← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/66/2018disposed of

Sukhbir Singh And Other v. State Of Haryana And Another

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages



      

 

!"#$$ % &'( )(*!+!",#- ./012!3.!"41&")'1(3+  556!*&"'+ 7+ .'&'( &38&"&&")&"'1(3  (+5")("'+  

    3(+("', 3./3(+116&9&':)7*&'(: 3'1(&556!*&"'+ 3"0/3!''&6:))!'!"&6)7*&'(("(3&6&38&"&     1(53&8(3!"'1(53(+("'3(7!(9&556!*&'!"!+ 3;)!

!*&'!"

3)(3)&'()

<5&++()28'1!+ /3'91!6()!+5+!"4 2/"*1

&55(&6+7!)(*;;"3)(35&++()!"<< %

   





   &")&9&3)!"4 *;5("+&'!"''1(;!"'(3;+ 3)(35&++()28"=26('1(./53(;(

/3'!" !7!655(&6 %  -  

   :"  - -:&3!+!"4/' +&;(&*>/!+!'!" 6"4  9!'1  '1(  (7!(9  556!*&'!":  '1(  &556!*&"'+  1&7(  &6+  !6() &556!*&'!"+((0!"4*")"&'!" )(6&8  )&8+!" !6!"4'1(3( 

  (6&8 '(31(&3!"46(&3"()*/"+(6 3'1(5&3'!(+&")*"+!)(3!"4 '1(?/)4;("'+ "=26('1(./53(;( /3'!"      

            <

   

!7!6  %#-  &")  !"#$%$

  <

 

!7!6 <-:)(6&8  )&8+!" !6!"4'1((7!(9556!*&'!"!+*")"() 9(7(3:  3  '1(  5(3!)    )(6&8  !"  !6!"4  '1(  (7!(9 556!*&'!":'1(&556!*&"'++1&66"'2(("'!'6()'!"'(3(+'"'1(("1&"*() *;5("+&'!":!

&"8

+'&")+)!+5+() (7!(9556!*&'!"

 3!( 68:'1( &*'+ '1(*&+(&3('1&'7!)("'!

!*&'!")&'()

# -:!++/()/")(3.(*'!"% '1(@&")*>/!+!'!"*':$%

3 +13':='1(*'= :'1(.'&'( &38&"&:+/41''&*>/!3(6&")!"7!66&4(+ .!"415/3&:.& !)":&;5/3&:&''&"A1(3&&")A1(3&A1(;&9&'!:!+'3!*' !") 3)(7(65;("'&")/'!6!'!+&'!"'1(3( &+*;;(3*!&6&")3(+!)("'!&6 .(*'3+-:&")$:.& !)"1(+&;(9&+ 669()28"'!

!*&'!")&'()

 :  !++/()  /")(3  .(*'!"     '1(  *'  1(  @&")  *>/!+!'!"

66(*'3

3+13':='1( 66(*'3= :7!)(&9&3)+#:%&")<)&'() $ :&++(++()'1(;&30('7&6/( '1(&*>/!3()6&")B##::  5(3&*3(/5''1()(5'1 '9&*3(+".& !)"!")3&):.& !)"8(5&++ 3&)&")&!3/;0!"0!") 6&")&")B:: 5(3&*3( 3(13!

&") 1&1!6&")!++&'!+ !()9!'1'1(&9&3) '1( 66(*'3:'1(6&")9"(3+

!6()2?(*'!"+:91!*19(3(3( (33()''1(6(&3"()3( (3("*(*/3'1( 6(&3"()*/3'2(69)!+;!++()'1(3( (3("*(5('!'!"+7!)(&9&3))&'()

# - #:91!*19&+!;5/4"()28'1(6&")9"(3+2( 3('1!+*/3'1!+

/3')!+5+() 2/"*1 &55(&6+7!)(*;;"3)(35&++()!"

   



& *&+( +/53& &")/51(6)'1(&9&3) '1(

66(*'3&++(++!"4*;5("+&'!"B##:: 5(3&*3( 3'1(6&")/5' '1()(5'1 '9&*3(+".& !)"!")&):.& !)"8(5&++3&)&") &!3/;0!"0!") 6&")&")&++(++()'1(;&30('7&6/( '1(&*>/!3() 6&")B %:-<: 5(3&*3( 3'1(6&")2(8")'1&' 1(3(& '(3:'1(&556!*&"'+ !6()(7!(9556!*&'!"<-

 !"'1!+ /3'+((0!"43(7!(9 '1(3)(3:19(7(3:'1(+&;(9&+ )!+;!++()" %$   .;(    '1(  6&")9"(3+  &553&*1()  "=26(  '1(  ./53(;(

/3' *1&66("4!"4 '1(  3)(3 )&'() 

<  5&++() 28 '1!+ /3'  !"



   



& *&+( +/53&  "  & *&+(

+/53& :"=26('1(./53(;( /3'("1&"*()'1(*;5("+&'!" 3'1(6&") &*>/!3()7!)(+&;("'!

!*&'!" '(3'1&''1(&556!*&"'+ !6().5(*!&6@(&7(('!'!"

!7!6  #-   -  '     

$    

        

*1&66("4!"4'1(3)(3)&'()

<5&++()!" 

 

 



& *&+( +/53& :91!*19&+4')!+;!++()&+9!'1)3&9""

# :'("&26('1(&556!*&"'+'&553&*1'1!+ /3''*6&!;+&;( 3(6!( :&+53!3''1&'7!)((&36!(3?/)4;("'!"  & *&+( +/53& :

*;5("+&'!"1&)2(("!"*3(&+()28"=26('1(./53(;( /3' @(&3"()*/"+(6 3'1(&556!*&"'++/2;!''()'1&''1(&556!*&"'+ 1&)(&36!(3 !6()3(7!(9&556!*&'!":91!*19&+)!+;!++()28'1!+ /3'"

%$  1(3(& '(3:'1(8 !6().5(*!&6@(&7(('!'!":91!*19&+4'

% )!+;!++()&+9!'1)3&9"'("&26('1(;'&553&*1'1!+ /3' 3'1(+&;( 3(6!(  &+  43&"'()  '  '1( 6&")9"(3+  28 "=26(  '1( ./53(;(  /3'  !"

 &*&+( +/53& ( /3'1(3+/2;!''()'1&')(6&8**/33()!" !6!"4 '1(3(7!(9&556!*&'!"*&""'2(+&!)'2(!"'("'!"&6:&+'1(89(3(2( 3( "=26('1(./53(;( /3'1(+/2;!++!"!+'1&''1(&556!*&"'+2(43&"'() +&;(&;/"' *;5("+&'!"&+1&+2(("43&"'()''1(6&")9"(3+28 "=26('1(./53(;( /3'!" &*&+( +/53&  "'1('1(31&")6(&3"()*/"+(6 3'1(.'&'(*/6)"'

)!+5/'('1(*"'("'!"3&!+()286(&3"()*/"+(6 3'1(6&")9"(3+9!'1 3(4&3)'("1&"*(;("' *;5("+&'!" 3'1(&*>/!3()6&")28"=26('1( ./53(;( /3'9(7(3:1(+/2;!''()'1&'"6!2(3'89&+43&"'()28 "=26('1(./53(;( /3'91!6(5(3;!''!"4'1(&556!*&"'+'9!'1)3&9 .5(*!&6@(&7(('!'!"( /3'1(3+/2;!''()'1&'+(*")3(7!(9&556!*&'!" !+"';&!"'&!"&26(&+'1((&36!(3"(9&+)!+;!++() '(31(&3!"46(&3"()*/"+(6 3'1(5&3'!(+&")*"+!)(3!"4 '1(& 3(+&!) &*'+:!" ;8 5!"!": '1(3)(35&++() 28'1!+  /3'"

<!"'1(*&+( '1(&556!*&"'+)(+(37(+'2(;)!

!()''1( (C'("''1&''1(&556!*&"'++1&662(("'!'6()'*;5("+&'!"!"'(3;+

?/)4;("' "=26('1(./53(;( /3'!" &*&+( +/53& .5(*!&6 @(&7(('!'!"*1&66("4!"4'1(3)(35&++()!" &7/3 '1(&556!*&"'+9&+ 4')!+;!++()&+9!'1)3&9"" # D!'1)3&9&6 .@9!66"')(2&3 '1(&556!*&"'+ 3;*6&!;!"4+&;(&;/"' *;5("+&'!"&+1&+2(("

43&"'()28"=26('1(./53(;( /3'''1(36&")9"(3+ 3;+&;( &*>/!+!'!"(*1"!*&6!'!(++1/6)"'*;(!"'1(9&8 )!"4+/2+'&"'!7( ?/+'!*(3'1(5/35+(3( (3("*(*&"2(;&)(' $($ )

< *    -  .

 $#9(7(3:'1(&556!*&"'+ +1&66"'2(("'!'6()'!"'(3(+' 3'1(5(3!) )(6&8!" !6!"4'1((7!(9 &556!*&'!"9(7(3:'1(&556!*&"'++1&66"'2(("'!'6()'!"'(3(+' 3'1( 5(3!) )(6&8!" !6!"4'1((7!(9&556!*&'!" 3)(3()&**3)!"468 1(3(7!(9&556!*&'!"+'&")+)!+5+() #-  &?(+1!")&6 7+ /)4( D1('1(3+5(&0!"4 3(&+"() , (+  D1('1(33(53'&26( , (+