Narinder Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others



















 




 




  



































 !"
#$
"%&'&#() *+ + ,  -&(."-
/&(01





















++++++"!&!&#("- 2"-'3'

/! !"
#$
3(4 5
(.
#!1"-'

++++++"'6#(."(!'

  )

 7 8
+
/
 /
/
 -"'"(!)



-+
+/+
 1"9:
.;#% !"
$#-
!1"
6"!&!&#("-+ -+
 01 ;
#"9:


3(4 5+

















<<<<<  /
/

+

- 9 +
1"
6-"'"(!
6"!&!&#(
1 '
5""(
$&9".
3(."-
-!&%9"'
,=
#$
!1"

#('!&!3!&#(
#$
(.&
'"">&(0
&''3 (%"
#$

?-&!
&(
!1"
( !3-"
#$

 $#-
@3 '1&(0
!1"
&A630(".
#-."-
. !".
 + *

(("B3-"
C ?1"-"5D
!1"
-A'
8&%"(%"
#$
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
? '
'3'6"(.".
5D
-"'6#(."(! #+
'
?"99
'
!1"
&A630(".
#-."-
. !".
 

(("B3-"
 ?1"-"5D
!1"
66" 9
$&9".
5D
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
? '
.&'A&''".
5D
-"'6#(."(! #++ + 8" -(".
%#3('"9
66" -&(0
#(
5"1 9$
#$
!1"
6"!&!&#("- '35A&!!".
!1 !
..&!&#( 9
&'!-&%!
 0&'!- !":
 (' :
?1#
&'
!1"
9&%"('&(0 3!1#-&!D:
1 .
'3'6"(.".
!1"
9&%"(%"
#$
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
#(
 + *
#(9D #(
!1"
0-#3(.
!1 !
/"(&#-
/36"-&(!"(."(!
#$
#9&%":
 ('
1 .
-"6#-!". !1 !
*
% '"'
?"-"
6"(.&(0
0 &('!
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
?1&%1
?"-"
3(."-
















&(;"'!&0 !&#(+ + "
'35A&!!".
!1 !

6"-3' 9
#$
!1"
#-."-
?#39.
'1#?
!1 !
(# ' !&'$ %!&#(
1 '
5""(
-"%#-.".
5D
..&!&#( 9
&'!-&%!
 0&'!- !":
 (' :
'

!#
1#?

0-#3(.
&'
A ."
#3!
$#-
'3'6"('&#(
#$
-A'
9&%"(%"
#$
!1" 6"!&!&#("-+
"
$3-!1"-
'35A&!!".
!1 !
";"(
#!1"-?&'"
9'#
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
1 ' 9-" .D
5""(
%@3&!!".
&(

#3!
#$

% '"'
6"(.&(0
0 &('!
1&A+
8" -(".

%#3('"9
$3-!1"-
%#(!"(.".
!1 !
!1"
% '"'
6"(.&(0
0 &('!
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
.# (#!
-"9 !"
!#
A&'3'"
#$
-A'
#-
% 3'&(0
#$
(D
&(43-D:
(.
- !1"-
-&'"
#3!
#$ $&( (%& 9
.&'63!"'
5"!?""(
!1"
6 -!&"'+
"
$3-!1"-
'35A&!!".
!1 !
!1"
?" 6#( 1"9.
5D
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
? '
63-"9D
$#-
!1"
63-6#'"
#$
'"9$."$"(%"
(. !1"-"$#-"
!1"
"B"-%&'"
#$
6#?"-'
5D
..&!&#( 9
&'!-&%!
 0&'!- !":
 (' :

? '
(#!
&(
%%#-. (%"
?&!1
9 ?+
"
9'#
'35A&!!".
!1 !
";"(
#!1"-?&'"
&!
&'
'"!!9".
6-&(%&69"
#$
9 ?
!1 !
A"-"
6"(."(%D
#$
':
6 -!&%39 -9D
!1#'" -&'&(0
#3!
#$
%#AA"-%& 9
.&'63!"':
% ((#!
5D
&!'"9$
%#('!&!3!"

; 9&. 0-#3(.
$#-
'3'6"('&#(
#-
% (%"99 !&#(
#$
(
-A'
9&%"(%"+

8" -(".
%#3('"9
$3-!1"-
'35A&!!".
!1 !
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
6-"$"--". (
66" 9
0 &('!
!1"
' &.
#-."-:
1#?";"-:
!1"
66"99 !"
3!1#-&!D .&'A&''".
!1"
66" 9
;&."
&A630(".
#-."-
. !".
 

(("B3-"
 
(.

6"-3' 9
#$
!1"
' A"
-";" 9'
!1 !
!1"
' A"
&'
%-D6!&%
(.
(#( '6" >&(0
&(
( !3-"
'
(#
-" '#(
1 '
5""(
''&0(".:
!1"-"$#-":
5#!1
!1" &A630(".
#-."-'
-"
9& 59"
!#
5"
'"!
'&."+
C+

(
!1"
#!1"-
1 (.:
9" -(".
/! !"
%#3('"9
%#39.
(#!
%#(!-#;"-! !1"
$#-"' &.
'35A&''&#('
A ."
5D
9" -(".
%#3('"9
$#-
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
?&!1 -"0 -.
!#
!1"
$ %!
!1 !
A"-"
6"(."(%D
#$
'
"'6"%& 99D
#$
%#AA"-%& 9
















( !3-"
% ((#!
5"%#A"

0-#3(.
$#-
'3'6"('&#(
#-
% (%"99 !&#(
#$
!1" 9&%"(%"+
"
9'#
%#39.
(#!
%#(!-#;"-!
!1"
'35A&''&#(
!1 !
!1"
&A630(". #-."-
6 ''".
5D
!1"
66"99 !"
3!1#-&!D
&'
%-D6!&%
(.

(#('6" >&(0 #-."-:
'
(#
-" '#(
1 '
5""(
''&0(".
!1"-"&(+
,+

$!"-
1" -&(0
9" -(".
%#3('"9
$#-
!1"
6 -!&"':
!1&'
#3-!
&'
#$ !1"
%#('&."-".
;&"?
!1 !
!1"
6-"'"(!
6"!&!&#(
."'"-;"'
!#
5"
99#?".+

6"-3' 9
#$
!1"
#-."-
6 ''".
5D
..&!&#( 9
&'!-&%!
 0&'!- !":
 (' :
?#39.

'1#?
!1 !
&!
? '
#(9D
5"% 3'"
#$
!1"
6"(."(%D
#$
'#A"
'
0 &('!
!1" 6"!&!&#("-:
?1&%1
'
6"-
9" -(".
%#3('"9
$#-
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
6"-! &(
!# $&( (%& 9
.&'63!"'
5"!?""(
!1"
6 -!&"':
!1 !
-A'
9&%"(%"
#$
!1"
6"!&!&#("- 1 '
5""(
'3'6"(.".+
!
&'

'"!!9".
9 ?
!1 !
A"-"
6"(."(%D
#$
 ':

"'6"%& 99D
6"-! &(&(0
!#
%#AA"-%& 9
.&'63!"':
% ((#!
5D
&!'"9$
5"%#A"
0-#3(.
$#-
% (%"99 !&#(
#-
'3'6"('&#(
#$
(
-A'
9&%"(%"
3(9"''
' !&'$ %!&#(
&'
-"%#-.".
5D
!1"
9&%"('&(0
3!1#-&!D
&(
%%#-. (%"
?&!1
9 ? !1 !
!1"
% '"
$ 99'
?&!1&(
(D
#$
!1"
6 - A"!"-'
%#(! &(".
3(."-
/"%!&#(
 #$
!1"
-A'
%!:
*C*+

6 -!
$-#A
!1"
5#;":

6"-3' 9
#$
!1"
#-."-
6 ''". 5D
!1"
66"99 !"
3!1#-&!D
?#39.
9'#
'1#?
!1 !
(#!
";"(

'&(09"
-" '#( 1 '
5""(
''&0(".
5D
!1"
66"99 !"
3!1#-&!D
&(
!1&'
-"0 -.+
+ (
;&"?
#$
!1"
5#;":
!1"
6-"'"(!
?-&!
6"!&!&#(
&'
1"-"5D 99#?".
(.
#-."-
. !".
 + *
6 ''".
5D
..&!&#( 9
&'!-&%!

 0&'!- !":
 ('
8&%"('&(0
3!1#-&!D
(.
#-."-
. !".
  6 ''".
5D
!1"
9" -(".
#AA&''&#("-:
 -&.>#!
&;&'&#(:
 -&.>#!

66"99 !"
3!1#-&!D
-"
1"-"5D
'"!
'&."
(.
!1"
A !!"-
&'
-"A&!!".
!# 9" -(".
&'!-&%!
 0&'!- !":
 (' :
!#
1 ;"

$-"'1
9##>
&(!#
!1"
0-&"; (%"'
















#$
!1"
6"!&!&#("-
(.
!#
6 ''

$-"'1
#-."-
&(
%%#-. (%"
?&!1
9 ?+

1"
$-"'1
#-."-
'1 99
5"
6 ''".
?&!1&(

6"-&#.
#$
!?#
A#(!1'
$-#A !#. D:
?&!1

$-"'1
669&% !&#(
#$
A&(.
(.
3(&($93"(%".
5D
!1"
#-."-' . !".
 + *
6 ''".
5D
..&!&#( 9
&'!-&%!
 0&'!- !":
 ('
(.

 
6 ''".
5D
#AA&''&#("-:
 -&.>#!
&;&'&#(:
 -&.>#!

(.
!1" 6-"'"(!
#-."-
6 ''".
5D
!1&'
#3-!
'
(#
#5'"-; !&#(
1 '
5""(
A ."
5D
!1&' #3-!
#(
!1"
A"-&!'
#$
!1"
% '"+ *+ "".9"''
!#
' D:

'6" >&(0
#-."-
'1 99
5"
6 ''".
&(
%%#-. (%" ?&!1
9 ?
(.
$!"-
0&;&(0
."@3 !"
#66#-!3(&!D
#$
1" -&(0
!#
6"!&!&#("-
#- 1&'
%#3('"9+











 




 



















































*+ + ,  



1"!1"-
'6" >&(0=-" '#(".















)





"'=#




1"!1"-
-"6#-! 59"

)





"'=#