High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/65/2018disposed of

Sukhbir Singh And Other v. State Of Haryana And Another

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages

$ $ %&' (')"*"#+,- ./012"3."#41%#(&1'3* 556")%#&* 7* .&%&' %38%#%%#(%#&1'3 '*5#('#&*

3'*'#&+ 3./3'*116%9%&:(7)%&': 3&1'%556")%#&* 3#0/3 "&&%6:(("&"#%6(7)%&''#'3%6%38%#% 1'53%8'3"#&1'53'*'#&3'7"'9%556")%&"#"* 3;("

")%&"# 3('3(%&'( 5%**'(28&1"* /3&91"6'("*5*"#4 2/#)1 %55'%6*7"(');;#3('35%**'("# $

%#(%9%3("#4 );5'#*%&"#&&1';"#&'3;* 3('35%**'(28#<26'&1'./53';'

/3&"# "7"655'%6$ -

:# --:%3"*"#4/& *%;'%)=/"*"&"# 6#4 9"&1 &1' '7"'9 556")%&"#: &1' %556")%#&* 1%7' %6* "6'( %556")%&"#*''0"#4)#(#%&"# ('6%8 (%8*"# "6"#4&1'3'

'6%8 &'31'%3"#46'%3#'()/#*'6 3&1'5%3&"'*%#()#*"('3"#4 &1'>/(4;'#&* #<26'&1'./53';' /3&"#

"7"6! $,- %#( !"#$%$

"7"6! -:('6%8 (%8*"# "6"#4&1''7"'9556")%&"#"*)#(#'( 9'7'3: 3 &1' 5'3"( ('6%8 "# "6"#4 &1' '7"'9 556")%&"#:&1'%556")%#&**1%66#&2''#&"&6'(&"#&'3'*&#&1''#1%#)'( );5'#*%&"#:"

%#8

*&%#(*("*5*'( '7"'9556")%&"# 3"'

68:&1' %)&* &1')%*'%3'&1%&7"('#&"

")%&"#(%&'( ,-:"**/'(/#('3.')&"#$ &1'?%#()=/"*"&"#)&:@$

3 *13&:<&1')&<!:&1'.&%&' %38%#%:*/41&&%)=/"3'6%#("#7"66%4'* ."#415/3%:.% "(#:%;5/3%:%&&%#A1'3%%#(A1'3%A1';%9%&":"*&3")& "#( 3('7'65;'#&%#(/&"6"&"*%&"#&1'3' %*);;'3)"%6%#(3'*"('#&"%6 .')&3*-:%#(@:.% "(#1'*%;'9%* 669'(28#&"

")%&"#(%&'( : "**/'( /#('3 .')&"# &1' )& 1' ?%#( )=/"*"&"#

66')&3

3*13&:<&1' 66')&3<!:7"('%9%3(*,:$%#( (%&'( @:%**'**'(&1';%30'&7%6/' &1'%)=/"3'(6%#(B,,:: 5'3%)3'/5&&1'('5&1 &9%)3'*#.% "(#"#(3%(:.% "(#8'5%** 3%(%#(%"3 /;0"#0"#( 6%#(%#(B:: 5'3%)3' 3'13"

%#( 1%1"6%#("**%&"* "'(9"&1&1'%9%3( &1' 66')&3:&1'6%#(9#'3*

"6'(2>')&"#*:91")19'3'3'

'33'(&&1'6'%3#'(3'

'3'#)')/3&1'

6'%3#'()/3&2'69("*;"**'(&1'3'

'3'#)'5'&"&"#*7"('%9%3((%&'(

, -,:91")19%*";5/4#'(28&1'6%#(9#'3*2' 3'&1"*)/3&1"*

/3&("*5*'( 2/#)1 %55'%6*7"(');;#3('35%**'("#

& )%*' */53%!%#(/51'6(&1'%9%3( &1'

66')&3%**'**"#4);5'#*%&"#B,,:: 5'3%)3' 3&1'6%#(/5& &1'('5&1 &9%)3'*#.% "(#"#(%(:.% "(#8'5%**3%(%#( %"3 /;0"#0"#( 6%#(%#(%**'**'(&1';%30'&7%6/' &1'%)=/"3'( 6%#(B$:- : 5'3%)3' 3&1'6%#(2'8#(&1%& 1'3'% &'3:&1'%556")%#&* "6'('7"'9556")%&"#

"#&1"* /3&*''0"#43'7"'9 &1'3('3:19'7'3:&1'*%;'9%* ("*;"**'(#$@ .;' &1' 6%#(9#'3* %553%)1'( #<26' &1' ./53';'

/3& )1%66'#4"#4 &1' 3('3 (%&'( 5%**'( 28 &1"* /3& "#

& )%*' */53%! # & )%*'

*/53%!:#<26'&1'./53';' /3&'#1%#)'(&1');5'#*%&"# 3&1'6%#( %)=/"3'(7"('*%;'#&"

")%&"# &'3&1%&&1'%556")%#&* "6'(.5')"%6?'%7''&"&"#

"7"6! ,- - '

)1%66'#4"#4&1'3('3(%&'( 5%**'("#

& )%*' */53%!:91")19%*4&("*;"**'(%*9"&1(3%9## ,:&'#%26'&1'%556")%#&*&%553%)1&1"* /3&&)6%";*%;'

3'6"'

:%*53"3&&1%&7"(''%36"'3>/(4;'#&"# & )%*' */53%!:

);5'#*%&"#1%(2''#"#)3'%*'(28#<26'&1'./53';' /3& ?'%3#'()/#*'6 3&1'%556")%#&**/2;"&&'(&1%&&1'%556")%#&* 1%('%36"'3 "6'(3'7"'9%556")%&"#:91")19%*("*;"**'(28&1"* /3&# $@ 1'3'% &'3:&1'8 "6'(.5')"%6?'%7''&"&"#:91")19%*4&

$ ("*;"**'(%*9"&1(3%9#&'#%26'&1';&%553%)1&1"* /3& 3&1'*%;'

3'6"'

%* 43%#&'( & &1' 6%#(9#'3* 28 #<26' &1' ./53';' /3& "# &)%*' */53%!' /3&1'3*/2;"&&'(&1%&('6%8))/33'("# "6"#4 &1'3'7"'9%556")%&"#)%##&2'*%"(&2'"#&'#&"#%6:%*&1'89'3'2' 3'

#<26'&1'./53';' /3&1'*/2;"**"#"*&1%&&1'%556")%#&*2'43%#&'( *%;'%;/#& );5'#*%&"#%*1%*2''#43%#&'(&&1'6%#(9#'3*28 #<26'&1'./53';' /3&"# &)%*' */53%! #&1'&1'31%#(6'%3#'()/#*'6 3&1'.&%&')/6(#& ("*5/&'&1')#&'#&"#3%"*'(286'%3#'()/#*'6 3&1'6%#(9#'3*9"&1 3'4%3(&'#1%#)';'#& );5'#*%&"# 3&1'%)=/"3'(6%#(28#<26'&1'

./53';' /3&9'7'3:1'*/2;"&&'(&1%&#6"2'3&89%*43%#&'(28 #<26'&1'./53';' /3&91"6'5'3;"&&"#4&1'%556")%#&*&9"&1(3%9 .5')"%6?'%7''&"&"#' /3&1'3*/2;"&&'(&1%&*')#(3'7"'9%556")%&"# "*#&;%"#&%"#%26'%*&1''%36"'3#'9%*("*;"**'( &'31'%3"#46'%3#'()/#*'6 3&1'5%3&"'*%#()#*"('3"#4 &1'% 3'*%"( %)&*:"# ;8 5"#"#: &1'3('35%**'( 28&1"* /3&# "#&1')%*' &1'%556")%#&*('*'37'*&2';("

"'(&&1'

'C&'#&&1%&&1'%556")%#&**1%662''#&"&6'(&);5'#*%&"#"#&'3;* >/(4;'#& #<26'&1'./53';' /3&"# &)%*' */53%!.5')"%6 ?'%7''&"&"#)1%66'#4"#4&1'3('35%**'("# %7/3 &1'%556")%#&*9%* 4&("*;"**'(%*9"&1(3%9##,D"&1(3%9%6 .?9"66#&('2%3 &1'%556")%#&* 3;)6%";"#4*%;'%;/#& );5'#*%&"#%*1%*2''# 43%#&'(28#<26'&1'./53';' /3&&&1'36%#(9#'3* 3;*%;'

%)=/"*"&"#')1#")%6"&"'**1/6(#&);'"#&1'9%8 ("#4*/2*&%#&"7'

>/*&")'3&1'5/35*'3'

'3'#)')%#2';%('& $($ )

* - !.

@,9'7'3:&1'%556")%#&* *1%66#&2''#&"&6'(&"#&'3'*& 3&1'5'3"( ('6%8"# "6"#4&1''7"'9 %556")%&"#9'7'3:&1'%556")%#&**1%66#&2''#&"&6'(&"#&'3'*& 3&1'

5'3"( ('6%8"# "6"#4&1''7"'9%556")%&"# 3('3'(%))3("#468 1'3'7"'9%556")%&"#*&%#(*("*5*'( ,- %>'*1"#(%6!

7* /(4' D1'&1'3*5'%0"#4 3'%*#'( +

'* D1'&1'33'53&%26'