Gurbir Singh @ Kala And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others




   
 






  

   !" #$%$!&' 





 
 















































   

 
 
 



























   







   !" #$%$!&' 








 
 















   

 
 
  



























    ' ()  *


+  
 


!
 "
#$
%&" 
 

 
" !
%
 $
'%$
  
  
(
)* 

 
"
!
+

, #$
%&" 
  
(

 
-
  
  
(



.....

+  
,- ).

/ 

 

 
/01$0*$&234 + &6!3 0%7 0%/% *  !" /&8 1 &6!3 0%  



/59$&6 0*$&23 5$ %/09$&6 0*$&23 5$ %$/ &6!3 0%7 0%/% *  !" /&8 1 &!3 0 
 
#
&



"
"
 &&
"##
0

"
 
 

 


1
/01$0*$&23

5$ %+ ,/0: 8*$&23,/01$&6 0*$&23 5$ %3 2/,/0% 3$1*$&23 &6 *3$&2 *$&23
 
"
23

 
,

,# 
"$
)4-
5 
6 
,,78

0


9:

(;

<=-=)4
 
  " 
-<$
-2$
--$
)23
 
)24

 
:


 
,$
)3<=
5
 
> :,>8

"
 ?

$
'"
/
/


 " 0 




 #

&

 
"# #
 )4=3=)4

"#  *
/59$&6 0*$&23 5$ %/09$&6 0*$&23 5$ % $/ &6$5;0 *$&23 5$ % 06 ;*$&23

   

1 */59$&6 0*$&23 5$ %/09$&6 0*$&23 5$ %$/, + :1$0*$&23,$5;0 *$&23 5$ % 06 ;*$&23,/0;0 *$&23 5$ % !;$,  3 &  *$&23,  ) <39$&6 0  *$&23  &6  + &6 ;  *$&23  5$ %  %< 0&;0 *$&23 
"
23

 
,,

0


''

( 
<=-=)4
 
 
" 
--<$
)33$
)23
 
)24

 
:



 
,$
)3<=
 
" 


 
%#
%"$
)4;4


& 

" "

&*
9:




" 0 




#
&

 
"# #

)4=3=)4

"#  */01$0*$&23 5$ % +

!6  6= 
 
 
" 
-<$
-2$ --$
)23
 
)24

 
:,

 
 
# 






  
 

;=-=)4

$
'


#


$ !#
 "

1

 

 
$
 

"#

 #
 
 







"
 
' 
! 

& 
 ? 
 



&

#
 
"# 
 
 
?



#
 #
/ 1


' 
! 


#


@A
 "

$

 



$
 



$
 















 


B
#


$ !#
 "

1
?
#


@A
 "


&

 



  
$
#


@A
 "

$








 "

/

9


1
:

"$
 


1
"
?

#




 


 1

/ 1
5"#  


$ '


#


8
?

#





 1



/ $
#


A 

""

#
 
&
 #

 



1
"
?
#


!#
 "

1

 " & "

 




#


"

#
 
?
#
  #



$
 



$
 








 
9 
"
?
 





 

?



#
"$
 


?

 




?



#
 
"





 
 

' 


B 
5"#  *

8


&
'

$






 







#

 




&



 
"?
 




&
 
  


 

" 









 



 
'





#




""

 

?


 


 

"?
 



#  




 " 
B 1

#$
 
&  
 





""
 

#
 
 
  "&
   !6  6=  
 
 
" 
--<$ )33$
)23
 
)24

 
:


 
,$
)3<=
 
"


 
%#
%"$ )4;4
 
# 






 

  
 


;=-=)4
 1


/

$
9
:

"

 



 ' 





 
 


 
"

 

  & # 
/ 1


)=*)
 




/
#

!#
 "

1$
'


C


$


  $
, 


$
 



$
D?




  


"#
 
 
?
/

$
9
:

"

 




 
 


&
% 
,


/

$ 9
:

"
 
 
 
#


#  
 


 1




&


/  1


 # 
/ $
/ 

$
9
:

"
?

#"


 


%
 
#


$



' 



C


 
 



&

   "&
 
 
"?
 
"#  1
'

"?


?


#
5



8

 
B 1





 
9 
"$
#


$
!#
 "

1
?



 
-*2
 
 



#
5



8
 
 


 
 
'

?
 
&

 

 
"
1


? 
/ 1
 1
#
 "

"" "
 
"

&
 
&




/ 
&
#

&

 
&


 0


 
9:


''

  
 

 & 
  "$
 
#


#"1
"# #
   / 
,




"

#

)4)=)4
     
)=)==
 "  





 
/
,E:0
! 

"


 
# 

 

"# #
 
 
/
,E:0
! 

"

  


# 

 

 

&1

  

 "# #
"
 
 


 
A




 )=)==
 
-==)==
 "&1

 :

#


$
 
+"
! 
)
,$ 

"
 
# 

 

 
#
 
 =3=)==
 , 
& 




  *    

                  

         



  

                           



  

     

         



  

  

 !

   



    

       "# $ %  %&'  & (

  &)   * %  %&'  & (

        + !





    



    , %  %&'  & (    

   - %  %&'  & (       $.+ / 0 /    /   1 :

#


$
 
+"
! 
)
,$ 

"
 
# 

 

 
#
 
 4=)==
 , 
& 




  *    

                  

         



  

                           



  

     

         

=



  

  

 !

   



    

       "# • %        %&     

              

) • %  %& 

       • !





    



    • %  %& 

     

   • %     %&  

          $.+ / 0 /    /  1

  
()


 



 1
 1





1
 
:
&

 
, 

 
$
 
 , 
 
 
, 

  
(
 
-
 

 

& 
" :



 
 
C

,



 

0


"# 


 *"#  
"
 


#   

"


 

"


& 




"


 1

" &"

#
 
?
 
"  
 
"# 
"


 
""




 
"
 A#
 "


"

#
1

0


"# 
" ,# 
"
&

&

#

1
 
# 1
"&
"

"

"1
 




"##"
 "




 ## 


#1
 
"

0 


&

 &
 
 
 
#

#&
C &$
"


"


 A"
 
" 

&&
 
 

 "
 # 
 &1

 "
?
#$
 
"1$
"



&



 
&


# "

"1
#1$
"

 "  

&

"##
 
 "
 "# 
?
 
& 
 , 
%"

 
 "
"##
1
"
&


?

 " "1
"



0 
 


"# #
  
&"#
 
  
9
"
" 

 
 $
 "
#1

#
 +/59$&6 0*$&23 &6!3 0%>%*  !" /&8 1 &6!3 0%- /&8 1 &6  0?

& $23!/0.'

-.  -0$:$& 5. @( 0$&6 0*$&23>% *  !" /&8 1-*/;0 : !/0.' -. -0$:$& 5.A *  !"

63?

6 %3>%) B:$ ?

& &6!3 0%-*/;0 : !/0.' -.

-0$:$& 5. %


 
 

=3=)==



 

4=)==
 
1
 
+" ! 
)
,$

"1
&
 
 
#


"# #
1 


"  $
& 1
 

 1
""

   "
D 

, 


"
"
 

9:

''




0




#

0 
 

 
"# #
"
  

 
"
/ 
 "
 &&
  
"

&

#

1


# 1

&E  
"

"
/ 
&
&
 
   
#

#&
:

&

 
"
 
""# "

 
"


1

" &"

 

&1
#
 
?
,  
 
"


 




 
A#
 "



A "

 

 
9:


''

 

"
"
 
 " 0 




0  :

&

 
&
" $
 !  6  6  = 

 
 
" 
-<$
-2$
--$
)23
 
)24

 
:,

"


?

$
'"
/
/ 
 !6  6= 
   
" 
--<$
)33$
)23
 
)24

 
:,
 
" 


 
%#
%"$ )4;4
 

"
"

 
&

9:


0 


 " 0 




# /

 
""

1   














-

+  
. 

&E& 


   B  
 ?

E 










FE(















 
 
















FE(