Mahinder Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another




   
      

 !"#$!%&'&"()*++, 
 






  




































  










 ) -. + /
0
 /+ 1  


 
  
 
 
 !
"#
"$!

 

%

!
" & 

 

'





(((((
0
 /+ 12+ 34   1.

 )


 
 


* 
+,
 

--.
 
'/01'0'/


.0.'

2  )
))
 !
'0'.
 
.-3'

.4

2  
'0'.

# 
!
   
  #&


%

1!
5!
# 
6 
##
* & 
    


& 
 
''0/'0'4
"7 
 '


' 8 


  
#

  
  
  

&




!
 




6

 &

8
&



&

  
. 2 #)
  :!

& 

 
&
 

+,



 
&
6
   

   
 

'

 
; 
!
    


&)&#
   


 


  
< 6 !
6 

   
& #!

 


'

&

& 



 
<&!

 
 

/ 8
 
6 
 & 


 

# 
#
 =,##*
  


 
'40>'0'4

9  !




   
& 
   
& 
 

 6

 






  
6
&##
 
4  



 !




&
 
?&#
  
-
9#!
5




-00-
 
0.-''0'4
8
#
7 & 



 &



    

 !  "  #! $#%  & $  $#% ! '

(#! $#%  & ) (# $#%  !# *  +,-
    "." /"

 $ #  !# * 

-

 )

 ! *    "  #! $#% '

(#! $#%  ."  /"

 $ #

* #  "*"#  ! #%! "-  #   &&

!* 

 ! &    *  #  1 #% * # 2& 34256 2 !3  3#% -   7 &

 !   !  !  *  #"! &&!- 8  #! "*"# # %#9(

9#  

 #!#& -  #   *

( * 

-: @

#)
#
)
6)


 
0/-''0'4

#


 



# )
##

#


 

A


.

3 5 


& #
 


 

& 

& 
   
 

 



)
  
&


 # 
 
   
 

1 5 
& #
  
#

 


'
   



# 


& & &


+,

##



& * #
 & 

*

 
 
    

#
9  
> 8
 
 &#

7 & 
 6 

/1'
6 
  :
)

< B#
  
9 






               

 ! "" #$

8
#
  
 
7 & 



% #& &$


* (  #  *  &  3#%  *(  2 & *  &   

   !  & 6 -  *(# # !  

&  * - ,    %#   ! * (  * # ## 3#% -

#& & #(

# &  6# !#

# &  3#%  &# #&"

#*  * !#%   %!

 

"    2 #(!

2  &&! (#

#"#  " #(

& 6# !#

&

**  &

"*!#% && -;# "*!#% && 9

*&  # %(!2 *(# # &

/

$

 &  ! & #"#  5 !9 <

- * 1 !$


# 

!(#&

&& #  "*!

2-

#&'&,&"#% *##  * !#%

 ! 2 1 ! # = #  & # 6# !#

# ! $


9  3#%   "

( 

    !  & 6  ! 6 #& = # & # *-

#&$&;# # *& 3#%  #!

"2# !*# !#  2= # ! #  

 !  & 6 9  ##  *(  2  & *  &   -

#&(& ! # #      &# #&"

#*  !21 ! %!

&&! !(#

#" ( 

! !# * 9((   #"

   &

# "

  & 



!  =

#(  2

# & *# #* 

 2 &"

!-

#&#&, = # & *!$


 !# ! #%# *

!# *  2 

!9 3#%   "

  ( ! % !  

% (#  &  && - 3#  ! #  &&   #((#% "

 !* (#   &&    "!9 * ! !

# 

 ***#

 2 1 !

4

% (#

#" & "#& (#

#" ( 

!

!# * -$ &&   9  * >#%9 *#(

 # 

 2   (  #  #"*

 *  # -  ! # #  # # #  #

  #  &!!   (#!#% "  & *2#  #   # *# #%*  & # &&  -

#&&?  !# #%# ! &" #  &&  9  "

 2



  #   (  ("#%  *!"# " & #(#!# * -

! !#

 & #% # &   = #  &  # * 1 #   !-

#&)&#"# 

  #((#% &&   # #  &"

"" 9&# 9"

#9*  #* #"# 

#  #     #(# & ( "

 #

***#

 #

#  &  & 1 #%  * #  ( 

! !# * -

#&!&,

9 3#%  "

 1  * !#% #& # (# & "*"#  2  !# *

9 * #2## & (#

## " 



# &  * !#% !

  ** # !*6!# @

#&

& #    = *  *# #*     # ** # #  8-- ! 8-<- 2(- A "#  &&   #((#%  &#  !  "#  2#% &

@

$

 (#"*#

# # #2! !"

#& "!# * 2 *#(

!# *

-3#% ! 2 6 #&#! # ! ##%  1   &&!# #((!# 

#(#  ># &#   "# & !"# !" -  1  &

#! & *  &#    "# "##%# 2  C
-0 8
 ## 6
#
&


  

 #

&

6##


*
#   
#  

&

 &


 6 


4'1

2  )
 A
 A
 !
'0'.

# 

 %# !

 & & &"   & !   "

   2 

! 2  * # - ## 5 #  &

  & % *

#(

 #!  #



# #

  ( *  #  * ##!# %&#    2#%

#   ## >*

-

  +, # 1 # *

#    

* !#% 

 

%-

 && #1

 2 #! 2# 

&& 

!  >  # &   #   *2#

  %- ,

     2 "!    >#%  # &  @

3

 

# &  * !#%  # #>  **

 &  * 

#9 ! (   % *2#  **  !     # & # =*!# &6!#  #"- -- ,
6




?&#
  
-
9#!
5


 &#
#
 6
)

"7
9 




              

 ! "" #$
!

 
 

## 6
+,
 

--.
 
'/01'0'/


.0.'

2  )

))
 !
'0'.
 
.-3'

.4

2  
'0'.

# 

!
   

 #&


%

1!
5!
# 
6 
##
*
 & 
    !
 
 )
*
*

  



& 
 
''0/'0'4
"7 
 '

-'  

**+

0
 /+ 1 *++,    Mangal Singh D 
A =  



E=

D 


#

E=