High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/54028/2025dismissed

Mahender Pratap Singh v. CBI And ANR

2025-09-25Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary24 pages

"#"$%"&'()*+* ,$'('-(."&'()*+* /0"(&"$,$/1/234(50 ****,"1414'("$ 6"$#-# "(1$/78-$"/-'9:(%"#145/14'(/(&/('10"$ ***"#2'(&"(1# ;;;;; <= > ?<@ A < ! ;;;;; CDEFEGHIJB $*K#0'LK55/$M/7N3"(4'$K&%'./1"M410 $*O47"#080/$&M/PN$*Q/$4#000/R$/NK&%'./1"# 9'$10"2"1414'("$* $*/%4S/T/7U-21/NK&%'./1"9'$$"#2'(&"(18:* $*O/%L4$/(34(50NK&%'./1"9'$$"#2'(&"(1O'** V ;;;;

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`"$/ 3/.0/ 3/-&/ R"4(5 ./#1$/1"& 10$'-50 10" &'.1'$#N M0' M"$"&4#.427"#'9U-$T""1/T/04T* ^*

( 10" &4$".14'(# 4##-"& R[ 104# '-$1 %4&" '$&"$ &/1"& ^**N 8: $"54#1"$"& / ./#" /(& /91"$ .'(&-.14(5 4(%"#145/14'(N .0/$5"#0""1 /(&

! " # $ % & "

'! ()! ) %# *+ , ! -. +/0 , -. + $ %. 1 % %# 2 "

. 34 % # %# +5 % 6%. +5 % %. . 7 $ % % % %

% % % %# % % " %

% %# !

% %

. 8

% % %# %# #% % 4 %

%# 0 ". $ % "

9 :;99 <=><;?@9

A%B $ %

/ 0 %#C DEFEGCC HICC JFKFLFMKELFCC NMOCC PLFIQRCC SOCC TGMFUC VC ! " " %

%# #% %

%# "

% %# *

% %

%# ! " " !

% !

%4 %# $ % '( .+..!

"% X %# YB! " %

%# "% %

# . 1 "%# Z [ 2. \ " "

$. * "

%%# % %

%" %# ! \ %# % % %# * ! %

0 % %

[

]. $

% %# % %#

% %#

%%# . W

" %

% #! %

" % % 4 . *

! %

% # % " %

( $)

! " # $%

& &% '

( )

* & &+( ,* & + * + !

&( -+ & * ! "&

+ + &&+ ! "&( - ! %"& + . ,

/& " (

&* '

-)( "

"&+ 1" 1 " "&+( / "

-) " "&+ "&+ "( 2 " "

&&+ "" "" ( - * & &+ & &+(

&&+

"" ( ) * & +

" &!

" + (( + "( 0

1 " + ( 3%"

"+ ( 0 * " " ( - "'

& ! " & &" &&+

"" ( 0 ! " & &" 4"5 " * ( - & & 1 "& "

* + * *

!!" # $# % &' # ! ( ) * !

!"!

) ) * " *

! + *, % &', *

) -

! !"

!!" #) .

# "

! # " *

#) -" * # ) .

!" !

" / ! ! * # ) -"

) -

! ! ## !"

0 #

*, ) -

!" !

" / ! *

* ! 0 # ) - # # ! # # #

) 2!! + !

!!" # * " * ) - +, * ,

)

, * " * #) 3) !

% &

& # ! ( $ * / " #!

" ) .

# * ! * / !

4%56) .

# ! *!

* * " ) -

* #

!" ! * $# !

) . * ! "

!" #

""$ % & !'& !#( ) ! ! $ #

" * "

"$ * "

% & ' #$ ' " # "$ ! $ ! + $ !

! "! *$ "#" ,% ! ! $

* ! # ! "$& + ' !& !" # #"& $ !

+ ! ) "& - .#

' ' / ' # $

0' !& !

$ "( 12) !" ""$ '"' "$& + 3 '

" #

' 4 ""$ !" '"' ' " ! ! /!'& ' "$ ! #" ' #$ !$ ' !3$ ! % ! ! # ! "$& + '& " '#$!$ ' 5

" "$

"!& 6 789:;66 <=>?@66 ABC66 DE?EF66 GHIJ66 :K6

"!# # !

% &

& !# ! '&!

! &

! &!"&# ! !(%

# &

!(%

) !

*+% & $" ', '&!

! # ! &&!

# " # $

) ! &" ) $ !#!-! ." $& / !&+!# #! #$ 0 1 23 45678 9:76;<= >58 ?7@:6;A @B CD6;7 @B E<;===F:@5AG6@H2@;B:;7;A IIJ K L$ $&! $& #!!% ''

, !

!!& !

$ &, # L$# '&!!#!

) ! .

M/ ! K'!( $& +%

)

!($

$ ) &!"

) & ! '$&'

) &! &# " !+#!

! & $" +#!

)!&!

" &% & J IJ K !(%

) ! !" )&%! &O &!"&# &!+!

#!&!# !

" /, ! .

M/ ! K'!( $& !

) P!

) & & +J -&J Q&)$ RJ -!

I P SJ T! /& # '& '

# # /, !.

M/ !K'!( $&!&! $ #!&0 ! &# "

) !+#!

! + +#!

)!&!

/L!

) P!

) &JQJJ ! !+#!

! %$ /! &! &#!# ! '&!

) ! $ !# #

'&!L$#! $ !# !$ !#J / V +#!

)!&!

" / ! +% # ! $ !# &! ! '&!

) !

!& # !(!' ) &

$ "

!! !& #

/ !&+! ) ! '&, ! %!&

%J -!%!

) !

/! !& ,

/ !&+!# !

! !

& $"+#!

)!&!

"J # P ! ! !W$'%!

$ !# ) " +#!

)!&!

" /!

! $' ! $& &

% ! L$#"! &! &# ! !+#!

! % ! )

& & $" #

$&&

%J !

V) ! !W$'%!

! $' $& '& +

) P!

) &JQJJ /! &!

&!#

# IP

Y !-! U

#$%&'()*+ ,-.

/.(-*010+2 3-)1.

4'1'*()*+ ,-.

5)+-,6 8((96.: '*: ;)(,)$ )* ' <&)$)*'1 /&)'1 = > ?

@ AB C D EF E

@ E E BB A @B

@ A

C @ F GE A C C

@ D A ?EE

@@ B EE

@ F H@ E

@ @ E A? A

@ ?EE

C EB

E E C F

@EBFC @

@ B

@ ? A = H@ FB

@EBF

E ?

F E

@ EF AE@

@ AB

@ E AAEEE G =J H@ ?B E FC E A@FE AAC B

F ? E E @ EE F

@ KIE LA C ?C

@ @

@ A E

@ ?E?B ?EE

C A

@M NOPQRSTQUSVMM WXYMM ZS[XYRQU\MM ]^MM _`QRSU[SM M ]^MaPTUSYbcTSMdQeUSVVSVMfUMgXPYeYXXhViM F @ H@ @ F AA ?EE

@B@ @ AC A@FE

@? @C @ E j H@

@ ?

@ E F ?B

@B@

@ A EE

@ A EC

F E F ?BC

! "" !

# $

! % !

! '

( ! "

$ #

)** +

(( '

,! (

- ,,, ,,, ,,, .

/0..

/1234564..

127..

82349:;95<4=45625>..

12?0:7:12?..

@469=325>..

9<.

A4B4759C=.9<.D2E54FF.

( ( !G ! ( H" ,

( ( ! - ) " "

! ( ! ( - I ! ! !

( ( % ( ! ( ! - #

( (

* - J- K LI M

N OP G !" ! -Q " & R -K,!"

! "#$%" "&'

"( )%

*"+ )$'

% # , - # . ,%

%% 0 "

"#"

"&/

% !

% "%%

" 0

" !

%0 "#! " %

% # $ "

" "

%%%%

0 " # "%%

% $

" # % #

## "& 0

# # $% ' % # "& & "#"

"& 1# "%%

$$ "

& !"

/ "

2&/ #" "%

% " $%

% "%% %

% # "&

%%'

" % #

" 3 # 0 " / #/ $" " % !"

" " #

" %%'

" #" "%/

" # % 0

" 5

"& !

% (

!$ % %%$$ 6 " 7"

"% %/ "& % #

&!"%

% % % " # !

# "%%%$"" 8

" % $0 ! % "/ % "

" "% # %$""%/ % !

% "

" % "%# 9 )# /

% " "

/ % 0 "% #/ #

$$ " %$"" 8/ # "/ " !

%! $ " # !/ !

%/ $ !

"/ %

" %"

/ %

"& #

!% " %

! " ! # $ % & % ' () * +$ ' & $, -") .$ !

'+ # '%

) /

/) 0)1) / # ' 2) ## !'% # ' !& '%

'% $ '+ ' % ' & & # !&

## 3 !% # 4 # & '% ) ") /

'+ '%

## '# 5% $ '+ '# ! )

$ # ! 07 % '

89' 8# $ !!

# ' ! !% '# !$ $ # '% 89' 0+'

8% 8# % '% ! $ '! : '+ # $

# ) "") /

## 5! 07 % )) ) ) $ ;);) );)

# % ! ## # # !

! !&#

# & # 4)) $ '+ ' %

! " # $ ! %

&" '((

) *"%

$$ & $$!

&" $*$! "( )( + $

"* ! " $

! $ $ , % $

$* $ % $!% & &"

- *

! .

$( , $

! ! !$ $!

$ *

! $ ( /

% ,

0( $ $$!%

$ " $ ! $ ! & $ "( 1 $ $$!%

* " " $ ! $

(

$ % !

&" ' ( 2 % , " $

$ $

$ ( )( + &

* ! $ $ $$ $ "

$ * !$" 3+#

$ $ $ !

45 $ $ !$"

3+#% "

" # $%$ &%

$ '

% %

( & #

) %$ %! ! $ *+% ! * & %%(%% ) %

! # ++ %+

% ,- # ++ % % #

$ %$ + & %$ # % % # # $%$

( &% %# % # & %

$ ' %# %%$ % %! . $

% # % % # % +% %%(%% % % % % # % + % % +%$ ( &%

$ & ! % %# %$ % # + %%(%% %

% &%$ # & /

% # ) &

# %

%$ $ ( %$ *+% (0(0 %%(%% #% % % +%$ &% %

%$ + %$

! &% ( 0 % +

( # &)%$ ( ! &% %

% # &+ 1 # ! 2% %% % # ,3 # ## % % &%$ % .% % / % %! 4%5 4$ !

% %$

+ % (% %

+ # .%% % % / .%

$ ! .%( $%$

## % &) %

+%% .%% 6&

% / $ % # 6* % /##

% $% ## % .%% %

## % / # + + #

%$ (% # %

$ ' %# %%$ %

!% %$%$ #+ % , # 2%

% % #

# $

"% &

% #

' ()

' ( * (' + '

( * (' ( * , & -

!" . /. - # 0&

/ . 3 0&

' + '

% & " 4 "

& '

" #

0 ' % " # %" " "

1& , '

, . . %#

!" #

%" ( * 1 $

( (' ( * , & - %" ' % & & , # + '

% ' #

" + '

( * 1 $

( ('

( * , & - . # ( * , & - -

& ' % & & + ' 5

" '

" # $ %& '" !

(

) )# + " '# ' & & - $ . ". )*

' " $ / " $ 0 $ #

# $

$ $

# ! $

# $ " 1 ("

/ 2'3 . ! $

# $ # ! # 4

. ! $ 4 " !.

(

/35675 "!

5 $ ##

# 0 $ #

. , $ , $#

(

# $$ $ / 2'3 !"# $&% & )*

' " 8 9:;<=88 >?@AB88 CDE88 9@B@F88 <G88 HEIE8 J8 . #!# $

# 4" $ 4.

!# / ! . K&&& / $

# $$

# " $ . (

. $

# . "

. $ $

# $ " $ & L $ !. $ #

!# " " !

" . $ "

& '

# .

# . $ " , "

# $

& 3 1

M'M

! " # #

$ % "#

# #

" #

# "# "

$& '$ ! (#)" *+ #, -./012/314,, 567,, 86.79, , :.3;9/63/3<,, 9=76.<=,, >/016;6351713;/3<,, 0.7/3<,, 86?/0@AB,, CD301E/;F,, G3,, 71, , H,, F, # #I J I## #I # + # K L$ M

N! #& # # ! #

# ! ###I

" $ O "!

!+# # #I ! +# + +" !

+ $ $ O#

, P/91307D,, Q,, P/9.,, R63/,, ?4S,, T=1,, R9D91,, 65,, UD0=VD, , C7D014=, , W,, F,

+# "

# #I # I "

#I +X

# "

" X # "

! ###I # "

"!#I + # X+ $ $ O#

)

I +# + #I + I

Y ###I # +# +! #

++ "

#I +# +# !#I "# + # $'$

+ #X

#I I +I# + #$ $$ $ O

" +# Z Y ###I )

# # $$ !

[ N , 8=D\917,GGG@,C76;10.71,567,>/016,86351713;/3<,

_*_ _ $# ]$^_'`

$ $

" #$%&'' %()"

+, - ./0 12340 45 467 1358779:/; 53 <:4/7==> =2?7 2/9 7@8714 <6737 1358779:/;= 237 :/:4:2479 24 467 :/=42/87 5A 467 5B34> C20 C5?7 2 37DB7=4 A53 ?:975 85/A737/8:/;- . 12340 53 <:4/7== =77E:/; 2 ?:975 85/A737/8:/; 1358779:/; =62FF 95 =5 G0 C2E:/; 2 37DB7=4 :/ 467 A53C 137=83:G79:/H8679BF7II- - ./0 13515=2F 45 C5?7 2 37DB7=4 45 A53 ?:975 85/A737/8:/; =65BF9 A:3=4 G7 9:=8B==79 <:46 467 54673 12340 53 1234:7= 45 467 1358779:/;> 7@8714 <6737 :4 := /54 15==:GF7 53 :/2113513:247> A53 7@2C1F7 :/ 82=7= =B86 2= B3;7/4211F:824:5/=- -J

/ 3787:14 5A =B86 2 37DB7=4 2/9 B15/ 6723:/; 2FF 85/873/79 173=5/=> 467 5B34 <:FF 12== 2/ 2113513:247 53973 2A473 2=87342:/:/; 4624 467 211F:824:5/ := /54 A:F79 <:46 2/ :/47/4:5/ 45 :C1797 2 A2:3 43:2F 53 45 97F20 467 1358779:/;=- - K6:F7 2FF5<:/; 2 37DB7=4 A53 ?:975 85/A737/8:/;> 467 5B34 C20 2F=5 A:@ 467 =8679BF7 A53 85/?7/:/; 467 ?:975 85/A737/8:/;- - I/ 82=7 467 ?:975 85/A737/8:/; 7?7/4 := 85/?7/79 A53 C2E:/; 532F =BGC:==:5/=> 467 53973 C20 37DB:37 467 .9?58247 53 12340 :/ 173=5/ 45 =BGC:4 <3:447/ 23;BC7/4= 2/9 1378797/4=> :A 2/0> :/ 29?2/87 5/ 467 5AA:8:2F 7C2:F IL5A46785/873/795B34- - 5=4=> :A 9:378479 45 G7 12:9> =62FF G7 9715=:479 <:46:/ 467 137=83:G79 4:C7> 85CC7/8:/; A35C 467 9247 5/ <6:86 467 53973 85/?7/:/; 1358779:/;= 4635B;6 ?:975 85/A737/8:/;:=3787:?79- M#

! #$&&' HBCC5/= :==B79 45 2 <:4/7== <65 := 45 G7 7@2C:/79 4635B;6 ?:975 85/A737/8:/;> =62FF C7/4:5/ 467 9247> 4:C7 2/9 ?7/B7 5A 467 85/873/79 7C547 N5:/4 2/9 =62FF

! " # $ % ! %&& '% (

! ) )

! %&&

%* ! " + ,-+./012304253+56+789:53:+ " ;

* $&( %

( * * $& % ! (

* %*& %& % % < * =!& >( ? =!&( @ # ( * % %&( ! * % ? AB ) ? B )( & *" # !

( *

( &

( !% " ;

!( & *(

* & ! *

" " #

* $&

* $& % C % % % & % & & " #

* &

* $& * %)" "A D

* $&( % * ( % ( & ( & *( & ( & * % ! " # %

! '%

% %

! % *( % ! " " ?%*E

! $&

!" #" $ #%

& #' &&

$ ''& (# "& $ #") * ''& && &+&%"# &) ) , ' !" ' #& #" #"" "#

$ #&$ ''$ #") * %& #" #&

! # - ' ' %!") ). * # #&

& $ "# ' %!") )/ * # && 0 # % ' '

% !" #& ") ) * # && %# '

% !" ' !" &#) * % ' && " ' 0#& ' %) * %# ' '

% !" &&

&&%$1 ) ) , %& %# & &

# - " - '$ ' %&&$ %

$ ' % 2#% # - &&

$ & "& " - ' # " &&

+ %

$ '

% !")

'$ ' %&&$ %

$ " - #&

$ & "& # -) * '$ % ' &&

! ! "

! "

! # ! $ # %&'"%$(&"") ) ) * "& & $

! $ ! % !

! "& +$"&

" ! !

! $ #

" !

% "

%%$ ! # !

$ !

" &"

! - "

" %$&"

! "

! #) . "

% "

! % &" !

! " ! # !

%%$ ! $ # !

$ !

" !

! /$"% %") 0! " % $"

" %!"

! ! "

! "

! # ! $ #

%&'" %$( &" ") ) .

$"$ %"& ! - - " !

") . %" % ! !

! $ !

!%") ) 0! $

! 2$

- " ,&

%%$ !

- " "%

$ % ! % ! - "

& "

% $%!

& &" !% %"

" %&'" %$

" %%) ) 0! "

! # !

$ !

! #

! ! ! " #$ $% & #

! # ! " " " "" "

! # # $'$ $%( & ) * " *

# # " #! +# $ , * #

! *

+# # * " *

$ $% & # # ! " - ..///* - 0 " -* 1 2 /& 2

# "$ $% 3 4# - " # - -

# 5 ! " !* " 4# #

# # #

! * #

! #6 # " " "

# $ / # # #

# " " ! $ 2#! "

! 7 !

"!#$ $%' )#+ # #

! * ! ! #6 ! !

# " ! ! - " " !* # !

5 " 7 -$ 9:88 ;<=>?>@>AB88 CD88 E=CF>AB88 GCHIJKA@L88 @C88 M>@AKLL88 CD88 NHHILKO8

!"#$ ! %&' & !

! & (#$!

& & '!

*+ ,-! !

# ./ $

$$&#+

! $ !0 & -! "'

(#$!

!"# '&+ (#'

-! "'

!*$ !0

!11!0 .'&

#2 34

-! "'

$ &

!"# )!

/ *+

#& $'

. & !(+ !# '&. !

-! "'

&11+/ 1"- .

#!".

& -! "'

,$"&15#6 !# 34

-! "'

$ &

/ *+ ("

(#$!

& -

#& $'

. & !(+7'&. !

$&'

!"# )!

&11+ 1"- .

#!".

& -! "'

,$"&15#4

&#- !(+ !

-! "'

# $.

- *+

$$ & -

!!#- & !# &

$ &11 * -$(&

#& #

!"# )!

,& &"

!#5- !"##7 #.$ #- $(- (!$ !# & + !

#&"

!#5-'& $$"

&$$( &1'$$ .# 4 9:;<=>?@=A==BCDE?D@ 4 F-,! & !# G"#- )#$!

/ $ &11 &--#$$

!"# *+ ,-! !

# . #!' & $( - '!

-& & -

' $( -

!#-# $$"- *+

!"# 4 (#$ !

!!#- & !# 011

$$&#+ &

# &#."'

$ &#

! * &--#$$- *+ & &-,! & !# (&# + (#$!

*!#

!"# 4 4

(#! - .$ &# &##- !"

#!' & + !

$ "& !

$ -$ #*- "1$ 4H4

! 4H43

!!#- & !# & $"

$ &11

$"# !'(1& ! &11

&1 #G"#'

$4 I!0,#/

(#! - .$ &# !

- #!' & '!

&11 .

$ "& !

'(1& - "

-# "1 4H4/ $"

&$ & F-,! & J$ ! /

!!#- & !# &

!"# )!

$ &11

$"# !'(1& ! &11

&1 #G"#'

$ !# !

. ,-! !

# . & *!

!! " !! #$! % & & '' ' !! % ' (!&

' & & $ !'!& #) * '! )

! +

$ )

, ' $ !'!&&" !+

) ! $ ' - ) + -)!$

!! $ '!&- *' )

! $ !'!& !!

) ",& ! . # /! - !!+ 0

!* ' $ !'!& *!&-

' *!& -

'" 1 & 2 '!& /'" -

"! "

! - ' )- " *! 3 ! & !& -

! &"%

'! !)-

!!$) ' + + 4

!* ' $ !'!&- ' + ' * ) " *5!

!" "

# $ % "

& & " # % ' ( "

&" )& # #" "*"& )& & ) * & " * "+ && + "& &' , --.,, /0123245,, 678491:,, ;64829<,, =;,, 3>46<7:,, 7?48294@2=9,, =;, , 4330A71,491,B6=377129<A,09176,C73@2=9,-DE,=;,@>7,F6BF., GG'G (

" "& H # &&" # &)" & $ * &#&)' I%

J& #" "& & "

* ) ) &#&) " K& K& && "&" # "" * &%)' GG' (

K& && "&"

# "" * & %) K %"" &&" L& GM # $ & " # &&" L& G $ ) &#&) % *")

&" " %"" &&" " &" * " # # # # && # &' ( "

" & & % L&M#N&O&'P G' ( J) " # ## I) " " # *

L "

" *), Q6.,, R7=6<7,, S4609,, T4U49,, VA.,, Q6A.,, /4A5779,, W406, , X4524, , D,

, T.,, C621>4649:,, F452;=6924,, VA.,, T.,, C0Y49Z4:,, F>79942, [

, S.,, R.,, \7764]64A41, , 491,, =@>76A,, VA.,, C62,, B64Y4A>,, R491>2,, 491,, =@>76A,

, ^21Z0@,, ^2Y4A>,, ^=6<=>429, M `%ab&cdM GG [ `%ab&cd[GG O_M

!" #$%&$'()$%* +," -' . /&% '# /$!/)0%& '/"% &*)% #- '-&/-0"&-&*" $#-.&*"1"&$&$-'"!2 32 4' 5$"6 -. &*" .-!" &*$% -)!& .$'#% '- $,,"( ,$&7 -! 1"!5"!%$&7 $' &*" $01)('"# -!#"! $& +"$'( 6",,.-)'#"#28 9:88 ;<=>?@A?=BC8 &*" 1!"%"'& 1"&$&$-' +"$'( % '%0"!$&$%*"!"+7#$%0$%%"#2 DEFGDFDE HIJIKLMINMIOPQ 1 !5""'R)0 ! SNTU V*"&*"!%1" R$'(W!" %-'"# X Y"%WZ- V*"&*"!!"1-!& +," X Y"%WZ-

[ 6\$'#"!]-/4#^_33