High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2307/2024allowed

Lucky v. State Of Punjab

2026-05-20Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel5 pages

!"# 7777'%.%.(*'4 ='4/ / *+&, $%&%' () *

&%' () -'!

&%' () 12

&%' () 12 4'/'*% 4'/'*% 4'/'*% 4'/'*%0 7777'/1(*-'*% !./.(*0 ./.(*0 !./.(*0 ./.(*0 &#

&# 8 ?

8 ?

2(&-.*30 2(&-.*30 2(&-.*30 2(&-.*30 &#

&# 8 ?

8 ?

@ 7 $ $ @ 7 $ $ @ 7 $ $ @ 7 $ $

47 &4+(% $.*35 '-.8 -=(!&

47 &%.*-'4 $.*358 -=(!&%' ) &%' &*- )(4 %5' 1'%.%.(*'47

47 -5.4&+ $.*35 5.*-8 *+&,7 AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA 8 7

8 7

$ $ $ $

# <&# () 14'/'*% 4'=./.(* 1'% %.%.(*8 %5' 1'%.%.(*'4 5&/ /( 35% /'%%.*3 &/.- -' () %5' .61 3*'- (4-'4 -&%'- 77 1&//'- ,# 2'&4*'- -3'8 $1'

'!.&2 ( 4%8 -5.&*& &*- 5 5&/ 14&#'- )(4 &22(<.*3 %5'

&112.!&%.(* )(4 4'2'&/' () ='5.!2' .* B '/% %.(* (* / 1'4-&4.8 .* !&/' (7 -&%'

'- 7978 4'3./%'4'- *-'4 4 $'!%.(* 9 () %5' $ !%8 :98 &% (2 2.!' $%&%.(* $&-&4 ;5&**&7 7

4.')2#8 %5' )&!%/ () %5' 14'/'*% % !&/' &4' %5&% B .*%&2 &*- 9 "3 () 1(1 11# 5 /" <&/ &22'3'-2# 4'!(= ='4'- )4(6 & %4 !" ,'&4.*3 4'3./%4&%.(* (7: &*- !(&!!

/'-8 *&6'2#8 (='-''1 $.*35 > .66# & &*- $ 4.*-'4 &2." > ;&2& <'4'

' &114'5'*-'-7 * %5' ,&/./ () -./!2(/ 4' / /%&%'6'*% () !(&!! /'-8 %5' 1'

'%.%.(*'4 <&/ *(6.*&%'- .* %5./ !&/'7 5'4'

'&)%'48 - 4.*3 %5' %4.&28 %5' 1'% %.%.(*'4 6(='- &* &112.!&%.(*

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

./5<&+.% '# =/7 5' $%&%' ()

./5<&+.% '# =/7 5' $%&%' () //&6 //&6 //&6 //&68 .* 4.6.*&2 11'&2 (7 () 9 4.6.*&2 11'&2 (7 () 9 4.6.*&2 11'&2 (7 () 9 4.6.*&2 11'&2 (7 () 98 -'!.-'- (* 779 779 779 7798 &,.*-4& &,.*-4& &,.*-4& &,.*-4& ; 6&4 '5'4& =/7 $%&%' () -./5&8 ; 6&4 '5'4& =/7 $%&%' () -./5&8 ; 6&4 '5'4& =/7 $%&%' () -./5&8 ; 6&4 '5'4& =/7 $%&%' () -./5&8 .* G (79 () G (79 () G (79 () G (79 () 8 -'!.-'- (* 9779 9779 9779 9779 &*- $&*+ =/7 5' $%&%' () &4#&*& $&*+ =/7 5' $%&%' () &4#&*& $&*+ =/7 5' $%&%' () &4#&*& $&*+ =/7 5' $%&%' () &4#&*&8 8 8 8 .* 9?

9? -'!.-'- (* 77 &*- $ *-'4,5&. 6,&2&2 77 &*- $ *-'4,5&. 6,&2&2 77 &*- $ *-'4,5&. 6,&2&2 77 &*- $ *-'4,5&. 6,&2&2

'/&. =/ $%&%' ()

'/&. =/ $%&%' () +&4&%8 +&4&%8 +&4&%8 +&4&%8 4.6.*&2 &*- 5&/ / ,6.%%'- %5&% .* %5' (='4&22 )&!%/ &*- !.4! 6/%&*!'/ () %5' 14'/'*% !&/'8 %5' .61 3*'- (4-'4 -'/'4='/ %( ,' /'% &/.-' &*- ='5.!2' .* B '/%.(* ,' 4'2'&/'- (* / 1'4-&4. %( %5' 1'%.%.(*'47 7 '&4*'- $%&%' !( */'2 5&/ (11(/'- %5' 1'%.%.(* .* 5&*- ,# &43 .*3 %5&% %5'4' &4' /'4.( / &22'3&%.(*/ &3&.*/% %5' 1'%.%.(*'47 3' B &*%.%# () !(*%4&,&*- <&/ 4'!(='4'- .* %5./ !&/'8 &*- %5' 1'%.%.(*'4 <&/

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

4#8 -'2.='4.*3 .%/ %'61(4&4# ! /%(-# %( %5' 4.35%) 2 (<*'4 (4 !2&.6&*% 1'*-.*3 %5' ).*&2 &-+ -.!&%.(* () !4.6.*&2 14(!''-.*3/7 5./ 14(!'- 4' ./ () 34'&%'4 14&!%.!&2 .61(4% &/ .% &.6/ &% /&)'3 &4-.*3 %5' %.2.%&4.&* =&2 ' () %5' /'.C'- !5&%%'2 '7378 ='5.!2'8 6&!5.*'4#8 -(! 6'*%/8 '%!7 &*- 14'='*%/ %5'.4 -'%'4.(4&%.(* <5.2' 2#.*3 -(46&*% .* 1(2.!'

&2"5&*& *%.2 %5' 14(!''-.*3/ !(*!2 -'7 7 4(6 %5' 1'4 /&2 () %5' 4'!(4-8 .% ./ &11&4'*% %5&% %5' -./1 %' .*=(2='- .* %5' 14'/'*% !&/' 1'4%&.*/ %( 4'2'&/' () !&4 .* B '/%.(*8 .7'78 $<.)% C.4' ,'&4.*3 4'3./%4&%.(* (7 :D?: (* / 1'4-&4.7 5'

1'%.%.(*'4 !2&.6/ %( ,' %5' 4'3./%'4'- (<*'4 () %5' &)(4'/&.- ='5.!2' &*- %5' /&6' ./ /%&%'- %( ,' 2#.*3 .* 1(2.!' ! /%(-# /.*!' %5' -&%' () .%/ /'.C 4'7 % &2/( '6'43'/ )4(6 %5' 4'!(4- %5&% %5' !(*%.* '- 4'%'*%.(* () %5'

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

./5<&+.% '#@

./5<&+.% '#@/ !&/'

/ 14& 5&/ 5'2- &/ *-'40 I:7 &=.*3 5'&4- 2'&4*'- !( */'2 )(4 %5' 1&4%.'/ &*- 5&=.*3 'F&6.*'- %5' .// ' &% 5&*-8 %5./ ( 4% ).*-/ %5&% -.))'4'*% ( 4%/ 5&=' %&"'* -.='43'*% =.'</ <.%5 4'3&4- %( .*%'4.6 4'2'&/' () !(*='#&*!'/ - 4.*3 %5' 1'*-'*!# () %5' %4.&2 .* $ !&/'/7 J5.2' %5' !( 4%/ .* !&/'/ 4')'44'- %( ,# 2'&4*'- !( */'2 )(4 %5' '/1(*-'*%$%&%' () //&6 5&=' *(% 4'2'&/'- %5' ='5.!2'/ .* %5' .*%'4.6 - 4.*3 $ %4.&28 #'% .* '*'4&2 '*'4&2 '*'4&2 '*'4&2 */ 4&*!' ( *!.2

4/7 =/7 $%&%' () *-54& 4&-'/58 */ 4&*!' ( *!.2

4/7 =/7 $%&%' () *-54& 4&-'/58

? $ ?K 4,.*-'4 $.*35 > $5.*-'4 ? $ ?K 4,.*-'4 $.*35 > $5.*-'4 ? $ ?K 4,.*-'4 $.*35 > $5.*-'4 ? $ ?K 4,.*-'4 $.*35 > $5.*-'4 =/7 $%&%' () =/7 $%&%' () =/7 $%&%' () =/7 $%&%' () *+&,8 ? $ *+&,8 ? $ *+&,8 ? $ *+&,8 ? $

*.*' ??K '+ $.*35 =/7 $%&%'

*.*' ??K '+ $.*35 =/7 $%&%' () &4#&*&8 $ () &4#&*&8 $ () &4#&*&8 $ () &4#&*&8 $

*.*' ?:K $5&6/ &=4'+

*.*' ?:K $5&6/ &=4'+ =/7 *.(* () *-.&8 $ =/7 *.(* () *-.&8 $ =/7 *.(* () *-.&8 $ =/7 *.(* () *-.&8 $

*.*' 22 9K &*&"4&6

*.*' 22 9K &*&"4&6 =/7 $%&%' () &-5#& 4&-'/58 427 '=7 =/7 $%&%' () &-5#& 4&-'/58 427 '=7 =/7 $%&%' () &-5#& 4&-'/58 427 '=7 =/7 $%&%' () &-5#& 4&-'/58 427 '=7 EK .46&2 EK .46&2 EK .46&2 EK .46&2 $.*35 =/7 $%&%' () *+& $.*35 =/7 $%&%' () *+& $.*35 =/7 $%&%' () *+& $.*35 =/7 $%&%' () *+&,8 ,8 ,8 ,8

K ;&<&2

K ;&<&2 ''% ;& 4 =/7 $%&%' () ;&4*&%&"&8 0; ''% ;& 4 =/7 $%&%' () ;&4*&%&"&8 0; ''% ;& 4 =/7 $%&%' () ;&4*&%&"&8 0; ''% ;& 4 =/7 $%&%' () ;&4*&%&"&8 0; ;09?: ;09?: ;09?: ;09?: &*- &*- &*- &*- 5&3.4&%5 =/7 $%&%' () &+&/%5&*8 0

5&3.4&%5 =/7 $%&%' () &+&/%5&*8 0

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

$ *-'4,5&. 6,&2&2 '/&.

$ *-'4,5&. 6,&2&2 '/&.@/ !&/'

/ 14&8 %5' (*@,2'

$ 14'6' ( 4% '615&/.C'- %5&% ='5.!2'/ &*- (%5'4 /'.C'- 14(1'4%# /5( 2- *(% ,' "'1% .* 1(2.!' ! /%(-# )(4 2(*3 1'4.(-/7 5' 4'2'=&*% (,/'4=&%.(*/ &4' &/ )(22(</0 I% ./ () *( /' %( "''1 / !5 /'.C'- ='5.!2'/ &% %5' 1(2.!' /%&%.(*/ )(4 & 2(*3 1'4.(-7 % ./ )(4 %5'

&3./%4&%' %( 1&// &114(14.&%' (4-'4/ .66'-.&%'2# ,# %&".*3 &114(14.&%' ,(*- &*- 3 &4&*%'' &/ <'22 &/ /'! 4.%# )(4 4'% 4* () %5' /&.- ='5.!2'/8 .) 4'B .4'- &% &*# 1(.*% () %.6'7M 7 !!(4-.*32#8 %5' 4'=./.(* 1'%.%.(* ./ &22(<'- &22(<'- &22(<'- &22(<'- &*- %5'

.61 3*'- (4-'4 ./ /'% &/.-'7 % ./ -.4'!%'- %5&% ='5.!2'8 .7'78 $<.)% C.4'

&4 ,'&4.*3 4'3./%4&%.(* (7 :D?: ,' 4'2'&/'- %( %5' 1'%.%.(*'4 (* / 1'4-&4. %( %5' /&%./)&!%.(* () %5' !(*!'4*'- %4.&2 ( 4%8 <5.!5 <.22 ,' )4'' %( .61(/' &*# !(*-.%.(* / &/ .% -''6/ ).%8 (* %5' 1'%.%.(*'48 &% %5' %.6' () 4'2'&/' () &)(4'/&.- 14(1'4%# (* / 1'4-&4. .* 5./ )&=( 47 7 '*-.*3 &112.!&%.(* /8 .) &*#8 /5&22 &2/( /%&*- -./1(/'- ()7

&# 8 ?

8 ?

6&5&=.4 J5'%5'4 /1'&".*3E4'&/(*'-0

'/E( J5'%5'4 4'1(4%&,2'0

'/E(