High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8217/2019dismissed

Sucha Singh And ANR v. Gurjant Singh And ANR

2020-02-13Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh9 pages

"#$ $%&'&(

)*%+")&,+"-"#+$. / $#&#&$.'

0$.'*' *.1"#)&,+"-"#+$. $'2-$#'

.$'$#(3 !.4"."".,5-6%"#$5

.#+$2$#&#&$.' !.*72"7)&,8"5-6%"#$5

.#+$.$'2-$#'

9#+&' 2$#&#&5#+$ 2$#&#&$.' %+"88$,$#+$ .-$. #+$ 8$".$-&6&8*-,$.&65 "#&"8"5-"#$- : 5;9<+&%+" "228&%"#& &8$- ;9 #+$ .$'2-$# -$ $-"# & #+$ '*&# *-$. #+$ 2.6&'&' .-$. *8$ #+$-$ &6&8 .%$-*.$5+"';$$ "88<$-5<&#+#+$2$#&#&$.-&.$%#$-#2"9%*.# $$ #+$ 6"8*$ #+$'*&#2.2$.#&$'5$ <+&%+<"''#"#$-#;$ "6"8*$ 7.$ #+" '%..$"'2$.#+$2$#&#&$.'328"&#&

+&7'$8 5"-#+$#+$. .

7.$#+" ' 8"%' +$2$#&#&$.'='*&#&'$'$$>&,"-$%.$$ -$%8"."#&# #+$$

$%##+"#".$,&'#$.$-$?%+",$-$$-$?$%*#$- : ;$#<$$ #+$2".#&$'5%*87&"#$-&#"7*#"#&;$&,$#$.$-5;$-$%8".$-#;$ &88$,"85*88"-6&-"-#+$.$'*8# " ."*-5<&#+#+$2$#&#&$."8' '$$>&,2''$''& $ #+$'*&#2.2$.#&$'5&$#+$$-$'%.&;$-"'

33 4#+&5@"8&"%8"6$5 22'&#$ *1";& &6$.'&#95 "#&"8"+$#+$.

+*'$&''#"#$-#;$"8.$"-9&2''$''& #+$2$#&#&$.'328"&#&

5"'

'*;7&##$-A*$.9;98$".$-%*'$8##+&'%*.# +$%#$#& #+$.$'2-$#3-$ $-"##+$.$ .$<"'#+"# #+$'*&#$;$&,'$$>&,"-$%8"."#&##+$" .$'"&-$

$%#5<&#+"

%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ 2''$''&"8''*,+#"#8$"'#A*"$ #+$'*&# 2.2$.#&$'5%*.# $$ <"'$%$''".&892"9";8$ +$'#"- #+$2$#&#&$.&.$289##+$"228&%"#& #+$ .$'2-$#3-$ $-"#5<"''&7289##+$$

$%##+"##+$<.&##$'#"#$7$# '#&88#+"6&,;$$ &8$-"##+"#'#",$"-#+$-%*7$#&A*$'#&'#"#$- #;$" ."*-*8$#89$?$%*#$-$52.2$.%*.# $$+"-"8.$"-9;$$"

&?$- +$8$".$-#.&"8%*.##&%$-#+"#"'2$.#+$$?%+",$-$$-5 #+$6"8*$ #+$2.2$.#9<"' 'B5 5

C35<&#++<$6$.5#+$6"8*$ $ 2.2$.#9'+<#;$D7.$#+" '%..$E"-#+$#+$.5&$*'$ 5'+<#;$D#7.$#+" ' 8"%'E#&'#;$#&%$-#+"#"# $28"%$#+$&72*,$-.-$.'#"#$'D#7.$#+" ' 8"%'E5<+$.$"'"# #+$#+$.28"%$'#+$2+."'$*'$-&'D7.$#+" ' 8"%'E "%#5-*.&, #+$%*.'$ ".,*7$#';$ .$#+&'%*.#5;#+8$".$-%*'$8.$ $..$-# #+$2.2$.#9"'+"6&,;$$.$ $..$-#&#+$28"&#"'<.#+D7.$#+"

' 8"%'E #<"'#&%$-#+"#%*'$8 .#+$2$#&#&$.'328"&#&

+"- 2.-*%$-;$ .$#+"#%*.#""7";"-& .#+$9$".

3 5&<+&%+#+$ 8"-.$6$*$<"'"''$''$-A*"=4#+&=#;$ ':2%"-#+$.$ .$&# <"'%#$-$-;9#+$28"&#&

#+"##+$%*.# $$<"'89#;$"

&?$-

33 #&7$'#+$8"-.$6$*$ <$6$.5&#<"'"8' *-#+"#&#+$'"&-"7";"-&5#+$ #+$.+*'$;$".&,+"-# *-"97$#& +$".,*7$# #+$8$".$-%*'$8 .#+$2$#&#&$.';$ .$ #+"#%*.#5<"'#+"#&"9%"'$#+$6"8*$ #+$2.2$.#9%*8-#;$#">$ #;$7.$#+" 'B5 5

C3"'#+"#<"'#+$6"8*$7$#&$-&#+$ $?%+",$-$$-5<+&%+".,*7$#<"'.$1$%#$-;9#+"#%*.#5+8-&,#+"# '&%$#+$28"&#&

'=<%#$#&&+&''*&#5<"'#+"#$#+$2.2$.#&$' <"' "6"8*$ 7.$#+" '%..$"-#+$#+$. .7.$#+" '

8"%'5#+"#<*8-;$#+$6"8*$#+"#<*8-$$-#;$#">$#"..&6$"#" %"8%*8"#& #+$%*.# $$+$1*-,7$# #+$)*2.$7$*.#.$8&$- *25& # !

%!$

$ '!( ) 5<"'.$ $..$-#5#+8-#+"##+$%*.# $$<*8-;$ 2"9";8$ &#$.7' )$%#&&6% #+$*.# $$'%#5 +$.$8&"%$;9#+$2$#&#&$.'328"&#&

"1*-,7$# #+$ $8+& &,+ *.# & )#*

$ '!( & !

'( $'(+',!'$ '!( BB$8+&5<"' *-#;$ 7&'%%$&6$-5&6&$< #+$ "%##+"##+$2$#&#&$.&#+$2.$'$#%"'$5+"- "8''*,+#2''$''& #+$'*&#2.2$.#9 )&7&8".895 " 1*-,7$# #+&' %*.# & !- )#! &

)#!5 B5<"'& "%# *-#;$2$."#&, ","&'##+$2$#&#&$.'5"'#+&'%*.#+"-+$8-#+"##+$'*;'#"#&6$.$8&$

"'>$- .;9#+$28"&#&

5$$-'#;$8>$-"#

3F3 $%$5+8-&,#+"#'&%$#+$6"8*$ $ #+$2.2$.#&$'<"'

7.$#+" '%..$'"-#+$#+$.7.$#+" ' 8"%'5#+$%*.# $$ <*8-;$2"9";8$ "%%.-&,89 $ .$ #+&' %*.#5 8$".$- %*'$8 . #+$ 2$#&#&$.' +"'

.$&#$."#$-#+$".,*7$#'7"-$;$ .$#+$#.&"8%*.#5##+$$

$%##+"#5 &.'#895 #+$'*&#;$&,$'$$>&,$

$%#&6$89%"%$88"#& #+$$?%+",$-$$-& A*$'#&5#+$%*.# $$<"'892"9";8$&#$.7' )$%#&6" #+$ *.# $$'%#5 &'+.#D#+$%# E<+&%+.$"-'"' 88<'(3 D /# ,,''(/0.' 1'! (# (3+$ "7*# $$ 2"9";8$ *-$. #+&' %# & #+$ '*&#' $?# +$.$& " #$.

7$#&$-'+"88;$%72*#$-"' 88<'(3 ???

???

6 ,! /(('(( , $ #('( $

!$'(3'*&#' .#+$2''$''& 8"-5+*'$'"-,".-$'3"%%.-&, ##+$6"8*$ #+$'*;1$%#7"##$.G"-'*%+6"8*$'+"88;$-$$7$-#;$3 <+$.$#+$'*;1$%#7"##$.&'8"-5"-3 " <+$.$ #+$ 8"- .7' " $#&.$ $'#"#$5 . "

-$ &&#$'+".$ "$'#"#$52"9&,"*"8.$6$*$#6$.7$#5 . .7'2".# '*%+"$'#"#$"-&'.$%.-$-&#+$ 88$%#.'=.$,&'#$."''$2"."#$89"''$''$-<&#+'*%+.$6$*$G "-'*%+.$6$*$&'2$.7"$#89'$##8$-333#$#&7$' #+$.$6$*$'2"9";8$G ???

???

???E &'$?#%#$#&<"'#+"#&"9%"'$$6$& #+&'%*.# %7$'#"%%8*'&#+"#%*.# $$&'#;$2"&-"-6"8.$7#+$6"8*$

#+$2.2$.#95'*%+6"8*$%"89;$#">$#;$"',&6$&#+$$?%+",$ -$$-5&$ 'B5 5

C35"-# '%..$ &'$?#%#$#&<"'#+"##+$6"8*$'%"8%*8"#$-<*8-"8'

3:3 ;$89A*"#+$'*&#2.2$.#9#+"##+$2$#&#&$.<"''$$>&,2''$''&

"- # A*"#+$ #+$. 2.2$.#9& .$'2$%# <+&%+ +$ 89'*,+# "

-$%8"."#&5<&#+%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ 2''$''& H$".$-%*'$8$?#.$8&$-*2"1*-,7$# "%.-&"#$ $%+ #+&'%*.#& #!-

& -''

"-#+$.'

:BF 5-$%&-$-

5#'*;7&##+"##+$2.&%&28$8"&- -<;9#+$)*2.$7$*.#&#+$%"'$ # !

( 1(' (#/!"5 <*8-89;$"228&%";8$<+$.$#+$%'&-$."#&&'7$#&$-&#+$-$$- '*,+##;$%"%$88$-;9#+$$?$%*#"# #+$-$$-5&$ %*.#

$$<*8-;$2"9";8$;9#+$28"&#&

& +$<"'#+$$?$%*#"# #+$'"8$-$$- #+"#+$'*,+##%"%$85<&#+'*%+"-6"8.$7%*.# $$#;$%"8%*8"#$-& #$.7' #+$%'&-$."#&'+<#+"6$;$$2"&-"'2$.#+$-$$-& A*$'#& $2&#$-#2".",."2+B #+$1*-,7$#&

%"'$#'*22.#+&'%#$#&#+"#"#;$'#&#%"89;$#+$6"8*$,&6$& #+$-$$-&A*$'#&5<+&%+#+$%*.# $$$$-'#;$2"&-

$.%#."58$".$-%*'$8 .#+$.$'2-$#3-$ $-"#+"'

2&#$-##+$'#"#*#.92.6&'&'%#"&$-&)$%#&&6%"-6 $<+&%+.$"-"'*-$.(3 D /# ,,''(/0.' 1'! (# (3+$ "7*# $$ 2"9";8$ *-$. #+&' %# & #+$ '*&#' $?# +$.$& " #$.

7$#&$-'+"88;$%72*#$-"' 88<'(3 ???

???

&6 '*&#'3 ???

????

???

3B3 %

."-$%8"."#.9-$%.$$"-%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ 333 # ;#"& " -$%8"."#.9 -$%.$$ . .-$.5 <+$.$ %'$A*$#&"8 .$8&$ &'

2."9$- ???

????

???E D /# ,,''(/0.' 1'! (# (333 +$"7*# $$2"9";8$*-$.#+&'%#&#+$'*&#'$?#+$.$&" #$.

7$#&$-'+"88;$%72*#$-"' 88<'(3 ???

???

."-$%8"."#.9-$%.$$"-%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ 333 # ;#"& " -$%8"."#.9 -$%.$$ . .-$.5 <+$.$ %'$A*$#&"8 .$8&$ &'

2."9$- ???

????

???

"%%.-&,##+$"7*#"#<+&%+#+$.$8&$ '*,+#&'6"8*$- &#+$28"&#.7$7."-*7 "22$"8 6 ,!/(('(( ,$ #('($ !$'(3'*&#'

.#+$2''$''& 8"-5+*'$'"-,".-$'333"%%.-&,##+$6"8*$

#+$'*;1$%#7"##$.G"-'*%+6"8*$'+"88;$-$$7$-#;$3 @+$.$#+$'*;1$%#7"##$.&'8"-"-3 ???

????

???

$ .+*'$'"-,".-$'3<+$.$#+$'*;1$%#7"##$.&'" +*'$.,".-$333"%%.-&,##+$7".>$#6"8*$ #+$+*'$.,".-$E &' %#$#& #+$.$ .$&'#+"#<+$.$"-$%8"."#.9-$%.$$ '$$>&,%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ 2''$''&&''*,+#5#+$ $$&'#;$2"&- #+$"7*#"#<+&%+#+$.$8&$ '*,+#&'6"8*$-&#+$28"&#5."8#$."#&6$895 <+$.$#+$2''$''&'*,+#&' "+*'$5&#<*8-;$"'2$.#+$7".>$# 6"8*$ #+$+*'$&#$.7' '*;3%8"*'$$ %8"*'$6 )$%#& #+$ %# $#+$2&#$-#<+"#+"';$$+$8-&2".",."2+: #+$ 1*-,7$#&

%"'$'*2."5##+$ 88<&,$

$%#(3

" ! $ H$".$-%*'$8 .#+$.$'2-$#'#+$.$ .$%#$-$-#+"# #+*' &# &' "%#*"889 #+$ '#"#*#.9 2.6&'&' <+&%+ "#*."889 $$- # ;$

88<$-"-%'$A*$#895<&#+#+$2$#&#&$.&+&'<28"&#+"6&, ,&6$#+$6"8*$ #+$+*'$#+"#+$&''$$>&,2''$''& 5#;$D7.$ #+" '%..$E5&#<*8-#;$#+$"7*# 'B5 5

C3#+"#<"'

7$#&$-"'#+$6"8*$ #+$2.2$.#9&#+$$?%+",$-$$-&A*$'#&& #+$2.$'$#%"'$#+"#<*8-;$"228&%";8$5;*#& "%#&#$.7' )$%#& &6% #+$%# 5&#<*8-;$#+$6"8*$ #+$2.2$.#9"',&6$& #+$28"&##+"#<*8-"2289 .$;*##"858$".$-%*'$8 .#+$2$#&#&$.'5<+&8$.$2$"#&, <+"#+$+"-".,*$-$".8&$.'*;7&##$-5 *.#+$.".,*$-#+"#& $6$#*"889#+&'

%*.#",.$$'<&#+#+$%#$#& #+$8$".$-%*'$8 .#+$.$'2-$#'5 &#<*8-#"%%$2#=#+$&-$ &&#$6"8*$=,&6$;9#+$2$#&#&$.'&#+$ 28"&#5<+&%+;6&*'89&'""22.?&7"#&5#.-$.#+$%*.# $$#;$ 2"&- "%%.-&,895 &$ #+$ 6"8*$ D7.$ #+" ' %..$E5 "- %'$A*$#89&#<*8-"%#*"889;$#+$6"8*$'+<&#+$$?%+",$-$$- &#'$8 #+"#<*8-$$-#;$#">$&#%'&-$."#&

33 "6&,%'&-$.$-#+$".,*7$#'5&792&&5#+&'2$#&#& %"#'*%%$$-$?%$2###+$$?#$##+"#&#<*8-#;$;#+#+$2.2$.#&$' &A*$'#&#+"#<*8-;$'*;1$%#7"##$. %*.# $$ !;*#89 #+$2.2$.#9#+$2''$''& <+&%++"';$$'*,+#;9#+$2$#&#&$.3 28"&#&

' +$A*$'#&#+$.$ .$<*8-;$"'#<+$#+$.&#<*8-;$'*;3 %8"*'$% 8"*'$&6 )$%#& #+$%##+"#<*8-;$"228&%";8$5.

'*;3%8"*'$$ 8"*'$6 #+$'"&-2.6&'& 792&&5&#<*8-"%#*"889;$#+$8"##$."-##+$

.7$.5;$%"*'$'*;3%8"*'$%8"9'-<",$$."82.2'&#& %*.# $$ 2"9";8$&%"'$"-$%8"."#.9-$%.$$<&#+%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ &'2."9$- .5 <+$.$"' '*;3%8"*'$ $ %8"*'$ 6 &' '2$%& &% # " %"'$ <+$.$ #+$ 2''$''& "+*'$.",".-$&''*,+# ;6&*'89&#+$2.$'$#%"'$&#;$&,"+*'$#+$2''$''&

<+&%+&''*,+#;9#+$2$#&#&$.328"&#&

'&#+$&.'*&#5&#<*8-;$#+$ 7".>$#6"8*$ #+$+*'$#+"#<*8-,6$.2"97$# %*.# $$

%*.'$5#+$'*&#&'"8'$'$$>&,"-$%8"."#.9-$%.$$<&#+ "%'$A*$#&"8.$8&$ 2''$''& #+$'*&#2.2$.#9 '$A*$#895#+$2$#&#&&$''$%$&'-&'7&''$-5;*#<&#+&# +$8-#+"#%*.# $$ <*8-;$2"9";8$89A*"#+$+*'$#+"##+$ 2$#&#&$.328"&#&

''$$>'2''$''&&#+$28"&#5"-##+$+*'$A*" <+&%+'&7289"-$%.$$ -$%8"."#&&''*,+# <$6$.5-",.$$<&#+#+$8$".$-%*'$8 .#+$2$#&#&$.'

#+"#<&#+'2$%& &%6"8*$ #+$'*&#2.2$.#9#+"#+$'$$>'2''$''&

+"6&,;$$,&6$&#+$28"&#5#+$.#+"'#"#&,#+"#&'&'D7.$#+" ' %..$E5&#<*8-;$#+$7".>$#6"8*$"'&'"''$''$-;$ .$#+$#.&"8%*.##+"# <*8--$#$.7&$#+$%*.# $$#;$2"&-5 '*%+6"8*$ ' .$,".-' #+$ %#$#& #+$ 8$".$- %*'$8 . #+$ 2$#&#&$.'#+"#&#<*8-;$#+$6"8*$-$%8".$-&#+$$?%+",$-$$-#+"# <*8-"22895%"#",.$$<&#+#+"#%#$#&;$%"*'$#+$2$#&#&$.3 28"&#&

'#+$7'$86$'5&#+$28"&#5+"6$"''$''$-#+$6"8*$ #+$2.2$.#9

".7.$#+"<+"#&''+<&#+$$?%+",$-$$-5#+$-&

$.$%$;$&,

;6&*'89"#8$"'# ' 3 F8"%' '$A*$#895<&#+'*;3%8"*'$$ %8"*'$6 )$%#&

#+$%# '#&2*8"#&,#+"#&#<*8-;$#+$7".>$#6"8*$ #+$2.2$.#9 &A*$'#&5<+&%+%*.# $$ <*8-$$-#;$%"8%*8"#$-"- 2"&-5#+$#.&"8%*.#&'-&.$%#$-##">$$6&-$%$#+"#&''*$ .7;#+#+$ 2".#&$'5"-#%7$#"%%8*'&"'.$,".-'#+$7".>$#6"8*$ #+$ 2.2$.#9"'#+$-"#$ #+$ &8&, #+$'*&#5"-#+$.$"

#$.-&.$%##+$ 2$#&#&$.328"&#&

'#2"9%*.# $$ '*%+6"8*$5<&#+&"

'2$%& &$-2$.&- +$2$#&#&&'-&'2'$- "'";6$

6%,".,C-&$'+ 2 + ' '!!'('$3(/'4 5'( + ' '!!'/!.' 5'(