'-:$-:6'(3&#'%$&'  

   

!"



#$  

%  &''(

!"

 !

  

  

 )  

  *+

" %$   %          6  "   "  D  @$  )  AA  4$   $               %                (( .7 (./.
9+/ 6" ""  " D  @$ )  AAA  "  3  + "";

#""D@$) AAA 5;

#

,     "        %  $   $"     

/.

<    '  (+

   "

%.8 .( (./7
9+/, "";

# " "  22/0, 5&6<

 5%"3 %;

#+"" """D@$)AAA

//

C$%#%  ' ()

"(.

// (./- #5$" '%$ ""&"'""$ "#"

@%  /( *$#5$"

'' (%% /7 /.

(./8  
9  +(,        #%    %;

# "D@$)AA /, 5"% 
1

  "4%7..

%$ % "

# 1-:.%$ %'

+(/

 

 

    

   -   *./0/  ( <=> ><

/:

" (( .7 (./.D @$)AA$ +

) !+&#$).+ (5&%$.'5)$:$*+66$4$&%9$&#$)
174%(,+/ !+&+6+/+&#+)7(&/!+-)+6+/+6'-7(&6++)."(%#$+-*5- +66(5&%$.'

6$4$&%9$&#$)174+). +),-5-/5)+4/+A#+/+-$.7(&/2(&7+*5-+/'-(>'*5-/ +6(5&/ A(#+-/57&%+-/2+*5-&#+6+/+9+)%#+#-/(*+-/ +-) +-+)/ 5-.+%*5-/+4+)+/ +,-+()+).+)%+ 9$&#$)6$4$&%+).
74 ()A(&#%$.'%(3&#'*(-&$()(3&#'3(66(9$),-(+.%+-')(&:(8'-'. 5).'-+)<*(&')&$+6>()'B
 !+&+6+C 4-$&%+-(+.D  25-+6$C(*+-C+9+)%#+#+-C#+,9+-+(+.

#'  +3(-'%+$.  :-$&'-$+  %#(9%  &#'  3563$664')&  (3  &9$) :().$&$()%$' $ $&#$)6$4$&% $$ $&#$)
74()A(&#%$.'%(3*(-&$()(3&#'-(+.% />
$%' : /-$"" " ""$-:.%%'"4$ ' (/ 

&")1+'$)$$% $/ % 5" "" ""@$ "D)AA%" (( .7 (./.


9+/ " ; # #@E@% @$"D+AA(( .7 (./.   % 
$"  $ %%""%

 

 

    

   -   *./0/  ( <  <

/7 5$"(. ., (./( "%" "%
01 :-'%/""

 B""&"'5" 1 5$ " " .8=(./(,/ .> (./("% " 5" "" $% $" #%
 +%+ #
%

,/ .> (./( 5"$ ",.

.> (./> " " %" ""/: .> (./, $$ 5$" '"

 4$ 5$" '" '  (/.8  /8 .- (./,  "  $ $            " '  /0(>  (, .0 (./, 5%" ".7 .8 (./:

4$ 5$" ' "$$"   "' ,->//8 /( (./:

/-

%" " (:

/( (./:%% 5$ " '" "' (00/7 ./ (./> 5%"

 %" "(> .:

(./>     "   "  $  ""        #%
 /, .> (./7$""  

5$" ' /8 4$$" "% ,.

.> (./7

1 ;

#;9" "%# @<   $$  %"""% %%  A%$" "' -.0/- ., (.(.$  $ 1 ,:

>7@$;

# " A$ $" " ,.

.> (.(($$3@1$"< 1 8(7>..=+ 4$$ %%' /8./8 ./ (.(/$ %  %"%"$"" " "$" "   
:#:23/"2 /0 59 $% $"%  %"= "$ D)AA"$33 %"% %  %"D)AA

(.

5  ""       %      +9 "%$  % "%""D)AA 5%+ 9 !'3(-'.':6+-$),+)<+-'+(3(*+-3+66$),$)(&')&$+6 E()'(9C/&9(:().$&$()%+-'-'F5$-'.&(A'3563$66'.$'

 

$ 9$&#$)45)$:$*+66$4$&%



$$ ()'  2  ()  A(&#  %$.'%  (3  &#'  *(-&$()  (3  &#' 3(66(9$),-(+.%)(&:(8'-'.5).'-+)<*(&')&$+6>()'B + !+&+6+ 4-$&%+-(+. A 25-+6$C(*+-C+9+)%#+#+-C#+,9+-+ (+.

0/1:23"40-08/2#,02302:23/2 ##:0,,/16/23/57

+239;+23/260?"/ 29:0,,/1/ 40+9"26/230:"23#/2;:23"9@#2 442;  :0,,/1  923  6/23/  $  ,/-/2  0  0,  23  "9@#2 442;:0,,/16/23/ )$:923/:23,02)"0,/

40060303 3016000

 3"13+/23608:236A0B1102/1+23 //2/0,,;2:23#/2//23044/2-+/0-"#30+23 "9@#2  442;  :0,,/1  6/23/  $  ,/-/2  0  23  "9?"2 232/0123/?"/-2+230223"9@#2442;/ 0,?"/29:0,,/16/23/ )$:923/:230 C"40D+  239;+  9"2  02"0,,;  23  6  A0B+    239; ?"/2302234262"23020?"020 #12-02/0,9#-0"#?"092323#/2/9#-/1 02/:/ (, A          !  ;   % 
9+( %  "$/ %&"+1+'$+$  5"" 4$ %""%!

  ;  %              "        A$ %" +5.$+6&'-+4*+-&'4   % %"""$

(:

'$ " ""$ #"% 1$"3 4$ %"                  $ 3     "    $        $$ %"3"  " +5.

  (7

"

(- 5" %$$ % ""

(8

 "" 

    C'

'( )

  C*
)''

D

!

!

    (323408/1E0 E (3234209, E