M/S R S Enterprises v. M/S Surbhi Traders
!"#
$
!
"#
# $ % &"$'(")$'
&
*(")$'
)
%&'(()*+%,"
)-
#"
$ +,-./ % (
( "* ($ $
.
$!0
$1 $
(
2
) %
)3" !0)
4
$ $
*
$ + "5( 6
* )
78!
*
.'" &-&'/01203340-5'""
33'&6)3 /4",
)0203- , $
$ $*
'
+, $+,-./ %) $$
"' *"
$ +, %! "
'
$ 9 $(* $ :, #" !'$
$ !
!
3 2
0) "' * ** !
3"" ! * !$ !0 0$
$ 6 "
) ' * $ + " ))
0 ""
"4 3""
"*
"**
3""
($ ) * 0) $)3""4 "
! $" $ $ 0) ' * **
$
3 " $3""
' )3") *
$ +,. " % ' $ *"
$ +,. *
$ !( !9 0 $ *
0) ' *
*) 3"
' ! "
" *) $
0*
#" $ 0) "
"%
*
" ("
' ! +,
3 " * $
( 0 $
$ !
"' * )3"";
$ " (
' $ $ ' *3"
< "
0) ( 4
)
"
) (" "% !
%
' "*
$
"
) " (" "
3 " ' "
73' )
0
0
*
= 3" * ' *>
) &(
7("
$ +,-./ " %3 $!
0 3"
! $$!0 "%
* !0
' +, " % 2
0) "%
* *$$ +, * ! "' *>
9 3 " (
*
"
(
< " $) "%
*
' +, ' (
"' *
"( $* $ *
*
2 0) "' '* "
$ + " !0 !#"! "*
$ $
' "
'
*
" % $ .+ " !0 ;
' % "*
" $*$
$ *
#" ) "*
) 3" "' * $" "4 *
!' * *
' +, $3 " "$ ' * $
-3 / " %?
+ 2
)
0( " $
' '
() 78!
*
0)&4/8)/&89&5&31&3/&--0:&34&5'"% ;12))8)03 )0203-<<&-8"7= 97+0/( )0203-
+ <<&-8">89*&40*&*83>"", 3"
0(
9 $(* "
!
' 0)"
" $ :#"$
$
(3 " !
'
)!0 (
)$ !
' ;
0 !0
0 *
* $ "
'
'
#" (
* ;*@5'
2 * 6* ! )5%
@$
(
3
3 ("
(
3"
3 $
)
3 "
*
' 0 $ "
*
(
0 $
"
0 "3 !0 ;
' "
' 0 3 $ !
("
*
#" ! "
3 $ "
' 4 (' )* 3!
$
*
; ( !
(
73' ) 3" $
$ ( (
$ "
' !4
0'
"$
(
!") "4 "'
(
& 0$
$!0$
)
'(0'0'?&41'&0/0''&//-&*-+ /(//(&-+*&4-)&*?@/(0' 81)/0')&/)8'<&4/05&3*0'
38)2--@''12&*/8?&/(&-+9)82/(&034&</083 #"
3 0 $
* $ 3 " " 9 $(* %1*:2&3/ 8) *&40'083 +(04( 03/&)<)&/' '//1/& 8) <)850'083 /(&)&89 *&4-)&'/(&2&303:89/(&'//1/&'0/'(81-*?&483'/)1&* 9)82 /(& */& 89 0/' &34/2&3/" 3 8/(&) +8)*', /(& %1*:2&3/*&4-)&'+(//(&-&:0'-/1)&(*'0*//(&/02& +(&3 /(& -+ +' <)821-:/&* 3* /(&)&98)&, 0/ (' )&/)8'<&4/05&&99&4/"< "
0)
3""
*$ !
' ;
0*
'A"
3 *)
$
9 $(*
(
3
'
( $0! $
. *3"
!
$ "* (
33""; $ "
" $
'A"
!$
!
3
$ * !" "
0!
3
$#"
*
"$ 0
@
3
3!
*
$ ;
$ " $@-* $$$/ . #" )'3 "9 $(* $ "78!
*
&-&'/012 03340- -
/ $ 0)&4/8)/& 89 &5&31&3/&--0:&34&-
/)
$1 $()%
)$ $
$ $ +, % $
*
$
* (
0$ $ "*
!& $
$ "
$1 $()%
)
"3 " B
$) $( 0%$(
) 0)
$$ $
# $
=""
"
*
A" &( $ C5 A"
C5