High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/54222/2025allowed

Malook Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-11-18Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel10 pages

CRM-M-54222 -2025

..49 49 49 49. 24 24 24 24

=8!

!- - +!-(#( % !"# $ =8!(*

!"&!'

!" !" !" !" *

)

) -!(!

) ) ) )+!,%!- +!,%!- +!,%!- +!,%!-124 124 124 124 &

)+!,%!- &

)+!,%!-124 124 124 124 6/ 8 6/ 8 6/ 8 6/ 8

/ -8:- $

1&+' !" - !*!

!-8 -80*-!!

1 # $ %8 ;;;;;

;;;;;

/18< /7 18< /7 18< /7 18< /7

-!(!

( %!!

!& # &!- !'

93 " !

! - 0 - #-(

123 <"-(- 567"- - "

" -!

#-% !*!

'(!%!-

893& !&288231 1 -!

( !-!&" - !""!

'!(*#

(%!# &!- -!'

1>.1?1@A A 4" ! -' '-# ( &(0' -* ' #%( '!(' 1?4<"-(- 5' 67 71 '! 1 ,- (-8 8 ! -+,!

" !!

(

( !*!

!- ( !

( ''#(!& &"%!

++!&

3 " !-

!&0 -!'+!-!&"-, ! '.''#(!&" !*!

!-1 1

,!01 ( (*

1 & ( & '.'

''#(!& ,

!& ! *-!(!

!-1

( & ('(#-!8 ! *!

!- ! %( ( " ( B ('(#-!1!

!&0 -!'+!-!&92 -,("!-

8 38 /!- !&'# (!"- !*!

!-( !- !& !*!

'#( &0(

'!388238/!- !&'# (!("#- !-- #!& ! *!

!- ( %!!

"(!0 ,* ' !&

C#!( 8 /!- '# (! ( - #!& , & -0 *-+ ( " ! ' +! ('-#*##(0 %!!

',* !& B 1 & #(1 ! *-(!'# '(! (#""!-( "-,

!-!

&!"!' (8 /!- !& '# (! ( "#- !- !- !& ((#,

- # &1 !*-(!'# +!-( ( !

%!'--!' 1*- ,!*-(!'# !+ '! + %!

( ! *!

! (*! " & ('(#-! ( !,!

" '.''#(!&1 ,!01 (*

8 /!- !& '# (! ( "#- !- !- !& !*!

!-((#""!-!&

'-'!- "-,-! 2 0!-8#(1-!

#-% (*-0!&"-8 98 /!- !& ! '# (! (!!( *'! -!'-& '#( &0 '!- "

' !& !&>8824(((- -!*0%0B0" ""

&+ & !& 8824"(*

11(( ( ,, (( !-" '!1 -1 ,- (-1

#- &01B '-! !

-!'-&8

(#%, ((

&!,B !( &(- -!*01!- !& !'# (!(**(!& ! *-!(!

%0-

(- (!&

( !*!

!- -!(!- #(

#-! &1 #(1 !*!

!-&!( &!(!-+! !' '!(( " ! -!

#- % 8 /!- !& ! '# (! ( "#- !- (#%, !& !

( % *! (%--!&%0 !-

-("!'

3>" !' 1 #(1 !(,!# %!& (, ((!&8 48 +!!-&'# (!"- !- +*- !( &+! ! -# !+ %!-!'-&(" !'(!8

@8 ! *!

!- B( --!( !& 388231 B!-!

" !-1

+!(

B( '-- !& # & ! ' C# ! *!

!- ( %!!

*-!(!

!& 28298298 3 *-(!'# B

!((!( +! %!!

!&1 # "B '12+!%!!

!D,

*- &2(%!!

#* & !8!*!

!-(%!!

,* ' !&( ''#(!&

C#!( (!0 !%( ("& ('(#-!( !,!

"'.''#(!&1 ,!01(*

8(*!- !*-(!'# +!-( 1 !-! !-, !- + %! '

!' ! *!

!- B ! ' -% & !D'!* "- ! ( & & ('(#-! ( !,!

8 ( *!-

! (#' & ('(#-! ( !,!

! %(!

'!"'--%- +!!+ '!& , !&!+

-0+#! &'

%! (! %( ( "- ,*

! *!

!-8 ! -! '! (#%(

!& ( !,!

- (!( (!- #( &#% ( %# ! " !(( %$!'

0" !

+!(

& (*# ! !*!

!-B( *-!(!

!(* 8!+!-'

0 &B!

!-!C# -!& %! '!& ! ('(#-!( !,!

,&!%0 !'.''#(!&B %!"#0 !( !& ! ,! " - 8 ! - + '

( - (!& -

+! - (! &!% %! ((#!(1 '(%!- '

!&#* &#-

!'#-(!" - 8 #- &!(

&!!, **-*- ! &!+! &!!*

!(! - + '

(1 ( !1 !( ,0 *-!$#& '! ! - 8

%! ( %!!

%-# "-B-&

' ! ! ! & " ! *!

!- %('

"-, ! *-'!(("$#( '!-

!-"!-

B !*-(!'# !+ '!8 @88 ( $# ' #-!1 B#& %! **( ! -!"!- $#& ,!

*((!&%0 #-

(#-& +!-(#( !"# $% (#-& +!-(#( !"# $% (#-& +!-(#( !"# $% (#-& +!-(#( !"# $%1*((!&

..@42?9 @42?9 @42?9 @42?9.29 29 29 29 <24) )229?71 B!-!

1 " !- -!0

#* !- &!'

" !$#& ,!

(" ! 6%!#*-!,! #-

+!-(#( ! " , &#1 22 #*-!,! #- 44?E , 8 $,#

(1 %&# , &, 0 F /& *# +!-(#( ! "

#$- 1 -' '( - #-!#1 29 ?2E ! %0 < 7 !

#-# +(8 #% & ,& - ,# A -861 2 <7 < ,

7>@E &G $0

+(8! !"-0 1%!-

*!'

/!+! **!< -878<(7@@H231&!'

&!& >8248231(!& #() I@83 ( B! !( % (!& *-

*! " B ' "!(( ,&!%0'.''#(!&# &!-!'

@>" !'

!-!

0 +!-0B!* !'!"!+ '!8#'( !,!

<(71%0 !,(!+!(1'

"-, ! (! %( ( "- ! ' "

&# & ,#( %! ('-#

J!& B # ,( '#

' $# B !- (#%(

!+ '!8-!+!-1 -!'+!-0(%!!

!""!' !&"-, !*((!(( " !*!

!-1B(%!!

(#%(!C#!

0 ,* ' !&( ''#(!&(!0 ! %( ( " & ('(#-! ( !,!

" ! '.''#(!&8 B!+!-1 ( -!

#-% *!-

( "! & %!- 0"

&#1 #- (-!%

!& ( - !% '!%! B!!

("!

#-&

*!-( %!- 0 &!

(#-

!""!'

+! &,

( - " $#( '! ( (

+!(

8 ! "

-0+#! &&, (( % 0" !& ('(#-!( !,!

,&!%0 '.''#(!& " B

! &,

" ! - #- & -! %! &$#& ' !&&#-

!'#-(!" ! -

''-& '!B !( % (!& *-

*!("B8B!+!-1B !&$#&

*!"--!

#-% 1

#- '

-!,

% #( ! '

-'#,( '!( # &!- B ' ! *!

!- ( %!!

!& - ,* ' !&1

'#&

! #-! " ! !

(1 !!+ '!

!*!

!- !""!

'!(B!( ! (*!'

'-! - %# !& !*!

!',, (( " !!

""!

'!8*- ,"'

!!D,

" !(!"' -( (!((!

(#-! !*-'!(("B , (#(!&1%#(!&-, (& -!' !&8K @88 #- !-1 #-

! '(! " (B

&!- (B

&!-

( :

( : +!-(#( ! " # $% +!-(#( ! " # $% +!-(#( ! " # $% +!-(#( ! " # $% *((!&

..33>?

33>?

33>?.24 24 24 24 <24) )2?@7(!& #() I98 ( (!C# #- %+!.( & -#,

1 ! "B

*( # !(!,!- !) <7 < 7 % *! ,!- (E

-!(*!' " # &!-' " ?4

""!

'!<(7 # &!- !'

? - !'

9 - !'

>. !-!" & "- ""!

'!<(7

',,!-'

0E ( !((!

0 -!C# -!& ,!! B ! -

#-<(7 " !'

3>"' 8 <

7 !-

#-<(7"!'

3>"' & **0 % *!<(7 ,!& ' -# &<(71

!- ,% ''# " 0

'#&

!-!( "&!, (!"'(!", 0-! ! '8 <

7 !-

#-<(7"!'

3>"' *!

% B!

% ((# "- ''# "

'-'!-

+ !B" - '!" ! " 8!8B!-! !% .** ( (#""!-!&

# &!-. - '#( &01 ! - ( *-'-(

&"0 !-!" - %# %! (#'% .** 8 8 ! B

( '

3><7<%7 " ' -!

! '

(H*-,! !-( '

-88 8H- 0 !-** '%!!D B8 8 ! B

( '

3><7<%7 " ' -!'#,#

#-! !- 8!8% !'

-!-!C# -!& %!( ("

!&"-% .*! %!(#''!(("#8 G8 - ' &!- %0 % #- " ! '

( *# !&

3><7<%7< 7"' 8!8I !-!-!-!( %! -# &( "-%! !+

! 0"(#'""!

'!K) < 7 ! % #- # ( " -# -!!+ , !- 1

'#&

'(!.& -01 !D'#( +!0 "- ! , *#-*(!"&$#&

(#'% *!8 <

7 #' ' &!- 1 ' '!-

! ((!((,!

'!1 (#& , --- ! (,! &!

-!! " ('-#

0-!C# -!&"- 'C# " !''#(!& !"

&$#& A'#,

" - 8 <

7 !<(7 " &!"!

'! %0 ** .''#(!&1 " 01

'#&

, !- H&'#,!

(#**- !-!"1 ,0 %! !&

%0 !% .

#- B !&$#&

(#'% *!8 G8 -' &!- " !'

( *# !&

3><7<%7<

8!85! !0 ',, 0""!

'!B ! % 6) < 7 ! B-& 5 !06 # %!

!-*-! !& ( -!C#

&!, ( -%! &(#%(

*-%% 0"-!.

""!

%0 ! % .** 1 - !- ,!-! !-!

' !1( #- ' *-!& ' "# #-!' &#' " !% .** 8 <

7 !!

-!"' #, - D"

'(!

'#&

! !'!&!

(" !% .** 1-!('- %!& ,1 & ! #-! " ""!

'! -! -!C# -!& %! &!+!&

8 B!+!-1 !

++!,!

" % .**

!- H !- ""!

'! '

*( "' -!(#

! ' '#( " (*-*!

0"-',,

""!

"# #-!8 <

7 ! % .

#- ,01 ! ,! " -

% 1

,*(! #* ! ** .''#(!& '

! B#&(#%, 1 (#'-!

#- ,!*!- &H

!-+(,0 *# !& %0 ! #- -

% 1 ""

&+ %!"-! ' '!- *!'

#& ! "

#- HC <#- (& 7 #&

( - !H' '!- '!

1 ! !""!' ! ( %!!

++!&

',, (( " 0""!

'!" !-%!

-!!(!& % 8 !"' ("

'(!1 ,*(

"(#''

,0 %!' &!-!& %!(#""

"-( ("'

#,!- !&

3><7<%7<

78 G8 !-!

! #-!1,&! &!D !

"!D!-'

(! " *B!- %0 #- E B ! ( ("0

(!" -!

! '

( ( *# !&

3> " ' E ( &!*!

#* ! $#& & ('-!

!D!-'

(!& %0 (#' #-

! "' ( &'

-'#,( '!("

'(!8!D#( &!

!(' *(( %0%! &&B ( B B#&' # !*-,! !-("- ( ("'

"-!C# -!,!

# &!-!'

3>< % &7(!+!-0'(! ( (B #

C#!"' (H'

-'#,( '!(8

(#' !,*

%# # * !

&!+#-8 - 1 ((#! (%!( !" ! $#& B (&, & & ('-!

" ! #- &!

B (#' , !-8K @838 (+ !B" !, !-1 !-

- ,*(!&# &!-!'

3> " !' ( &(& # !&8 @898 (*!-'#( &0'!- "

' !& !&>8824"

!&%0 !!- !'# (!1 !*!

!-(-!&0(#""!-!&

'-'!- "-*!- & "20!-12, ( &32&0(1A (B %!

++!&

0 !-<(78 >8 #-

$#& ,!

!& ( :#B

&!- +!-(#( ! " :#B

&!- +!-(#( ! " # $ # $ # $ # $% % % %*((!&

..@92>9 @92>9 @92>9 @92>9.29 29 29 29<24) )22@?47E" !--!0

#* !- &!'

" !$#& ,!

(" ! 6%!#*-!,! #-

#((

-: +(8,!!'081 !" -<?27

E%&# !, #0 +( 88 0 <??7

4E +!& #, % +(8 !"-( - & !-129<37 < ,

79?9E &#( ,F#((

+(8 !< "! 7-!*- !&(23 3E ,

**! 894H22 & !& 2>82822 !& ( I

(B( (#%(+(8! !"L!( !

KEI

(& -0F * +(8 ! ! " L!( !

K1 *!'

/!+! **! < -87 84432.2& !&8282 !&(I,,&,

+(8 ! ! " #$- KE ,

**! 8@? " 2 & !& 248282 !&( *:- -F *-#(,+(8

" 1 & #- #&-0 +(8 ! " &0 -&!(1 29<97 < ,

7>E(!&1 #() I>88 ! -

(*!!&0 & !D*!&

#( - 0 ("!

#-& *-!+!

# &#! &**-!((

'-'!- E ,

! ! 0 &' '!- '',*

!''#( (B!( '#- 0

,* -,!

!% 0" ''#(!& &!"!

,(!"1%# !-! ( +!--'

!-!( *+

B0"-(*!!&0 - 8 (-

( %!!

-!*! !&0' # !&

!-!'!

*( & !- &!'

" ! %+!.-!"!--!& #*-!,! #- 6($#& ,!

(+! &&B (!- !(" &!'

(*!

#* !B+ ( (""# &,!

(8!' '!* " (*!!&0 - (, , !&

!- '!( !((!

*- " ! "# &,!

"! & %!- 01 #- !!& &*-!(!-+!&# &!-#-

8 ! -

(*!!&0 - %!

( B ! ' # -!( -

,*(!& ! ,! " ! --!( " ! ''#(!& & ' (!C#!

'-'!- B ' '

#!( ( !(1 ,!01 ! ( ! "

+!(

C# -01 - 1 **! & -!+ ( 0 *(( %! *-!$#& '! ,0-!(# &#! ,*!-, (( %! &+ &%!&!0(

'! ! ,! " ! ',, (( " ! ""!

'! ! '- ,

*-'!!&

' (#,, !

01 '#& %! +!- !&8 ! (*!!&0 - 1 !-0 !-

&C# '& (*(-!(

!C# "'- ,

$#- (*-#&!

'!8! +!-'-B&!& #- .&'! (1 !!+0+#,!"B- & !-!(# *-!((#-! !*-(!'# & ! '!1

&#% %0!!*( !!

-! '- ,

$#- (*-#&!

,!'

(,# &!-( -!(( &( -

8B!+!-1

%! !D'#(!"-!!*

!(B-&",'!(

''#(!&"-

&!"

!*!- &" ,!8 &!( (!-+! 0'-!& ! '- ,

$#( '! (0( !,1 - !- ,!( "- (& ( ! " "" -(8 !

#- !! " (*!!&0 -

&!& + & **-!(( & *-!+!

&!0 %0 ,*(

! #- & ! *-(!'# %

*-'!!&B ! - B -!( %!& (* '8! #- !!(!-+!( -!!"&*#-*(!8 -( 01 *- !' ( !''#(!&

( **-!(( +!*-!.

,*- ( ,!

E (!' &01 -! !+!( ! ''#(!& " ! ! 0 *#% '(#(* &#! # -!(+!&'- ,

'- !( &( 01 *- !' (

( ! - ( !+ '! B %! ( - ,!,- !( & ,,!& %0 ! *(( ! " ,!1 #(1 ,*

! % 0 " ! ''#(!& &!"!

,(!"8 !(B # (0

!' (!C#!

'!("*-!. - &! !

-! -+!8 ''#(!&1 *-!(#,!&

1 *-+!

!-B (!1 -! (#%$!' !& *(0'

' & *0( ' &!*- + ( " $ . "!1 #(#0 &!- !-#('

(8 C#0 ,*- 1 !%#-&!

"&! !

" (#' ''#(!&"-!C#!

0"(!+ 0

,!,%!-(" ", 08 !-! ( 0! !- (*!' " ! , !- B ' &!(!-+!( ' &!- ( ( !8 ! !

! *-!(!

'(! -! ! ''#(!& %!

++!&

',,!-'

0 " ' -% &# &!- !' 1?48L !' &!-

% *!

'(!

',,!-'

01 ! #- ( !!*

& !

#-(!

#,!- !&# &!-!'

3>"' 1?4B ', & !( #- ( ' - % ''#(!& 0 " !- !-

! *#% ' *-(!'# - &" !-+

( ("

(!"" B

(B '-!

-!( %! -# &( "- %! !+

! ''#(!& 0 " ! ""!

'!'- !&H!

!& & 1! !0 ',, 0""!

'! ! % 8!( -

#-("!'

3>" !' 1?4 ,#( %! ,!

'##(0 ('-#

J!&

( ! %'&-* " ''#(!&6( "# &,!

(*!!&0 - 8!-

"! &*!-( %!- 0

%!-!

&!-!& -0%0# B-- !&&!0(

!$#& *-'!((1 *- '#-0B!-!(#'&!0<(7 !- - %# %! !''#(!& - $#( "

!& !!

&" !*-(!'# %0 ' -!( (8

%! !* %!

& %-( "-

! *!- & " ,! %0

-!"# !

#-( &&B

3>" !' 1?48! !

( #-!

(B (&,1

-&!- !

(#-!(*!!&0 ,!0& (*(" !'(!(# &!- !' 1(*-+ &!&"- !' "(*!'

#- ( &!-!'

3@." !' 8B!+!-1 #- '

#- !( 6( !0! !*- -' !&&!0( &(0( !, '

!""

'0 "-#( - ! !

( +!*#-*(!8 #- "B (&# 0.%# & !

(#-! &!(

%!',!',*

+ "

&#6("# &,!

B (

( # !8L !&!

B % *!

'(! +!- !&%0 !-

#-("!'

3>" !' 1 ?41 ! #- ,#( ( - ! $#& #( % '! %! B!!

! !

(

'#-% !,!

'!"&-# ( & !('-( ' -

" !''#(!& " - &!D*!&

#( - 8-

'-'!- 1B # $#( "

%! '#(!1 - (( - ("-,

*-!. - &! !

,*- ( ,!

1 # ',!

' !*-

*!"$#( '! &!C# 08 1 !# !C# +'

"!-!

'! ( B!-! ! - ( " !& ' '#&! B

-!( %! ,!1 -!(#

'-'!- 1 , !(

( ! *-!'

#( "# &,!

( " "! & %!- 0 - !& # &!- ! B &1 ( (#'1 '

%!- 0 +!--

!( # -0!,%- '-! !&# &!-!'

3>" ! ' 1?4# %!' &!-!&(*!-"' ("

'(!8 !- B-&(1 - "%

'(!*!-

',,!-'

-# &"# &#!&!0

- 1'

%!( & %!"! !-!&%0!'

3> " !' 1?48K #""

'! (01 "#- !- &! !

" ! *!

!- ( &!- - B--

!"' ( &'

-'#,( '!(" !'(!8 8 + !B"%+!1 !*-!(!

(B!&8!

!- -&!-!& %!-!!(!& -!

#-% ("#-

% H(#-! 0% &( !( ("'

" !/&8' '!- !& - #- H# 0

( - !8B!+!-1

( ,0 %! ,*(!& %0 ! ' '!- !& -

#- H# 0

( - !1 !*!

!-(-!,

%# &%0 !"B

() < 7 !*!

!-( , (.#(! ! %!- 0 - !&8

7 !*!

!-( ,*!-B 0!+ '!1-- &'#,!

-01&#-

! - 8 <

7 !*!

!-( %(!

,(!" 0& !%!"-! ! - 8 < +7 ! *!

!- ( ',, 0 ""!

'! B ! % 8 <+7 !*!

!-(&!*( (*((*- 1 " 01B #- 8 <+ 7 ! *!

!- (

( '!* ! #,%!- ! +!(

'!-H " ' '!- !& '! &( '

! ('!.* ! #,%!-B # *- - *!-, (( " ! - #- HC

( - !8 <+

7 ! *!

!- (

0 ,

!- -0 &!0 ! 8 <+

7 !*!

!-((#%, 1 !"

-( B-

&0" !+!-0 , 1 ""

&+ 1 %!"-! ! ' '!- !& -

#- 1 ! !""!' ! ( %!!

++!&

',, (( " 0""!

'!" !-%!

-!!(!& % 8 '(! ! *!

!- ( "# & %!

++!&

0 ""!

'! " !- ( %!

- !& %

! *-!(!

1 !%( (" (""

&+ - !-B (!1 ! ! , & !& ,+!1"- B 1"-' '! " (% ' *!1 %# " '#-(!1 ( %! - '

!& #* ,!- ( !-!"8 ?8 '(!"%-!'" 0" !"-!( &'

( & (! ',0%! ,*(!&%0' '!- !& - #- H# 0

( - !(& -!' !& !-!

%+! - #* (B

0 !- (#""

'#(!1 ! !H',*

( %! %!- 0 ,+! ' '! " % " ! *!

!-8 28

-&!-!&''-&

( &!-!

%+!(%!' ( -#!&( !D*-!(( " *

!,!- (" !'(!8 8

'! !,

'(!(%!!

&!'

&!&1*!

, ('! !#( ** 1 " 01((( &(& (*(!&""8 <

+!,%!- +!,%!- +!,%!- +!,%!-124 24 24 24 ,+ - L! !-(*!

H-!( !&) !(H L! !--!*- %!) !(H