Subhash Chand @ Subhash Chander v. State Of Haryana & ANR
!"
#$# %&''(!)!"*#+
,-./%)/ /%"01,-/%)/ /%"0'2 334!(%"& 5'2)-) ,&%&' %26%"%%"0%"&/'2 ')3"0'"&)
2')'"&* 25!72%8,!"9/:0;(%&' 2&/'%334!(%"& 2"7-2!&&%4:004 : %26%"%<!&/ 2%"=/%"7/%2: : %26%"%
/' 32%6'2 !" &/' 32')'"& 2';!'< %334!(%&!" !) 2 80!!(%&!" 20'2 0%&'0 3%))'0 .6 &/!) -2& </!4'
0!)3)!"9.-"(/%33'%4);!0'(88"20'23%))'0!" #>
%"0%<%20!"9(83'")%&!"&&/'8!"&'28)20'23%))'0 .6 -2& !" !;!4 33'%4 # $ >
:"$$:
%2!)!"9-&)%8'%(?-!)!&!"4"9<!&/&/'';!'<334!(%&!":&/' %334!(%"&/%)%4)!4'0%334!(%&!")''7!"9("0"%&!"0'4%6+ 0%6)!"!4!"9&/'2' '4%6334!(%&!"
&'2/'%2!"94'%2"'0(-")'42&/'3%2&!')%"0(")!0'2!"9 &/'=-098'"&) ">.4'&/',-32'8' -2&!">
!;!4 #@$%"0 !" #$%
!;!4 $: 0'4%6 + 0%6) !" !4!"9 &/' ';!'< 334!(%&!" !) ("0"'0
<';'2: 2 &/' 3'2!0 0'4%6 !" !4!"9 &/' ';!'< 334!(%&!":&/'%334!(%"&))/%44"&.''"&!&4'0&!"&'2')&"&/''"/%"('0 (83'")%&!":!%"6
)&%"0)0!)3)'0 ';!'<334!(%&!"
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
44'(&2:&/'4%"0<"'2)!4'0.='(&!"):</!(/<'2'2''22'0&&/' 4'%2"'02''2'"('(-2& /'4'%2"'0(-2&.'4<0!)8!))'0&/'2''2'"(' 3'&!&!") ;!0' %<%20 0%&'0 $@: </!(/ <%) !83-9"'0 .6 &/' 4%"0<"'2).'2'&/!)(-2& /!) -2&0!)3)'0.-"(/%33'%4)
@ ;!0'(88"20'23%))'0!" &
(%)'
)-32% %"0-3/'40&/'%<%20&/' 44'(&2%))'))!"9(83'")%&!"1 @@::C3'2%(2'2&/'4%"0-3&&/'0'3&/&<%(2')",%!0" !"0%0:,%!0"6'3%))2%0%"0 %!2-87!"7!"04%"0%"0 %))'))'0&/'8%27'&;%4-'&/'%(?-!2'04%"01#:$:C3'2%(2' 2&/'4%"0.'6"0&/%& ,8'&/'4%"0<"'2)%332%(/'0 ">.4'&/',-32'8'
-2&" (%)' )-32% : -2&'"/%"('0&/'
(83'")%&!"2&/'4%"0%(?-!2'0;!0')%8'"&!!(%&!" /'2'%&'2: )8' &/'2 4%"0<"'2) !4'0 ,3'(!%4 A'%;' '&!&!"
!;!4 @
$$' !
(/%44'"9!"9&/'20'20%&'03%))'0!"
(%)' )-32% :</!(/<%)9&0!)8!))'0%) <!&/02%<""@ :&'"%.4'&/'8&%332%(/&/!) -2&&(4%!8 )%8'2'4!':%) 32!2&&/%& ;!0''%24!'2=-098'"&!" (%)'
)-32% :(83'")%&!"/%0.''"!"(2'%)'0.6 -2& A'%2"'0(-")'42&/'%334!(%"&))-.8!&&'0&/%&&/')!"(' &/'24%"0<"'2)/%;'.''"92%"&'0/!9/'2(83'")%&!".6 ">.4'&/'
,-32'8' -2&:&/'20'23%))'0.6&/!) -2&8%6.'80!!'0&&/'
'D&'"&&/%&&/'%334!(%"&)8%6.'%<%20'0)%8'%8-"&(83'")%&!" /'%334!(%"&)(%"%332%(/ -2&%)<'44.6!4!"9 ,3'(!%4 A'%;' '&!&!": /<';'2: ,3'(!%4 A'%;' '&!&!") !4'0 %&'2 0'(!)!" !" (%)' )-32% : <'2' <!&/02%<" & '"%.4' &/' 4%"0<"'2)&%332%(/&/!) -2&&(4%!8)%8'%8-"&(83'")%&!"
'"(':&/'%334!(%"&).'%4)%<%20'0)%8'%8-"&(83'")%&!"
# "&/'&/'2/%"04'%2"'0(-")'42&/',&%&'(-40"& 0!)3-&'&/'("&'"&!"2%!)'0.64'%2"'0(-")'42&/'4%"0<"'2<!&/ 2'9%20&'"/%"('8'"&(83'")%&!"2&/'%(?-!2'04%"0.6 ">.4'
&/',-32'8' -2& <';'2:/')-.8!&&'0&/%&8'2'46.'(%-)'!")8' &/'2 (%)'): ">.4' &/' ,-32'8' -2& /%0 %<%20'0 /!9/'2 (83'")%&!":<!44"&%92-"0&(4%!8&/')%8'%8-"&.6!4!"9&/' 2';!'<%334!(%&!" &'2/'%2!"94'%2"'0(-")'42&/'3%2&!')%"0(")!0'2!"9 &/'%2')%!0%(&):!"863!"!":&/'20'23%))'0.6&/!) -2&"
!" &/' (%)' &/' %334!(%"&)C4%"0<"'2) 0')'2;') & .' 80!!'0&&/''D&'"&&/%&&/'%334!(%"&)C4%"0<"'2))/%44.''"&!&4'0& (83'")%&!"!"&'28)=-098'"& -2&!"
(%)' )-32% '(/"!(%4!&!'))/-40"&(8'!"&/'<%6 0!"9)-.)&%"&!%4=-)&!('2&/'3-23)'2''2'"('(%".'8%0'& ( ) * $ ,
+@
<';'2:&/'%334!(%"&))/%44"&.''"&!&4'0&!"&'2')&2&/'3'2!0 0'4%6!"!4!"9&/'';!'<%334!(%&!" 20'2'0%((20!"946 /'2';!'<%334!(%&!")&%"0)0!)3)'0
, A
#+
E/'&/'2)3'%7!"9C2'%)"'0* ')C E/'&/'22'32&%.4'* ')C