Karamjit Kaur v. Union Territory, Chandigarh
!
#$%
$!&$$
$
$' $! ((((
')* +, '*-.+ )/ #0123
!$ 4%5
!6 # 7
$!7 %
!
!
# $ %& & '
((((( $!7 %
!
#6
&! "
&! !
)* +, ,+,) " '+)-,+,). '01
" 2 3
!
- !
"
,) +4 ,+,, . '51
&! )* +, ,+,) " '+)-,+,) . '01 "
2 3
!
- !
"
,) +4 ,+,, . '51 $ !
7 ! && /!
&! !!
&
9
)
. 1 "& % !& ,,8-,,9 ":
$;
" )4 +9 ,+)<. '41 7 ! 2 3 % 7
" 7
!$ """ && "2 3 => & 7 !
" % &
-
,
? "&
&& 2 3 &
)**8 :!& 7
" 7&!
% !
&
" !& %& % ! %
&!
! '48 %&! "& !&! 6:@ ))8 ,4 +9 ,+)4 ! 0+8 0*<' :
&
&!
: !
" ! " "
!& ! !
%
7 %
% !
&% ''&%.7 1 "
!
7
%%
! .6:@ ))8 ,4 +9 ,+)41 7 & "
" !
7 7 & % &&%% "% %& : !
! 7& "
! !!
& "!
& ,+ )+ ,+)<. ')1 %
!; ! "
% % & 7& 4+ +0 ,+)< "
%
%$ %"
"
% !
% "
!!
&
7 ,, +5 ,+)< . ',1
7 7
!
"
& & !
%
%!; %
% & 7
!$ """ & "2 3 =>
& "
!
)4 +9 ,+)<. '41 % 7 % !$ """ & "2
3 => :"
! )4 +9 ,+)<. '41 '
A
!"# "$#%" # "& ' & ((' & !"
")!"# *'+ ,+-./ , !" "
) !"# 01 ,!
50 6 "" !"# 7 4 8 : "
!! !
"&
% 7
# !
&"
7
)4 +9 ,+)<. '417
7 % ""
" : 7
&& ' $7 " "
# !
& 7 !
" % %&&" & 2
& ,9 72 3 & )*84. " B )*84 & B1%! '
9
:; " " & "" ' 7 .'""" " (" " ""&#"
" #' (( &# # ((" # :; ((" " %"$ '" 0 %"$ " !" * , !
:4;+(( #" " ("
* , ! ' :3; !"0 "
'("" 0 :; :4; " "< ( "# &'8 : 7 ! !!
"7 !
" % ""! ! % &"&&% 7 " & ,9 ")*84 & %! &!7& 2 3
# !
& "
7 7
! " !
" 7
""
:& 7 7
! " !
7 3 & "2
3 % !
" & )< 72 3 & )*84%! '
9, # 70+ " #"
& "(("& ' #<"8 :& 7 7& !
&"
!
"! ,, " & !
%
&!
C "
7 & !
& "
"
)4 +9 ,+)< . '41 7 ! 2 3 %" ! !
2 3 & % && !
;
&7 "
"
7
7 7 7 &7% """ " ?%& 3 & 2 3 '! '
3 &
&!
: ! " !
7 !
": ! 7
! 3 & &
!
"2 ""3
":@ %
& 7 7 " !
!
&,+8% : ,* +5 ,+)<% 7 ! "
7 !
" " !
%
)) )) ,+)9% %&&!
7 ! 2 3 7 2 3 " 7 &
2 3 "&& ! 3 & 3 " !
!
)4 +9 ,+)<. '41 / ! " %
& )0
": ! : 7 !
% !
&
!!
& % & & "!
! : " 7
! % ! && & )4 +9 ,+)< . '41 :& 7 7"
,0 %!!& & % % & "!
! 7 ! !& !
2 3 &
& !!!
& 7
"
& %
&!
!
)* +, ,+,) " '+)-,+,) . '01 "
2 3
!
- !
"
,) +4 ,+,, . '51 &! 7 @ ),8,+'C ",+,4
& )* +, ,+,) % & !
7
!
!
D/'2 3 &
%
7
! " && "2
3 => ! !& !&! & 7 !
!&
%
/ && ! !
7 !
" 3 &2 3 "
!
"
'
&&
&
!
'5
!
! " 7
&% "
&& % '
5=0
+*+>?-+)*$@ $/ A+ ?-/-
* $ -
+ 5A+ /+,+.$ +
-++ +5 /- !
+>+)* /+ -A,-/ +*+* , 5 461BBC , A 646BC +# D 6D 6646 , " # 4616 * " #
# " & 61 3C6:6C" ;& '"&' '"
2-* C ""
46164 " / 36C 3B0+ -.! ./0!
*< /" "'" (( ( ""
6D6B " '
$#% $57 "E0 "
' &' '"2-* C ""46164" / 36C3B0+ -.! ./0!
"" " 61 636C6"& < " #"
$#%
!( + '" "66B04 ""6B6D(( ( "!@.41B31$2 6 ")!"#F$ G . " # ! !"# #"# & < "( " ( G . "
#!7
H+(" "(" ' 6C " & ' (&( "
" ( #" '/ < (# " "&&" ' "2( "# ( < ( & " "
( " "
!(! &" " " 3 & "
(!(+
& &(# " " " " ( "# '
" ""'"
&(" # "(&( "
""
&'
H " #D66 *'&
!7 "5E0
(("
6C66"6C66! "'"E" " " ( "# "" 666 ("
" ! + / / ,' ?" ># !* .A/++0666063 "/& A /#"$2-*C""46164)" / 36C 3B0+ -.! ./0!
" <" # "#
#'# " * "7 < (( # < : "#'# " ; &' " 5E0
E( "/ "(" " ((
&( "#'
!- ( (( # " " &" " ! "5E0
0 ' !"# "$#%8 # !
& "
%&
7
/! !
. '51 7 " & 7
""
!!
& !
!
!!
&
"
& % 7
<
: 7 && !
&"
7 "&!7 % 7& %! ! 7 $ !
!
&
: 7 !
" %!
!!
& 7& "&%7 !
!& " & !
# !
& "
& 7 2 B7&
! "#$$%% ! " &'($
!"#)*"
!
. '51 & !
&"
7 !
! ! % !
7 ! " % ""
2 3 &
% 7
! " !
"!
! "
&
"
% !
# !
&"
7 !
. '51 %!
% &7 ! & "! % " &
% ; &
7
" %! " & ,9 )*84 &
*
:
& !
&"
7
$% 7& !
)+
6 & " . '41
&"& 7 &" & " !
. '51 " 7
!$ "" " && " 2 3 => & 7 !
" % &
- 7
$ !
! &
!% 7 !
" "
7
7 "
!
"
; "" &"& " & ,9 )*84 & %!% &7
! % & !
! "
!
"!
:!
% . '41 7& & 2 B7& +, !- #% @ ,5 447
&"
&& %' H:D; - #" *(" (( &" #""* BC4 "&(33 ("
"* BC4"7 H, # > 70 " #"
& "
((" & ' # <"H :C;E(G, #G&("
! . /0 - 1 2! 33# $$3&" H, # & " " #" ( "
E ( " # " " H :1; '"* " ( < " #< #'# "
( " (" "& & (" " + B31 " BC4 * " " :; " # ' (( ( " ( +* & / & ((# " ## ' (( #"' # <" &' # "("& #" " ( & & "
&# E(G> " G- (" ' (( & &#( "( "
"* 1 * " ( " &, ( -""70 H,"70:;+ " & "" ' .'""" " ("
" ""&#"
" #' (( &# # ((" #H
:B; ## ( " * "
# * '# "" ' " %" .'((""* ( #'#(( #" < ((" " + " * - ""( (( # &#'(( ( <"
"* 1-'& ("
(" " (( # G' G ' " " &
( # & ( " ( " /
* & ( ('"#(( # (&& " "
((" :46;(( ###+ " * " " E( G' G (( @"""& & " & ( # % ( "(("# #! " ( ""
(( " ' ( G' G " ' ' ( # & ( " ' (( " ##' E( " #" ( + & (( & "
> " '& " #( )"* BC4* (("" " #"
& "(("
&' #<"- " #( & " &( "&( ( ("
' " E & <"" # ' #"E "& & "< (( ( " #" ( # " ( '&' (( " #" #" " -
# ( "
:4;- ""'&' " # " & " ## ( &' ((
#" #" ' " ( ('""(' 1 (( "' #' (( &#
# ((" # +""
(( &#' & '& ("
& "' ( ( :4; 5' & ## < & (( # ( "+ 4 !'&("' "
#' (( &' & # " D01 '0#" " " " ( " " & "(("" ("
("""6663"" (" (( "& &# :44;A (#& & " "
" ("- "(( &E#(( "
('""" 1:4; BC4 "' (( " # ! " + C
!0 <# #!< "("
("""6663@" " & "#" #!" & & ( " - #" ( 33 (" " % !"
!"" # " (' " #<" * * @ ' "
" & ( # '#
H ))
6 ! " !- #
&& % 7 '
A6-( ' ! ' ""# ((" #" " ""
(( " " 0&#( ' ""
#'"
(' . "$#% "
". "+ B31: "
GB31+ G;BC4* ' "E (& ""/ B B31+ + ((" " " B31+ "BC4* & ""
(( !"# "> ' " " ' # &'" & E #(&" B31+ "BC4* ## (' "+ "* - ( (( !&#' ##' (' ' + " * ! E (&"+ C !
-" "& " " "
E (& " '&! #' " E (&" ' &' "' '#
"$#%'# '
" "
&
E " &" '# ( ' & "
I8 ),
% "
!& !
" & ,9 )*84 & E" "& 7 "&
7 !
7 !
!
7
7& " %! ! 7 $ & ! %! !
& 7
:&
! $ %"
!
!"
7 !
" %!% &"&&
" & ,9 ")*84 &
)4
B &!
!
. '51!
!
""!
!
" ' ! & % & 7 " & " 7 72 B7& .4- &4
3%!5#$$5" E%
&& % 7 % '
AC@ &( "# ?"# #!"(("(0 ## ' "
,' A 2 & ' " " (0" #$ " "(( -& ""
("E ""( "
&(" " E"@" & "" ' "
& ( "'# "('" ' " #" & ( "#' (( (&< "'(( " '
"( " - E( " "
( " " ( " ((I8 )0
: % 7
! $
% "! ! " !
"
7
B7& +, !- #%! 7
& 7 , !- # %
7 && % )4 +9 ,+)<. '41 7;
)5
! 7 !
"
%% !
!
% &7 & &&!
;
& " /!
"
! &"!&7 " " !; & 6:%!%
)8
% " "
)9
&& &! .1"&&& !&
)/ #0123 8$!7 %
!9 +('
# '
) C $- -@ , C 7&
-@