Malkiat Singh v. Financial Commissioner And ORS
!
" !
!#$%
-
- ------ %$*$*&,%3
4%3+5+
%8%,5%7 5,9#:
&$2%3+ ------
%+;&,(%,$+ < =
0 0
3%+%,$ 3- 35, #,+#.7
(8&)#$% ;%$*$*&,%3-
3- *36#.9*$ !*>#,#7 0%,*&3 ! 5,9#:-
%+;&,(%,$ ;3&)%%(%( #1#*,+$ %?;#3$%- - - 0
=
%$*$*&,%3
3$*).%+ @ &,+$*$5$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%3 #.*#7 +%%/*,1 # ,#$53% )%3$*&3#3* +%$$*,1
;;%#.+7 5,9#:
+2&3$ < &66*++*&,%3<- - 3*%'.A7 (%6*+% 023* 53(%8 0*,127 ;3%8*&5+ 05.2#,*7 %2+*.
!*+$3*)$
%3&B%;537 ;3&)%%(*,1+ >%3% *,*$*#$%( '*..*,1 5;
8#)#,)A7 >2%3%5;&, )#,(*(#$%+7 ,#6%.A7
;%$*$*&,%3 ,13%9 #;;.*%( =#6:#3(#3-
#;;%#3+ ,13%9 >*$2(3%> #;;.*)#$*&, #))&3(*,1.A7 #*:
%2+*.(#37 #.>#,(* 2#* 3%)&66%,(%( ,#6%
#;;&*,$6%,$ 8#)#,)A-
-
#;;%#3+ :%'&3% &..%)$&37
%3&B%;53
+2&3$ <&..%)$&3<7
3#*+%( #, &:9%)$*&, 65,#(*
;3&).#6#$*&, %''%)$%( 8*..#1%-
- ;&, $2*+7 )#..%( 3%;&3$ '3&6 '*%.( +$#''
#'$%3 )&,+*(%3*,1 3%;&3$ %2+*.(#3 *,(*)#$*,1 65,#(* )&,(5)$%( %8%, # 3#;#$
- @- 3%)&3(%(C &..%)$&37
7
=#6:#3(#3- - 2%
7
'*.*,1 #, #;;%#.
:%'&3%
%3&B%;53 !*8*+*&,7
%3&B%;53
+2&3$ <!*8*+*&,#.
&66*++*&,%3<7 >2*)2 (*+6*++%(7 -
-
2%3%#'$%37 # 3%8*+*&,
:%'&3%
>2*)2 )#6% #..&>%(7
@- - @
6#$$%3 3%6#,(%( '3%+2 (%)*+*&,-
- $3#,+;*3%+
@- - @
7
:%'&3% &53$ '*.*,1 #
@7 >2*)2 )#6% (*+;&+%( &'7 - -
6#$$%3 3%6#,(%(
(%)*(*,1 )#+% #'3%+2-
- ;&, 3%6#,(7
*6;51,%(
3%6#,(%( )#+% '3%+2 )#,(*(#$%
>2%3%#+ )&6;#3*+&, 6%3*$+ )#,(*(#$%+7 2#8% $>& &3 6&3% )#,(*(#$%+-
- #'&3%6%,$*&,%( )*3)56+$#,)%+7 3%.*%'
+7 ,&$*)%( #:&8%-
- ,&$*)%#:.%
0*,127 >2& #;;&*,$6%,$ ;%$*$*&,%37 )&,$%+$*,1 &$2%3 ;%3+&,7 ,#6%.A7
0*,127 3%;&3$%( 2#8% (*%(-
2% #.+& ;3&)%%(%( #1#*,+$ %?;#3$%7 - - 7 &53$-
2#8% )&,+*(%3%( +5:6*++*&,+ :%2#.'
;%$*$*&,%3-
@- )#+%7 )#6% 05.2#,* &..%)$&37
%3&B%;537
&:+%38*,1
!
" !
#$ %
& '(
%
!
)
!
*!
"
*!
!
" + ) ,
!
-! ! +
&.
@-
;;#3%,$.A7 >%3% $>& #;;.*)#$*&,+
&$2%3 ,13%9 0*,12-
0#*( ,13%9 >*$2(3#>, )#,(*(#$53% 3%6#*,*,1 )#,(*(#$%-
=%#3,%(
+$5(*%( 5;$& $2 ).#++ 2#8*,1 #;;3&?*6#$%.A
#)3%+ .#,( #,(7 $2%3%'&3%7 2*6 )&,+*(%3*,1 2*6 +&.% )#,(*(#$%-
=%#3,%(
>%..
+*,)% (%)%#+%( ;3*6#3*.A 65,#(*
;3&).#6#$*&, )#..*,1 #;;.*)#$*&,+ 2&>%8%37 #;;%#.
(*+6*++%( !*8*+*&,#.
-
&:+%38*,1 / !
!
!
+ ! 01''02'3 4
5
"
"
+ *
+ "+
6 "
!) 7 8
,
" 5 6
"
"9 $
!
" 9
* 1#:
'1;02'0
%
$ "
!
+
4
!
" "
!'( "
# "
! <
"
!" !
)9 *'0 '(2'02'/! 30/=303='/#='/:
$ 01=0( "$-
>!?)9*'## '2'0022/! //(=/0(=12;$ "$-
>!? )9*(' ''2;022/"$-
>!"
! 303=30/=3/ $
*' )9*(0 002102'/ ! 3(: ! 0'
"$-
>!"
*0+
'
!
6 6 " 6 +
6 "
*'
+
4
"
) ,
!" " 01''02'3"
" " <
!
"+ 4 ) ,
!
.
@-
'53$2%3 3%8*+*&,
7 *,*$*#..A #..&>%(
@- - @
6#$$%3 3%6*$$%( #'3%+2 (%)*+*&,7 2&>%8%37
@- - @
,%?53% +%$ &53$7 - -
@ 6#$$%3 3%6#,(%(
(%)*(*,1 3%8*+*&, #'3%+2-
2%3%#'$%37
#1#*, 3%6#,(%( 6#$$%3 '3%+2 ;3*6#3*.A )#,(*(#$% #,(7 $2%3%'&3%7 )&6;#3*+&, )#,(*(#$%+ ;&++*:.%-
- 6A )&,+*(%3%( 8*%>7 3%#+&,*,1 3%,(%3%(
3%6#,(*,1 6#$$%3 5,+5+$#*,#:.% %A%+ .#>-
'7 ;53+5#,)% ;3&).#6#$*&, 8*..#1%7 >2*)2 &3(%37 $>& )#,(*(#$%+ #;;.*%( )#,(*(#$%+ >*$2(3#>,
@
)#,(*(#$53% #))&5,$7 '#5.$ )#, >*$2 )2&*)% &..%)$&3-
- 8*%> 6#$$%37 #..&>%( +%$$*,1
'53$2%3 6#*,$#*,*,1
>2%3%:A 0#+&.*7 %2+*.
!*+$3*)$
%3&B%;53-
%,(*,1 #;;.*)#$*&,
+7 *'
#,A7 +2#..
#.+& +$#,( ).&+%(-
0
!
-
-
+9/+ 2%$2%3 +;%#/*,13%#+&,%(
"%+
& 2%$2%3 3%;&3$#:.% "%+
&