High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/91/2018disposed of

Maya Devi v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"" # $%& '&( ) !* +" ,-% $.$&/ 001 ($!% /) ,%$%& $2.$!$ &)0!'&!%

2&)&!%*

23 4$.,$ ! 5'/($%& 2

2 $.$!677$28$15'/($%&5 2%9&$001 ($!%

2!6:2 %%$15'' % !$1'/($%&&!&2$1$2.$!$ 9&02$.&2 !%9&02&)&!%2&/ &8$001 ($% ! ) 2-'

($% !

2'&2'$%&' ;0$))&'<.%9 ) :2%89 1&' )0) !7 <:!(9 $00&$1)/ '&(--!2'&20$))&' ! ;

; #

$!'$8$2' !7 (-0&!)$% !%9 - !%&2-) 2'&20$))&'<.!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2% ! / 100&$1#> "

5!" "5$2 ) !7:% )$-&$(?: ) % !1!78 %9 %9&&/ &8001 ($% !5%9&$001 ($!%9$)$1) 1&'$001 ($% !)&&6 !7 (!'!$% ! '&1$. "'$.) ! 1 !7%9&2& &1$.

%&29&$2 !71&$2!&'(:!)&1 2%9&0$2% &)$!'(!) '&2 !7 %9&4:'7-&!%) !=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2% !

;

/ 1 #+" $!'

!"#$%$

;

/ 1;"5'&1$. "'$.) ! 1 !7%9&&/ &8001 ($% ! )(!'!&' 8&/&25 2 %9& 0&2 ' '&1$. ! 1 !7 %9& &/ &8 001 ($% !5%9&$001 ($!%)9$11!%<&&!% %1&'% !%&2&)%!%9&&!9$!(&' (-0&!)$% !5 $!.

)%$!')' )0)&' &/ &8001 ($% !

2 & 1.5%9& $(%) %9&($)&$2&%9$%/ '&!% ($% !'$%&'

+"5 )):&':!'&2,&(% !# %9&@$!'(?: ) % !(%5 #

2 )92%5=%9&(%=5%9&,%$%& $2.$!$5):79%%$(?: 2&1$!' !/ 11$7&) , !790:2$5,$ '!5$-0:2$5$%%$!A9&2$$!'A9&2$A9&-$8$% 5 )%2 (% !' 2'&/&10-&!%$!':% 1 % )$% !%9&2& $)(--&2( $1$!'2&) '&!% $1 ,&(%2)"5$!' 5,$ '!9&)$-&8$) 118&'<.!% ($% !'$%&'

5 )):&' :!'&2 ,&(% ! > %9& (% 9& @$!' (?: ) % !

11&(%2

2)92%5=%9& 11&(%2=5/ '&$8$2')+5#$!';'$%&'

5$))&))&'%9&-$26&%/$1:& %9&$(?: 2&'1$!'B++55C 0&2$(2&:0%%9&'&0%9 %8$(2&)!,$ '! !'2$'5,$ '!.&0$)) 2$'$!'$ 2 :-6 !6 !' 1$!'$!'B 55C0&2$(2& 2&92 $!' 9$9 1$!' ))$% ) &'8 %9%9&$8$2' %9& 11&(%25%9&1$!'8!&2)

1&'<4&(% !)589 (98&2&2& &22&'%%9&1&$2!&'2& &2&!(&(:2%9& 1&$2!&'(:2%<&18' )- ))&'%9&2& &2&!(&0&% % !)/ '&$8$2''$%&'

" +589 (98$) -0:7!&'<.%9&1$!'8!&2)<& 2&%9 )(:2%9 )

:2%' )0)&' <:!(9 $00&$1)/ '&(--!2'&20$))&' !

& ($)& ):02$$!':09&1'%9&$8$2' %9&

11&(%2$))&)) !7(-0&!)$% !B++55C0&2$(2& 2%9&1$!':0%

+ %9&'&0%9 %8$(2&)!,$ '! !'$'5,$ '!.&0$))2$'$!'

$ 2 :-6 !6 !' 1$!'$!'$))&))&'%9&-$26&%/$1:& %9&$(?: 2&'

1$!'B#5";5C0&2$(2& 2%9&1$!'<&.!'%9$% ,-& %9& 1$!'8!&2) $002$(9&' !=<1& %9& ,:02&-&

:2% ! &($)& ):02$5!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2%&!9$!(&'%9& (-0&!)$% ! 2%9&1$!'$(?: 2&'/ '&)$-&!% ($% ! 9&2&$ %&25%9&$001 ($!% 1&',0&( $1@&$/&&% % !

/ 1 + " "'

(9$11&!7 !7%9&2'&2'$%&' ;0$))&' !

& ($)& ):02$589 (98$)7%' )- ))&'$)8 %9'2$8!! + 5%&!$<1&%9&$001 ($!%%$002$(9%9 ) :2%%(1$ -)$-& 2&1 & 5$)02 2%%9$%/ '&&$21 &24:'7-&!% ! & ($)& ):02$5 (-0&!)$% !9$'<&&! !(2&$)&'<.!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2% @&$2!&'(:!)&1 2%9&$001 ($!%):<- %%&'%9$%%9&$001 ($!% 7%%9&,0&( $1@&$/&&% % !' )- ))&'$)8 %9'2$8!%&!$<1&9 -% $002$(9%9 ) :2% 2%9&)$-&2&1 & $)72$!%&'%%9&1$!'8!&2)<.

!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2% ! &($)& ):02$& :2%9&2):<- %%&'

%9$%'&1$.((:22&' ! 1 !7%9&&/ &8001 ($% !($!!%<&)$ '%<& !%&!% !$15$)9&8$)<& 2&!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2%9&):<- )) ! ) %9$%%9&$001 ($!%<&72$!%&')$-&$-:!% (-0&!)$% !$)9$)<&&!

72$!%&'%%9&1$!'8!&2)<.!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2% ! &($)&

):02$ !%9&%9&29$!'1&$2!&'(:!)&1 2%9&,%$%&(:1'!% ' )0:%&%9&(!%&!% !2$ )&'<.1&$2!&'(:!)&1 2%9&$001 ($!%8 %9 2&7$2'%&!9$!(&-&!% (-0&!)$% ! 2%9&$(?: 2&'1$!'<.!=<1&%9& ,:02&-& :2%8&/&259&):<- %%&'%9$%!1 <&2%.8$)72$!%&'<.

# !=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2%89 1&0&2- %% !7%9&$001 ($!%%8 %9'2$8 ,0&( $1@&$/&&% % ! %&29&$2 !71&$2!&'(:!)&1 2%9&0$2% &)$!'(!) '&2 !7 %9&$ 2&)$ ' $(%)5 ! -. 0 ! !5 %9&2'&20$))&' <.%9 ) :2%!

; !%9&($)& %9&$001 ($!%'&)&2/&)%<&-'

&'%%9&&D%&!% %9$%%9&$001 ($!%)9$11<&&!% %1&'%(-0&!)$% ! !%&2-) 4:'7-&!% !=<1& %9& ,:02&-& :2% ! & ($)& ):02$ ,0&( $1 @&$/& &% % !(9$11&!7 !7%9&2'&20$))&' ! $/:2 %9&$001 ($!%8$)7% ' )- ))&'$)8 %9'2$8!!+ E %9'2$8$1 ,@8 11!%'&<$2%9& $001 ($!% 2-(1$ - !7)$-&$-:!% (-0&!)$% !$)9$)<&&!72$!%&'

<.!=<1&%9&,:02&-& :2%%%9&21$!'8!&2) 2-)$-&$(?: ) % ! 8&/&25%9&$001 ($!%)9$11!%<&&!% %1&'% !%&2&)% 2%9&0&2 ' '&1$. ! 1 !7%9&&/ &8$001 ($% ! 2'&2&'$((2' !71. 9&2&/ &8$001 ($% !)%$!')' )0)&'

+" $4&)9 !'$1 /) :'7& E9&%9&2)0&$6 !7C2&$)!&'

* &)C E9&%9&22&02%$<1& * &)C