High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/88/2020dismissed

Abhishek Kalia v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-12-05Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj9 pages

"!# $ %!& !

' ( "

#$%&'( )*+,("(*#&#" -"

! )

*!+ !!,(-. %! !+ /// "(*#&#" -" .

* ''

. 5. ( %( &%60(&

..#!!( % ..7' & 5!- ' + 8! (.# ''

' !#7 ( &%60(& ..#!!( % ..7' & 5!- '

&# ( %(+#7 % !' 5 7'#5 (!(! !''!.( %!% !- ' ,9-!,.!

(.#7 9!(%!& .#

(' ! 7 7 .

(.#7 +# #7

..# 7 !..#!!(( &%60(& % ..7' & 5!- ' +#7 ' !9# (#%%! !!'! % ( & . ( (+ -9 % #7 7( & .# , '!

9(+( &%60(& ..#!!( % ..7' & 5!- ' . ( (+

* '! !- ' % (7'#5 5 !(! ( ( :1+6+410; '( & ! ( (( + $ #(5,

!((,9!&!(!( (:0+01+4103'(& ! (*,

!((..'

.7'

% (& !# (!.

:<1 !+ + ( ( .7'

(7(+ !% %.

% . ! ' ! 7 =( 7!!5 9 !' ( +4 0>+0+410>, 9-!, 7 !7

(.!( '

. 9 % 7 ( !% '

9( 5, !' ( +4 (5( +110>( (40+;+410>!5 !(# (!

:62!+9+>00,:>< ?0@,:66 ( :4: 9!5 !(

.$ ,$.

!02, !((,5 ! ( %7 &77!+ - 5 55 .& - 5 . !#5 &, 9-!,%# ( %% .

5(# (!.

:4:,:>< ?0@,:62,>00, :66 # ( ( # 79!( ( (.

# (!

06:!+ +9% (# (!.

<;3 (<12 5 ' ! ('! +55!-(% 7,' ! ('! % ('! ' # (!.

<34!+ +++ * * 61<0 ( * * :<134 4102%! '!& 5%!B# 5%

B# +.#!

-(!(!( (00+01+4106..'

% ( (B#( + ' ! !% !% (' # (!$.

:<1 !+ +%! 5.

5 "C , 7 (! (%!5- 5% .7'

5 7 ( '! +8! (*, !((-(!(!( (:0+01+4103..'

/ 7B# 9% 7 &"C (% !

9 7 # (.

( 7B#!' ( +:! (+55!-(&

7, '!%!!( '' # (!.

:<1?0@!+ + %! ! ((( +$ #(5, !((7'#5 5 !(!

( (:0+01+4103+ 8! (''

..'

'' % (& !' ( +4 (:-(7'#5 (!(!( (:1+6+410;+55!-( & 7 !?# (@''!.( &9&% % '! !- ' + 8! (.# !-7

((

! (''

9 # (-!

9 ( %.

(.!.#7 .% .9! 5 &..'

'' % ( &!' ( +4 (:&!-! 5 9

! (!(!'(&

! ( *, !((+ #7 -(

& ! 9 7 !7 (.!( 9 ! (!' ( +4+$% ( % (%!- # 5 ! ('! ,9!

5 '!

5 %% .# (!.

:62 (:66 9!

& !(! #7 ! (%7 &77!+ #7 (#! 5 - 5

5 '!

5 D#

#%!' ( +49! # ( ( . 79! ( (& - 5 55 .&+ #

&, .

# (!.

06:!+ +9% &%! %% .# (!.

<;3 (<12 +#7 !% ! ! ('! ''!.(

&9&%% 5 * * 61<0 4102 ( * * :<134 %! '!& 5%!B# 5% (% ( 5

!'!.# #% '!.% 9, B#(

-(!(!( (00+01+4106+#7 %!7 %.

(.!.#7 .% ., ''! !' ( +4(7( % 7 (7 .#!

( # (!' ( +:

9! %!'!.( 5# (!.

:<1!+ ++# #7

!% (' # (!.

:<1!+ +9.9(# & ..'

(& ! (*, !((,9!-( -9% !(!( (00+01+4106% E 5#!

%!7 (

9' , ( % (%!- # ( !(!

'# ! (% ! % . ( #.77

( %% .# (!.

0;;,41: (400 ( . &9! %!

5 7%! (5 5% .7'

5 ' ! (% !+ #

&, % (# (!.

:<1 !+ +9..'

(& ! (*, !((+# #7

! (''

7! &% ( ''!. %.

(.!.#7 .% . ( 9''

. (!-!( 7 ( ( !(!'(& ! (*, !((-(!(!

( (:1+6+410;+ # %#!

!#7 % ( 5% ''

! (*.# ( -..'

% (# (!

:<1!+ +7! & % !(!'(& 5 #!

( (00+01+4106-(9. 9B#(,

&# # &% 9+#7 . .'

5 7(5 ! ('! 9! % (%!- # ( .#% 7 D.'

%% . # (!.

<;3 (<12 ,! %% .9!( (& - 5 55 .& % ( !% ! 9B#(& + #7 $.

0;; 9''

. 7(

% 7 +%#!

!#7 +4( 7( 7 # (!.

02<!+ +%! ! (*, !(( 5 !# 9B#(& 5 #!

, % 7 7(&!' ( +49'!-(+#

#7 7'#5 (!(!(!- (+ -!( ! (.# ! 5 ( -5 !#5 !.!(.!%#

&+ - 5'!#( !.!(, % ( C#

(. % .

!-!& - -( ! - # !&'!- % $.

:<1!+ + ( %$.

0;>!+ +!! - ( 7!!'!(#.(# (!)

% !

( "

!% ! !)

(

* )

(* +(

'($ * )

(

)

! +( *

+( ,-

!! "

)(

! "

(

& "

)(

/("

* ! ! (

1 (

2 F0;>+ !.# %!.

9%# # ! &% '# .!- ,%!%% .5 '# .C# . (%!%% . ! (.#7 5- -( .+ ?0@#!

.5 = .

?@?@% &%% .'# # (!.

064 033? .

#-@% ( (?<>%0321@,!

?@% & 7 %,!

.77 ,#.%% .,!

?@% &.!7 . '!.& .77 #.%% .,D.'

.7'

9! 5% '# .!- . .! (!

%7 !'# .!- 97(7 ! - & #!( G ?@?@% &%% .'# # (! &% %

9 5.

( (?<>%0321@, 7 &,.

0;: 0;2 ? .

#-@,0;;,411,41> 400? .

#-@ (443,9 #.%% .

5( - .77

( ,! ! , &'!.( 5 &#!

?@% &%% . (.!( .

<2:,! '# # (!.

<60,.

<6>!.

<62,% ((, 9 #.%% .

5( - .77

(

1 !'.

%(.#7 '!(#.(!5- -( . '!.( 5 &#!

?@% & .!7 . '!.& .77 , !

.77 , ! 7 %, &%% .'.%( #

#?@!# .

#?@,D.'

.7'

9! 5 #!

,!%7 !#!

9. #!

#!( + ?4@A!.7'

7(&'# .!- # (!

# ?@ % # .

?0@ & # ! & 9. (7 ! - & #!( 7& !(! 9 (!9 % .7'

( (.'&%#.!(! #!

G (#' !.'

& #!

, %#!

!'!.( 5

.7'

) !-(( #.9 (!9

!(!(%

! #!

%%! . . .

#((+ ?:@ .

#?@%# .

?0@, !7H#!

H7 - ,

- #!!7 #!

, ( .

#( !# . # (&!

# (! ! , !- . !$ .

%(.

!(& .

'#!'% .

+ ?<@ ! '#!'%.

#?@%# .

?0@,#!

(7( #!( #!

9.'' !( ! & %!7 '' (.!! .%#.%!7!#!

.%- #!

%!79(.! '' !( ! &

, '! .' #!

- 5!( !&!5 .- C#!(.

9 9 . C#!(.

#.- #!

# ) !-((

?@9!'' 7! #!

, ''

% %!!C#!(.

9.#.#!

(7( #!( G ?@9!'' - ( - ##!

,#. #!

(7( #!( - ! - # #!

..!( 5 #!% .!'!.( 5 . .

9 9. %% .

5( - .77

(+I

'!# # !&'!- %$.

0;>!+ + 9# (7 .

! 85 #! .

'!- 9. %#!. ( 9'!

?0@$.

0;>?0@?@( 9 %% .# (!

064 033 , 7 !

.77 #.%% . ( % &.!7 . '!.& .77 #.%% .+ $%!$.

0;>?0@?@. .! (, 7'!

%% .'# 7 (! .77

( ! &'!.( 5 &.#!

+ $.

:<1 !+ + '!.! '!.(#! %

9( %! '!.# %%% .# (!$.

0;>!+ +%!.

9%#

# ! &+ ' ! -($.

:<1!+ +'!7! & '!7 % (% (%!- #.7'

7 (% !,9-!,

5 9! # ( ( . 9B#(& +.#!

B#( & - 5 '9! # (! .

<34 !+ ++ 5!( %(%! - 5 '!- %$.

0;>!+ + ($.

:<1 !+ +! ! &(%%! %!79 .

((& ! ( .# !+8(5 5% & - %

7 B#( ( . # !B# 5!( %!

- 5 # !&'9!# (!$.

0;>!+ ++$.

0;>?0@?@ !+ +( 9 %% ..77

((#! 5 .#!

'!.( 5+ E $#'!7#!

! "# $%%& ( -9 5#5#( $.

:<1, .#!

# ( 7 .7'

!5!( 5 .77 % %% .!%!!( $.

2 0;>?0@?@ .

. ( (& 9!(E.#!

%%'

D'( ! %C# .E+9 #..#!9

&% ! %C# .!B#! ( -!&.+ .#!

B#( .#! ( %C# . ( #'!- #%'!.% 9+# 7

#%%. #5 !!- . .

# ( .77

( .

7 5 7 %! '!.( 5# (!

:<1!+ ++ 5 . (! !5#7 !(&.# %!

! - 9

(, #!

% '

7'#5 (!(! ( (:1+6+410;,'(& ! ((( +$ #(5, !(( #%%! %!7

5 & ( !#

& '!

' !&(7(+ "(*#&#" -"

) 3(

#.& A !' 5J! () J A ! '!

) J