Badri Mandal And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"!
#$%&%%&
$ '( & )) (
! "
!
#$"
# " %"&
! ' ((((( ) (*& ) * & &
!!$ + $!
,'-
.$. '/'0 1$ 23 0- '4/5'/',6
&
7 $!
0)-687 005607 00- 08/ 5)
! 9&
! $&1$
& !
" '//:'/', 6 ;$<'=
7 ' * "
!
" " > $
$ %$" )//-0 3? =
=
" !!
$ 3 9 " $ ?
!!
$ =
>29.& !!
$ ,/'///,0/0)0)-@'8/5'/',
$$
A !
"
$
)8 -0 5:5<= ! "
!!
$ =
. = !
!
" @* !
" =!
"
!
B
&.
!
" !
$$ =
= * !
"
"
&
$$ !!
$ $ . !$"
. =& * !
" =
9&9" 6):0/7!
" = $ 0)0/5',//800':
!
"
23 & 0 ? !
$
$
& " !
!!
!
$
"
&"!& & =
=
!
& '< !
"
=
!
$ =
? !
$ $
$
!
"=
& =
23<!
" '//:'/', = $<
!
"
# $ %& ' ( ) * +" $ , " " - ? !
$
$
23 1$ = !
=
!!
$ "$
!& & =
.! "
=
!
$=
! !
! $
?!
$ $
$&"
$$
',/:'/', &
9
"
=!
&
!
! =
" )/)/'/', & ! "
9 ? !
$ $
$
$$ $ = $ . & & =
!" !$
!
$
* $ &
& 8 ? !
$ $
= $ !& $ $$
!
!!
!
$
! !&$
!
!
" &$
$& ! !
! &. !
*
!
"
!
" ; & !
1$
&$ = !
!
"
$
& .
!!
$
!67 1$
!& ! $ ? !
$ " A
=
1$ =
9 $!
,'- '/'0&$
&;! !$ $ @
&
$&" !
$ "
, ?!
$
' $&"
"!&
"
=
* !
"
;!$ !
" '//:'/', !
!
& !
!
" 1$
2$
"
!
" & $ =
!
! $$ $!* $ =
!
"$ ;!$ & =
!
$
& =
!
1$ ! "
"&1$ 5 3 !
$
$
!
+!, ""- 4 * $
!
=
!
"
&1$
& !
"
" & & =
* " $
$"
=
236 ! "
"7!&1$
&
!
"
" & =
=
23
!&$ -
.
/#)- +0 + /!"!
#" 1
+!,!#. +
-+ * %23 6
& C
997 !
8-' 99 ):40$
. '
% ' $
' " ' / - 1 1+!04+!5)-+5"1)#1!*6
& '/'07
!
'/'0$
.
% '
$
" ' / -
.
/#"
(6 : * !
"
67$
=
!
"#$ % &
'
% % 67 3 $ " (
)'
*+,+*-.*.
D$ !
E& $" $< F,0) % ' )
#!1 ' 222 222 222 222 222 222 222 34
5 % ' ) 2 /
#!1 '
2
67*+ / *+ ' ) 2
% " 2 "% '
%
$
" " " )
&
7 "
$ ' (
$ 7 )
8 9
) "
" " " " $
"
"% ' ) "
" $ /
2 / )
"% '
/ / " ) *+
"% ' / ) 67 3 $ " /
)' *+,0-00
E& $"9 $< # "
% '
) 2 ,0! ' )
5 *+ ,0! '
'
#!1 ' . " ,0! ' "% ' ) "
3 % " 2 *+: ) "
5 *+ / " *+ ' :2 % '
/ *+
2
$
" " "
"
$ ' (
$ )
*;+<" 9 "
) *;+:2 "% ' 2 $ /
2 / ) *;+<
#14'
% "% ' #14'
% ' 2 #14' $
" " #14' " % '
/ " /
" = /
8
< "% ' 2 $
) % '
( " '
*;+: 2 ,0! ' "
" % ' ) >$" " % ' 2 "
< "
" % ' 2 ,0! ' "
#14'
"
% ' " )
% #14' " ")
- 67 3 $ " '' 1 2 '' 3 % ' 4%
56
()
1#*+7
2 8 9:9 58; .
D$ !
E& $" $< 3 /"
5 *+ ,0! % ' / % ' 7 *+ / % ' )
/
:
" #!1 ' '
"?4# ) ,0!
9 *+ ) 2 /
,0!" % '
/ / 2 7 * +: % '
2 7*+ / *+ 7 * + )
"
2
7 * + 2 ,0!
"% '
%
" )
" $ "
7
% * +(
" 2 ) 7 * + '
" " " ) 7 *2+ " % ' ) " /
7 *2+ 2 * + *2+ @
9 % ' / )
$
)
- 6 7 3 $ "
: < =>% /<
1# *+? 8 9:9 58; +?0
D$ !
E& $"9 $< #' ' " " 5 + ,0! ' ) 9
#!1 ' 2 "
7 + 2
$
" " "
7 + " 2
$ ' (
$
%% )
7 +
#14' ( (
" "
#14'
( ( ) 2 ,0! ' " % "% ' #14'
% ' 2 #14' $
" " #14' " % '
/ " /
" % " 2 % '
2 " !?A !?4 ' .
* +
7 +2 ,0! ' ) 9
" "
" % ' ) 7
" " " - #.0"!"9+ .6: )/ * !
.
=
"= .
=
!" !67!
$ &
&= !
" $
%
!
0'/
99 ):406 =!
0,: '/'07 3 ! F G . = F - -* ; $
!
;!
! &
!
"< !
" "
3
= !
" $ !
" !" !!
$ &"
&
9
;! ! = !
" =
$
!
0'/ 99* H
1$ =
9
&;! $!
$!
8-' 99 !
$ 1$
23!" !
& !
"
" & & =
)/) ! $
= $ & "
$ !
"& =
9 $!
8-' 99 ):40 )/' 3 =
9
= !
! = = !
;
9 = $ & &
! =
9 & &$
$ $ !3
= H$!
=67 !
<&
! ""
&$ I
$!
=67
9 = $ " &$ !.
$& !* =
9
!
&!
$ =
= & " $* =!
! =
$
9 = !
& !
& =
=67
" $
! =9 & & $!
&$3 $$!
=
"
=
!
"
% !!$" ! = !
"!
$ ". " &
= !&
! = !
!
*
9 = !
;
$
! $ ! & "
$
$
=67
=
$ = !
; &
=
& =
$ !
&$
! =9 * ";"
" @!
&>& ! &
!
A 6=
=
=
= !
!
; 7
=
9 $!
== !
!
$ =
!
$ " $ !2$
";" @> ' ) A $
$!
=
$& $ ! = !
$
9 ; !
=$!
8-' 99 "
=
9
&$
! 9
!$
$ !* $! &
=67
$
H!
" $ &
9 H
$
!
$
$! $!
" $ ! !!
!=
= "
! !
"3
= H!
8-' 99 !
= = !
"=$ ! = $ 1$ &
H !$
$
& !
$ ! =
;
$ ! $& $ ! & =
!$
$ !
% )/0 * & ! 67 !
;
!
8-'
99 ):40 = $ =
!
"
!
,'- '/'0 = !
=
= )) * E& $"9
! (
6$7
$!
=
9 1$ !" !
&
" " " !
" $ ! " !
0'/ 99 6 =!
0,: '/'07 9 = ;! =$!
0'/ 996 =!
0,: '/'07!!$"!&&
9 " !
1$ !"
!!" !
$ ! $ ;! $!
=3 =
$
!" ! = " " ! ! " "
$
! " $ != !
&! $ !
$ &1$ &
9 !
$ 672$
E& $"
! /
6$7
& !
!
& "
& .
= !
$
!" ! $
!!$
$!
& $
!
! $! !
$ & !
!
&$ !
&
9
= ;" 1$
!" !
&
" !
" = !$ ="
! $ $ ! " ! . "$ !
H ! $
9 $ !
!
""
&$& ! !
% &1$ = ;! $!
$!
*
"!
!
$ "
D$ !
E& $"9
! '' 1 !6$72$
D$ !
E& $"9 $ " =>% /< !6$7
! < =! (
6$7 /
6$7# '' 1 6$7* $ $! = & !< =
" !
!
1$ 23!" !
& !
"
"
$ ! $H!
$ !" ! = $ &;!$ 9 . =H! $!
! = $ & $& &$
! !$
9 =
$
$
"
! $" & !. $!
1$ = $ $
$ ! )))
$ $1$ !
=
& $ !
& ;! =
!!$"!
"&
$! * !
$!
"$
$ ! !
! $
!!$" !* !" $ ! "
" $" $ H "&
&
$
$"
! A ! $
!
& 3 $! . 1$ !" !
& $ !
" & =
!
"$ !
"" "
I
&! !$ !& = " & " !
!
&
"
%7 ! * !
$ <& $
!$ A
$
!
"!
$& ! ! = * $! & !! $ !
$ $ ! =
& ! =
" 9 " $!
!
$ "$ $ !!
.$"
$& !!
!
$ ! "
A
= !" "
" " . "$ & !!
67 )' * !
" !&$
" !
! ;! $ "
$! $ ! 1$ !" !
& !
"
"
& & =
!
" !
"
!!$ > !
"
$ & "
!
""! $ &
& !. $& ! $ 9&2$!
!
$ ! !$
" !$ &$
"!" $
$& !! ;!
1$
& !
$ " @=
" <& ; !$ $& "!
!
!
"
.&
"
" "
$
$! "" $
"!
I $!
! !$ " &
"$ !
" ! !$ $ .*
$!
A!" "&
!
"
" !
& ; ! $ !$
= "!
!
!" $ ! "I !&$
""
%3 & ! !
H
!
"
!
" !
"
" & =
!!$
!
" !
"
" !
$ $ $ & !. $
!! $1$ & $
9 &$ !
A
!
) & !
" !
"E
!
"
" ! ! $ "
$
"
= !
&$!" * $! "
"! !
$" "
! !
"
" !
$!
!
"
"
& $
$" "
!& "
$ $
! !&$ = !
!$ ;
$& ! " " ! $"!
$ $
$ !
""! !
)')
!
!
!
* ! =
!= ! $ $
6$!
! !&$7 !
$" " & !$$ $ .
!
=
!$& !
= "
$" !$ !
$
&
!
!
!$ $
%8 $& ! " 1$ !
!& $3$!
!
$
;! = &= !
,'-
'/'0
!
= !
"
" $ 67 " &!$
239" 9 " =
!&$ = $
"
$
&! $! $
!$ $&
$ ! 2 !& $! !
!
! $
$!
" $ ! "$ $ !
&!
A
!
! ; ! ! )'' * "
=
!671$
$ =
!&$ &""
! !& $
9 1$
.
!
$
!$ ! ;
$ $ 67
;!
!
&
9
! & & =
= !& $
!
" & 3
"& &
=
!. "$
* = $ &
! A
$! ! = !
&
& $ "
"
= $ &
) 2 $ 9!$" ;& !
"". !& =!
! $ = !@ " $!
;!= $
$ $& & & $
!
$ " ;
!$ != !
9 ! !
=!$ !
$ !
!
$ )0 1$ $
& $"
= $ "
%2 3 * $!
9
& ;! 1$ 239" 9 "
!&$
& !
"
" * $& ! "
"! $
!& $
$ " $ "
!
& =
!
" !
"
!!$ 33 I " !$ $ $! !
!
!&$ & ! .
$=
$
= !$ !
9
9 " !
"
!!$
9 "$
"
=
$ !"!
!
"
"
$
333 * !
$ "
=
! =
"& !
$ 637 $ 63376$7
9 "$ $ .!$$ $ $ !$
!
$
! ;
$ $ ! & & < = ;!
$! ! &9 ! =$1$ !
$ !
!
$*
&
9
= ;! $!
! "$ &. !
"$ &!
!=
&!! D$ !
!
!!1$ #.0"!"9+ "
1 ;+ "
# "
: )8
!
!
& 1$
6
! "
"7
& !
"67 '//:'/',
! & "
!
$
!
=. =
!
&
!
$ $ & =
"@
!
&$
!
231$
!
$ !
! &$ $!&
!
!&$ @ "
& !
!"!
# ), 3 =
!
$ 67 * H. 1$ 23 0- '4/5'/', 6
7 $!
0)-687 005607 00- 08/ 5) ! 9&
! $&1$
& !
" '//:'/', 6 ;$<'7H" 67 & " &
!
"
!
9 ! ! $
!!
!=
= =
& $!=
" 67
!
6 7 ! 67 9) (: "&)'
'/', . (/ I
. J I
& J