M/S Indian Acrylics Limited v. M/S Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And Others
! "#$ % $
$&' $'()*
"
# #$% &
!'
! !
!
! * +#, " - .""
)!"
* "!
+!
-&/012/3 .
)# &/,* & "!
' ( & 0* "!
+!
! 1& .""4" 5 ,6
2, +
'
3/ $#/
!
4 ,*
',
/ 5 6! 7
! +! +/
'
'
/%
%
8
!#
,/ / 1 !#
/#
&# ! * 7
#%
, !
#
',
#/ #
!
'
9# )!"
* "!
!# +!
, +
' /# !
'
/#
&# ! * 7 ' ,
%!"
!
!
+ !
'
'
:
$#
:
-789&/'0)7) -&&' 9:1&/'0)45 ;6 - ; # "20) The scope of the appellate powers and the review powers are well defined. The power of review under Order 47 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is very limited and it may be exercised only if there is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record. The power of review is not to be confused with the appellate power. The review petition/application cannot be decided like a regular intra court appeal. On the other hand, the scope of appeal is much wider wherein all the issues raised by the parties are open for examination by the Appellate Court. 21) A fortiori, what was not decided in appeal by the Division Bench could not be decided by the Division Bench while deciding the review application. It is for this reason, we are also constrained to set aside the review order."
!
'
!'
-)5$6
&/012/, )3) 078)/0&/'0) 5-6
7:<<':
(/9,:'=3) ''0>.190)0&/'0) :
# 1 ;
!"! !
# <
!
!
!
!* + * ',, "%
+
! ! ' ,!#
/!/
',
!% !
! ! ++
+!
: ;
%!"
!
!
+
+
!
!
+
! ',, '!# '
:
$#
$#/
4 ,*
# *
&
*
/ + , !
,"/
+# !# $'('9?'0 4 58>"6 $<0 "12'
Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No