← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/106/2018disposed of

Birkha Since Deceased Thro His Lrs v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages

 

     

 

 !"# $ %&'(') * !+ "#  ,-.% (')'%*'(&.,/0.1*  223 )%!&* 4* 5&%&'%,6%!%%!(%!&.',  '*2!('!&*  

     ,'*'!&+ ,5/,%&5 !0.7 ,8%,& -5 !0.%!(

,9 :%65% ! 7(4)%&'7,&.'%223 )%!&*

,!-/, &&%37(( & !%3(4)%&''!',%3%,6%!%     .'2,%6', !&.'2,'*'!&,'4 ';%223 )%& ! *,<(  )%& ! ,(',(%&'(  =2%**'(>6&. * /,&;. 3'( *2* !0>/!). %22'%3*4 (')<<!,(',2%**'( ! = = $

   





   %!(%;%,( !0 )<2'!*%& !&&.'< !&',<*,(',2%**'(>6!?>3'&.'5/2,'<'

/,& ! 4 322'%3$ #  

   7! #  #7%, * !0/&*%<'%)@/ * & ! 3!0  ; &.  &.'  '4 ';  223 )%& !7  &.'  %223 )%!&*  .%4'  %3*   3'( %223 )%& !*''- !0)!(!%& !('3%6#(%6* ! 3 !0&.','

<23'%( !01* . * *%!%223 )%& !, <23'%( !0&.'3'0%3,'2,'*'!&%& 4'* (')'%*'(%22'33%!& ,-.%7;.( '(!$  # & **&%&'( !&.'

%223 )%& !&.%&&.'(')'%*'(3'&>'. !(' 0.&3'0%3.' ,*

 ,&.','%*!*<'!& !'( !&.'%223 )%& !7&.'%223 )%!&*%,' <23'%('( %* 3'0%3  ,'2,'*'!&%& 4'*    &.'  %,'*% ( (')'%*'(  %22'33%!& ;'4',7 & *<%(')3'%,&.%&&. *,(',*.%33>')!* (','(!36,&.' 2/,2*','2,'*'!&%& !&.'%,'*% ((')'%*'(>','&. * /,& <'!('( <'< 2%,& '*%!!'A'(; &.&.' %223 )%& !  * &%-'!!,'),(

4 3< *)*&%!(*( *2*'( '3%6 &',.'%, !03'%,!'()/!*'3,&.'2%,& '*%!()!* (', !0 &.':/(0<'!&*!?>3'&.'5/2,'<' /,& !      

            =     

4 3  $"#  %!(  !"#$%$

   =  

4 3= #7('3%6#(%6* ! 3 !0&.''4 ';223 )%& ! *)!(!'( ;'4',7  ,  &.'  2', (    ('3%6  !   3 !0  &.'  '4 '; 223 )%& !7&.'%223 )%!&**.%33!&>''!& &3'(& !&','*&!&.''!.%!)'( )<2'!*%& !7 %!6

*&%!(*( *2*'( '4 ';223 )%& !

 , '367&.'%)&*&.')%*'%,'&.%&4 ('!&  )%& !(%&'( "

#7 **/'(/!(',5')& !$&.'1%!()@/ * & !)&7 B$ , *.,&7?&.')&?7&.'5&%&'%,6%!%7*/0.&&%)@/ ,'3%!( !4 33%0'* 5 !0.2/,%75% (!7%<2/,%7%&&%!8.',%%!(8.',%8.'<%;%& 7 *&, )&  !(,('4'32<'!&%!(/& 3 & *%& !&.','%*)<<',) %3%!(,'* ('!& %3 5')&,*#7%!(B75% (!.'*%<';%*33;'(>6!&  )%& !(%&'(  

7  **/'(  /!(',  5')& !     &.'  )&  .'  1%!(  )@/ * & !

"

33')&, ,*.,&7?&.' 33')&,?74 ('%;%,(*"7$%!(=(%&'( B

7%**'**'(&.'<%,-'&4%3/'&.'%)@/ ,'(3%!(C""7

D 2',%),'/2&&.'('2&.&;%),'*!5% (! !(,%(75% (!6'2%** ,%(%!(% , /<- !- !(3%!(%!(C 7

D2',%),','., %!( .%. 3%!( **%& * '(; &.&.'%;%,(&.' 33')&,7&.'3%!(;!',*  3'(>:')& !*7;. ).;',','',,'(&&.'3'%,!'(,'','!)')/,&.' 3'%,!'()/,&>'3;( *< **'(&.','','!)'2'& & !*4 ('%;%,((%&'( #  "7;. ).;%* <2/0!'(>6&.'3%!(;!',*>','&. *)/,&. *

/,&( *2*'(>/!).%22'%3*4 (')<<!,(',2%**'( ! 

   



& )%*' */2,%%!(/2.'3(&.'%;%,(&.'

33')&,%**'** !0)<2'!*%& !C""7

D2',%),',&.'3%!(/2& &.'('2&.&;%),'*!5% (! !(%(75% (!6'2%**,%(%!( % , /<- !- !(3%!(%!(%**'**'(&.'<%,-'&4%3/'&.'%)@/ ,'( 3%!(C$7#=7

D2',%),',&.'3%!(>'6!(&.%& 5<'    &.'  3%!(;!',*  %22,%).'(  !?>3'  &.'  5/2,'<'

/,& ! &)%*' */2,%7!?>3'&.'5/2,'<' /,&'!.%!)'(&.'

)<2'!*%& !,&.'3%!(%)@/ ,'(4 ('*%<'!&  )%& ! .','%&',7  &.'  %223 )%!&*D3%!(;!',*   3'(  52') %3  1'%4' '& & !

4 3" # #'  

$

   ).%33'!0 !0&.',(',(%&'(  =2%**'( !

    

  

& )%*'  */2,%7  ;. ).  ;%*  0&  ( *< **'(  %* ; &.(,%;!!" 7&'!%>3'&.'%223 )%!&*&%22,%).&. * /,&& )3% <*%<','3 '7%*2, ,&&.%&4 (''%,3 ',:/(0<'!& ! &)%*'

*/2,%7)<2'!*%& !.%(>''! !),'%*'(>6!?>3'&.'5/2,'<' /,& 1'%,!'(  )/!*'3  ,  &.'  3%!(;!',*  */>< &&'(  &.%&  &.' %223 )%!&*0&&.'52') %31'%4''& & !( *< **'(%*; &.(,%;!&'!%>3'

$ &.'<&%22,%).&. * /,&,&.'*%<','3 '%*0,%!&'(&&.'3%!(;!',* >6  !?>3'  &.'  5/2,'<'  /,&  !  & )%*'  */2,%  '  /,&.', */>< &&'(&.%&('3%6))/,,'( ! 3 !0&.''4 ';223 )%& !)%!!&>' *% (&>' !&'!& !%37%*&.'6;','>','!?>3'&.'5/2,'<' /,&.'

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

  = !&.')%*'&.'%223 )%!&*D3%!(;!',*('*',4'*&>'<(  '( &  &.'  'A&'!&  &.%&  &.'  %223 )%!&*D  3%!(;!',*  *.%33  >'  '!& &3'(  & )<2'!*%& !  !  &',<*    :/(0<'!&    !?>3'  &.'  5/2,'<'  /,&  !

 &)%*' */2,%52') %31'%4''& & !).%33'!0 !0&.',(',2%**'( !%4/,&.'%223 )%!&*D3%!(;!',*;%*0&( *< **'(%*; &.(,%;!! " E &.(,%;%351; 33!&('>%,&.'%223 )%!&*,<)3% < !0 *%<'%</!&)<2'!*%& !%*.%*>''!0,%!&'(>6!?>3'&.'5/2,'<'

/,&&&.',3%!(;!',*,<*%<'%)@/ * & !;'4',7&.'%223 )%!&* *.%33!&>''!& &3'(& !&','*&,&.'2', (('3%6 ! 3 !0&.''4 '; %223 )%& ! ,(','(%)),( !036

= .','4 ';%223 )%& !*&%!(*( *2*'( "#  %:'*. !(%3 4* /(0' E.'&.',*2'%- !0D,'%*!'( + '*D E.'&.',,'2,&%>3'

+ '*D