Sultan Singh v. Darshan Singh And Others


  
      




! "#
$%%












&'

"( "#")#* + #',%% -."&!

! "#/,%% 


     


 
  
      01 % 2
 3 41  




 
 
!" #
  



$%%
!" #
 
    3 41 5   &  


 
 
( 
!


   
 "
))*
#
 
(   
#
+  
,

 "
#
  
- 
 " 

#
" 

.
 
  
 



 /


)01*)1&2

  
' 
(
 
, 

-  % / 
 
"

)310)1&*
456
3
 
56
27
 
 /
( && 
  
# 

 


1818)1)3 
 
 
  
( 
4 
  7
 

, 
-  
 
:
+;

&<

-

" 
&3&
((
-
 / 

-

 


&*10)1)3



 
 
  
  "
9 , 
+

"   

(
# 

"


   
 
 

/  
 

!

"
#
// 
"

" 
# 
 " 
&)1*)1&2


)11*)1&2
456
&7
 
 
" 
 " 
)&1*)1&2


)01*)1&2
456
)7
 
!

"

 ) 
  
#"

 

 
 
"


 
 ##

 
 
 
#
"

"
#/ "
#
 / 



)3&&)1&=

-
 
 
/  

% "  


 
 
 / 
#  
>
&
 
 
8
, 
"  


&21?)08
 
#
 

&=
, 
&8
/ #/


#

-
>
23
/


>
20
/
"
>
))


>
&1
48&27
&<?&?)
41)7
&8?)?&
4)&=7
 
&8?&?&
4<27
 



!


 
"

<&2



  

" ,
'


 
 
#"

9/ 
#
)118@10
 


!

 
$
' 
'

 
  "
, 
4A 
  B7
'


 / 
-




+(


>

 "
, 
 
 

 
>
8&<&

)3&&)1&= )& 1 
 

"   
-
&* 31 111

"
 1 1 -


 ##
 
2 23 111

 
3 == 111

)3&&)1&= 122 311

)2&))1&=
 
 
# 


 1
 
33 311
 )<&1)1&3
 
 
" 



'






# 6
# 6" 
 


 
#
 


-
)*&1)1&3

#  
> &C
.
 




#  "


6

 "


 
 
"

"/ " 
 / 
-
6 

))1&)1&2


)) :
))1&)1&2
 
 ##


#
 
 


-
#/
011
/

311
/
. 
- 
 " 
"   
 
. 
6 

#  
>
&
# 
  
'


 ##
/,


 "

## !


 
!
 
 "   


 
- 


#/


" "


  - 
#  
>
&

 % 
!
6" 
#
 

 )< +

# 
 
 
"

  

"

#
 

 / 
#  
>
&
6"


>
&0=*?&
 )1&&)1&3

#!
#
#  
>
)
 
<

"
#
8
, 
&2 /
"/ 


>
))??&1
48&27
'


, 
#/

#
  

 




 
 ##
 
#  
>
&
  ",

 

" ! 
'




6"
-
# , - 

 

#
#  
>
)
 
<




 
   


 
 ##C



 
 
 ##C
 
 " 
<1?<&13)1&2
 
#  
# 

"/
/

 
#
 
 
 
,

"

/
#
 
 #
" / < D
 "
#
// 
 
#  
# 

   "
 
-
" . 
"
 

 

!


 
)01*)1&2
'

#

##


 ##


 "
!

 "
 
#


# 
 / 
 
 
"/

 "

-
#
% / 
 
"

)310)1&* <& 

!
 
 

 

% / 
 
"
   
/!

 
 
:
+;

&<
#
 
(
# ( 
"
&018

1&1*)1&0
,



 
#
 

 
"



-

 
 
% / 
 
"
'


 



 
 

-
  

!



!
-
// 
#
 
 



!
#

""
!

" #
+
-
# 
 
 

 



)01*)1&2
- "
 


""


!!

#
# 
  " 
 


" 
- 
!

##  
!


  
"


"/

 % / 
 
" = > "
#
 
 
 
-

!

   ? ##
- 
" 
 
/

#


 
-   
+
 
 
  
"

"

  




 
! 
!
-
// 
 


- #
 



#
 !

"
+
-
# 
!
 

    
#
"

"
#/ "
#

 / 



&*1*)1&3 




#
 
 
 



 
E!

/
 
   =& 
  ? ##
# 

 

 
/!

 
 
:
+

&1
#
 
(
#
( "
&018
- 

/ 
#"
"


% / 
  "

)310)1&*


 
/
-
"

"

"
 
 6
+
-
 #
"  "
 
 
   ?#  

". 
, - 
#
 

 

"
 



 ,
## 

  =) D
"/ 
#



 
 
 
"
#/
 . 

 
##
.
 


 

 
" !
!

 "
#
"


/ 

"
 






 
 
 
( 
!




1818)1)3 / 
 
# 
  
 
:
+;

&< ((

- 
""/

 
,

"   
#   3 

!
 
# 

  
#
 
 
:
;+++

&47

-
" 
&1=
#
 
(
# ( 
"
&018
'



"/


 / 
 
    
  "
9 , 
!


 

 &*10)1)3 3&  
  # 
 
"


. 
 
 

 
 
"" 
#
 


1818)1)3

  
( 
4 
  7
, 

-

 
 

&*10)1)3
 
 
 
  
  "
9  

!,
 
!

 
%  " 
#



(

-
# 
 
!


  
D
 "
#
 "
 
  
!  
 "
 


 
"  2


(


 
" 


#
 " !
 


 

/ "

 
6/ 
   
,
"





!

 "
 
/ 
"
 "

*  
" 
#
  

 
  

"  


 
 
  
  "
9 

- 
 
 
( 
9 
4 
  7
# 

% "
  
#


 
 



% / 
 
"

"" " -
-


 


"



!
 



 


!

 "
! 

"
+


! / 
 
 
 / 

"
" " !
 
  
-
!


!
-
// 




"


 
 
 
 
( 9 
 
"
 
  

 

"/




#


 

% / 
 
" *& +

# 
/ 
 
,



  #
 

 

% / 
 
"
-
# 
-
-


"   
#
  
", 
#/
 


-

 
#  ". 
, - 
#
 
"
:
 
/ 
 
"   
 



 
 
 
 
!


  
- 8 
" 
 
" 



 #
#
   



 
!


 
 

/ 
 
#


"
 
 
( 

-

 
    
  "
9 

 
- 
 
# 

 ""
"


#
 



 
!

 "

"
+

"   

!  

/ 
 
"

 





 
 
 
"
-
!
6"


 %  " 
% 
 

"   "
- 

 

!

% 
#
  
 
:
+;

&<
#
 
( #
( 
" 8&  
" 
# 
 
 
" " 
#


 
- 
# "

6"


#
!

 
%  " 
 "


 "
#

%  "  


/ " 
#
% "
  #
 
#
 / 
#
 
!


  

 
0 
 
( 

 
,



 
#
 



% / 
 
"
-


-


" 
 
#
  
 
-
 #

 /
 "  "
#



"

 
##"
  

 
!

". 
, - 
#
 

 

% / 
 
"
 &21=)1&8
+ /"


 
  
#
#


 
 
: +;

&<
#
 
(
#
( 
"




 
#/
 

# , - 
#
 
"
 
 
( 
9 
" "
 
  
!


# 

1&1*)1&0
##
#/

   
 6 
  0& :
 
 
 

-
 
"

"
"


   
 


, - 
#
 
% / 
 
"
 




#/


 ,
## 
 
 

 #
-


 
#/
 

#
, - 
'


  ( 
9 -!


"


#
 
/ 

" %"



"   
 
"
 
#



 
&2
#




-


"
 -   
 

    
 


  !  "

"
 



!  

"  "

  
  ##$%#&  !   '( )  *

 +  !

 

!


 , 
-   

  



 
* ( .

  

    
 

"  



   /0% 1       

"



  
 



"

 
- 

  

 /02 1  
   




..

* -

(
 1  
-

 


 

 3  '"





 

 4
 
#  
 "


 


  7 



    /08 1  -  





! 



 5(  5'9#&&  %# 1      
"
 !(
 


  
"

 

 4
 
# 



#8%#:-


- 

 

 
" "


  "

"
  !    

 !

!
 , 
-  


(

 ; 




  5(  5'8:%# 

 * ( .

 <  '"




- ..

*  




 !
 )
 




 ("   

"

  


 
"

 


  ..

*  ! 

"

  
 )
  

   


 3   

   


  =

  


    
" "





 (   5'#&&  %# 
 
  



#8%# 
 

 4
 
# 



 3  '"

- 

  

 /08 1

 
   
  
#8%#:


 "



 4
 
#



  5' 8: %#-  ##$%#&


 "



 -  
 
""
 





  
 







   

! 

  




 "



   !
 
- /(
 

  

  
 






  

!
"  !
 
  ( 

 

       

 

   


 "("



  


  
"



 !


  




  . 

 
5
>'

?




 '"

5
>'

?- =     
 

 
 




+ 5 
  
 


"   


 !
(
   

 
@ &1 


 
-
"

 
#"
 

    
#
"

"
#/ "
#
" "
-


 
E!


  
+



/ 
 

"
    ##

/!

 
 
:
+

&1
#
 (
#
( 
"

 
,

// 


  
- 
 

"
#
 
% / 
 
"
 
 
 
  
-

 6
 
"

" &1& F/
 
#

#
 
 
// 
  ""/ 
 
% / 
 
"






 

  " " !
 
 
 
  

". 
"
   . !"
, - 
#
 

 

% / 
 
"



/
'


 
 
:
+

&1
((
-
# 

 


&21=)1&8
+
 
"

"/ "
 
 
( 
4    7
, 




"

#

 
 , - 
#
 
% / 
 
"


#/
&21=)1&8 &1) : "
 

#
, - 
/ 

&21=)1&8
  
" 
#
#


 
 
:
+;

&<
(( 


 
 #/

6 

 

 
#

#
  
 

1&1*)1&0
'


-
 

-   
 

 
#
   
'


 
( 
4    7

 #
""
" "
 
-
 
  
 
-

/  

 
&1< F /
 
 
 
"




!
  
# 
  
-

# 

""

 
#  #"
'

 
 

 
/ 
"

"/ "
#

 
, - 
#
 
% / 
 
"
-


"/



 " 


  "

#
% 
"



-

/#
-

  

,
  
 

". 
, - 
#
 % / 
 
"
 

#-
 
 

#


    


 ,
## 





  !
 
%" &1= 
"
"
 
 
% / 
 
"
 
"
 
 


 
"



&21=)1&8
-

-
/
 
#
/  
 

 
#

#
 
,



 
#
 

 

% / 
 
"
'


  :
+;

&<
((

 
/ 


#  " "/ 
#
/ 
#"
 
 
#
 


# , -  &13 +
!

-
#
 
# 

 " 



(
# 


 
!

%  "  



- 


# 
  
 
:
+;

&<
((
- / 
 
 
( 
4 
  7
, 
 
 
#
  
-
 / 
 
 
     "
9 , 
'


#


"

 
"
- 
- 


""
"


#
#"
 
-
 

 "
#
# "

6"


#
!

 
%  "   &12 ( .  
!


 


! 
#
/ 


 / 


&&
+

-!
6
" 
 
 
!  


 
" "  
"
 !
 


"  
 "

"


6 
#




 
  !



/ 
#
 
 

 
-
 
 
'

!  

" # 
 "

 
 
"
 
%  "   /
#
 
 
"


 
!

 

#
 
#
%


 
#

#
"   
#


( &)
+
!

-
#
 
#"
 
 
 
 
 
# 

% "
 
 
#
 
# 



 

" 
  
#

-


 "

  
 " .  

 
/
"


 

 
 
# ""

- 
 
"
#





# 


3 41 ,%%  &)& 2""'

Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No