Shamsher Singh And Another v. Union Of India And Others

CWP-30760-2024 (O&M) - 1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CWP-30760-2024 (O&M) Date of decision: 19.11.2024 Shamsher Singh and Another ....Petitioners

Versus

Union of India and Others

...Respondents

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMAN CHAUDHARY ***** Present :

Mr. Rajeev Anand and Mr. Ujwal Anand, Advocates for the petitioners Mr. Karan Kumar Jund, 



 

  ***** AMAN CHAUDHARY, J. (ORAL) 1.




 
 

 
 

 









 




  



 

!

"


 
 


# $  








%&

 

 ' 
 
   

 
'
(
 

)
  

   
'





  


 

 ' 
 



(



 (

 
 











 



'  





'
  

(
'





'







 








  *"%+&, %-".

 

%.-.%-".

/0 
.


  



 (
  



,
# $

 
(


3 '
4-
%--% 
%6



'
  

3 '
",

%--.
5/0 
%6
 (
 


 


 


 


 5 6

CWP-30760-2024 (O&M) - 2- 
 



 

  





%&

'




'





(
 

 '  7
/0 
%




 
   '  

(





'



)


!

"
5


!

%
8

 6 (
 






*




%-"4
$

'

 





 
  
)
 

$

(
(

 9 
-%
%-".
5/0 
"-6


'
 
 

!

('
%-
%-"&
5/0 
""6
 

 (
 


*


'
)
  
'


 
 


 
 :

# $
 ;
'

< (



= 

3


3 '
4-
%--% 
%6


%






 


 
 
 ' 

'
 ' 
  
 


 (




  


 1 2
 



 
 


#0

( 

 

 



 '   

 







>

'

 

 
 




 ' 

)
5 

 6

 
 
# $


'
 ' 
 
 
  

 ?
"-




/ 
'

 
 (
 
  
  




  




 '  

  ' 




/ 
 '
 


'  (

)


  ' 



< (
( 

)




 
 


 
 


# $



'









 

'
 


'  (


)  




 


   
 


 
 
 '   (
 
 

'

< (




 
'

'

 




 
)
 

*
 

 







'
)



/ 
#(

 


'


 
'


 (
   

 ( 







< (




$ @' 
/0



 
 

 

 


 
 
 
5":.:6
%


A-:

 







 


 
'

 

0  < (
 

' 

' 

 < (


'

 
 


 

'

CWP-30760-2024 (O&M) - 3- 



 

 
 
  !

  
5%-"+6
""


4"


/0


 






  


 


 

'
 


' 

 ' 
 


'

 

 
  







( (
 ( )








 
 





 ""

  
'



 ( 


'  (
 

(


  

(




 


 (




 
'
) 




 


 


( 

  
0 



 

 (









 ( 
  


' 

 

/0


"#$%
& 
 

'
( )


*'
 '
 ')
&+

  
5":.%6
A 

.+&

 


 
(  
'
 




  

 >

'


'

   (
 


(


 (
 
"%

 



'



'

(
 




 
 > 

9 
",
%-"& 
""6

9 
-%
%-".
5/0 
"-6

 




 


 




0


'




B 
= 
C  

# $

3 '
4-

%--%
5/0 
%6

  

3 '
",

%--.
5/0 
46?

2.
Learned counsel for the respondents despite his best efforts, has been unable to controvert the factual position and draw out any distinctive aspects in the aforementioned judgment or cite any contrary law. 3.

In wake of the aforesaid, the present petition is disposed of in terms of Harteg Singh (supra).

(AMAN CHAUDHARY) JUDGE 19.11.2024 M.Kamra Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes / No Whether reportable :

Yes / No