High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/160/2018allowed

Subhash Chand v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2018-09-14Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"# $% $ &'(()"*"#+$,

-./0&*0 0&#1 223")&#'

4(5*.* -'&'( &56&#&&#1&#'0(5 (*2#1(#'*

5(*(#'+ 54"75&8-"#90:1;)&'( 5'0(&223")&#' 5#7.5 "''&3:113 : &56&#&<"'0 5 &#=0&#70&5: : &56&#&

0( 25&6(5 "# '0( 25(*(#' 5(;"(< &223")&'"# "* 5 81"")&'"# 51(5 1&'(1

2&**(1 /6 '0"* .5' <0"3( 1"*2*"#9/.#)0&22(&3*;"1()88#51(52&**(1"# $>

&#1&<&51"#9)82(#*&'"#''0(8"#'(58*51(52&**(1 /6 .5' "# ";"3 22(&3

$ % >

:# % %:

&5"*"#9.'*&8(&)?."*"'"#3#9<"'0'0((;"(<223")&'"#:'0( &223")&#'0&*&3*"3(1&223")&'"#*((7"#9)#1#&'"#1(3&6, 1&6*"#"3"#9'0(5( (3&6223")&'"# '(50(&5"#93(&5#(1).#*(35'0(2&5'"(*&#1)#*"1(5"#9 '0(=.198(#'* #>/3('0(-.25(8( .5'"#>

";"3!$%&#1 !" #$%

";"3! %: 1(3&6 , 1&6* "# "3"#9 '0( (;"(< 223")&'"# "* )#1#(1

<(;(5: 5 '0( 2(5"1 1(3&6 "# "3"#9 '0( (;"(< 223")&'"#:'0(&223")&#'*0&33#'/((#'"'3(1'"#'(5(*'#'0((#0&#)(1 )82(#*&'"#:"&#6

*'&#1*1"*2*(1 (;"(<223")&'"# 5"(36:'0(&)'*'0()&*(&5('0&';"1(#'"")&'"#1&'(1

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

33()'5:'0(3&#1<#(5*"3(1/=()'"#*:<0")0<(5(5((55(1''0( 3(&5#(15((5(#)().5' 0(3(&5#(1).5'/(3<1"*8"**(1'0(5((5(#)( 2('"'"#* ;"1( &<&51 1&'(1 % : <0")0 <&* "82.9#(1 /6 '0( 3&#1<#(5*/(5('0"*).5' 0"* .5'1"*2*(1/.#)0&22(&3*

;"1()88#51(52&**(1"# &

)&*(

*.25&!&#1.20(31'0(&<&51'0( 33()'5&**(**"#9)82(#*&'"#B ::C2(5&)5(5'0(3&#1.2''0(1(2'0'<&)5(*#-&"1# "#1&1:-&"1#6(2&**5&1&#1 &"5 .87"#7"#13&#1&#1 &**(**(1'0(8&57(';&3.('0(&)?."5(13&#1B $:%:C2(5&)5( 5'0(3&#1/(6#1'0&' -8('0(3&#1<#(5*&225&)0(1 #>/3('0(-.25(8(

.5'# )&*( *.25&!: .5'(#0&#)(1'0( )82(#*&'"#5'0(3&#1&)?."5(1;"1(*&8(#'"")&'"# 0(5(&'(5: *8( '0(5 3&#1<#(5* "3(1 -2()"&3 @(&;( ('"'"#

";"3!

% %' !

)0&33(#9"#9'0(51(51&'(1

2&**(1"#

)&*( *.25&!:<0")0<&*9'1"*8"**(1&* <"'015&<## :'(#&/3('0(8'&225&)0'0"* .5'')3&"8 *&8(5(3"(:&* 25"5''0&' ;"1((&53"(5=.198(#'"# )&*(

*.25&!:)82(#*&'"#0&1/((#"#)5(&*(1/6 .5' @(&5#(1).#*(35'0(&223")&#'**./8"''(1'0&''0(*"#)( '0(53&#1<#(5*0&;(/((#95&#'(10"90(5)82(#*&'"#/6 #>/3('0( -.25(8( .5':'0(51(52&**(1/6'0"* .5'8&6/(81""(1''0( (D'(#''0&''0(&223")&#'*8&6/(&<&51(1*&8(&8.#')82(#*&'"# 0(&223")&#'*)&#&225&)0 .5'&*<(33/6"3"#9 -2()"&3 @(&;( ('"'"#: 0<(;(5: -2()"&3 @(&;( ('"'"#* "3(1 &'(5 1()"*"# "# )&*( *.25&!: <(5( <"'015&<# ' (#&/3( '0( 3&#1<#(5*'&225&)0'0"* .5'')3&"8*&8(&8.#')82(#*&'"#

(#)(:'0(&223")&#'*/(&3*&<&51(1*&8(&8.#')82(#*&'"#

$ #'0('0(50&#13(&5#(1).#*(35'0(-'&'().31#' 1"*2.'('0()#'(#'"#5&"*(1/63(&5#(1).#*(35'0(3&#1<#(5*<"'0 5(9&51'(#0&#)(8(#')82(#*&'"#5'0(&)?."5(13&#1/6 #>/3( '0(-.25(8( .5' <(;(5:0(*./8"''(1'0&'8(5(36/()&.*("#*8( '0(5 )&*(*: #>/3( '0( -.25(8( .5' 0&1 &<&51(1 0"90(5 )82(#*&'"#:<"33#'&95.#1')3&"8'0(*&8(&8.#'/6"3"#9'0( 5(;"(<&223")&'"# '(50(&5"#93(&5#(1).#*(35'0(2&5'"(*&#1)#*"1(5"#9 '0(&5(*&"1&)'*:"#862"#"#:'0(51(52&**(1/6'0"* .5'#

"# '0( )&*( '0( &223")&#'*C3&#1<#(5* 1(*(5;(* ' /( 81""(1''0((D'(#''0&''0(&223")&#'*C3&#1<#(5**0&33/((#'"'3(1' )82(#*&'"#"#'(58*=.198(#' .5'"# )&*( *.25&! ()0#")&3"'"(**0.31#')8("#'0(<&6 1"#9*./*'&#'"&3=.*'")(5'0(2.52*(5((5(#)()&#/(8&1(' ( ) * % ! -

<(;(5:'0(&223")&#'**0&33#'/((#'"'3(1'"#'(5(*'5'0(2(5"1 1(3&6"#"3"#9'0((;"(<&223")&'"# 51(5(1&))51"#936 0(5(;"(<&223")&'"#*'&#1*1"*2*(1

- @!

E0('0(5*2(&7"#9C5(&*#(1+ (*C E0('0(55(25'&/3(+ (*C