High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/69/2018disposed of

Jaspal Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages

"#$ %

&'()(*"+"#,$- &+.&/0"#12 ../"*&#' 3+ 0'&'(&45&#&&#)&#'2(4 (+.#)(#'+

4(+(#', 4064(+22/&7&'8)3*&'(84'2(&../"*&#' 4#964 "''&/8))"'"#&/)3*&'((#(4&/&45&#& 2(.4&5(4"#'2(.4(+(#'4(3"(7&../"*&'"#"+4:)""*&'"# 4)(4)&'();.&++()<5'2"+ 64'72"/()"+.+"#1<6#*2 &..(&/+3")(*::#4)(4.&++()"#;;%

&#)&7&4)"#1 *:.(#+&'"#'2":"#'(4:+4)(4.&++()<5#=</('2(06.4(:( 64'

"# "3"/..(&/% -

8#--8&4"+"#16'+&:(&*>6"+"'"#/#17"'2 '2((3"(7../"*&'"#8'2(&../"*&#'2&+&/+"/()&../"*&'"#+((9"#1 *#)#&'"#)(/&5 )&5+"#"/"#1'2(4(

(/&5 '(42(&4"#1/(&4#()*6#+(/4'2(.&4'"(+&#)*#+")(4"#1 '2(?6)1:(#'+#=</('2(06.4(:( 64'"#

;

"3"/! %$- &#) !"#$%$

; !

"3"/!;-8)(/&5 )&5+"#"/"#1'2((3"(7../"*&'"#"+*#)#() 7(3(48 4 '2( .(4") )(/&5 "# "/"#1 '2( (3"(7 ../"*&'"#8'2(&../"*&#'+2&//#'<((#'"'/()'"#'(4(+'#'2((#2&#*() *:.(#+&'"#8"&#5

+'&#)+)"+.+() (3"(7../"*&'"# 4"(/58'2(&*'+'2(*&+(&4('2&'3")(#'""*&'"#)&'() $-8"++6()6#)(40(*'"#%'2(@&#)*>6"+"'"#*'8 % 4 +24'8='2(*'=!8'2(0'&'(&45&#&8+612''&*>6"4(/&#)"#3"//&1(+ 0"#12.64&80&")#8&:.64&8&''&#A2(4&&#)A2(4&A2(:&7&'"8 "+'4"*'

"#)4)(3(/.:(#'&#)6'"/"'"+&'"#'2(4(&+*::(4*"&/&#)4(+")(#'"&/ 0(*'4+-8&#) 80&")#2(+&:(7&+//7()<5#'""*&'"#)&'() 8 "++6() 6#)(4 0(*'"# '2( *' 2( @&#) *>6"+"'"#

//(*'4 4+24'8='2( //(*'4=!83")(&7&4)+$8%&#);)&'() 8&++(++()'2(:&49('3&/6('2(&*>6"4()/&#)B$$88 .(4&*4(6.''2()(.'2'7&*4(+#0&")#"#)4&)80&")#5(.&++ 4&)&#)&"4 6:9"#9"#)/&#)&#)B88 .(4&*4(4(24"

&#) 2&2"/&#) "++&'"+"()7"'2'2(&7&4)'2( //(*'48'2(/&#)7#(4+ "/()<?(*'"#+872"*27(4(4((44()''2(/(&4#()4((4(#*(*64'2( /(&4#()*64'<(/7)"+:"++()'2(4((4(#*(.('"'"#+3")(&7&4))&'()

$ -$872"*27&+":.61#()<5'2(/&#)7#(4+<(4('2"+*64'2"+

64')"+.+()<6#*2&..(&/+3")(*::#4)(4.&++()"#

& *&+( +6.4&!&#)6.2(/)'2(&7&4)'2(

//(*'4&++(++"#1*:.(#+&'"#B$$88 .(4&*4(4'2(/&#)6.' '2()(.'2'7&*4(+#0&")#"#)&)80&")#5(.&++4&)&#) &"4 6:9"#9"#)/&#)&#)&++(++()'2(:&49('3&/6('2(&*>6"4() /&#)B%8-;8 .(4&*4(4'2(/&#)<(5#)'2&' 2(4(&'(48'2(&../"*&#'"/()(3"(7../"*&'"#;

"#'2"+ 64'+((9"#14(3"(7'2(4)(4827(3(48'2(+&:(7&+ )"+:"++()#% 0:( '2( /&#)7#(4+ &..4&*2() #=</( '2( 06.4(:(

64' *2&//(#1"#1 '2( 4)(4 )&'() ; .&++() <5 '2"+ 64' "#

& *&+( +6.4&! # & *&+(

+6.4&!8#=</('2(06.4(:( 64'(#2&#*()'2(*:.(#+&'"#4'2(/&#) &*>6"4()3")(+&:(#'""*&'"# '(4'2&''2(&../"*&#'"/()0.(*"&/@(&3(('"'"#

"3"/! $- - '

*2&//(#1"#1'2(4)(4)&'();.&++()"#

& *&+( +6.4&!872"*27&+1')"+:"++()&+7"'2)4&7## $8'(#&</('2(&../"*&#''&..4&*2'2"+ 64''*/&":+&:( 4(/"(8&+.4"4''2&'3")((&4/"(4?6)1:(#'"# & *&+( +6.4&!8 *:.(#+&'"#2&)<((#"#*4(&+()<5#=</('2(06.4(:( 64' @(&4#()*6#+(/4'2(&../"*&#'+6<:"''()'2&''2(&../"*&#' 2&)(&4/"(4"/()4(3"(7&../"*&'"#872"*27&+)"+:"++()<5'2"+ 64'# % 2(4(&'(48 2( "/() 0.(*"&/ @(&3( ('"'"#8 72"*2 7&+ 1'

% )"+:"++()&+7"'2)4&7#'(#&</(2":'&..4&*2'2"+ 64'4'2(+&:( 4(/"( &+ 14&#'() ' '2( /&#)7#(4+ <5 #=</( '2( 06.4(:( 64' "# &*&+( +6.4&!(64'2(4+6<:"''()'2&')(/&5**644()"#"/"#1 '2(4(3"(7&../"*&'"#*&##'<(+&")'<("#'(#'"#&/8&+2(7&+<(4( #=</('2(06.4(:( 64'2(+6<:"++"#"+'2&''2(&../"*&#'<(14&#'() +&:(&:6#'*:.(#+&'"#&+2&+<((#14&#'()''2(/&#)7#(4+<5 #=</('2(06.4(:( 64'"# &*&+( +6.4&! #'2('2(42&#)/(&4#()*6#+(/4'2(0'&'(*6/)#' )"+.6'('2(*#'(#'"#4&"+()<5/(&4#()*6#+(/4'2(&../"*&#'7"'2 4(1&4)'(#2&#*(:(#'*:.(#+&'"#4'2(&*>6"4()/&#)<5#=</('2( 06.4(:( 64'7(3(482(+6<:"''()'2&'#/"<(4'57&+14&#'()<5 #=</('2(06.4(:( 64'72"/(.(4:"''"#1'2(&../"*&#''7"'2)4&7 0.

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

4(:( 64'''2(4/&#)7#(4+4:+&:(&*>6"+"'"# (*2#"*&/"'"(++26/)#'*:("#'2(7&5)"#1+6<+'&#'"3(?6+'"*(4 '2(.64.

; - !0

$ 7(3(48'2(&../"*&#'+2&//#'<( (#'"'/()'"#'(4(+'4'2(.(4"))(/&5"#"/"#1'2((3"(7&../"*&'"# 7(3(48'2(&../"*&#'+2&//#'<((#'"'/()'"#'(4(+'4'2(.(4") )(/&5"#"/"#1'2((3"(7&../"*&'"# 4)(4()&**4)"#1/5 2(4(3"(7&../"*&'"#+'&#)+)"+.+() $- &?(+2"#)&/!

3+ 6)1( D2('2(4+.(&9"#1 4(&+#() ,

(+ D2('2(44(.4'&</( ,