Lal Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another


  

 
  
 
   

 !"#$%"&'('#)*+,,



 

         



  *
 -./ , 0 /0 // . ****  

  ! 

"#  $" 

 % & ! '(



 0 )%""1 #2%3'45 , )*+   

 %  &# ! #  !../ -#0       #!  

    #  

  !  

! !1  2      ! !  3**3.33(    !4# 5 ).+   5 1  *667$#*667 !# #!

#5 % )(+  "  1 1!3**3.33( !   

 !1

  !   (336.33(     2  ,   !  3**3.33(    !  .738.339    "  1     !  *:3/.3*8  ! 

2 !  !

- 2 - )8+   !

    !  ! 2   !!3**3.33(   !*:3/.3*85# ! !   !3**3.33( 2 ! ..3:.3*83**3.33( )7+  !# ! #  1! ! #!  !      *667  1#!

       !#     !  (336.33(# #  ! "  1 ! !*:3/.3*8 2   ! 

1       !     !    #  !  3**3.33(  ,   ; !   !3**3.33( #

< 

  
   

  



  
 



! 
 



 !

    "#

$ 
%& ##"





 !

 "#

$ 
%& ##"

%   

 

 

!   & !



 ' '

(

(

'

    

     

!

 )!

 '

&



! * '



  '

+# 



 

'

%*



!

'



  
 

 %  '  '

 % %



& 

%*    % 

 

'

 ,  

   - !&

'

%*

 !

 %  

 '

'


 

* %


'


 
 &

!


 






'

  '



%*





  '

"# 

"

 
  



- 3 - .  



  
 



! 
 



 !

  

   "#

$ 
%& ##"





 !

 "#

$ 
%& ##"

%   

 

 

! 

 !



 ' '

(

(

'

    

     

!

 )!

 '





! * '



  '

+# 



 

'

%*



!

'



  
 

 %  '  '

 % %



& 

%*    % 

 

'

 ,  

   - !&

'

%*

 !

 %  

 '

'


 

* %


'


 
 &

!


 






'

  '



%*





  '

"#  /

)/+ 0  #   #   1  # 1

   &#        5 2  3**3.33(     5       1  #  

4#! !3**3.33( )9+ '!  1  #  .3*..3*6  # #  5  '. 5

# 0 & =#   #! -11 #! -   > 5*8*3.3.3

 5!  ! 

   %<<  !4#  ! #51  # #!      1 # 5     

 " # #!*(3:.3*80# #51  !!  1  ..3:.3*8  !!     1  !    #!

1  #51    ! 

- 4 - !1   ##  !  5 1

   ):+ 0#51  ! 1   *669  .338      



      

    !

  .738.339   ! ! !#5!    !! #< 5!  .33(#!

  5 2!15  )6+    !#   '(  #     1 

#  11 ;!

    5   !

#   1   %   !   5 2   

 %  1  

   %  !   &# 1 ;-#   !
  " # 


$" % & ' ()*
+' !  21 1#55 !1#   1#5! 

!

 11#5  %  )*3+ '  #1  5 5      )**+     !#       

#

!  )*.+ 1     2   1   1    !  3**3.33( );#  <*+    5 ! 5 * * % & 


,  % &

- 5 -  -".'/+/. 0!*6*3.3.(

 

 

 1  # &#!   !1    5 # #!  # 1-#  #   )*(+ !!      * * % &-)# + 

 1 1     !  !  !    

2 !  !3**3.33(1 *33..338#5 "  1 )*8+ '     5    ! #  * * % &-)# + 5!5 !    55#!1  ! #  !  )*7+

 !!   *8*..3.( 0 0

0 )%""1 #2%3'4

2%3"

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No